Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we being taken for a fool.?

317 replies

Indoctro · 21/08/2022 06:16

Have you watched this video by Neil Oliver

AIBU to start believing he actually has a valid point. I am not normally part of the tin foil hat brigade but I most definitely have been starting to question what's been going on recently

I'd be interested to hear other people views on this subject.

Thanks

OP posts:
GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 21/08/2022 11:17

Conspiracy theories have always abounded, especially during difficult times. During the Plague, people thought "foreigners" were poisoning the water supply.

It's just fear - feeling that fear, and passing it on to everyone else so you're not along in your fear. The reality is, the world is chaotic and shit and unfair. We are on the outer edges of the climate crisis, the rich are (predictably) getting richer and the poor getting poorer: same as it ever was.

Absolutely this. The psychological effect of the last few years has been very interesting to behold. A lot of people seem to have suddenly realised how easily our lives and society can become fragile and uncontrolled and it’s fried their circuits. People are frightened and looking for control/an explanation of it all, and conspiracy theorists fill that gap nicely. Not that I think conspiracy theorists are acting out of malice; they’re looking for control and explanations too.

I have a fair amount of time for Neil Oliver; his passion for history is wonderful but he does tend to be rather hyperbolic and apply his own narrative. The latter I’ve definitely noticed in his books and podcasts, when he will create a backstory for a place/event that I don’t see any evidence for. The story is nice but it shouldn’t be presented as fact. That seems to have tipped over into his politics and crashed spectacularly into post-covid paranoia.

Yes, the world is a bit shit at the moment. But if we draw back and look back through history, periods like this have happened. Look at the 17th century when we had the execution of a king, the interregnum, the Restoration, the plague and the Great Fire of London in the space of what, 15 years? The idea that bad things are orchestrated by a shadowy Bond-style cabal is quite ridiculous - the worst is probably that the Russians are just shit stirring.

I do feel sorry for people like Mr Oliver, they can’t be in a very good mental place.

goshy · 21/08/2022 11:16

This leaves knowing we will have to poach other countries doctors who will also need them - and that's assuming they'll come here.

why would they come to a high tax, high cost, low wage economy? There will be better offers on the table. Lots of the west needs more immigration to support the ageing population but the immigrants will have more power as more countries will be trying to attract them.

Freedomfighters · 21/08/2022 11:14

CJsGoldfish · 21/08/2022 11:10

The conspiracy nuts are out in force lately 🙄

Can't we send them off to their own special board out of the way?

Anyone who disagrees with you is a conspiracy nut? Sure thing.

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 11:14

Yes @MercurialMonday - I was agreeing with you but pointing out that just increasing medical school places won't solve the problem.

Hungryharriet · 21/08/2022 11:14

Mummyford · Today 10:52

Hungryharriet · Today 10:34

The government is made up of individuals, most of whom genuinely care about their constituents. It's too broad a statement to say 'the government is working against us.'
World politics are to blame for a lot of the UK's current issues (another broad statement).

@Hungryharriet

Like the 265 MPs who voted against forcing water companies to prevent raw sewa@Hungryharrietge dumping int

@Mummyford Do you have a link?

MercurialMonday · 21/08/2022 11:13

foliageeverywhere well yes but that wasn't the reasons the government minster gave - he cited cost of training to government as reason for the cap and had the assumption we could just pick up doctors from else where if needed in future.

That kind of the point though the lack of interest in doing anything about any of it.

No concern about improving condition to keep doctor we have already trained or finding solutions to lack of training places( I'm not suggest there are any easy solutions)

The social care problem has been visible on the horizon for decades - how to fund and how to get staff - no party wants to deal with it so it's pushed down the line. Now it's so bad it affecting hospitals as the can't discharge people. Every one pointed out the problems with every solution and did nothing about the problem - except with brexit and covid and living cost rises make it worse quicker.

We'll need even more trained doctors in five years time as population increases and more age - doing nothing about lack of training places or increasing students means we know we won't have them. This leaves knowing we will have to poach other countries doctors who will also need them - and that's assuming they'll come here.

