Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel a bit shakey after ds 10s behaviour

644 replies

BearGryllsDad · 21/08/2022 16:19

For reasons I won't go into I had to take the DCs into town with me to do some exercise. Afterward I took them into M and S as I wanted to check out the sale and get the kids a meal in the cafe (kids eat free, or one does anyway). I have never heard so much moaning and playing up as this from ds who is 10 nearly 11. At one point he was crying because he finished his food and leave even though I still had food on my plate and my drink. His little brother was happily entertaining himself, but ds was making a scene to the extent some people were noticing.

Then whilst I had a quick look arousnd the sale items, mum, mum, mum I want to go. Mum, mum, mum. You said one shop. And on and on he went. I told him to give me five minutes, but he couldn't. At one point he lay on the floor feigning something. He started winding up his younger brother calling him a weirdo and sniggering at him. Pointing out pink t shirts and saying they were for him. In the end I told him to stop as he was being infuriating. I didn't loose my temper and kept it together. But I am sitting at home feeling an angry, shakey mess. I've even had a few tears. I often feels like he tries to control things and play up if we have to run errands or so something that is not centered around him. As soon as he gets home he plugs into YouTube and that may be part of the problem. I know m and s is boring but should he be able to tolerate 30 minutes of boredom at his age without making such an embarrassing scene?

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 24/08/2022 08:02

And realistically he should feel ‘a bit ashamed’ of this behaviour. It’s really bad behaviour. I’m sure he’d feel pretty ashamed if his Year 6 teacher had been browsing the sales and spotted him. I feel like at the moment there’s this move towards protecting kids from any negative feeling whatsoever. I do consider myself a more ‘gentle parent.’ I don’t allow any shouting or harshness in my home. But some negative feelings are appropriate. A feeling of shame when you’ve behaved extremely badly is appropriate. And anyway this boy didn’t seem to feel any shame or upset. He went home and played on his computer.

Justmuddlingalong · 24/08/2022 07:48

Yes. Because in later life, everyone will spend the time to nurture connections with him. Especially when he's expected to do something when he'd rather be doing something else.🤔

catflycat · 24/08/2022 07:29

BearGryllsDad · 21/08/2022 16:40

understand the shops were boring but sometimes things have to be done that are. Not everything needs to be fun and exciting, and it's important for children to know the world doesn't just revolve around their wants. YANBU to expect to be able to finish your meal I would furious too.

At one point in the cafe he either purposely or carelessly bounced his arms up and down on the table spilling my hot tea. I think that's the point at which my internal rage began to kick in. For reference his 6 year old younger brother sat nicely the whole time.

If you don't find that the other kis is always angelic when one is struggling with their behaviour, then I don't believe you have siblings!

But in all seriousness, as so many on here are encouraging you to take things away from him I would really think about that, what are you trying to achieve? If you think the content of what he's watching on YouTube is inappropriate (I don't let my nearly 10yo have unmonitored access to YouTube, kids YouTube maybe..) then that's a conversation to have with him, figure out what's suitable and safe and set boundaries, perhaps he is even dependant on it and some action is needed BUT arbitrarily taking things away to make him behave how you want him to is controlling and authoritative.

Do you want him to just behave in the way you want when you're there to threaten him with something, or do you want to model kindness, be interested in him and what is actually causing this behaviour (behaviour is a form of communication), and try and work through it with him? You seem to feel a bit ashamed of how he behaved - I get this, it's so hard when society tells us how our kids should behave in public - but do you really want him to feel shame? Or do you want him to feel safe and happy?

If it were me I wouldn't take my kid shopping if I could possibly avoid because I know it's the most boring thing for them - but if I had to I would manage my expectations about how they will react to it, knowing they'd hate it. It's probably plan something they want to do while we're out looks taking the football or getting a milkshake.

I'm a huge fan of 'gentle parenting', which would basically advise to nurture your connection with him and try and understand what's going on, rather then trying to fix things through asserting your control and power, because while you may get the short term results you want, it's damaging to your relationship with him in the long term and doesn't actually solve the issue or teach him the kindness and patience that you want him to demonstrate.

Madamum18 · 23/08/2022 18:19

I am amazed at how many people seem to think it is unreasonable for a 10 year old to behave appropriately and support his Mum for a bit on one day! Clearly he has had lots of child centred stuff during his holiday and at 10 years old he understands a bit of give and take and being a bit bored whilst waiting for someone else!

I think though, that he is getting away with it too much. He really should not have gone on his computer after that behaviour. He is not getting any consequences is he!!

