Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men holding hands in the Street

537 replies

girlfriend44 · 20/08/2022 20:00

Saw two men walking along hand in hand earlier and I admired their bravery and thought hope nobody starts on them.
Have seen women before but not men?
Do you think they were brave. Would you be scared for them if they were your sons?
Brave men. Perhaps it's something we will see more of in the future?

OP posts:
phishy · 21/08/2022 01:47

You always seem inordinately worried about men in your threads OP.

In an earlier thread today your response to a post about men being responsible for 97% of violent crime was ‘women are violent too’.

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 01:40

CareeringLi · 21/08/2022 01:38

There's a pattern of posts developing on this thread.

Poster shows up, doesn't read thread. Announces how homophobic the OP is, witters about it being 1982, enlightens the thread as to how cool and inclusive their bit of the world is, and how no eyelids are batted, etc.

They then get told why their attitude is absolutely "I don't see colour" and their so-cool-I've-never-see it bleating misses the point entirely.

Next, the same posters start flapping and lashing out and chucking their words/insults around about how misunderstood they are and how they DO IN FACT tick every box going that enables their narrow POV, so we can all fuck off because they've been there, man. Well they haven't, but they know someone who has.

Then another poster shows up who tells the OP to get back to 1970, when that POV was last aired...etc.

Loopity loop.

Yup.

CareeringLi · 21/08/2022 01:38

There's a pattern of posts developing on this thread.

Poster shows up, doesn't read thread. Announces how homophobic the OP is, witters about it being 1982, enlightens the thread as to how cool and inclusive their bit of the world is, and how no eyelids are batted, etc.

They then get told why their attitude is absolutely "I don't see colour" and their so-cool-I've-never-see it bleating misses the point entirely.

Next, the same posters start flapping and lashing out and chucking their words/insults around about how misunderstood they are and how they DO IN FACT tick every box going that enables their narrow POV, so we can all fuck off because they've been there, man. Well they haven't, but they know someone who has.

Then another poster shows up who tells the OP to get back to 1970, when that POV was last aired...etc.

Loopity loop.

Linning · 21/08/2022 01:28

Lesbian here, and yes of course it’s brave, being gay is still illegal in most countries and being assaulted for being gay is still fairly common.

And whilst holding hands for two women is more common I still have to be very aware of where I am at and who is nearby if I am going to indulge in any kind of PDA with another woman, as the threat is still very real so yes if I was a gay man I would probably fear even more as people tend to have an even more adverse reaction to gay men vs women.

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 01:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No, actually. My point is that I don’t have it hard at all. I have experienced no horrors whatsoever. Your reading comprehension, much like your ability to create a coherent argument, is not great.

You started this exchange, not me. The irony of you accusing anyone else of making this thread (that you’ve been all over since long before I turned up) about themselves is delicious. And now I really am going to stop rising to this nonsense and leave you to it.

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 01:15

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 21/08/2022 00:59

As you’ve just called me ‘a straight person’, clearly listening (or reading) isn’t something that interests you.
No they didn't, they said if you're in an opposite sex relationship then you're not going to get the same prejudices as if you were in a straight one, are you.

Nope. They said, verbatim: Holding hands is brave, whether you see that or not as a straight person. To me, a person who is not straight. And they haven’t disagreed that they called me straight.

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 01:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 01:13

Molly887 · 21/08/2022 00:58

Yeah, if you’re claiming there’s no homophobia in
Hackney, you can go whistle. I genuinely don’t understand the point you’re trying to make. Homophobia exists. Pretending otherwise does no favours to anyone. I have absolutely no idea what you’re trying to do here unless it’s to
undermine people in ss relationships.

I never said homophobia didn’t exist in Hackney.
I said that two men holding hands wouldn’t be a remarkable sight in Hackney (directly answering the OP’s question). You think that is ‘undermining same sex relationships’, but you referring to me as ‘a straight person’ is fine? That’s supportive of the queer community, is it? Such grotesque hypocrisy. You ‘go whistle’.

