Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think divorce is sometimes unfair to the higher earner?

85 replies

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 21:31

I went to see a solicitor and they told me I'm in an awful position. I have worked my arse off, doubled my salary in 4 years and set for another promotion in a few months. I bought a flat years ago, did it up and sold it for a big profit (before meeting DH) and put all the profit into our family home (joint mortgage)

DH has halved his salary in the same time period. He wants to be a 'house husband' and spends a lot of his time telling me to 'push myself' and asking what I can do to earn more.

I didn't mind, thought it could work quite well, but he hasn't picked up any of the house or childcare stuff. And just sleeps and sits around and goes to the pub. We pay for childcare even on his days off so he can 'do house things, find other work, clean' but he doesn't do anything of the sort. I have talked to him about it. he gets grumpy.

Anyway - the solicitor told me that basically he could end up with quite a bit more than 50% of the house because he'd struggle to get mortgage on his salary for a 3 bed house - so will need a much bigger deposit to buy a house suitable for the kids

And lawyer told me that I can expect 50/50 with DC (they are v little) but DH could go for more as the kids get older, he coudl easily argue that I have much less and it makes more sense.

If he got more than 50/50, I could end up losing my house and kids.

I obviously think it's fair if the woman has sacrificed her career to look after kids for her to get a 50% share etc, but what if you're the higher earner AND look after the kids and home. Is it really fair I have invested in my career and our home and he's done FA and I end up worse off than him???

I have to stay with him don't i? There is no abuse. I just don't love him. He's like a lazy difficult teenage son moping around my house while I get on with everything.

OP posts:
category12 · 20/08/2022 23:04

silentpool · 20/08/2022 22:59

You are better off divorcing in the long run OP. However, get your ducks in a row - stop paying for childcare and make life less comfortable for him. This may encourage a return to full time work.

Could you drop down a day for a period of time to reduce the disparity in incomes until after the divorce? So you are both part time?

No, OP shouldn't stop the childcare if she wants the dc 50/50 or more - she doesn't want him to actually provably be looking after the dc more than she does.

If anything, she should start doing more of the pick-ups, but definitely keep the childcare going.

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 22:59

@ReneBumsWombats I did say this to the solicitor and he said I could get social services involved if I thought they're in danger. I don't really. He does bare minium parenting. He will give them his phoen so he can play video games but he will keep a vague eye on them. with dinner...I finish work and ask what they've had for dinner and he says "oh I haven't done that yet" and it's 6.30pm and they need to go to bed in 30 mins. But he'd do it if I wasn't coming home. I bloody hope he would anyway. So it's not dangerous, but they're better off at nursery

OP posts:
silentpool · 20/08/2022 22:59

You are better off divorcing in the long run OP. However, get your ducks in a row - stop paying for childcare and make life less comfortable for him. This may encourage a return to full time work.

Could you drop down a day for a period of time to reduce the disparity in incomes until after the divorce? So you are both part time?

TheBestBitch · 20/08/2022 22:59

He’s a disrespectful lazy twat

get a good lawyer and leave

it’s annoying but leave now while they’re small, he’ll be expected to work and the longer you leave it the worse it’ll be

onthefencesitter · 20/08/2022 22:57

This happened to my MIL. She raised 4 kids while working and her ex did FA (didn't work and was in bed all day) for maybe 15 years (supposed to be raising the kids after losing his job but my MIL did the earning, cooking, cleaning and childcare). In the end, she remortgaged her house and gave him £110k (this was over 10 years ago before the prices of London terraces really exploded and the house was probably undervalued too). She said that while it was painful as she was on a low income, she felt it was worth it in the long run as it was 1 payout rather than her having to support him for the rest of her life

She kept the house (he wanted her to sell it and downsize with 4 kids in local schools!). He never paid a penny in child support despite the youngest being 10; my DH was 18 when the divorce came through. He has moved overseas with the 110k and now has a new wife. Didn't come to any of his kids' weddings. I have only met him once and so have his children since he left.. he only came back as his parents paid for him to see his mum one last time. He didn't want to pay for youngest daughter to visit him either

I think it was really unfair.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/08/2022 22:56

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 22:52

But he sees himself as a "modern man" and modern dad because he "supports his wife to pursue her dreams"

Supporting his wife = telling me to get promoted so we can afford this and that while still expecting me to clean the loo.