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 11:13

Freedomfighters · 21/08/2022 11:11

Yes I do. You only have to follow the news across the world regularly and carefully to see that these things are happening. Neil Oliver is only voicing what I already know.

Ok cool - so his claim on how we're moving to a social credit system where only those that are well behaved will be able to buy things.

How does that benefit a capatalist western government? Why would the Tories want this?

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 11:12

AKnitterofThings · 21/08/2022 11:10

It shocks me to hear those with differing opinions constantly being called ‘conspiracy nut’ ‘loonies’ etc. What is wrong with someone having a different view and why is that so frightening? I home educated my children 20 years ago and I was considered weird, now it is more mainstream, especially since lockdowns. Surely we should all be looking outside of the box rather than just folllwing and doing what we are told. I like listening to differing view points, so that I can make my own mind up about things. If we only accept one narrative then we are no better than North Korea.

If someone, like NO, is rambling through all these claims without presenting any evidence backing them up, then yes I think it's a fair title.

Present a single, well reasoned viewpoint that challenges the "narrative", with credible evidence behind it, and I'll take it seriously.

derxa · 21/08/2022 11:11

An example is covid vaccines - I am fully vaccinated, accept the risk of any side effects is worth the upside of protecting the most vulnerable etc. Last year I met with a male colleague mid 40s who was really healthy, ran marathons etc. He suffered an extreme reaction to the vaccine (think it was called myocarditis), was to do with his heart. He had to be hospitalised and it has had a lasting impact as he can no longer run as before and he needs to be monitored regularly etc. I was pretty shocked when he told me that this side effect was more common than had been reported, I was not even aware it had ever been reported on.
I'm double vaxxed but the vaccine triggered an auto immune disease. This was confirmed by my consultant. I've been through hell. I'm now deeply cynical concerning anything to do with Covid.

Freedomfighters · 21/08/2022 11:11

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 10:35

As to the PPs.

Have you read the full transcript and do think think he's providing credible evidenec for what he's claiming? @Freedomfighters

Yes I do. You only have to follow the news across the world regularly and carefully to see that these things are happening. Neil Oliver is only voicing what I already know.

AKnitterofThings · 21/08/2022 11:10

It shocks me to hear those with differing opinions constantly being called ‘conspiracy nut’ ‘loonies’ etc. What is wrong with someone having a different view and why is that so frightening? I home educated my children 20 years ago and I was considered weird, now it is more mainstream, especially since lockdowns. Surely we should all be looking outside of the box rather than just folllwing and doing what we are told. I like listening to differing view points, so that I can make my own mind up about things. If we only accept one narrative then we are no better than North Korea.

CJsGoldfish · 21/08/2022 11:10

The conspiracy nuts are out in force lately 🙄

Can't we send them off to their own special board out of the way?

CherryGenoa · 21/08/2022 11:09

And I agree with others that our skills at appreciating nuance are diminished and polarisation thinking is dominant.

ClaudineClare · 21/08/2022 11:08

@Bluebellsunderthetrees Yes the WEF has influence, but the likes of NO seem to think that it is secretly running our governments. Your post making connections is a good example of this, making 2+2= something bad.

Is Chelsea Clinton a bad person wishing evil on us all whilst drinking the blood of children in the backroom of a pizza joint?

FOJN · 21/08/2022 11:08

Yes, the WEF and Schwab have ideas. I am asking you what power it and he have to put these ideas into practice? Why have conspiracy nuts people only become fixated on the WEF and Schwab since 2020?

Attendees at DAVO 2022 include 50 heads of state.

Leaders from around the globe to meet in Davos, Switzerland for the World Economic Forum's Annual Meeting 2022.
The meeting is centered around the theme History at a Turning Point: Government Policies and Business Strategies.
Nearly 2,500 leaders from politics, business, civil society and media to participate in the unique spring 2022 Annual Meeting.

www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/05/davos-2022-whos-coming-and-everything-else-you-need-to-know/

I don't think you can read this and claim the WEF doesn't have influence.

