Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School food in North America - is it that bad?

135 replies

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 18:33

My DD and I were watching a video on 'school food around the world'. The North American meal didn't look very fresh but ok. It was chicken nuggets, very gloopy looking mash, peas, a giant chocolate chip cookie and some tinned fruit. But in the comments loads of people were saying that's gourmet food compared to what you actually get. People saying the food is routinely burnt, under cooked, rotten. Loads of comments all agreeing on this. So I'm just being curious - can it really be that bad? If it was wouldn't parents, teachers and governors complain? And how could they pass an inspection?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sashh · 26/11/2022 04:40

FredGarland · 20/08/2022 19:34

I watched a video by Evan Edinger on YouTube this week: he was comparing a New Jersey school menu to two British school menus.

He said that pizza counts as a vegetable - genuinely thought he was joking but this agrees with him 😶

Ketchup is also a veg.

We might serve pizza in UK schools, but not for breakfast.

The UK food sounds really terrible. Who has a 'frozen' salad bar??

I think the not fresh salad and the frozen food were seperate.

Nanof8 · 26/11/2022 02:24

Canadian here. The school lunches at my son's elementary school were awesome. The main lunch lady made a lot of it from scratch. They had things like lasagna, homemade stews, chicken pies, a lot of us parents tried to convince the school to let us come have lunch as well. 😆
Bread was donated from a local bakery. Lots of fresh fruit as we live where there are loads of Orchards.
She would also do up full turkey dinners for special occasions a few times a year.

UndertheCedartree · 23/08/2022 08:24

NoBarrelOfLaughs · 21/08/2022 16:46

A sunrise stick would be a taco stick. We have a large Hispanic population, and lots of Mexican food. Whole wheat tortilla, rolled with meat and cheese filling, so like a rolled up burrito or taco.
A sun butter cup is sunflower seed butter (tastes like peanut butter and has similar protein), in a little cup for dipping crackers into.

Ah, I see, thank you!

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 22/08/2022 22:22

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 20:16

Pizza counts as a vegetable? I have heard of fries be referred to as a vegetable - in an American book I think! I'll check the video out, sounds interesting.

I seem to recall that Reagan classified ketchup as a vegetable in terms of required portions of fruit and vegetables!

There also was a legal speed at which ketchup should leave a bottle lying horizontally on the edge of a table, Heinz used to advertise that their product left the bottle at 0.028 mph!

UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 23:24

EthicDiss · 21/08/2022 15:20

I find it disgraceful too - particularly as we know that poor nutrition leads to poor behaviour and school attainment (for women at least) impacts the health of the next generation.

Really makes me angry that nutrition for kids is not invested in.

I agree, it is so important.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 23:22

EthicDiss · 21/08/2022 11:25

I went to a few schools, including one in North America (public school system), one in Continental Europe (private) and one in the UK (private). Honestly, the Continental European one was streaks ahead of the other two which were pretty comparable. The latter two were both boarding schools and the one in the UK served a very similar menu to the school in the US, unless there was a parental event or another event going on in where there were leftovers.

The menu for breakfast was always cereal or toast with a cup of juice.

Lunch rotated but there was definitely Burger Wednesday, Pizza Thursday and Chip Shop (Fish or Sausage) Friday every week. We did get something that vaguely resembled a roast on Sunday and I cannot remember the rest of the week. We did have a salad bar but it was never fresh; all vegetables were frozen and reheated (grim) and usually it was just peas and carrots, or peas and corn with some form of potato. Or rice, I think we had rice occasionally. I cannot remember what the evening meal was because I basically figured out it was better to cook a simple stir fry or similar in the evenings in the boarding house as we had a couple of hobs we could use. In the boarding house we had access to crappy white bread, jam, margarine, and milk - we could take as much as we wanted but there was an allowance of what each house was given each day.

In Continental Europe breakfast was decent cereals or porridge, you could mix your own muesli, croissants and pastries, cheeses and hams plus as much fruit as you wanted. Lunch (as a boarder) you could either take your own packed lunch, or, as most of the school did, you sat down for a proper meal, starter, main, and desert if you wanted. There was a long rotation period - maybe 4 or 6 weeks and everything was cooked fresh, and sourced from fresh ingredients. Some of the mains I remember were Horse (!) steaks, three vegetables and steamed potatoes, freshly made pizza where you could chose your toppings, Risotto, Pasta, Pork medallions, and lots of vegan options as well. I think we had three or four options for mains a day plus sandwich and salad stations. Dinner in the evening was always a home-cooked meal in the boarding house (there were not as many boarders so perhaps this is why that happened).

The variety of food I could get in the US school was far better than in the UK private school - but the European school topped them both. Needless to say there were virtually no behavioural issues at the European School, very little class disruptions, and people rarely were ill.