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 01:08

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 00:52

Terribly sorry, but when no homophobic attacks have happened, there's no statistical record!

You seem terribly upset at the idea that you might be less right-on than you think. And I'm sorry for that. You also seem to believe it's 'bi erasure' that you're in a relationship with a man, and that this materially changes the way your sexuality and relationship status might be interpreted in public. I'm sorry for that too. I'm not totally sure what you want me to do about it? You see, I don't have homophobic bigot friends who'll beat you up when they see you with a man, because they secretly know you're bi. On the whole, this isn't how bigotry works. I have spent a fair bit of my adult life in hetero relationships, and I was very conscious that my same-sex attractions were invisible. No one was beating me up for being attracted to women, because I was in a relationship with a man. It's pretty basic.

The fact we can't ignore is that, where you live, homophobic attacks have happened. It is silly, and naive, to pretend otherwise. It matters because this thread is full of people claiming that 'London' is a safe place for gay people (and gay people who are in visible gay relationships). This thread is full of people mocking the OP for even thinking homophobia exists. That's a really dangerous attitude.

You claim that where you live is statistically safer for queer people than Hackney, but you have no stats on that for either where you live or Hackney. I see.

It’s bi erasure to ignore the decade I lived here when I was with a woman and still felt exactly the same. Safe. Nobody was beating me up then, either. But, ignore that, as it doesn’t fit your (increasingly incoherent) narrative.

Does your bizarre rationale work for everything, then? I’m also Black. Racist crime exists everywhere. It’s considerably less prevalent in certain places. I feel safe where I live, it’s one of the reasons I choose to live here. Am I ‘right on’ because I’m not terrified walking down the street? Am I refusing to be an ‘ally’ (to whom? Myself?) when I say that I and all the Black people I know round here are fairly certain they were not going to get beaten to death by racists? Because Black people have definitely been beaten to death by racists. It’s a thing that happens. And, in your world where logic and stats don’t matter, this apparently means I’m meant to live a life of terror and I’m brave for walking down the street. Anything else is ignoring the fact that racist attacks have happened!

You are ridiculous. I am just going to ignore you, now as you’re genuinely making me feel sick.

alexdgr8 · 21/08/2022 01:03

it's quite normal in the middle east and large parts of asia to see men holding hands, or linked arms, etc.

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 21/08/2022 00:59

As you’ve just called me ‘a straight person’, clearly listening (or reading) isn’t something that interests you.
No they didn't, they said if you're in an opposite sex relationship then you're not going to get the same prejudices as if you were in a straight one, are you.

Molly887 · 21/08/2022 00:58

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 00:47

Oooh, yet more bi erasure on this thread. Well done.

I don’t ‘want’ you to say anything. You tagged me and told me to listen to the experiences of others and I replied in kind. As you’ve just called me ‘a straight person’, clearly listening (or reading) isn’t something that interests you.

Yeah, if you’re claiming there’s no homophobia in
Hackney, you can go whistle. I genuinely don’t understand the point you’re trying to make. Homophobia exists. Pretending otherwise does no favours to anyone. I have absolutely no idea what you’re trying to do here unless it’s to
undermine people in ss relationships.

AuntTwacky · 21/08/2022 00:53

Bi erasure? What on earth is that

Vegay · 21/08/2022 00:52

@Rottenpumpkin with all due respect, if you are not concerned about a cause, and have different priorities, the label of ignorance would not be an insult in that case, just a fact.

Unfortunately, you sound like a very ignorant individual - 'Your lifestyle choice'.

Bet you'd bring back section 28 in a heartbeat

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 00:52

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 00:42

Where are these statistics, please? I’ve asked for them, but they don't appear to be forthcoming. I wonder why?

Yes, crime happens everywhere. That’s the nature of crime. However certain crimes happen significantly less in certain places, to the extent that they are not a major factor in people’s day to day lives. I live here and I’m not scared. Nobody I know is scared. We’re not going to be scared because you think we ought to be.

