Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think divorce is sometimes unfair to the higher earner?

85 replies

MirrorM · 20/08/2022 21:31

I went to see a solicitor and they told me I'm in an awful position. I have worked my arse off, doubled my salary in 4 years and set for another promotion in a few months. I bought a flat years ago, did it up and sold it for a big profit (before meeting DH) and put all the profit into our family home (joint mortgage)

DH has halved his salary in the same time period. He wants to be a 'house husband' and spends a lot of his time telling me to 'push myself' and asking what I can do to earn more.

I didn't mind, thought it could work quite well, but he hasn't picked up any of the house or childcare stuff. And just sleeps and sits around and goes to the pub. We pay for childcare even on his days off so he can 'do house things, find other work, clean' but he doesn't do anything of the sort. I have talked to him about it. he gets grumpy.

Anyway - the solicitor told me that basically he could end up with quite a bit more than 50% of the house because he'd struggle to get mortgage on his salary for a 3 bed house - so will need a much bigger deposit to buy a house suitable for the kids

And lawyer told me that I can expect 50/50 with DC (they are v little) but DH could go for more as the kids get older, he coudl easily argue that I have much less and it makes more sense.

If he got more than 50/50, I could end up losing my house and kids.

I obviously think it's fair if the woman has sacrificed her career to look after kids for her to get a 50% share etc, but what if you're the higher earner AND look after the kids and home. Is it really fair I have invested in my career and our home and he's done FA and I end up worse off than him???

I have to stay with him don't i? There is no abuse. I just don't love him. He's like a lazy difficult teenage son moping around my house while I get on with everything.

OP posts:
MirrorM · 21/08/2022 09:33

I don't think the solicitor was saying this is definitely what would happen but it was that 30 min free advice and she was giving me poss outcomes. She said she thought the hardest thing would be the house...because his salary is low he would need a much bigger chunk of the equity to afford a 3 bed house for both DC and that he would be likely to get that. I understand it is for the kids. Which I get. But it would sting. If Dh was going to be a mature, loving co-parent then absolutely fine but him getting a nice chunk of equity and house so he can have the kids over and then ignore them/cover it in coke and beer cans etc is pretty rubbish.

Think she was just giving me a reality check. I'm trying to be pragmatic and work what best for the kids and me longterm.

I could run this ship by myself and I would love to. But its not as simple as that.

I do feel guilty or weird about him not being able to afford legal advice though. He has no savings and often has 50 quid or so left at the end of the month. He has no family with money.

I sound like a controlling husband. I'm really not. He wants to be like a teenage boy. He even jokes and calls me "the mother".

OP posts:
StellaGibson2022 · 21/08/2022 09:03

See another Sols - plenty of divorced women who were stay at home mums have needed to get a job/better paid job post divorce. Why would it be any different for your husband?

Also 50/50 is the starting point for finances, not a given. You need a better solicitor.

houseonthehill · 21/08/2022 08:58

I wasn't accusing you of anything personally, OP. It just struck me that the solicitor's advice/guidance was identical to the advice/guidance given here about marital assets etc. with the sexes reversed. And how often men grumble about similar divorce settlements elsewhere, using similar language.

marblemad · 21/08/2022 04:07

Gather any evidences you can to prove he caused a hostile environment and pushed you into a situation where you are both the primary carer and earner for the children. Get better legal advice and with evidentiary backup and better legal support you could easily go for a more proportional split (if you can prove he does nothing and forced you into that situation) and get primary custody of the children. If you aren't going for primary custody however then expect a 50/50 split until the youngest is 18.

pounchill · 21/08/2022 04:06

Just stop supporting his lifestyle. Make him contribute equally to the house and bills and work as hard as you do. It's not that easy to divorce and win, as you have kids and he's still the dad.

MangyInseam · 21/08/2022 03:54

Yes, there is a lot of scope in a divorce to screw over the other person, and sometimes it is the higher earning individual who ends up screwed.

ChloeKellyIsAnIcon · 21/08/2022 03:48

Well it's not really being a high earner that's the problem. It's having a lazy arse for a husband!

Divorce him OP. Bite the bullet and take the financial hit now. It will probably get worse the longer you leave it. And surely he won't want to have the DC more than 50% of the time if he's so lazy?