Never mind his personal narrative. Ignore it, means nothing, not your problem. Look to what's best for you and your kids. This isn't it.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/08/2022 22:54

he is verging on the neglectful (forgetting dinner, getting absorbed in computer games)

IANAL but surely this counts against him in awarding custody? If he's forgetting to feed them? How old are they, are they safe while he's absorbed in gaming?

Agree with PP that it's better to split the assets before they grow any bigger...and before harm is done to the children.

goshy · 20/08/2022 22:54

honestly I advise every women to marry to protect themselves except high earners/rich woman. In order to protect yourself don't marry.

I'm also a bit hypocritical as I have no problem with a SAHM getting 50/50 in the divorce but if I was the high earner & the SAHD wanted 50/50 they can feck right off.

RunningSME · 20/08/2022 22:53

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 22:50

@houseonthehill I do cleaning and kid admin in between meetings. The kids go to nursery more than they need to because he is verging on the neglectful (forgetting dinner, getting absorbed in computer games), he forwards me emails from his own mother in the hope I'll reply. We agreed he take more of a house husband role and go down to a couple of days a week and yet he barely goes into work, and chills the rest of the time. I promise this isn't like some entitled husband complaining his wife hasn't done the dusting.

In your scenario I’d just offer him 10 grand to sling his hook. If he’s not working you’ll be able to do to him exactly what my ex did to me and utilise the fact that he won’t be able to afford to Solicitor.

NoSquirrels · 20/08/2022 22:53

He won’t want them 50-50.

Do not stay with him.

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 22:52

But he sees himself as a "modern man" and modern dad because he "supports his wife to pursue her dreams"

Supporting his wife = telling me to get promoted so we can afford this and that while still expecting me to clean the loo.

OP posts:
audeloquipalam · 20/08/2022 22:50

RunningSME · 20/08/2022 22:14

Does it actually though because I don’t know any women who are stay at home moms and don’t actually do the cleaning or indeed the childcare, do you ?

You might not.

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 22:50

@houseonthehill I do cleaning and kid admin in between meetings. The kids go to nursery more than they need to because he is verging on the neglectful (forgetting dinner, getting absorbed in computer games), he forwards me emails from his own mother in the hope I'll reply. We agreed he take more of a house husband role and go down to a couple of days a week and yet he barely goes into work, and chills the rest of the time. I promise this isn't like some entitled husband complaining his wife hasn't done the dusting.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 20/08/2022 22:48

I have to stay with him don't i?
No you do not, YABU to think you do. Cut your losses. 50/50 now is much less than what 50/50 will be in x years time. After divorce, he will be expected to find work and support himself. No judge is going to rule that you have to keep him in the lap of luxury for life. To be fair, many women didn’t “sacrifice their career” plenty of them have sat at home and done nothing but run up credit cards. Yes divorce is unfair to the higher earner, but the sooner you make a clean break the better off you will be.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/08/2022 22:43

I think you need to think of it as what the CHILDREN need. He gets money for a house yes, but that's because the children need somewhere to stay when they're with him.

The paid childcare surely means he can't argue he's a SAHD when he's not actually looking after them. And would be even want >50% if he can't be arsed to look after them now? That's what I'd fight for, the children to not be with him more than needed.

Divorce, suck up the split, and you can move on free of this lazy gobshite.

category12 · 20/08/2022 22:42

You may lose out in the short-term but you're a grafter, have a high income and are looking at promotion. There's no reason you can't divorce and put yourself back into a great position financially. Might be worth holding off on accepting the promotion if that's possible until you divorce.

