Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this neglectful?

43 replies

Ritascornershop · 21/08/2022 12:15

I was a teenager in the 1980’s and my own kids were teenagers ten years ago. My mum died five years ago with dementia (but seemed sane, was married, had a job, went on big holidays with my dad after the kids grew up). Recently I’ve been thinking about a couple of personal care things from my teenage years. I do not know what to make of this. We we fed well, clothes kept clean (till I was old enough to do laundry), new clothes bought.

However: I got my period when I was 11 and after a one time purchase of pads my mum never bought me pads or tampons again. I didn’t have money, I was 11, and because it was never discussed I assumed it was too shameful so never asked. So I spent years stuffing my pants with toilet paper, which as you can imagine was not efficient. Also, while I’ve always been small boned and slim we have big boobs in our family. Mum took me to buy a bra when I was 13 (at which point I was 32C, I was 34DD by 19) and that was it. One bra. So I’d take a bra out of her drawer and she must have noticed but never spoke of it.

wtf?!!!! I just can’t imagine what she was thinking. I know she loved me, otherwise took good care of me, but this is so strange. I can’t imagine doing the same to my daughter when she was a teen.

Anyone else have this? And I’m not being unreasonable, right? This was neglect?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
1Dandelion1 · 22/08/2022 00:15

My mum was the product of a neglectful mother, how her and my Aunt made it to adulthood i don't know, but because of this she was completely opposite but over the top with hygiene, and san pads where always available and hung up in a drawstring bag on the back of the bathroom door (no tampons as my mum didn't think they were safe for teens).

I found the over the top aspect embarrassing at the time, but i know my best friends mum was like hers and didn't wash her clothes, explain about periods or buy her san pro, and i know my mum supplied them to her and let her shower and washed her clothes whenever she was at ours.

Ritascornershop · 21/08/2022 23:12

I don’t think different times entirely explains it as some girls were getting bras and pads and tampons. Different in that some people were extremely embarrassed by it, but not everyone found it paralysing.

OP posts:
Saz12 · 21/08/2022 21:25

Different times! My mum was lovely, and a midwife. But absolutely no talk about periods, no bra purchase, no deodorant chat, nothing whatsoever of “that type of thing”.
The only Conversation was “if you can’t be good, be careful” re: HIV /AIDS when I’d have been mid teens.

KyaClark · 21/08/2022 20:29

I felt I couldn't tell my mum (70 now - had me at 38) when I started my period so I hid it for almost two years! It just wasn't something that we had ever spoken about. She gave me a book when I was 11 and that was it. A family friend eventually explained it all to me.

Recently, my mother was horrified that my niece had left a packet of pads in the bathroom, in full view of her brother!

nicknamehelp · 21/08/2022 20:28

My dm wouldn't discuss anything like periods when I got my 1st and was obviously scared at this blood in my pants I got told off for being silly and being an inconvenience as it meant she had to go buy pads. It was never to be discussed again. I would have to make pads last longer than they should till I started earning money to buy my own. She wouldn't buy me underwear luckily I had an aunt who would.
I know she loved me she just struggled with me growing up.

queenMab99 · 21/08/2022 20:24

Although my mum told me about periods at 11 and supplied me with sanpro, the problem for us was disposal, we had no bins in the lavatory or bathroom, and men weren't to know anything about it, so we couldn't carry it through the house to the outside bin.(the bin men might notice it!) My mother had a system, we had to put it in a paper bag and hide it under our bed, then while my father was at work, she would collect it and burn it in the grate. I found all this secrecy very confusing, and I am sure my father, who was very sensible, and had 2 sisters, wasn't totally unaware of women's biology. Apart from that my mother was very hot on personal hygiene, as having had no indoor facilities in her childhood, she absolutely relished daily baths for the whole family, in the 50s when I was a child, and no one was ever allowed to miss out. We were very lucky.

Ritascornershop · 21/08/2022 19:59

@sammylady37 My experience was a bit different in that I had a lot of independence but no idea about men at all. I assumed they were as romantic as I was and it took till my 50’s to grasp that most of them just want sex. I wish my mother had given me guidance there too. They let us down, our mums, in quite important ways.

