Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think divorce is sometimes unfair to the higher earner?

85 replies

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 21:31

I went to see a solicitor and they told me I'm in an awful position. I have worked my arse off, doubled my salary in 4 years and set for another promotion in a few months. I bought a flat years ago, did it up and sold it for a big profit (before meeting DH) and put all the profit into our family home (joint mortgage)

DH has halved his salary in the same time period. He wants to be a 'house husband' and spends a lot of his time telling me to 'push myself' and asking what I can do to earn more.

I didn't mind, thought it could work quite well, but he hasn't picked up any of the house or childcare stuff. And just sleeps and sits around and goes to the pub. We pay for childcare even on his days off so he can 'do house things, find other work, clean' but he doesn't do anything of the sort. I have talked to him about it. he gets grumpy.

Anyway - the solicitor told me that basically he could end up with quite a bit more than 50% of the house because he'd struggle to get mortgage on his salary for a 3 bed house - so will need a much bigger deposit to buy a house suitable for the kids

And lawyer told me that I can expect 50/50 with DC (they are v little) but DH could go for more as the kids get older, he coudl easily argue that I have much less and it makes more sense.

If he got more than 50/50, I could end up losing my house and kids.

I obviously think it's fair if the woman has sacrificed her career to look after kids for her to get a 50% share etc, but what if you're the higher earner AND look after the kids and home. Is it really fair I have invested in my career and our home and he's done FA and I end up worse off than him???

I have to stay with him don't i? There is no abuse. I just don't love him. He's like a lazy difficult teenage son moping around my house while I get on with everything.

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 20/08/2022 22:09

I knew someone in your position - the woman wasn't a high earner by MN standards but he got residence of their child and she had to pay to support him. Despite the fact that he'd been a waster his whole life.

Rainbowqueeen · 20/08/2022 22:06

The problem is not that you are the higher earned. It’s that your H Is not contributing in a meaningful way to the relationship.

The solicitor has given you a “what could happen” scenario. My view from what you have written is that your H will have no interest in being a parent and you will have the DC all the time within a year of your divorce.
Yes he will get a substantial portion of the joint assets. But the assets will continue to grow over time.

In your shoes I’d get on with the divorce now. If the kids are only little then he’s less likely to want to care for them. Your pension is a marital asset. Better off losing part of it now rather than in 10 years. Ending it now gives you time to rebuild your life.

Perhaps seek a few other opinions from solicitors and also ask about the scenario in 10 years time do you can compare.

RunningSME · 20/08/2022 22:03

I definitely agree with see more than one solicitor I had some absolutely shit advice off one, The one I ended up representing me wasn’t a lot better but they were slightly.

you don’t actually need them to do the paperwork or even represent you in court but you do need to take their advice write everything down and follow it.

YellowPlumbob · 20/08/2022 21:59

You pay for childcare, so that should prove he is not a stay at home parent reliant on your income

GiltEdges · 20/08/2022 21:58

You need a better solicitor. Get a second opinion and plough on. It sounds like your life with be infinitely for the better with him out of it, you have to hold on to that. We only get to live once.

Tandora · 20/08/2022 21:58

I don’t get it, why would he get more that 50/50 custody?

SpinCityBlues · 20/08/2022 21:55

Paperwork is your friend.

underneaththeash · 20/08/2022 21:54

Stop paying for childcare on his days off then.

IncompleteSenten · 20/08/2022 21:38

it's fair if either one of you has sacrificed their career to look after kids for them to get a 50% share etc, but he is royally taking the piss.

I'd pay a solicitor who specialises in this area to advise. You need a second opinion I think.

If he is not in fact doing the child care and you can prove this with childcare expenses then he'd have a hard time claiming to be a sahp surely?

ColdCottage · 20/08/2022 21:37

I have no legal knowledge but could you do a few things like maybe buy a 3 bed property to rent near by while your assets are combined. Then when things are split it's reasonable to ask him to move in there.