Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will you/have you stopped buying “branded” food?

163 replies

BabyofMine · 21/08/2022 00:48

I remember a few years back a nice thread about what branded foods were good and worth the cost. I remember a lot of people thinking Napolina tomatoes were really tasty compared to “own brand” tinned tomatoes.

With the price of food going up and up, I wonder whether the devotees of certain brands will be still getting them because they’re worth it, or making sacrifices to save some money?

So if you’ve been a devotee of a name brand food, are you giving it up?? What would you be really reluctant to ever compromise on? What’s a false economy? I’m not asking if you are going to be making savings/changes overall, but if you were really dedicated to one particular brand would you give it up??

My favourite “branded” thing is Hellman’s mayonnaise and I’m not planning on giving it up but I am using a lot less and being more careful to only put a little bit on my plate so I don’t waste it.

YABU= I will NOT be giving up my favourite branded foods.
YANBU= I will be giving up my favourite brands to save money.

OP posts:
daisychain01 · 21/08/2022 07:49

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 21/08/2022 01:57

I will compromise on absolutely everything.... except marmite. Own brand "yeast extract" is disgusting and should be banned.

The good thing about products like Marmite and Heinz tomato ketchup is they aren't fast moving, unlike a tin of beans or chopped tomatoes - you can buy them once in 3-6 months at £3 a time, so to my mind, why compromise, just enjoy 👍

Tesco chopped tomatoes are staple foods in our house, once mixed with a squirt of concentrated tomato and fresh basil leaves (torn not cut, if you're a Jamie Oliver fan!), you can't tell the difference.

Drivebye · 21/08/2022 07:48

I buy the products I think are the best not because they are a brand. For example
I will look at egg content in mayo, how many ingredients there are and how much added sugar there is.

There are some products where we prefer branded: Weetabix but otherwise I experiment to find preference. (I know btw that I am lucky I can afford to chuck crap stuff)

ivykaty44 · 21/08/2022 07:47

I’ve swapped lots of branded stuff warburtons for Aldi toastie loaf and as the most recent. Not nice for sandwiches but fine for toast.

my neighbour used to work in Banbury for a bakers that supplied M&S, Aldi etc and the only thing that changed was the bags on the production line to denote the supermarket

ivykaty44 · 21/08/2022 07:46

Example is tried Aldi biscuits and they were not pleasant at all, kind of chemical taste to them so this worries me about the ingredients used and whether they are more harmful for your health?

you can make biscuits easy enough and freeze the dough in balls - just pop them in the oven when you want a biscuit - then you know exactly what has been put in the baking

ivykaty44 · 21/08/2022 07:44

Ive never purchased branded goods, I just purchase the items needed and what looks best value. TBH if your the worried about taste of mayonnaise, make it from eggs and oil as its not difficult or make sauces to go with meals or bake beans in bulk and freeze

I use laundry powder for. lights and liquid for darks - any brand

lillipilli · 21/08/2022 07:44

I am prepared to try any substitutions but one thing that’s really bugging me is the quality of some own brand stuff. Example is tried Aldi biscuits and they were not pleasant at all, kind of chemical taste to them so this worries me about the ingredients used and whether they are more harmful for your health?

womaninatightspot · 21/08/2022 07:42

I’ve swapped lots of branded stuff warburtons for Aldi toastie loaf and as the most recent. Not nice for sandwiches but fine for toast. My last two brands I can think of is Yorkshire teabags but only on special offer and hp sauce.

I always buy decent toothpaste though, oral b brush heads and those little plastic toothpicks for in between teeth. I had to have a root canal last year. Multiple appointments, 100 quid and that was NHS, time of work etc. I feel like decent dental hygiene is a long term cost prevention exercise.

SwordToFlamethrower · 21/08/2022 07:41

I don't buy anything branded. You're only paying extra for the cost of their advertising anyway. I used to buy proper pespi/coke but the aldi version is so good, and less than 40p, so now I have absolutely nothing branded anymore.

RoseAndRose · 21/08/2022 07:40

I am using a lot less and being more careful to only put a little bit on my plate so I don’t waste it

That's how things should be all the time. Reducing consumption (in this case literally!) is good for the planet, and in reducing the obesogenicity of society (not saying you're fat, OP, just like I'm not saying you're single handedly responsible for environmental crisis, rather that individual choices help frame social norms)

Whatthetrolley · 21/08/2022 07:38

If I buy branded things, it's because they are on offer. Cereal is the main one has to be Kellogs rice krispies or cornflakes. Although my son wanted mini chocolate Weetabix and the price has shot up so I bought him Asdas own and he seems quite happy.