OP posts:
sammylady37 · 21/08/2022 18:24

It was the personal hygiene stuff, but the general
lack of guidance too. I’ve never had much confidence and I wonder how much years of not having guidance contributed to it. I so often felt for years that I did not know how to adult

I can empathise with this. My mother never gave me any life guidance, and was extremely over-protective. I had never been anywhere in my own until I left home to go to uni, and then I was expected to cope in a big city, when I hadn’t done anything on my own prior to that. I’d never navigated public transport on my own, never shopped for food, clothes etc, never been to the cinema, to friends houses, never been out socialising, nothing, and then I was loose in a city. But perhaps the biggest thing of all was that I had zero clue about men and dating and relationships. I’d never even spoken to a boy my own age til I went to uni, as I’d gone to a single sex school. I had no clue about boundaries, appropriate engagement, expectations etc. i veered from being in awe of men to just wanting to fit in and being desperate to kiss a boy, any boy, just to be ‘normal’. I really resent that that’s how I was sent out into the world.

sammylady37 · 21/08/2022 18:19

I’ve remembered too that dental hygiene was never deemed important when I was a child. I’ve lost 4 of my adult teeth and every remaining tooth has had work, be it a filling, multiple fillings or root canal treatment and crowns. Every single tooth in my head.

KeepYaHeadUp · 21/08/2022 18:03

This is so sad, OP, and not normal. Possibly neglectful - though I don't know enough about dementia etc to comment in terms of your mum's intentions. How was she with you more generally? As someone has said it could be she was incredibly embarrassed. If she showed love and care elsewhere I'd say it wasn't typical neglect.

Ritascornershop · 21/08/2022 18:01

I’m so sorry to hear that others went through this! It seems it was much more common than I would ever have guessed. When I think of little me, and teenage me, I have so much compassion for that girl.

It was the personal hygiene stuff, but the general
lack of guidance too. I’ve never had much confidence and I wonder how much years of not having guidance contributed to it. I so often felt for years that I did not know how to adult.

I think my mum was depressed as well, but going through a dreadful divorce I was often depressed too, but I didn’t let my kids down, so I do feel that she dropped the ball.

OP posts:
redskyatnight · 21/08/2022 18:00

I had similar. My mother had light periods and seemed to think I could cope on about 3 tampons per period, whereas I had heavy periods and 3 wouldn't even last a day. She refused to believe me so I supplemented with toilet paper.

She refused to buy me a bra until I was 13 stating that I was too young to have one. I was bullied at my school for lack of one with fairly sizeable boobs.

When I had my own children my mother said something along the lines of I should make the most of them while they were little and children weren't nearly as interesting when they got to 10 or 11 and started having their own minds about things. At this point it clicked that I think she was trying to keep me "young" - she didn't want a child going through puberty and literally lost interest once I did (a pattern she has repeated with my own children, and all her other grandchildren).

SammyScrounge · 21/08/2022 17:51

qpmz · 21/08/2022 12:56

Sounds like your mum was embarrassed about puberty and normal bodily changes. This made you feel shamed/embarrassed to ask. It's sad but common in certain generations.

My friend, Irene, age 12, went to a school run by nuns. They were seriously weird. One day Irene was in a class suffering bad stomach pains. She had told her Mum but she had sent her to school anyway.
The pains got worse and eventually she got up to go to tell the nun. When she rose, blood started dropping on the floor.
Irene thought she was dying what with the pain and the blood. The nun said nothing but wrote her a pass to get out of school and told her to go home.
No one had thought to tell her about menstruation, not her mother, not the nun.
She was crying and afraid and the nun offered no comfort to put Irene's mind at rest.Attitudes are very different today

HowToStopThinking · 21/08/2022 17:44

Yes this was neglectful, I'm sorry that you had to go through that!

When I started my periods my mother bought me one pack of pads and that's it! My dad beat me with a belt one time I asked my mum if I could please have some pads one month! I once asked my head of year, I was 13, she told me to ask my parents. I took a paper round job, before and after school, so I could earn some money for san pro, I was 13/14, in the early 90's when I started that job, my mother took my wages from me for 'lodge'. I took on another paper round after school, so I did two at the same time, and didn't tell anyone so I could just afford san pro.
My mother, and my father by proxy, were abusive shits, I haven't spoken to either of them for almost a decade and ever will again, not just because of the san pro and 'lodge money' issue but for the many, many other abusive and neglectful crap they did to me.

I made sure to be open and honest with my girls, they come to me and their dad of they need san pro, however I always make sure we have a huge basket of pads and tampons available at all times. Both girls have just started using period pants so we've bought lots of them for both of the girls.