EmmaH2022 · 21/08/2022 11:06

Asurvivor · 21/08/2022 11:02

I think the problem is how polarised our thinking has become in the west. Why does everyone need to be fervently for or against something, no middle ground. The left is forever looking for the purest causes and to take the moral high ground - no room for discussion or seeing the other’s point of view. The right seems to be looking for conspiracy theories in everything - again no room for discussion or a difference of opinions. Was it always like this? I thought that the centre was where most people were, where did the possibility of reasoned debate weighing up the pros and cons go to? What happened to finding common ground?

An example is covid vaccines - I am fully vaccinated, accept the risk of any side effects is worth the upside of protecting the most vulnerable etc.

Last year I met with a male colleague mid 40s who was really healthy, ran marathons etc. He suffered an extreme reaction to the vaccine (think it was called myocarditis), was to do with his heart. He had to be hospitalised and it has had a lasting impact as he can no longer run as before and he needs to be monitored regularly etc. I was pretty shocked when he told me that this side effect was more common than had been reported, I was not even aware it had ever been reported on.

I think it is detrimental to the roll out and acceptance of vaccines if side effects are hushed up and the view is pushed that the vaccine is only good. And having geniuine comcerns about the vaccination is only bad. It just gives ammunition to anti-vaxxers that there is a conspiracy going on if the full facts are not presented for people to make up their own minds. And we should be allowed to make up our own minds and not forced to abide by the left wing morally-right groupthink.

We used to be able to have this kind of centre-ground discussion - there are plenty of other examples I could give, so what has happened? I really don’t understand.

agree.

I was accused by a neighbour of being an anti vaxxer...I had two vaccines. You say one word querying the narrative and you are a CT. It's mad.

CherryGenoa · 21/08/2022 11:06

fruitbrewhaha · 21/08/2022 10:12

You should read Naomi Klein The Shock Doctrine.
naomiklein.org/the-shock-doctrine/
It's a few years old now, 2008, but very relevant today. Capitalism requires violence and "shock". The public's disorientation following natural disasters, wars etc is systematically utilised to push through radical political and corporate measures. For instance after the New Orleans flood all the schools were privatised. The disaster response it's self is privatised and corporations profit, which is exactly what we've seen with Covid.

We are all taken for fools.

This. The book is very well researched and contains many supporting references, but for those wanting a summary, this Guardian article will ground you in the basics in about ten minutes.

LondonWolf · 21/08/2022 11:06

Doing that not going that.

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 11:06

I think it is detrimental to the roll out and acceptance of vaccines if side effects are hushed up and the view is pushed that the vaccine is only good. And having geniuine comcerns about the vaccination is only bad.

I was pretty shocked when he told me that this side effect was more common than had been reported, I was not even aware it had ever been reported on.

@Asurvivor

Side effects aren't being hushed up. It is widely known that vaccines can cause myo/pericarditis, and people are encouraged to report this and anything else on the surveillance system used in their country.

Many research groups worldwide have bene looking into, and publishing articles on prevalence, mechanism and prognosis of side effects. It's ridiculous to say otherwise.

It remains the case that it is safer to be vaccinated than not, which is why people get so frustrated with people trying to push cherry picked "statistics" to imply they are not safe.

LondonWolf · 21/08/2022 11:06

Of course! I admire the passion of the man to say what he believes. He will not be seen as PC by many people but thank God for the likes of him, Calvin Robinson, Laurence Fox etc. who are standing up against MSM. Not a popular MN belief, I know but I am entitled to my opinions.

Agree. I don't have to agree with everything they say to be glad they have the right to say it.

Have you actually read the transcript of his latest interview, and do you think he is providing credible arguments for the things he is claiming?

I've read it and I don't know so I will go find out more. What I dislike is the immediate dismissal of his being a crackpot conspiracy theorist without any addressing of what he's actually saying, which makes me suspect that those going that probably know as little as I do.

EmmaH2022 · 21/08/2022 11:05

ClaudineClare · 21/08/2022 10:59

Yes, the WEF and Schwab have ideas. I am asking you what power it and he have to put these ideas into practice? Why have conspiracy nuts people only become fixated on the WEF and Schwab since 2020?