I will not compromise at all on Diet Coke but again it is bought when in offer. Recently I got 4 x 24 pack for £28 so happy to pay £7 per pack. Morrisons had it for £5.99 a pack earlier in the yer, that's the best price I've seen it.

DogsAndGin · 21/08/2022 07:37

No chance. It’s motivated me to buy and eat less but better food. I would rather eat simply and have the very best bread and cheese money can buy than eat a cheap unhealthy processed dinner.

BooksAndHooks · 21/08/2022 07:35

The only branded stuff we have now is Pepsi max and vege stuff like quorn as there are no alternatives to that.

AuntieStella · 21/08/2022 07:35

I'm going to be dreadfully po faced and say that I've never gone in for branded goods (except for Heinz beans, tomato soup and ketchup - which I think is more being accustomed to a specific taste than quality) and Marmite.

So I wont be changing away from the brands I buy as there weren't very many of them in the first place.

Mol1628 · 21/08/2022 07:33

I tried to give up cathedral city cheese but the alternatives are horrible. The Lidl brand one is probably second best so when I do get to a Lidl I’ll buy that.

fufflecake · 21/08/2022 07:31

I think if I were having guests round and cooking I might go for the fancier tinned tomatoes though

fufflecake · 21/08/2022 07:31

I've not bought branded stuff for years. We buy it on occasions like if my DSC are coming for the holidays I might buy some branded cereal but I think that's just about it.

orbitalcrisis · 21/08/2022 07:31

Ergh! I can't believe ho many people like Heinz ketchup! The last time I had it it was all watery and far too sweet. I like nice rich, thick tomato sauce.

Fifife · 21/08/2022 07:29

We have given up lurpak more for the principle I've noticed the price has since come down! So lots of people must have decided they didn't want to pay it greedy company. I love Hellman's mayonnaise I can't give up branded crisps they just taste a lot better. I can taste no difference in ketchup I normally just get the Sainsbury's own brand.

InChocolateWeTrust · 21/08/2022 07:23

I dont buy masses of packaged food and never think there's much difference between different brands when it comes to (for example) flour or sugar or dried beans/pulses.

I do like lurpak butter but I suspect I would like other lactic butter too it's just that I don't see any other brand sold in the supermarket I usually go to.

We are on v high incomes so won't make any major changes to what food we buy. We have become over recent years much more waste conscious though and eat less meat than we did.

mathanxiety · 21/08/2022 05:27

The only items I won't give up are Tetley teabags and Lavazza coffee.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 21/08/2022 04:57

TeapotTitties · 21/08/2022 00:50

I think probably the only branded food regularly bought in this house is Heinz ketchup. I can't think of anything else really so no, we won't be giving it up.

I used to think that, then we got given Tesco own brand as a substitution, and it was fine . I can tell the difference, but it's amazing how quickly we got used to the Tesco one.

Probably about half my food shop is branded and half own brand. I agree about Hellmans mayo, I've never found an own brand that is half as good. We also always have Hovis 7 seed bread as our regular sliced loaf and I've never found a decent substitute for it.

I think we will move to more own brands, but not the "value" range. Not yet, anyway.

pounchill · 21/08/2022 04:12

Heinz spaghetti hoops.Have tried loads of options and serve them up to family without telling them and they won't eat others because they are crap. Most alternatives are identical but surely there's a cheaper can of hoops around !

Housenoob · 21/08/2022 03:53

There are only two things I won't compromise on, everything else I've not bought branded for years:

  • Cola. Would never buy anything other than Coke/Coke Zero.
  • Baked beans must be Heinz or Branston. Own brand beans are disgusting and I always feel like I can actually taste the sugar in them
BarbaraofSeville · 21/08/2022 03:38

We've always had a lot of own brands anyway and don't like Heinz beans, Branston are far better.

For mayonnaise we get it from Aldi and I saw a taste test recently that said it was most like Hellmans.

But I don't understand what people are doing with all the ketchup. A bottle will last us for about 2 to 3 years yet some people seem to be buying it nearly every week Confused

Gingerkittykat · 21/08/2022 02:44

I thought i couldn't give up Heinz ketchup but bought Asda brand, it is different but we soon got used to it.

Lidl Danepack isn't as nice as Lurpak but is half the price so we will keep it.

Asda beans and sausages were disgusting, I'll be trying other brands before I go back to Heinz though.

Tesco own tomato soup was very similar to Heinz, but Asda's one was bitter and not as creamy.

I now need to find a cheaper decaff coffee.