Coyoacan · 21/08/2022 03:10

I sounds like you can afford a shit hot lawyer and that it would be worth it. The one you have is extremely pessimistic at least as far as the children are concerned. Everything indicates that you can prove that he hasn't been a SAHD

TooBigForMyBoots · 21/08/2022 02:52

I'm sure it is. No system is perfect.🤷‍♀️

FollowYourOwnNorthStar · 21/08/2022 02:47

I can’t help with the decision to divorce or not - that has to be your personal decision - but from RIGHT NOW you need to get good advice about your position and how to improve it. You have sleepwalked into this position now - don’t want a year when it’s worse because he has dropped down more days and/or given up work entirely, AND your pension has grown (that you might need to give him a share of) AND your house equity has grown (that he will get a share of).

At a minimum, get him back to 5 days/week working and make sure he has a pension that he is paying into (hopefully this will reduce what he can claim from yours), and start saving a chunk of money in cash slowly withdrawn each week as you
do other things.

And I agree with others as to finding a solicitor who represents high earning women. They will no doubt have other excellent ideas, especially around keeping paperwork etc as to the kids attending nursery when he is home.

Overall, it sounds like it will be a financial hit, but better to do it now and you can recover (especially pensions and home equity) rather than later when you have more in both to lose and less time to make them up. But you have to be certain you want too.

KohlaParasaurus · 21/08/2022 02:42

I agree with the advice previous posters have given to divorce him now, take the inevitable financial hit, and reclaim your future. You'll still have your ability to earn well and rebuild your savings and pension. He's not going to improve and you'll lose more if you wait.

I had something similar happen in my first marriage. Handing over a large chunk of assets to the layabout my XH had become stung at the time, but I've never regretted divorcing him.

JacquelineCarlyle · 21/08/2022 01:15

goshy · 20/08/2022 22:54

honestly I advise every women to marry to protect themselves except high earners/rich woman. In order to protect yourself don't marry.

I'm also a bit hypocritical as I have no problem with a SAHM getting 50/50 in the divorce but if I was the high earner & the SAHD wanted 50/50 they can feck right off.

I agree with this.

Starhaf · 21/08/2022 00:30

I was in a similar position. Ex(d)h and i were both hardworking, worked for others initially and then self employed - earned similar amounts & had a good lifestyle. We sold one business, kept the other and went back to being employed due to the lengthy unsociable hours and having a young child. Business profits went into house equity.

Ex(d)h became extremely lazy, dropped to part time hours (ok, as we still had one business) but then out of the blue & with no discussion quit input into the business. Without his input the business could not work & so it had to be parked. I worked hard, took several promotions, 2 hours commute per day, did a masters degree on top of full time working and did all the child admin and most of the housework. He chose to work part-time at just above minimum wage and continually turned down offers of promotion and opportunities to undertake qualifications which would improve his earning potential. He chose not to pay into a pension, despite receiving sound financial advice, until the latter years of our marriage when he paid a small amount into a private pension.

When it came to divorce, I was given the same advice as you were about likely asset split due to a) his comparative lack of earnings; b) his age (11 yrs older than me; c) length of marriage (27 years) d) his claim that he needed to be home for childcare reasons (albeit our child was then 17!). Don’t forget he will also have claim on your pension as well as the house and any assets!! Mediation was a non starter. The legal advice was to agree a 50/50 split of everything (including pensions) as going to court to settle would be costly & may well result in him being awarded more than 50%.

I was happy with 50/50 of house equity & assets - but devastated that in this situation he had a claim on my pension funds. I offered him more than 50% house equity in recognition that he would find it harder than me to get a mortgage if he would leave my pensions alone -but he followed his solicitor’s advice to go for my pensions, not realising that while the £s sounded high, he wouldn’t be able to access the cash without a heavy tax penalty. So now he has little prospect of a mortgage (it dragged on for years), house prices have rocketed and he cant just cash in the pension pots he’s acquired - So he’s a bit stuffed really! 🙄

Capturetotalelotion · 21/08/2022 00:29

Get a better solicitor and get rid. My DSIS didn’t do this and she is still working herself into the ground while he DH does the bare minimum and is the opposite of supportive. She still has a nanny with two secondary age kids and one off to uni as he can’t be trusted to be sober enough around the kids. He is in and out of work. Don’t do it to yourself. Good luck OP.

