Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not agree with this school reward system?

63 replies

Danceswithduck · 21/08/2022 11:04

Dd is headed to secondary school in September and they’ve done the big sell on their reward system of merits or whatever that are calling them.
If they get enough over the course of each term they can opt into trips. More points equals better and more exciting trips 🙄
Now I appreciate some kids might need this but dd is very intrinsically motivated and doesn’t need this stupid system. All it does is take away any natural motivation to strive to do well. No wonder the education system struggles. We have to bribe children and then they lose their natural curiosity and intrinsic motivation.
DD has been brought up to be very motivated but that will be knocked out of her by these types or reward systems, although no doubt some in her class need to be bribed to behave or make any effort.
DD likes to learn for the sake of learning. These systems take that away.
AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 21/08/2022 13:57

Threelittlelambs · 21/08/2022 13:28

Is it possible to devise policies that will permit maintenance of intrinsic motivation in those who have it, while providing extrinsic motivation to those who need it, and what would that look like in a school?

It looks like streaming.

Streaming as we know it doesn't do that… there'll be kids capable of very high academic achievement who study for the joy of it, and kids capable of very high academic achievement who need external rewards and penalties to apply themselves.

Does anywhere even do streaming any more? I thought that went out decades ago in favour of subject-specific setting (and, I suppose, in some areas, the grammar system is a kind of separate-building streaming).

Iknowforsure1 · 21/08/2022 13:51

@ThanksAntsThants
because you don’t have to go and work in a particular place. Because the fact you managed getting employed, you already proved to be equal to your colleagues by passing all the requirements. Children do not have a choice. They are not adults, their personality is still developing. They also are under immense pressure, much more so comparing to adults. I can’t even start talking about those disadvantaged who don’t stand a chance for so many reasons. This system is cruel and will destroy many.

Lessofallthisunpleasantness · 21/08/2022 13:48

They don't have to go on the trips. If your child doesn't want to take part, they don't have to. The school is there for all the children not just yours.

Iknowforsure1 · 21/08/2022 13:46

I agree. It’s more of a punishment system. Trips are educational and if anything, help less motivated pupils to stay motivated and love school more. Maybe I’d understand when the efforts are rewarded with something like a book gift or a voucher or similar. Not a trip. Too divisive.

Pumperthepumper · 21/08/2022 13:33

saraclara · 21/08/2022 13:24

Yes. It sounds like your DD has everything in her favour. Many kids do not. Some will find school really hard, because they simply don't have the innate academic ability. Or their home situation is awful. Or they struggle with the social stuff.

It is WAY harder to be intrinsically motivated when you have all that against you. And what might seem like only a very small positive step in attainment to most kids, can be massive for a kid who struggles. Yet most people won't even have noticed or cared that they achieved it. So yes, they should be recognised. And any negative effect on your daughter (if there even if one) is of far less impact than the positive one for that child.

Except it’s so unlikely that a struggling child would be able to ‘behave’ all year long for the motivation of a trip at the end. Particularly if they do have a hard time at home and come to school hungry/tired/emotional. It’s another barrier for them.

maddy68 · 21/08/2022 13:31

Your daughter will benefit from the awards scheme too.

You are going to be one of those parents aren't you.

Support the school or send her elsewhere

Threelittlelambs · 21/08/2022 13:28

Is it possible to devise policies that will permit maintenance of intrinsic motivation in those who have it, while providing extrinsic motivation to those who need it, and what would that look like in a school?

It looks like streaming.

saraclara · 21/08/2022 13:24

ClocksGoingBackwards · 21/08/2022 11:30

You realise that the school isn’t set up to revolve entirely around your DD and her needs and that there are other children in the school that might benefit from this way of doing things?

Yes. It sounds like your DD has everything in her favour. Many kids do not. Some will find school really hard, because they simply don't have the innate academic ability. Or their home situation is awful. Or they struggle with the social stuff.