Oh I have no idea. i read the Fourth Ind Rev when it came out in 2016-17.

I suppose certain things became more obvious in 2020, like the HSBC ads, my neighbour told me it was a deep fake when I was surrounded by the ads every time I went through Euston!

If you look at our gov website, you can see how many speeches etc UK govt give at WEF. I'm not sure I get your question. It's like the WHO. Are you going to say they have no influence?

they might seem like a talking shop but all countries at least listen to them. The want a global pandemic response written up now as well - I suspect they will get this. Do you see all international orgs as having no influence?

Asurvivor · 21/08/2022 11:02

I think the problem is how polarised our thinking has become in the west. Why does everyone need to be fervently for or against something, no middle ground. The left is forever looking for the purest causes and to take the moral high ground - no room for discussion or seeing the other’s point of view. The right seems to be looking for conspiracy theories in everything - again no room for discussion or a difference of opinions. Was it always like this? I thought that the centre was where most people were, where did the possibility of reasoned debate weighing up the pros and cons go to? What happened to finding common ground?

An example is covid vaccines - I am fully vaccinated, accept the risk of any side effects is worth the upside of protecting the most vulnerable etc.

Last year I met with a male colleague mid 40s who was really healthy, ran marathons etc. He suffered an extreme reaction to the vaccine (think it was called myocarditis), was to do with his heart. He had to be hospitalised and it has had a lasting impact as he can no longer run as before and he needs to be monitored regularly etc. I was pretty shocked when he told me that this side effect was more common than had been reported, I was not even aware it had ever been reported on.

I think it is detrimental to the roll out and acceptance of vaccines if side effects are hushed up and the view is pushed that the vaccine is only good. And having geniuine comcerns about the vaccination is only bad. It just gives ammunition to anti-vaxxers that there is a conspiracy going on if the full facts are not presented for people to make up their own minds. And we should be allowed to make up our own minds and not forced to abide by the left wing morally-right groupthink.

We used to be able to have this kind of centre-ground discussion - there are plenty of other examples I could give, so what has happened? I really don’t understand.

LemonSwan · 21/08/2022 11:02

Well have to say the man has a point if he what he’s saying about the farmers is true.

Why are we not having a dig for victory style push. Why are farmers being encouraged to sell? I would have thought after Brexit it would have been an ideal time to invest in more food infrastructure. Why do we not have banks of glass houses at the ports like they do in Netherlands.

Its strange. Have to agree with him about that tbh.

Perhaps it’s not a nefarious conspiracy and instead some kind of culture problem? Gov think farmings beneath our economy 🤷‍♀️

goshy · 21/08/2022 11:02

Do you think if this protest took place in China or Russia it would last any longer than an hour? With military involved? So they were bloody lucky to be in a democratic country like Canada.

Yes let's be more like China & Russia 🙄

DrBlackbird · 21/08/2022 11:01

HoppingKangaroo · 21/08/2022 10:39

Also just look at what happened to the trucker protests in Canada - Trudeau froze their bank accounts. Something a dictator would do - not something in a free democratic country were people should have the right to free assembly.

People have the right to peaceful free assembly. They do not have the right to obstruct or break laws of that country. This month long blockade was an unlawful demonstration that created chaos for ordinary Canadians and was leading to loss of jobs and income for many ordinary workers.

The anti-vaccination protest blockade was condemned by the Canadian Trucking Alliance and Canada’s Teamsters Union as about 90% of Canadian truck drivers were already vaccinated and relatively few of those protesting were actually professional truck drivers. Moreover, this protest took place in Canada yet strangely protesters wore Trump and MAGA hats and donations to the protesters flooded in internationally, particularly from Florida.

Trudeau had to act. Freezing bank accounts was actually strategic and clever because it didn’t use overt force that could have so easily escalated. So I was glad that Trudeau finally stepped in and took action… after a month. Do you think if this protest took place in China or Russia it would last any longer than an hour? With military involved? So they were bloody lucky to be in a democratic country like Canada.