Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School food in North America - is it that bad?

135 replies

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 18:33

My DD and I were watching a video on 'school food around the world'. The North American meal didn't look very fresh but ok. It was chicken nuggets, very gloopy looking mash, peas, a giant chocolate chip cookie and some tinned fruit. But in the comments loads of people were saying that's gourmet food compared to what you actually get. People saying the food is routinely burnt, under cooked, rotten. Loads of comments all agreeing on this. So I'm just being curious - can it really be that bad? If it was wouldn't parents, teachers and governors complain? And how could they pass an inspection?

OP posts:
SummerLobelia · 21/08/2022 09:01

It's an independent school I should say which is why they can do compulsory school dinners I expect.

SummerLobelia · 21/08/2022 08:57

I am in the south of England and our school is both nut and seed free (so people can't bring in hummus for example as a snack- the sesame seeds).

The school though has compulsory school meals for everyone, no packed lunches with a single exception I can think of (that I personally know of I mean) for a child who had so many allergies that her diet was exceptionally restricted and it was too risky for her to even go into the dining room.

DS1 has an anaphylactic peanut allergy.

I look at alot of youtube videos about school meals. It started because my older DS has alot of sensory issues around food and I was looking for ideas for meal plans that he might be able to cope with. It is another stereotype I am sure but I like the French school meal videos as they are really serious about what they feed children - The Michael Moore one was very interesting (the link should come up below).

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=school+meals+in+france

BigFatLiar · 21/08/2022 08:24

Snog · 21/08/2022 07:51

Interesting that some US states provide free breakfast and lunch for all at school.

There's been some study done (mainly California I think) that found it was cheaper simply to provide free meals for all than have to check eligibility, collect money etc. Some areas have picked up on this and others are opposed on the grounds that it smacks of socialism.

Lemonyfuckit · 21/08/2022 08:20

steff13 · 20/08/2022 20:17

At my daughter's elementary school she gets three choices of an entree every day. So one day it will be a chicken sandwich which is a grilled chicken breast on a bun or maybe a pizza and then there's usually a vegetarian option. You can always have a salad instead of one of the other entree choices. There are two vegetables as a side or fruit and a vegetable everyday everybody gets that regardless of what entree you choose. Oh and you can also choose a peanut butter sandwich if you don't want the salad or one of the other entrees peanut butter sandwiches always on the menu. And there's a dessert, and you can choose to drink water white milk or chocolate milk.

Why do Americans call main courses entrees? Entree means starter in French. What do Americans call starters?

Snog · 21/08/2022 07:51

Interesting that some US states provide free breakfast and lunch for all at school.

NoBarrelOfLaughs · 21/08/2022 06:48

I forgot to mention, this is elementary school.

NoBarrelOfLaughs · 21/08/2022 06:42

I’m a Brit living on the West Coast, and this is our breakfast & lunch menu. It’s ok, my child eats it 2-3 days out of the week. The breads, buns, pizzas, muffins and tortillas are always whole grain or brown bread, which isn’t mentioned, and there’s always fruit and veggies and a small salad bar, as much as they like. There’s a sweet treat most days, which bothered me until I saw it, a cookie is the size of a ritz cracker, so I don’t worry too much about a tiny dessert.
In our school district, everything is free for everyone regardless of income, so free breakfast and lunch, and has been for about four years. They also had pick up spots for meals during lockdown, which I know some families used and appreciated.

School food in North America - is it that bad?
School food in North America - is it that bad?
BritWifeInUSA · 21/08/2022 05:42

I don’t have children but I’ve just looked at our school district website and the menus for this month. It’s not the greatest but it’s not bad either. Everything is served with a side salad, a portion of fruit and a serving of milk. Seems to be similar to what’s offered in UK schools in terms of variety and cost.

MooseBreath · 21/08/2022 05:20

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 22:04

Thank you. What did you bring in your packed lunch?

Generally a sandwich (tuna/ham/turkey, etc), a juicebox, an apple, a granola bar, and a packet of fruit gummies (or some other processed sugary snack).
We didn't bring peanut butter because there was a girl with an anaphylactic allergy in my brother's class, but there was no outright ban (there is now!). Pretty much everyone brought the same stuff for lunches because it was cheap and relatively healthy.

DayYTY · 21/08/2022 00:22

Cheeselog · 20/08/2022 22:02

Allergy rates do vary by country! I'm not sure about the difference between the UK and USA but wouldn't be surprised if peanut allergy was less prevalent in the latter due to the greater popularity of peanut butter, so kids are desensitised to it. Israel has extremely low rates of peanut allergy and this has been put down to the fact that one of the most popular snack foods is peanut puffs (Bamba) which are given to toddlers from a young age.

