Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Luxury hotel for one night or caravan for a week?

38 replies

SeasonsOfLife · 20/08/2022 23:41

I was just having a little debate on this one.
With my family (dh and 2 dc under 4) I prefer having one or two nights away in a luxury family friendly hotel in the UK rather than a whole week in a caravan. Whereas some of my friends would go for the latter and think I'm weird for only opting for 1 or 2 nights. But I think it's quality not quantity. I'd prefer to pay the same price as a week in a caravan, on a nice hotel with a big bedroom, activities for the children, swimming pool, good food, gardens, etc... to be looked after basically.
Opinions please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
rookiemere · 21/08/2022 13:18

I think it depends very much on the location- if you're going to be out all day, then why spend money on expensive accommodation.

Also if I have to share a room with DS, then it's less of a holiday so for the last few years we've done 3 star hotels with suites or adjourning bedrooms rather than sharing a room at somewhere swankier.

At caravan sites we tend to go for a lodge rather than a caravan so we get a bit of comfort, but still have the space.

Now DS is 16 he doesn't want to go on holiday with it, so enjoy it whilst they do.

Testina · 21/08/2022 12:36

I don’t think “quality vs quantity” is the right comparison. The hotel simply doesn’t beat the caravan park on measures of quality for all children. Entertainment, for example - Haven is much better quality for a most young children than a hotel. You might not like a cheesy disco and a trashy arcade -but many young children LOVE them!

mycatisannoying · 21/08/2022 10:18

Two nights away in the luxury hotel. Sans enfants Grin

WonderingWanda · 21/08/2022 10:17

A luxury hotel would be wasted on my kids and I wouldn't be able to enjoy it. I presume you'd all be in one room? My kids sleep talk and snore and would need to go to sleep early so we'd be sat in the dark waiting for them to sleep. A caravan is a much better holiday for kids, separate bedrooms, lounge space, usually near a beach and a fun pool. Kids love it. When I stay in luxury hotels it is without my kids so I can stay up late drinking cocktails, lounge about reading in a huge bubble bath, maybe go to the spa, read a paper over breakfast. None of these things happen with children in tow.

MsJuniper · 21/08/2022 10:07

We love a caravan holiday and I enjoy making the space nice when we get there. Even the basic ones have plenty of room for what we need and we use them as a base for excursions.

Recently however, PILs booked a smart hotel for a weekend as a treat and despite my reservations about the children, they had a whale of a time and enjoyed the novelty of the hotel restaurant, swimming pool and grounds.

I'd say caravan in sunny/hot weather when you are out and about all the time, hotel if booking out of season as they won't want to leave the luxury!

GoAround · 21/08/2022 09:52

I agree with you! If you want hotel recommendations, Four Seasons Hampshire is ahmazing for young families.

womaninatightspot · 21/08/2022 09:45

I’m with you. I sometimes go to Crieff hydro for the night with the kids. You can use the facilities from the morning of arrival. So we go early, swim, brilliant free childcare in afternoon and I go for a massage/ haircut. Cinema in evening. Pizza delivery from place in Crieff. Hang around till 4 next day, redoing it all. Kids have fun, I always get home feeling really relaxed. Much better than a week somewhere rubbish where I have to do everything I would at home but without facilities like a hoover that sucks or a dishwasher.

Juicesausagecake · 21/08/2022 09:40

The Ickworth is awesome. I have been to Moonfleet, Fowey Hall and the Ickworth. It is the closest you can get to a holiday with small children, and I feel like I have tried all options, including camping and the caravan. Camping is my second favourite.

Whaleandsnail6 · 21/08/2022 09:37

I love a caravan holiday. Especially something like haven when the kids were little. But when we go away, we don't spend a lot of time in our accommodation, so I'm happy with cheap and basic for a longer amount of time than something a bit posher for shorter time. We've just done 2 weeks camping (with electric,couldn't have done without that!) and loved it.

Happymum12345 · 21/08/2022 00:35

There are different levels of caravans out and sites out there. They are much more fun for children of that age to stay in, but It depends on what you want out of a holiday.

Mumspair1 · 21/08/2022 00:29

Definitely a hotel over a caravan. I would choose a hotel with lots of things to do though or at least something nearby. We have done this many times with dc. I can go for a luxury spa treatment while dh takes dc to an activity. At those ages OP I think you can easily do a hotel over a caravan holiday.

converseandjeans · 21/08/2022 00:28

Surely there is something in between? I think children would prefer a week in a caravan. I don't think a posh hotel is the right place for small children - it's the type of place people go with no kids to get away.

swg1 · 21/08/2022 00:26

SeasonsOfLife · 21/08/2022 00:21

@swswg1 totally agree with you regarding safety and I'd feel the same.

Love the idea of a holiday cottage. However my 3yo ds has potentially got adhd (awaiting assessment) and can be impulsively destructive or like a bull in a china shop and dd is only 1 and is into grabbing everything! I would be on edge the whole time that they'd destroy the place. So again, maybe when they're a bit older.