That’s an interesting ‘translation’. It’s also ignorant bigoted nonsense. The fact that I’m not straight has been overlooked (cool bi erasure! Well done!). The fact that I’ve lived here whilst dating other women is overlooked. The fact that my circle and surroundings are queer are all overlooked.

So, based on the above, I'm now wondering what’s wrong with you. But, to be honest, I’m not particularly invested in finding out. You, my love, can piss right off.

Terribly sorry, but when no homophobic attacks have happened, there's no statistical record!

You seem terribly upset at the idea that you might be less right-on than you think. And I'm sorry for that. You also seem to believe it's 'bi erasure' that you're in a relationship with a man, and that this materially changes the way your sexuality and relationship status might be interpreted in public. I'm sorry for that too. I'm not totally sure what you want me to do about it? You see, I don't have homophobic bigot friends who'll beat you up when they see you with a man, because they secretly know you're bi. On the whole, this isn't how bigotry works. I have spent a fair bit of my adult life in hetero relationships, and I was very conscious that my same-sex attractions were invisible. No one was beating me up for being attracted to women, because I was in a relationship with a man. It's pretty basic.

The fact we can't ignore is that, where you live, homophobic attacks have happened. It is silly, and naive, to pretend otherwise. It matters because this thread is full of people claiming that 'London' is a safe place for gay people (and gay people who are in visible gay relationships). This thread is full of people mocking the OP for even thinking homophobia exists. That's a really dangerous attitude.

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 00:47

Molly887 · 21/08/2022 00:33

I’m a woman in a same sex relationship. I live in London. I’ve experienced shit in Hackney. Not sure what more you want me to say.

Same sex couples are at some degree of risk wherever they are. That includes Hackney. Holding hands is brave, whether you see that or not as a straight person.

Oooh, yet more bi erasure on this thread. Well done.

I don’t ‘want’ you to say anything. You tagged me and told me to listen to the experiences of others and I replied in kind. As you’ve just called me ‘a straight person’, clearly listening (or reading) isn’t something that interests you.

Rottenpumpkin · 21/08/2022 00:46

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 00:31

So, to translate ... a woman with a male partner thinks that no one experiences homophobic violence where she lives. Even though there is evidence that, quite recently, appalling homophobic violence has happened there.

And the answer is 'crime happens everywhere'? Confused
What is wrong with you?!

Why can you not accept that, just maybe, being a person in a hetero relationship, you don't see what people in same-sex relationships see, even in your seemingly safe area of London? Why can't you recognise that what's happened locally to you is really scary?

FWIW, I'm a lesbian living in the arse end of nowhere. There is a lot of homophobic feeling. We've had letters through the door and comments to our faces. But there's no history of any kind of physical attack here. Statistically, where we live is a whole lot safer than where you live. Brushing off hate crimes by saying that they 'happen everywhere' is a really shitty thing to do.

Your lifestyle choice.

No one else cares despite the big fuss the media makes.

Don't flatter yourself.

Rottenpumpkin · 21/08/2022 00:43

LastWordsOfALiar · 20/08/2022 20:09

Where do you live where it isn't?!

My close relative is lesbian and talks about how she'd be worried about being openly gay in most places.

I think you're ignorant to homophobia.

Maybe some people just don't care enough?

You don't get to label others ignorant just because they have different priorities to you.

Such arrogance.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 21/08/2022 00:43

Livelovebehappy · 20/08/2022 23:38

Erm, yes I have. But I think more people have said they’ve witnessed hand holding going unnoticed in cities and towns than not…..

Did you gloss over the posts referring to homophobic attacks in London?

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 00:42

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 00:31

So, to translate ... a woman with a male partner thinks that no one experiences homophobic violence where she lives. Even though there is evidence that, quite recently, appalling homophobic violence has happened there.