It was the allergy rates varying per country that I was interested in, as I have read about the difference in Israel.

Both of my children’s school class themselves as “nut-free schools” - their wording - I have no issue with it either way, as neither of my children like nuts anyway, but I had a university flatmate with a peanut allergy, so it is something that I am used to taking into consideration.

agedasiago · 20/08/2022 23:56

There will be a LOT of variation. My experience is in Massachusetts (USA) where breakfast and lunch are currently free (fully subsidised) for all students.

Breakfast is typically at least cold cereal, granola, etc. with milk, yoghourt, fresh fruit, muffins, bagels, toast, cheese, spreads, juice, milk, etc. Maybe more hot/fresh cooked things in a larger school, a small school may only have take-away boxes or bags.

For lunch, where I am there is a main dish (with a veggie option - may be separate or a version, like "assorted calzones" where some are meaty and some are meat-free) plus a "deli station" (DIY sandwiches) and a salad bar. Then there will be at least one steamed fresh vegetable, some kind of starch like potato or rice or noodles, and fresh fruit. Drinks are water, milk (has to be fat free or 1% but includes flavoured milks) and fruit juice. In the high school (age 12+) there are vending machines with juice, energy/sports drinks, sparkling and still water, iced tea, American lemonade, etc. - but Coke, etc. is not allowed.

I don't think the main dishes are all that healthful - it's a lot of chicken, beef (almost no fish or seafood, and I think no pork or ham), burgers and fries, calzones, pizza, pasta "casserole" things, DIY tacos, various "bowls", etc., and they repeat a lot. But the sides are well thought out and nutritious and the deli and salad bars are really nice. I've never heard of anything spoilt or burnt; it just wouldn't be served. Everyone involved in school meals has to have a state-administered children's nutrition and health certification. There are state standards on nutritional balance, calories, etc.

There's also a cool "farm to school" program, Harvest of the Month, which is done state-wide, where they focus on one local crop every month (pumpkins, peaches, cranberries, cucumbers, wild rice, etc.) The cafeteria serves dishes made with that crop locally-grown, there are posters and info sheets and stickers and such, and the high school does an optional informational session for the students with someone like a local farmer, chef, etc. about that item, and students have a chance to share recipes, photographs, creative writing etc.

MuffinMcLayLikeABundleOfHay · 20/08/2022 22:48

 No.

Like @TeacupDrama drama has already said, it's not good practice to have a nut ban on schools. It's not recommended.

shinynewapple22 · 20/08/2022 22:42

MuffinMcLayLikeABundleOfHay · 20/08/2022 21:04

UK secondary teacher here. All of the schools I am involved in are nut free.

They shouldn't be, it's against guidelines. And dd is anaphylactic to peanuts.

@MuffinMcLayLikeABundleOfHay not sure your response to the poster saying their school was nut fee makes sense - did you mean yes they should be ?

viques · 20/08/2022 22:41

If I ever have the misfortune to be reincarnated as a child I hope I am Japanese because Japanese school lunches look amazing.

MuffinMcLayLikeABundleOfHay · 20/08/2022 22:38

Why not?

This has already been dealt with. 🥪

BlackbirdsSinging · 20/08/2022 22:37

Thankfully all the schools in my area are nut free. Can you imagine how scary it would be for the allergic child, their parents and the lunch time staff if it wasn’t.
Its like those awful people on planes who insist on eating their nut snacks and cause terrible allergic reactions in those that are susceptible. I think one poor girl ended up with brain damage as a result.
Thankfully most people are considerate of those who are vulnerable.

ilovepixie · 20/08/2022 22:35

MuffinMcLayLikeABundleOfHay · 20/08/2022 20:21

Why would a chicken sandwich be an entree?

Why not?

savoycabbage · 20/08/2022 22:29

Nut bans in all the schools and nurseries here. If your DC takes something in with nuts they are not allowed to eat it (if it is spotted).

It's that 'if it's spotted' that is the problem and gives a false sense of security.