TiredYorkshireMam · 21/08/2022 17:32

@Ritascornershop yes I really don't understand it either.

My mum is very critical and judgemental of others, so I don't know why she didn't seem to care that I looked awful, or give me pointers in how to conduct myself. Just general life advice really.

She wasn't an "absent" mother. She was there and the house was clean and tidy. But that was about the extent of it. Looking back now it just seems ridiculous- my dad worked long hours in a stressful job. She worked part-time in a comfortable job.....but she wasn't bringing up her kids!

I think she just didn't really know what to do, really. She's not a bad person and she's not lazy. I just think she didn't really think about it much. I don't really know who she thought was bringing her kids up, obviously just thought she didn't really need to do anything Confused

I think she has suffered with anxiety and depression most of her life, and possibly some form of autism as well. But she won't do anything about it. She is a deeply unhappy woman but there's not much I can do about it.

I do feel very disappointed because I think it could have been different if she just had a bit more awareness / self-awareness.

Ponoka7 · 21/08/2022 17:21

sammylady37 · 21/08/2022 17:03

My mother, now in her late 80s, was very lax when it came to my personal hygiene and care, when I was a preteen and teen. She actively discouraged regular showers/hair washing, saying it was a waste of water, my school uniform was rarely washed- my (only) shirt was washed maybe every second week and the skirt and jumper were washed maybe once a month, at most. Before anyone asks, I was not allowed do my own laundry. She gave me sanitary pads when I had my first period and told me to remind her to buy them for me every month, but despite my reminders she never did so I used wads of toilet paper too. I gave up reminding her. She never brought me to get measured for a bra, just gave me a hand me down from my older sister, and only gave me one. When it tore, as I was significantly bigger than my sister, I sewed it up. She never bought me deodorant. Really, I must have smelt terribly bad, between no deodorant, infrequent showers and unwashed clothes. And looked terrible too, with lank, greasy hair.

I don’t understand why she was like that with me. It wasn’t due to a lack of money, and it wasn’t lack of education on her part. I do think it was neglectful, despite her not being so in other ways.

That was my experience. My Mother was born in 1928. I can remember her taking me aside and telling me that I didn't have to put clean knickers on everyday. I also wasn't allowed to do the washing, so it wasn't a case of her being over worked. Everyone in the family smoked and I was bullied because of my lack of hygiene. It had a lasting effect on me and my self worth, which meant I've underachieved. I'm just about to spend £thousands on my teeth thanks to early childhood neglect. This is a woman who worked in a good job and had her hair done twice a week in the hairdresser's. There was a definite air of not letting girls get above themselves and taking the one's who tried to fight back down a peg or two. I always have to comment when older people say that we should keep periods etc private.

35965a · 21/08/2022 17:13

It is 100% neglect and saying sometimes it was embarrassment or common with a previous generation doesn’t mean it wasn’t.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 21/08/2022 17:09

UWhatNow · 21/08/2022 12:59

Did you tell her you needed pads and a new bra

🙄 doesn't take a genius to work out an 11 year old with no money is going to have monthly periods and will need more than one bra throughout their teenage years.

Also if the read the post, the OP was to ashamed to talk to her mum about it as her mum made her feel it was a taboo subject

sammylady37 · 21/08/2022 17:03

My mother, now in her late 80s, was very lax when it came to my personal hygiene and care, when I was a preteen and teen. She actively discouraged regular showers/hair washing, saying it was a waste of water, my school uniform was rarely washed- my (only) shirt was washed maybe every second week and the skirt and jumper were washed maybe once a month, at most. Before anyone asks, I was not allowed do my own laundry. She gave me sanitary pads when I had my first period and told me to remind her to buy them for me every month, but despite my reminders she never did so I used wads of toilet paper too. I gave up reminding her. She never brought me to get measured for a bra, just gave me a hand me down from my older sister, and only gave me one. When it tore, as I was significantly bigger than my sister, I sewed it up. She never bought me deodorant. Really, I must have smelt terribly bad, between no deodorant, infrequent showers and unwashed clothes. And looked terrible too, with lank, greasy hair.

I don’t understand why she was like that with me. It wasn’t due to a lack of money, and it wasn’t lack of education on her part. I do think it was neglectful, despite her not being so in other ways.

Ritascornershop · 21/08/2022 16:50

Yes @TiredYorkshireMam it’s the floundering that I don’t understand. Why would they leave us to flounder? My mum didn’t give me any tips on makeup or hair or how to handle adult men pestering me when I was a teenager (which happened a lot and I thought I had to be polite to sex pests).