I think you need to identify consequences for good and not so good behaviour and sit down and tell him:

eg if you come and sit quietly whilst I do my exercise class, eat lunch and go to M&S without spoiling our time, then you can.....(and make it "extra" to the normal, whatever it is!)
If you can't do that then there will be no .....!

  • so he knows what the consequence is either way. And then you have to STICK TO IT until he stops testing you to see if you measn it.
Good luck!
BearGryllsDad · 23/08/2022 17:15

Not at all. The OP is being entirely unreasonable expecting her kids to fit round a day of her doing what she wants. And I bet there’s a huge backstory to it

What kind of huge backstory are you imagining? 🤔

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 23/08/2022 17:15

@Redjoy

yup kids have to learn that the world does not revolve around them and sometimes they just need to fit in. like you do , like I do, like everyone does. That’s life and kids need to learn that, these pandering parents are doing their kids no favours - those kids are gonna get an awful shock in life

petmads · 23/08/2022 15:41

Kids eh nip this behaviour in the bud if it happens again copy him he will be mortified and embaraased when hes stopped explain to him this behaviuor is not acceptable and you will do the same everytime he behaves like that . It may work or just ignore him easier said than done i know ive 3 adults now thankfully.

LaDamaDeElche · 23/08/2022 15:04

Redjoy · 23/08/2022 14:00

Not at all. The OP is being entirely unreasonable expecting her kids to fit round a day of her doing what she wants. And I bet there’s a huge backstory to it ..

Yes, god forbid kids have to fit in with anyone else's plans from time to time. When you think of the many days that children spend that are just geared around them, your comment sounds a bit strange.

LoisLane66 · 23/08/2022 14:56

There's no need for that behaviour. Give him a choice. No TV or devices for 3 days if he kicks off. Explain firmly that he can't be left at home while you shop therefore he has to behave when you need to take him with you to a place he doesn't want to go to. YOU make the rules not an antsy kid who wants his own way and makes a scene. No rewards for good behaviour, it should be a given. I can't believe the number of parents who can't control their own children.
I've taken 5 on holiday...on my own.
Taken 5 shopping and for meals ...on my own.
Taken 5 on flights...in my own, all without ever having to warn them about their behaviour prior to leaving the house, no tantrums just good kids looking forward to whatever the day brought and none were teens. It's learned behaviour and parameters at home.

6079SmithW · 23/08/2022 14:41

I can’t believe the comments on here sometimes!
@BearGryllsDad l think that it was perfectly reasonable of you to take your children with you on your scheduled day. Children need to learn to be bored and how to deal with it. There are so many boring things to deal with in life!
I also think you have every right to do something you need sometimes. Children need to learn that you’re not “just mum”, you’re a person too and that you also deserve to be happy. IMO being a mum isn’t about choosing to sacrifice yourself for your DC.

Deadringer · 23/08/2022 14:33

^^^Rubbish

Redjoy · 23/08/2022 14:00

Not at all. The OP is being entirely unreasonable expecting her kids to fit round a day of her doing what she wants. And I bet there’s a huge backstory to it ..

Buttonjugs · 23/08/2022 13:16

Are you sure he’s neurotypical? Sounds like very ADHD behaviour to me.

LuckySantangelo35 · 23/08/2022 11:48

gatehouseoffleet · 23/08/2022 11:19

He was playing up. He didn't want to be there. That's all. Nothing to get uptight about!

Since when have most boys liked clothes shopping with their mums? I am a girl and I didn't like it. I didn't play up, I just hung around looking like a wet weekend. OK I wasn't an embarrassment (which is your main issue I suspect - people LOOKED and STARED and were disapproving - ie it reflected badly on you (in your own mind at least)).

Being shakey? I hope your kids never get a detention at secondary school...or do anything more serious (and they will).

Not sure how removing screen time after the event will help. It seems to be the MN "punishment" of choice. What does it achieve?

@gatehouseoffleet

seems in your world OP should have just abandoned her meal when he started crying to leave

TwoShades1 · 23/08/2022 11:30

It possibly seems a bit much but it depends how long the exercise took and whether he had appropriate entertainment during that time. I can see how browsing a shop when already bored would be difficult. If he had sufficient entertainment for the exercise portion then it does seem a bit much. My step daughter is a similar age and whilst she may have a bored face and sigh and ask when we are finished she certainly wouldn’t cry or lay on the floor.

gatehouseoffleet · 23/08/2022 11:19

nannykatherine · 23/08/2022 10:31

Is this a serious comment?
the behaviour is absolutely awful and needs stopping right now otherwise what kind of controlling adult will he be ?

