Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we being taken for a fool.?

317 replies

Indoctro · 21/08/2022 06:16

Have you watched this video by Neil Oliver

AIBU to start believing he actually has a valid point. I am not normally part of the tin foil hat brigade but I most definitely have been starting to question what's been going on recently

I'd be interested to hear other people views on this subject.

Thanks

OP posts:
MindBodyChocolate · 21/08/2022 10:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

johnd2 · 21/08/2022 10:04

This is full of suppositions about motivations and very little actual facts. I think never attribute to malice what could be sheer incompetence.
I think I'll stick with the guardian for now. They do a much better job of exposing important facts (if you look at the right sections of the web site)

AKnitterofThings · 21/08/2022 10:03

Big Neil Oliver fan here. He is one of my heros and I enjoy his GB News monologues. I suppose that makes me a bit of a loony on MN.

FOJN · 21/08/2022 10:02

DogInATent

My you got a good long post out of a cherry picked quote. Well done you.
I'd have more respect if you had included the final sentence in that paragraph but I suspect it would have denied you the opportunity to present yourself as clever and well informed whilst you told the rest of us what we us all already know.

Anothernamechangeplease · 21/08/2022 10:01

I really fear for our democracy when I read threads like this. How can we possibly expect anything other than corrupt, incompetent government when people lack critical thinking skills to the extent that they believe shit like this.

goshy · 21/08/2022 10:01

But there is no point lamenting the situation in my eyes without a solution.

ZandathePanda · 21/08/2022 10:00

OP watch The Undeclared War.

I think there’s more than a few Russians trying to stir up conspiracy theories on twitter to get people freaked out. Just look at how they are controlling the narrative on Ukraine to their own country. Look at the Cambridge Analytica scandal too. Data harvesting to try and manipulate votes.

Every so often they will ‘get’ a more persuadable person. They use data to profile you in order to create more unrest. The aim is to destabilise.

The question is, are you the one trying to cause chaos or the suggestible person who spouts it forward? 😉Or is the Russian theory a conspiracy too?!😁

GoWokeGoBroke17 · 21/08/2022 10:00

ClaudineClare · 21/08/2022 08:39

So we have shadowy forces that are powerful enough to be secretly doing whatever it is the likes of NO think they are doing.

Why aren't these all powerful shadowy forces shutting down the people shouting about their dastardly secret plans on YouTube and Mumsnet etc? Perhaps they are not so powerful after all...

Trump, Jordan Peterson, Tony Heller and many more have all been banned on twitter for speaking out against the mainstream narrative.

Until you actually try to speak about these things you won’t understand the censorship you will face.

I know someone who has run a profitable website for the past four years, but because it goes against the narrative it has been repeatedly de-monitised by Google, his social media was all ‘shadow banned’ where he would get thousands of followers removed daily, people would message him and say that they repeatedly follow him but then the next day they have been removed. Now some of his social media have just been outright banned.

This site isn’t ‘tin foil hat’ stuff, it’s weather, it uses scientific studies and all facts are backed up, but again it just doesn’t fit the narrative so it just gets banned.

Youtubers get ads removed ALL THE TIME for the same reason.

If you are not part of the fight you don’t see the censorship that is everywhere- and therefore are part of the problem.

And the fight being literally just free speech, whichever side of the debate you may be on.

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 09:59

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 09:58

When it has a robust evidence basis.

Which none of the things he was rambling about do @lightand

I'd suggest you "open your eyes" to how much money someone can make from posting these kinds of articles & videos. And how posting rational but boring explanations gets you barely any clicks.

There are certainly people being taken for fools here.

MsRosley · 21/08/2022 09:59

goshy · 21/08/2022 09:32

@MsRosley what do you think the solution is?

@goshy I honestly don't know, but if you look at the statistics for the massive decline in insect and animal numbers over the last 50 years, the natural world is clearly in crisis. Globally humans are using resources at a rate that would require there to be at least two planets unless we cut down. None of this is sustainable, even without taking climate change into account.

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 09:58

lightand · 21/08/2022 09:36

More and more people coming round

At what point does a conspiracy theory become mainstream?

When it has a robust evidence basis.

Which none of the things he was rambling about do @lightand

JocelynBurnell · 21/08/2022 09:57

Is Neil Oliver trying to take us for fools.

These theories on youtube can be a nice little earner.

Riverlee · 21/08/2022 09:56

Third time lucky!

vaxxers

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 09:56

Indoctro · 21/08/2022 09:54

So people are focusing too much on who the video is by

Forget Neil my point is I was already starting to question what is happening in the world and then I came across his video and he basically is also questioning what is going on

Is anyone starting to ask / think why .? That is what I meant.

See above @Indoctro

I didn't outright dismiss because it was Neil, I read through the entire transcript.

Yes he is still talking bollocks.

With the classic "OPEN YOUR EYES" line at the end. CBA with this nonsense.

Sirius3030 · 21/08/2022 09:56

CornishGem1975 · 21/08/2022 09:08

I don't generally believe in conspiracies but fuck me, the further we go into this shit show I'm starting to hope this is all part of a bigger plan and not just the fact that we continually elect shambolic people to manage the country.

Usually cockup rather than conspiracy.

orbitalcrisis · 21/08/2022 09:55

I thought it was all rumour, conspiracy and myth but here you are, GB New's viewer.

Riverlee · 21/08/2022 09:55

vaxxers

oops, link fail.