I know that when I started school mum would brush my hair (which was quite long). She was terrible at it though, just yanked a comb through and it hurt and so she gave up. I visited my grownup sister once, aged about 12, and she decided to brush my hair and there was a huge rat’s nest (as she called it) of tangles at the back of my head. She had to cut some of it out.

But mum was fine in other ways, proud of me for being clever & tried to cook things the family would enjoy (with mixed results: she was not a good cook - dad cooked on weekends).

OP posts:
TiredYorkshireMam · 21/08/2022 14:28

@Ritascornershop my mum was similar, but maybe a bit more extreme.

I don't know if it was "neglect" as such, but a lot of it has come back to me in recent years and I do feel very sad about it.

I think I was fairly well looked after when I was a young child. But by the age of around 10 or so (possibly younger) I was just left to it.

She was a respectable woman. She had a good job and she worked part-time, presumably to facilitate looking after me, but she just didn't really.

She was very emotionally distant, didn't really speak to me much. Didn't teach me anything (cooking, make-up etc). Always looked vaguely surprised when it was revealed that she should have done something but hadn't, for example, seeing something that her friends were doing for their kids.

I didn't really have appropriate clothes. I had a brother two years older and would wear a lot of his stuff. When out with my friends I never had a jacket, even in winter. Mum never seemed to notice but friends mums did and would often give me a spare.
My clothes were always washed and folded and put away. But when I desperately needed new clothes I had to ask for them. She would then take me out, always to the cheapest shops, and she would let me try on and choose more or less what I wanted. But I can remember her just standing there as I tried things on. She never had an opinion or helped me with what might look good or whatever. I chose some awful, unflattering things and she just let me.

She never checked if I'd brushed my teeth. I was quite self conscious and went through a phase of piling on very thick face make-up in completely the wrong colour (think this must have been given by somebody as I didn't have money to buy it). I was very pale with very dark, cheap make-up caked on my face and I can't imagine ever letting my daughter go out like that. But she did and I still don't really understand why.

If I ever misbehaved she was quite hard on me. Very critical. But I was floundering without any guidance and I'm amazed she couldn't see that. If I did something wrong, she would mostly be annoyed that it would reflect badly on her. She was obsessed with appearances, so it seems so strange that she didn't care that I looked very much like an urchin for quite a few years.

I've done fine for myself in life, but I do often wonder how much better I could have done with a bit of guidance.

Ritascornershop · 21/08/2022 14:18

There was definitely no talk of what makes a healthy relationship (how to get a job, etc).

@Thelnebriati aside from walking myself to the hospital at age 14, I also was sent to get my stitches out weeks later alone. Then years later I married someone emotionally neglectful.

I guess I hope that by finally thinking about it I can change some habits of not prioritizing myself. Now my kids are grown I want to take better care of what’s important to me.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 21/08/2022 14:05

Yes this was neglect. It doesn't matter if she felt embarrassed, she could have just put a bag of items in your room or the bathroom. Or left you with some money to buy your own.
I often used to go without shampoo, toothpaste, a toothbrush, deodorant; and had whatever hand me down clothing we were given. We weren't poor.

The way she reacted to your migraine suggests she took it personally. Was there ever a time you needed medical help and didn't get it?

ColumboOnTheCase · 21/08/2022 13:58

Yes sadly the same happened to me, except I had an oversized bra which I sewed up to fit. I did a terrible job (Irony being my mum was a seamstress). I'd like to say it was the times but in my cousin's home they used to keep sanitary products well stocked in the bathroom. My mum was a prude and self absorbed but much like yours I was well fed and taken care of in other ways.

ILoveRumblyRabbit · 21/08/2022 13:57

Yes, it was neglect. I too experienced similar from my mother and wider relatives. There was no discussion of any kind about puberty, sex or relationships or how to manage anything related to them. It was a lot of self discovery and trying to manage as best I could when actual advice would have really helped me. I try not to hold negative thoughts on my upbringing though as I can't change it, but I have a much better relationship with the children in my life as a result and feel I am more switched on to signs of neglector effects of poverty which is useful in my professional position. In my local educational establishments, all sorts of period products have been made available to youngsters for free and it's such a relief knowing that those resources are available to those who still find themselves needlessly in the same predicament as we were.