And the answer is 'crime happens everywhere'? Confused
What is wrong with you?!

Why can you not accept that, just maybe, being a person in a hetero relationship, you don't see what people in same-sex relationships see, even in your seemingly safe area of London? Why can't you recognise that what's happened locally to you is really scary?

FWIW, I'm a lesbian living in the arse end of nowhere. There is a lot of homophobic feeling. We've had letters through the door and comments to our faces. But there's no history of any kind of physical attack here. Statistically, where we live is a whole lot safer than where you live. Brushing off hate crimes by saying that they 'happen everywhere' is a really shitty thing to do.

Where are these statistics, please? I’ve asked for them, but they don't appear to be forthcoming. I wonder why?

Yes, crime happens everywhere. That’s the nature of crime. However certain crimes happen significantly less in certain places, to the extent that they are not a major factor in people’s day to day lives. I live here and I’m not scared. Nobody I know is scared. We’re not going to be scared because you think we ought to be.

That’s an interesting ‘translation’. It’s also ignorant bigoted nonsense. The fact that I’m not straight has been overlooked (cool bi erasure! Well done!). The fact that I’ve lived here whilst dating other women is overlooked. The fact that my circle and surroundings are queer are all overlooked.

So, based on the above, I'm now wondering what’s wrong with you. But, to be honest, I’m not particularly invested in finding out. You, my love, can piss right off.

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 00:38

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 00:30

If you have stats that indicate gay men are targets of such appalling violence where I live, please share them. Thus far, you’ve linked an article detailing one (horrific) crime.

Me: Hackers is LGBT+ friendly and that wouldn’t be a remarkable sight.

You: For that to be true, Hackney must never have any homophobic crime! I’ve found a homophobic crime, therefore you are wrong! Also, how dare you call your home something I don’t like! You and the other (non white immigrants) who call if that are in a Jilly Cooper novel!

That’s not rational. If you can’t see how it’s irrational, then I’m actually quite sorry for you.

Oh, I'm so sorry. One appalling homophobic attack is clearly fine. Goodness! I'm so embarrassed - I had no idea we were meant to put up with one attack before we started to think about statistics. Blush

redbigbananafeet · 21/08/2022 00:35

SunnyD44 · 20/08/2022 20:34

So common in india

They actually link pinky fingers..

’
@brownbeauty80 this is my kind of holding hands 😆

Are there openly gay men in India?

This isn't a sign of homosexuality. The same as egypt. Before marriage there is a lot of male 'comforting' that happens in Islamic counties.

redbigbananafeet · 21/08/2022 00:33

Jovanka · 20/08/2022 20:11

Where do you live where it isn't?!

Hackney

Glasgow

SarahAndQuack · 21/08/2022 00:33

(Oh, and I've been that woman in a relationship with a man, and I never reached this sort of nasty complacency. It's not inevitable, and you should think why you feel the need to deny the experiences of visibly gay people while you're in an opposite-sex relationship, rather than acting as a member of a LGBT community and an ally.)

Molly887 · 21/08/2022 00:33

Cherchezlaspice · 21/08/2022 00:26

I live in Hackney. I am bi. I have lived in Hackney dating women and I now live in Hackney with my husband. I live opposite a famous queer venue. I worked in a queer bookshop throughout uni. My friends are queer.

This is our experience. The fact that it doesn’t fit into your parochial world view is unfortunate. But, no, two men walking down the street holding hands would not be remarkable here. I wouldn’t think they were brave. I wouldn’t worry about them. I wouldn’t think anything at all. Perhaps YOU should listen to the experiences of others.

This does not mean that homophobic crime never happens here. Crime of all kinds happens everywhere.

I’m a woman in a same sex relationship. I live in London. I’ve experienced shit in Hackney. Not sure what more you want me to say.

Same sex couples are at some degree of risk wherever they are. That includes Hackney. Holding hands is brave, whether you see that or not as a straight person.

Swipe left for the next trending thread