Styperbolic · 21/08/2022 00:27

Definitely find a different solicitor. Preferably one who is both female and successful (like you) and who specialises in divorce

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 21/08/2022 00:18

YANBU. And while I'm not quite in the same position (not contemplating divorce but am getting ticked off at the basic lack of any proactive, well, anything, from husband) this would definitely be the case should we divorce. He's been a SAHD for years now, and while the mortgage is in both our names, it was all my money that was put down. And obviously he has not contributed financially at all while he's been out of work.

smileandsing · 21/08/2022 00:17

It is a terribly unfair system when it comes to cocklodgers, which is what your H seemingly is.

I'd start taking responsibility for the children and the house away from him completely. That way you can prove that he hasn't gone part time or 'given up his career' to raise the children when he tries to use that to get the house and/or be the resident parent. You can already evidence that as you're paying for childcare on his days off. Make sure it can't be disputed. Don't tell him what you're doing obviously.
Make it clear to him that you expect him to work full time, just like you do. That way he can't say you agreed to the arrangement.

Another option if you can afford it, and your employer allows, is to flip things so you work part time and take on the bulk of the child caring and household responsibilities, even just for a while to see things through.

There's no way you won't lose financially while he gains, but you can try to minimise the impact.
When it comes to the children try to think about what is best for them, not either of you.

I looked at all this when being the only earner in the household on a very good salary. Because I basically did everything household and child related, paid for everything, etc. while he lay around on the sofa all day, and I could evidence that I was entitled to the greater share of everything, and would be resident parent and have the greater amount of time with our child. He had no intention of taking on even 50% of the child caring responsibilities though, but the fact I could prove I did it all, and paid for everything while he contributed nothing financial or practical was what swung things my way.

Hankunamatata · 21/08/2022 00:09

Did you ring fence your deposit for family home? Does your dh work?

Kylereese · 21/08/2022 00:08

I agree OP it’s not fair to you.

same as when women walk away with lots of a man’s financial benefit because they raised the kids when in reality they were just never interested in careers or high earnings to begin with (not a criticism).

Goldbar · 21/08/2022 00:05

Of course you shouldn't stay. Sunk costs fallacy. You're better off paying what you have to and ditching him asap.

LittlePurplePetunia · 20/08/2022 23:35

audeloquipalam · 20/08/2022 23:34

Reading this thread I’m starting to wonder. Was my ex a fanny lodger? I don’t know if the term exists but she certainly displayed all the symptoms.

She could well have been!

audeloquipalam · 20/08/2022 23:34

LittlePurplePetunia · 20/08/2022 23:27

Get a new solicitor who is ruthless to get rid of this cocklodger. Personally I wouldn’t rock the boat with him, I’d smile and put up with his shit then smack him in the face with a ton of bricks legally, just like I did with my ex husband. Meanwhile smile and nod, be extremely pleasant to him (although I know it’s fucking hard), play the long game ☺️

Reading this thread I’m starting to wonder. Was my ex a fanny lodger? I don’t know if the term exists but she certainly displayed all the symptoms.

LittlePurplePetunia · 20/08/2022 23:27

Get a new solicitor who is ruthless to get rid of this cocklodger. Personally I wouldn’t rock the boat with him, I’d smile and put up with his shit then smack him in the face with a ton of bricks legally, just like I did with my ex husband. Meanwhile smile and nod, be extremely pleasant to him (although I know it’s fucking hard), play the long game ☺️

audeloquipalam · 20/08/2022 23:26

goshy · 20/08/2022 22:54

honestly I advise every women to marry to protect themselves except high earners/rich woman. In order to protect yourself don't marry.

I'm also a bit hypocritical as I have no problem with a SAHM getting 50/50 in the divorce but if I was the high earner & the SAHD wanted 50/50 they can feck right off.

Hypocritical but honest. You are rare, but that isn’t due to your fundamental position.

ILoveMonday · 20/08/2022 23:17

Your solicitor sounds a bit shit if she's telling you to give him 50% of everything. I think you need to find a solicitor that will emphasise the fact that you are doing everything and his contribution is minimal. He hasn't really supported you in your career and unless it's been a particularly long marriage 50% of everything is a big ask.

The way I would try to negotiate this would be to say that he can have 50% of the house as a clean break settlement. Given that you both have jobs he shouldn't need his ex-wife's money.