You'd be silly to stay just because he will take some of the assets - which he will need to give the kids a decent time when they're with him.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/08/2022 22:41

I were in your very same situation if we decided to get a divorce early on in our marriage. Now my dh is taking home 7 figures

Your husband halved his salary in four years, wanted to be a househusband, did absolutely nothing around the house, used childcare on his days off and is now earning a million a year?

user1487768885 · 20/08/2022 22:36

I think this pretty sums up marriage. It's all about trust & sacrifice. I were in your very same situation if we decided to get a divorce early on in our marriage. Now my dh is taking home 7 figures
Marriage is a risk but for most people the best thing ever happened to them

I'm so sorry that it has not worked out for you but don't ever give up your search for happiness

Jet27 · 20/08/2022 22:27

Yes definitely, and especially if the higher earner is a woman but has maintained the more traditional gender role of housekeeper/default carer of children, at least when around, which is often the case.

I was in a very similar position to you except, to be fair to my ex, he was quite a decent sahd when the dc were very little. However, he had not given up any career to do that and was making it very clear he had no intention of bringing money in once the dc were at school.

I was quite lucky in that when we split (his decision - affair) we had very little in the way of assets as we'd just moved to a bigger house so there wasn't much equity. The only other asset was my pension, which he didn't want. My solicitor said that as there was so little equity a judge wouldn't force a sale as ex would have had no chance of getting a mortgage due to lack of job/terrible credit history. However, had there been loads of equity we'd probably have had to sell, which would have been a nightmare. As it was I bought him out with the maximum I could borrow at the time and have to give him a further £10k for his share when ds2 is 21 in 8 years. That's fine, but what does piss me off is that he has paid no CMS by not working/doing ad hoc shit since we split, so I feel I will subsidise him forever, really.

He could have gone for rp or whatever it's called now but he didn't want to. He did try and insist on having them 50% of all holidays despite me being a teacher and having agreed to work f/t while they were babies knowing I would have the holidays. He had me in tears at the mediator over that one but in reality has never had them in the holidays any more than he does in term time, except for 2 weeks away his dm has paid for in an 8 year period. I expect it will be the same for you as if he can't be arsed now it's not likely he will change. I think the system is set up to imply that whoever is the breadwinner must have had a slightly lesser role in the home and when that's not the case it can feel really unfair. Really unfair.

You won't lose your kids - you do everything for them and they will realise that easily as they grow older. Definitely see another solicitor and get rid of him. Even if you do end up out of pocket, which you will, and have to go through some tough times, it will be so worth it not to be dragging that dead weight around the dc will be able to see a clear contrast between the two of you, rather than maybe wondering why you enabled him when they are older.

HeadNorth · 20/08/2022 22:21

My useless alcoholic uncle still enjoys a share of my lovely aunts civil service pension. Yup, divorce is great if you are a useless waster, sucks if you are a worker.

houseonthehill · 20/08/2022 22:20

I don’t know any women who are stay at home moms and don’t actually do the cleaning or indeed the childcare, do you ?

Actually, yes, similar accusations about laziness, leaving the kids with her Mum, the state of the house etc. It's often irrelevant to the divorce, except perhaps in judging who is the primary carer.

Merryoldgoat · 20/08/2022 22:18

houseonthehill · 20/08/2022 22:11

This sounds very similar to what blokes post online when grumbling about the likely outcomes of an impending divorce.

It does indeed.

Merryoldgoat · 20/08/2022 22:18

That’s what marriage is. If you don’t want that risk then don’t marry.

RunningSME · 20/08/2022 22:14

houseonthehill · 20/08/2022 22:11

This sounds very similar to what blokes post online when grumbling about the likely outcomes of an impending divorce.

Does it actually though because I don’t know any women who are stay at home moms and don’t actually do the cleaning or indeed the childcare, do you ?

houseonthehill · 20/08/2022 22:11

This sounds very similar to what blokes post online when grumbling about the likely outcomes of an impending divorce.