Riverlee · 21/08/2022 09:55

Vaxxers

Whether you’re a pro or ant-vaxxer, I think everyone should read the book Vaxxers. It’s written by the scientists who were there at the forefront, developing the vaccine, the science behind it, the previous vaccine developments and processes which led to the quick roll out of the covid vaccine. It’s a fascinating insight and well worth reading.

foliageeverywhere · 21/08/2022 09:54

From the transcript:

the idea of cash being ultimately replaced with transactions based on the exchange of what amount to glorified food stamps that will only be accepted if our social credit score demonstrates that we’ve been obedient girls or boys …
This is a popular CT, but has no benefits to a capatist Western Government. Literally no rational as to why they would want this.

Then there’s the so-called vaccines for Covid – I deliberately say “so-called” because by now it should be clear to all but the wilfully blind that those injections do not work....of countless deaths and injuries caused by those medical procedures.
Cba to engage, but feel free to AS me and what I posted on the last thread about this guy & his anti-vaccine agenda.

...Raid the house of Donald Trump. Meanwhile Joe Biden and his son Hunter – he of the laptop full of the most appalling and incriminating content – fly together on Airforce 1. No raids planned on the Obamas, nor on the Clintons.
Grin

Yup he's still talking absolute bullshit @Indoctro ...that's 10 mins I'll never get back.

Indoctro · 21/08/2022 09:54

So people are focusing too much on who the video is by

Forget Neil my point is I was already starting to question what is happening in the world and then I came across his video and he basically is also questioning what is going on

Is anyone starting to ask / think why .? That is what I meant.

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 21/08/2022 09:53

user1471505356 · 21/08/2022 09:47

Another David Icke?

Yes, I think you're right. The problem today is that he is one of many so it's harder to spot.

WeAreTheHeroes · 21/08/2022 09:51

I started to read the transcript but had to give up. This kind of thing is always presented in a way that makes the supposed "truth speaker" superior. It's always highly emotive and light on actual facts.

With the proliferation of social media anyone can find support for their own illogical, minority viewpoint these days.

We don't live in a global dictatorship where Spectre pulls the strings. There's a pandemic. The vaccines lessen the effects of the virus. I was vaccinated against whooping cough in the 70s but still got it, to a far lesser degree than my unvaccinated sibling.

Argh - please people stop listening to this shit and employ some critical thinking.

user1471505356 · 21/08/2022 09:47

Another David Icke?

CrunchyCarrot · 21/08/2022 09:46

I occasionally listen to Neil Oliver on YT but of late (like so many others, e.g. John Campbell) he has started going down the conspiracy rabbit hole. It's really so sad. He seems now full on anti-vax:

Then there’s the so-called vaccines for Covid – I deliberately say “so-called” because by now it should be clear to all but the wilfully blind that those injections do not work as advertised. You can still contract the virus, still transmit the virus, still get sick and still die.

He is just so wrong, I wish to goodness he would listen to proper virologists!! He is supposedly educated but yet chooses to believe rubbish - because he wants to and it fits his own agenda.

As for the rest of it, again, he's going Great Reset on us, isn't he.

It’s hard to think that all of it, all the misery, all the suffering of the past and to come might just be about money, greed and power. It is hard to tell yourself you’ve been taken for a fool and taken for a ride. It’s hard, but the view from the other side is worth the effort and the pain. Open your eyes and see.

Yes, I do agree re greed/power/money but I think he (and others) are distorting things as well. When people say they don't listen to/believe MSM (mainstream media), well, who then are they listening to? Another lot of brainwashers on bitchute etc!

Yes we do need to take care of our natural world but it's going to be an epic battle against large conglomerates - is it a conspiracy on their part? No I don't believe so. Is our world being deliberately sabotaged? No, it's just a very sad consequence of greedy stupid humanity. Maybe however it will still end up in the same (bad) place regardless of how we get there.

DogInATent · 21/08/2022 09:46

Anyone even mildly curious should be wondering about things like why energy suppliers are posting record profits whilst we, the consumers, are seeing our bills rise at an alarming rate

Because these are only contradictions to people that don't think, aren't that bright, or haven't attempted to think about how the world works. Fortunately for the conspiracy grifters there are a lot of people in those categories to sell their tinfoil hats to.

Primary energy prices are rising because the West has chosen to restrict the availability of gas and oil from Russia as a sanction on Russia for invading the Ukraine. But we still need the same amount of energy to generate power, heat homes, run vehicles, as feedstocks, etc. So the market price has risen because everyone's chasing a smaller pool of 'politically ethical' oil and gas. But it hasn't become more expensive to produce, so the primary producers that get the oil and gas from the ground are seeing their profits rise. The gas and electricity coming to your home comes from distributors that buy energy at mix of forward and spot market prices. Their costs have risen, which is why your bill has gone up (and why so many energy distribution suppliers have gone bust). The company you pay your bill to are unlikely to be seeing record profits from the rising prices.

Prices for energy in the UK are rising faster than elsewhere in Europe purely because other European governments have chosen to intervene. The UK Conservative government seems to be adopting a minimal intervention approach and hoping that we can all cut back on usage. Other European countries are in a worse strategic position than the UK (Germany has been overly dependent on Russian gas and is working double-fast to fix this before winter) but have decided to act to reduce the impact on consumers and business.

And Neil Oliver is an ).(