How can so many schools just flagrantly ignore the advice of Anaphylaxis UK? I'm glad my dd went to schools that followed the guidance.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 22:27

HerRoyalNotness · 20/08/2022 22:15

South Tx here. Elementary have a rule that they have to take a fruit and a vegetable to get the meal rate $2.25 or they’re charged extra. They have fresh salad every day, veg might be cooked broccoli, carrots etc. They do have pizza day once a week, but still gets served with a fruit. They have a sharing table for anything unopened they don’t eat which other kids can choose something from. They’re only allowed water during the day but can have a milk at lunch.

from my older two, in middle school there were two lines. The meal line or the quicker faster food line. My oldest seemed to live on cheeseburgers for 3 yrs. Middle child does the proper meals and there will be chilli’s, curries etc.

no idea at high school, but last week he said lunch was 5 pieces of cantaloupe, a skinny piece of chicken and 2 pieces of bread. Not exactly a full meal for a growing teen.

as for thé PP not finding fresh food in US supermarkets, how ridiculous! It’s the same as anywhere, shop the outside of the store for all the fresh food, meats and dairy. All the processed stuff is in the middle aisles.

Sounds a bit of a mixed bag there.

I have to say at the supermarket I usually go to there is processed food all over not just in the middle aisles, so not sure supermarkets are the same anywhere.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 22:21

savoycabbage · 20/08/2022 22:04

I'm in the South East. Definitely here it is the norm to not allow nuts.

It's standard for nuts to not be used as an ingredient in school meals but I've never come across a nut ban.

Nut bans in all the schools and nurseries here. If your DC takes something in with nuts they are not allowed to eat it (if it is spotted).

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 22:18

TeacupDrama · 20/08/2022 21:59

the anaphylactic society doesn't recommend nut free or indeed any allergen free as it leads to complacency and unfair treatment as a school may ban nuts for a nut allergic child but then won't ban strawberries for a similar severity of reaction, when it comes to anaphylaxis it is the severity of the reaction that matters not the trigger if you have that type of reaction to strawberries / latex / eggs you are no more or less likely to die than someone with similar allergic repsonse to peanuts
this is rarely understood as many believe that anaphylactic reactions to peanuts are worse than anaphylactic reactions to kiwi milk latx etc when they are not

I was always under the impression that nuts were banned in schools as more DC were allergic to those than were allergic to kiwi for example.

OP posts:
HerRoyalNotness · 20/08/2022 22:15

South Tx here. Elementary have a rule that they have to take a fruit and a vegetable to get the meal rate $2.25 or they’re charged extra. They have fresh salad every day, veg might be cooked broccoli, carrots etc. They do have pizza day once a week, but still gets served with a fruit. They have a sharing table for anything unopened they don’t eat which other kids can choose something from. They’re only allowed water during the day but can have a milk at lunch.

from my older two, in middle school there were two lines. The meal line or the quicker faster food line. My oldest seemed to live on cheeseburgers for 3 yrs. Middle child does the proper meals and there will be chilli’s, curries etc.

no idea at high school, but last week he said lunch was 5 pieces of cantaloupe, a skinny piece of chicken and 2 pieces of bread. Not exactly a full meal for a growing teen.

as for thé PP not finding fresh food in US supermarkets, how ridiculous! It’s the same as anywhere, shop the outside of the store for all the fresh food, meats and dairy. All the processed stuff is in the middle aisles.

Nandocushion · 20/08/2022 22:05

DayYTY · 20/08/2022 20:07

I read an article on the BBC news website about how different countries around the world are struggling with food prices. In the US they interviewed someone who was responsible for sourcing good for a school and she commented about when she couldn’t get peanut butter, which the children all love. I was surprised because schools in the UK are now generally nut free and wondered if that’s not normally the case in the US/if maybe there are less nut allergies?

Sorry, not really the point of the thread but it made me think of it!

All the schools my DC went to in the US (not very many tbf) took the view that they simply couldn't guarantee a nut free environment and it was up to students with allergies to keep themselves safe. They didn't serve peanut butter or anything, but they knew students might eat it before coming to school etc so nothing was guaranteed. They were very very strict on the no sharing food rule instead.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 22:04

MooseBreath · 20/08/2022 21:38

Canadian here. My primary school (Reception-Y5) and middle school (Y6-Y8) didn't even have a cafeteria. All lunches were packed from home, but in primary there was milk provided (white or chocolate) if parents paid. High school (Y9-Y12) had a small cafeteria where you could buy pizza, chips, and a few other overpriced greasy options, but the vast majority of students brought food from home, went home for lunch, or walked over to a local takeaway.

Thank you. What did you bring in your packed lunch?

OP posts:
savoycabbage · 20/08/2022 22:04

I'm in the South East. Definitely here it is the norm to not allow nuts.

It's standard for nuts to not be used as an ingredient in school meals but I've never come across a nut ban.