Oh do give over.

gatehouseoffleet · 23/08/2022 11:19

BearGryllsDad · 21/08/2022 16:24

if that’s the worst of his behaviour I think he sounds like an alright kid….

Really? Crying because I wouldn't leave the cafe half way through my meal, writhing around on the floor in M and S because I wouldn't immediately leave? He is neurotypical so it's not a sensory thing.

He was playing up. He didn't want to be there. That's all. Nothing to get uptight about!

Since when have most boys liked clothes shopping with their mums? I am a girl and I didn't like it. I didn't play up, I just hung around looking like a wet weekend. OK I wasn't an embarrassment (which is your main issue I suspect - people LOOKED and STARED and were disapproving - ie it reflected badly on you (in your own mind at least)).

Being shakey? I hope your kids never get a detention at secondary school...or do anything more serious (and they will).

Not sure how removing screen time after the event will help. It seems to be the MN "punishment" of choice. What does it achieve?

nannykatherine · 23/08/2022 10:31

HotDogKetchup · 21/08/2022 16:22

if that’s the worst of his behaviour I think he sounds like an alright kid….

Is this a serious comment?
the behaviour is absolutely awful and needs stopping right now otherwise what kind of controlling adult will he be ?

Lynz78 · 23/08/2022 09:42

Definitely reduce screen time or make him go without a couple of days. I have to do it with my son it seems to act like a reset button. He can be a right horror and emotional couple of days off and he is back to his caring better behaviour ways.

janex1 · 23/08/2022 09:22

Completely unacceptable behaviour. At that age children should see a meal out as a treat not torture. Essential that you set firm boundaries now. Will be hard in the short term but we'll worth it in the long-term

MsTSwift · 23/08/2022 08:49

We know an indulged child who tantrums to get her way. Adoring parents taught her that her every whim is the priority. Sadly her peers don’t agree she is becoming increasingly friendless in early secondary other kids really don’t appreciate the tantrums.

LuckySantangelo35 · 23/08/2022 08:25

Kanaloa · 22/08/2022 21:54

Am now imagining a child bawling lying on the floor in year 6 when he isn’t getting his way and the teacher smiling indulgently as she explains ‘aww he’s teething.’

Come on. How many weird excuses can people come up with? I do wonder why so many children seem so so immature when I meet them then I read the long list of excuses for an almost 11 year old boy tantrumming on the floor like a toddler and crying when he’s finished eating. That’s what a child of 10 months might do. Waahhh waahhh mummy I’m finished eating mummy if I’m finished everything should be finished WAHHHH. It’s utterly bizarre behaviour for a secondary school child, molars or no molars.

Totally agree

Tatws · 23/08/2022 07:36

I have had similar from DS 9 years old. I have turned of the WiFi on his gadgets before. It seems to work as he responds when I threaten the removal of his Internet access.

I limit screen time to 3 hours daily but difficult to police. A colleague made a comment "you may be breaching his human rights". What is the world coming to? My parents tolerated very little back in 80s and they grumble at the mention of their grandchildren watching YouTube.

ellyeth · 23/08/2022 00:05

I've noticed similar behaviour from my 10 year old gc and my feeling is he has far too much access to mobile phone, games, TV, You tube, etc, etc. When he wants something he wants it NOW and sulks or makes a scene if he has to wait. It is very worrying and, if it were me, I would take away all devices for a couple of days and then set fairly rigorous limits. It is a horrible situation that seems to be more and more common.

Mumkins42 · 22/08/2022 23:59

If this were me, I would feel uncomfortable and a bit embarrassed myself so I absolutely get your feelings. I would be triggered inside too. This draws attention and makes us feel out of control; been there....

But now, I'd personally want to know what's behind the behaviour. I don't believe kids want to be these unpleasant manipulate demons that need swift sharp discipline or else they're doomed to a life on insolence and disrespect - as most replies on here suggest. If you're son is NT then I'd want to explore why he went to that extreme. I don't believe for one minute an NT kid at that age wants to make a show of himself in the shops for no good reason. And again, I agree with the poster that this isn't the worst thing in the world. Yes it's embarrassing and I'd not like it either - but he isn't exactly on the path to becoming a mass murderer. Just ask him, be kind, be calm, be caring, ask him what was up. Tell him you aren't happy about it and.you have issues with YouTube & go from there. You don't have to start punitively. Maybe he did just want YouTube badly enough - my gut says there's more to it.