It is WAY harder to be intrinsically motivated when you have all that against you. And what might seem like only a very small positive step in attainment to most kids, can be massive for a kid who struggles. Yet most people won't even have noticed or cared that they achieved it. So yes, they should be recognised. And any negative effect on your daughter (if there even if one) is of far less impact than the positive one for that child.

Pumperthepumper · 21/08/2022 13:07

I agree too OP, reward systems linked to trips are terrible for so many kids. It means they are punished months later for something they probably can’t even remember. There are loads of ways to build motivation in class, external rewards only work for a handful of kids.

NumericalBlock · 21/08/2022 12:49

I think they're awful. I remember missing out some of the bigger trips that were for those who had received lots of gold stars. Because I was a mostly well behaved, quiet student who did well (all Bs and Cs at GCSE) but not amazingly well, I didn't often get gold stars because I didn't stand out enough to recieve them for being 'hard worker' or 'good example' and I didn't misbehave so I didn't get them for 'trying hard' or 'listening well for a whole lesson'. When I got to secondary school I had big issues with forgetting my homework and books (diagnosed ADHD as an adult so not something I could 'just remember' despite all the organisation systems in place). These reward systems are so damaging to the average student and I am astounded that they still exist.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 21/08/2022 12:45

It always feels like whenever anyone suggests looking at psychological research to guide pedagogical practice they always seem to go for the new, exciting, and largely untested stuff like learning styles or… something about rubbing your chest and buttons? Confused Or it's implemented in ways that aren't justified by the research, like classes for all kids on mental health, mindfulness and CBT techniques, when we don't know what will happen when masses of previously healthy teens are encouraged to dwell on their bad feelings like this (paywalled, sorry: www.newscientist.com/article/mg25534002-000-uk-schools-are-teaching-teenagers-about-mental-health-in-the-wrong-way/).

A few years ago, my Freeview box used to pick up Teachers TV and it was heaving with dodgy psychological fads and not so much of the more established stuff (and I recognise that, as the article linked above by @Assistanttotheregionalmanager demonstrates, motivation is complex, and all our actions are motivated in some way by rewards and penalties, even if it's sometimes intangible and difficult to properly untangle, but there is at least a lot of research going on for decades with observable results, even if the theory is disputed).

MardyBumm · 21/08/2022 12:43

The system is not perfect but needed to help prevent low and high level disruption in classes. What do you think happens to those children to don't have intrinsic motivations? They often disrupt lessons which means your child's education will suffer.

mondaytosunday · 21/08/2022 12:39

I agree. Our old school had a points system, but they were awarded for different reasons by different teachers. One would give points if you did particularly well in homework or in a debate or essay. One did it if you were normally pretty distracted but did well that class. One did it if you were helpful to another student/teacher.
Most of the time they were given to those who were a bit wayward as encouragement. But my daughter pointed out that if you were well behaved all the time and did your best effort every day you were not rewarded that much.
There was no prize other than a particular house 'winning' by getting the most points collectively over the term, so there wasn't any real consequence to get but getting more points.
Having trips based on this system seems totally unfair.

Waitwait · 21/08/2022 12:34

Totally agree OP. To those saying “schools need behaviour systems”, our school (admittedly a fee-paying one but that obviously doesn’t automatically equate to good behaviour) intentionally doesn’t have a system of merits. It stands against this idea that education is all about where it can take you (what job, reward, etc), as opposed to education for its own sake and human flourishing. The upshot of this is that from the very start in the infant school, children genuinely strive to learn for learning’s sake. The closest we have is a house system for sports day, swimming gala, etc. so they win points for their team, but not academic achievement or effort. The children all love learning - it really is noticeable on a far greater level than I have seen elsewhere.

DD’s gymnastics does the stupid “Star of the Week” BS and while I know they ensure everyone gets it throughout the year, it’s zero motivation - the first children to get it are always the disruptive ones or ones who find gymnastics difficult, and then they have no incentive for the rest of the year. Others like my daughter who are fairly competent are disappointed every week and finally get it for who knows what.