Oh you can totally find lovely family friendly cottages - I've been doing it for years! Stay away from AirBnB cos you're right, a lot of people there are basically renting out their own space and it can be a bit of a nervy thing with tinies. Look for people who rent cottages out as part of a regular thing - cottages on farms are often great and the ones set up for kids expect them to be kid-like. We've stayed some lovely places where they took my kids to gather eggs from hens and stuff. Check reviews and be picky but I promise the GOOD cottages are amazing and fine for tinies.

swg1 · 21/08/2022 00:23

SeasonsOfLife · 21/08/2022 00:15

@GhoulWithADragonTattoo maybe one day we'll try it. We have done 2 short breaks in hotels as a family of 4 which were good. But I purposely chose big family friendly places with a swimming pool, games room and acres of gardens. I suppose I just imagine caravans being restrictive.

So for around the same price as a night you can get something like this for a week:

www.countrycottagesonline.com/england/devon/combe-martin/the-linhay-at-wheel-farm-cottages-cc-3737.html

(I have not stayed here, it's just the top option on a quick search for places with pools)

I would hands down prefer that tbh. Not because of price. There would be more space for us to spread out in, less people to share the pool with. We could eat out - just because you're not in a hotel doesn't mean there aren't nice places to eat nearby. And I've stayed in a lot of hotels with work - even the nice ones don't have particularly thick walls. A family friendly one sounds like paying to listen to someone else's baby scream all night.

SeasonsOfLife · 21/08/2022 00:22

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 21/08/2022 00:18

I am sure the guests in a hotel would prefer you went to a caravan..

Thanks for that 😬

OP posts:
SeasonsOfLife · 21/08/2022 00:21

swg1 · 21/08/2022 00:12

I would be really hesitant about taking other services from a hotel that thought that was okay tbh. Like that is a big enough difference in "what is safe" from my opinion that I wouldn't want to leave my kids with them unsupervised by me because I'd struggle to trust them.

You will find other child-friendly holidays - it doesn't have to be a caravan or nothing. I'm typing this from an amazing cottage right now and I have zero regrets on my holiday choice. But honestly I'd give this one a swerve for safety reasons.

@swswg1 totally agree with you regarding safety and I'd feel the same.

Love the idea of a holiday cottage. However my 3yo ds has potentially got adhd (awaiting assessment) and can be impulsively destructive or like a bull in a china shop and dd is only 1 and is into grabbing everything! I would be on edge the whole time that they'd destroy the place. So again, maybe when they're a bit older.

OP posts:
Creepymanonagoatfarm · 21/08/2022 00:18

I am sure the guests in a hotel would prefer you went to a caravan..

Antarcticant · 21/08/2022 00:17

Caravan, but I'd choose that even if they cost the same.

HeddaGarbled · 21/08/2022 00:15

It would be selfish to spaff the family holiday budget on one night in a posh hotel. That’s not what the children would get much out of and you know it. Fine before you have children, fine when they’re off your hands, not fine when planning a family holiday.

SeasonsOfLife · 21/08/2022 00:15

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 21/08/2022 00:08

With 2 under 4s caravan will be much for fun. Go to one with entertainment and a pool and it will be great. A posh hotel with tiny kids you will be on edge the whole time and won't enjoy it.

@GhoulWithADragonTattoo maybe one day we'll try it. We have done 2 short breaks in hotels as a family of 4 which were good. But I purposely chose big family friendly places with a swimming pool, games room and acres of gardens. I suppose I just imagine caravans being restrictive.

OP posts:
swg1 · 21/08/2022 00:12

I would be really hesitant about taking other services from a hotel that thought that was okay tbh. Like that is a big enough difference in "what is safe" from my opinion that I wouldn't want to leave my kids with them unsupervised by me because I'd struggle to trust them.

You will find other child-friendly holidays - it doesn't have to be a caravan or nothing. I'm typing this from an amazing cottage right now and I have zero regrets on my holiday choice. But honestly I'd give this one a swerve for safety reasons.

CuriousMama · 21/08/2022 00:11

TypeMite · 21/08/2022 00:09

I'd rather die than stay in a caravan so definitely the hotel!

Quality over quantity

Bit extreme

TypeMite · 21/08/2022 00:09

I'd rather die than stay in a caravan so definitely the hotel!

Quality over quantity

SeasonsOfLife · 21/08/2022 00:08

swg1 · 21/08/2022 00:06

Wait wait.

Baby monitoring and babysitting Enjoy a grown-up dinner date by taking advantage of our complimentary baby monitoring. This system allows you to personally monitor your child from anywhere in the main hotel on a handheld device. Simply request the service from Reception and they will provide you with the equipment you need along with details on how to use the system. Please note that a deposit of £150 will be added to your room until the device is returned to Reception. This service is not available in The Lodge, however, we can organise a babysitter – often our own Den team. Please contact our Reception team to book.

This super-expensive hotel is offering me.. a fancy baby monitor so I can pretend I'm not leaving my under 8s alone in my room whilst I'm elsewhere in the hotel? Ahahaha. Hell no. I consider myself a pretty relaxed parent but the "And if there was a fire alarm then what?" here is not even worth thinking about.

@swg1 yes, that bit didn't convince me either I have to say. Not keen on that idea and wouldn't do it. Buy the rest of it I like the sound of.

OP posts:
GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 21/08/2022 00:08

With 2 under 4s caravan will be much for fun. Go to one with entertainment and a pool and it will be great. A posh hotel with tiny kids you will be on edge the whole time and won't enjoy it.