I honestly think it’s just lazy, unreflective “this is how we’ve always done it” pedagogy that sums up my problems with so much of the education system.

wb3 · 21/08/2022 12:15

Threelittlelambs · 21/08/2022 11:35

DS was punished with behavioral points at school and therefore banned from trips away from school grounds, and couldn’t dress down on certain days due to these points so effectively punished three times over (detention served)
No motivation to do better as these lasted the years.

Self esteem destroyed.

Why did he continue to misbehave?

C152 · 21/08/2022 12:12

YABU. Teachers have always bribed children - whether it's who gets to choose the reading book or sit next to the teacher in infants school, a new pencil/eraser/free time to the table who works the best / gets the highest score in primary school or merits or whatever, in high school, it's always happened and always will. Some kids do need extra encouragement and, even as an adult, isn't it nice to be recognised and rewarded for a job well done? If the rewards are actually given fairly (to those who deserve them), why would this demotivate your DD? If she loves learning, she will continue to love learning.

Where it is demotivating is where rewards are given inconsistently/to those who don't deserve them. Unfortunately, there's nothing to be done about that, except say that life's unfair.

Completelyovernonsense · 21/08/2022 12:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

Newrumpus · 21/08/2022 12:03

Threelittlelambs · 21/08/2022 11:35

DS was punished with behavioral points at school and therefore banned from trips away from school grounds, and couldn’t dress down on certain days due to these points so effectively punished three times over (detention served)
No motivation to do better as these lasted the years.

Self esteem destroyed.

This is really tricky. Reward trips are earned for doing things right. Encourage your son not to see being missed off the reward as a punishment but as a reward not yet earned. The detention is the punishment; the behaviour point is the record. I know this is an extreme analogy but a criminal conviction will be punished by the court, the convict will then have a criminal record which may prevent certain privileges being accessed.
This may help your som understand that he hasn’t been punished multiple times.

reallyisthisallthereis · 21/08/2022 11:56

Token economy systems which is basically what merit systems are, are used in many settings. Unfortunately they rarely make long term changes to behaviour of individuals, but do help to manage behaviour in institutions. So I do agree to an extent with OP.

However as a teacher over 20
years, they can help motivate some students, particularly those who struggle to motivate themselves. They do need to be used realistically and merits given for work above and beyond, but it gives you a way to praise effort.

Often kids work hard but don't initially see it rewarded in higher grades and it can be a long hard slog to see the rewards of their efforts, unlike others who are always top of the class.

If you can come up with a better system to keep these students motivated, please feel free to share!

confusednewbie · 21/08/2022 11:55

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 21/08/2022 11:53

No. I did look at my psychology certs.

Then I’m sure you’ll recognise there are differing views in all research and hypothesis.

Assistanttotheregionalmanager · 21/08/2022 11:54

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 21/08/2022 11:41

You’ve clearly little experience or learning in the field. As you were.

No such thing as intrinsic motivation

Have a read

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 21/08/2022 11:53

TeapotTitties · 21/08/2022 11:49

Did you stamp your foot and pout as you typed that? 😂😂

No. I did look at my psychology certs.

TeapotTitties · 21/08/2022 11:49

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 21/08/2022 11:41

You’ve clearly little experience or learning in the field. As you were.

Did you stamp your foot and pout as you typed that? 😂😂

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 21/08/2022 11:46

If we dial down all the accusations of not caring about other kids or just wanting to brag, this is actually a really interesting topic. Is it possible to devise policies that will permit maintenance of intrinsic motivation in those who have it, while providing extrinsic motivation to those who need it, and what would that look like in a school?

MulberryMoon · 21/08/2022 11:46

I don't envy my children's teachers having to control 1400 teenagers contained in one building. You can't expect them to use the same methods as you use on 1 child. I'm not sure about linking it to trips, but getting rid of merits and behaviour points which keep a record of behaviour so it can be addressed? No