At the end of the day school food come down to funding and cost cutting and many schools simply don't see it as a priority, which I find is incredibly sad.

The UK food sounds really terrible. Who has a 'frozen' salad bar??

The European food definitely sounds the nicest!

OP posts:
Cheeselog · 21/08/2022 17:45

DayYTY · 21/08/2022 00:22

It was the allergy rates varying per country that I was interested in, as I have read about the difference in Israel.

Both of my children’s school class themselves as “nut-free schools” - their wording - I have no issue with it either way, as neither of my children like nuts anyway, but I had a university flatmate with a peanut allergy, so it is something that I am used to taking into consideration.

I looked it up after writing this post and it does look like peanut allergy is marginally less prevalent in the US than in the UK, but also the stats aren’t very good. For the US I found between 0.6% and 1.5%, and 2% for the UK, so slightly more here. But on the rise in both countries.

NoBarrelOfLaughs · 21/08/2022 16:46

UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:47

Thank you for that information. I think free breakfast and lunch for all is great.

Especially on the breakfast menu, things I didn't recognise. What is a 'sunrise stick' (I think it was)? And a 'sun butter cup'? And I suppose the other thing that stands out is the ubiquitous chocolate milk!

A sunrise stick would be a taco stick. We have a large Hispanic population, and lots of Mexican food. Whole wheat tortilla, rolled with meat and cheese filling, so like a rolled up burrito or taco.
A sun butter cup is sunflower seed butter (tastes like peanut butter and has similar protein), in a little cup for dipping crackers into.

BlueberryMuffin817 · 21/08/2022 16:10

When I went to school in the 90s/early 00s we did have pizza but it was usually a treat on some Fridays and only a single slice. The portions were always very small but what do you expect for $1.25. I remember there being grilled chicken, pasta, wraps, maybe the occasional chicken burger. You had the choice of milk or chocolate milk and if you didn't want the meal of the day you could buy a sandwich (all different types) or get a salad (I remember all the popular girls ordering the Greek salad). There was one vending machine in the building selling drinks/snacks near the gym but it wasn't turned on until school was finished for the day.

EthicDiss · 21/08/2022 15:20

I find it disgraceful too - particularly as we know that poor nutrition leads to poor behaviour and school attainment (for women at least) impacts the health of the next generation.

Really makes me angry that nutrition for kids is not invested in.

SaintHelena · 21/08/2022 13:01

We need some social scientists to explain these different attitudes. Utterly disgraceful that the meals are so bad in the uk.

EthicDiss · 21/08/2022 11:25

I went to a few schools, including one in North America (public school system), one in Continental Europe (private) and one in the UK (private). Honestly, the Continental European one was streaks ahead of the other two which were pretty comparable. The latter two were both boarding schools and the one in the UK served a very similar menu to the school in the US, unless there was a parental event or another event going on in where there were leftovers.

The menu for breakfast was always cereal or toast with a cup of juice.

Lunch rotated but there was definitely Burger Wednesday, Pizza Thursday and Chip Shop (Fish or Sausage) Friday every week. We did get something that vaguely resembled a roast on Sunday and I cannot remember the rest of the week. We did have a salad bar but it was never fresh; all vegetables were frozen and reheated (grim) and usually it was just peas and carrots, or peas and corn with some form of potato. Or rice, I think we had rice occasionally. I cannot remember what the evening meal was because I basically figured out it was better to cook a simple stir fry or similar in the evenings in the boarding house as we had a couple of hobs we could use. In the boarding house we had access to crappy white bread, jam, margarine, and milk - we could take as much as we wanted but there was an allowance of what each house was given each day.

In Continental Europe breakfast was decent cereals or porridge, you could mix your own muesli, croissants and pastries, cheeses and hams plus as much fruit as you wanted. Lunch (as a boarder) you could either take your own packed lunch, or, as most of the school did, you sat down for a proper meal, starter, main, and desert if you wanted. There was a long rotation period - maybe 4 or 6 weeks and everything was cooked fresh, and sourced from fresh ingredients. Some of the mains I remember were Horse (!) steaks, three vegetables and steamed potatoes, freshly made pizza where you could chose your toppings, Risotto, Pasta, Pork medallions, and lots of vegan options as well. I think we had three or four options for mains a day plus sandwich and salad stations. Dinner in the evening was always a home-cooked meal in the boarding house (there were not as many boarders so perhaps this is why that happened).

The variety of food I could get in the US school was far better than in the UK private school - but the European school topped them both. Needless to say there were virtually no behavioural issues at the European School, very little class disruptions, and people rarely were ill.

At the end of the day school food come down to funding and cost cutting and many schools simply don't see it as a priority, which I find is incredibly sad.

ICaughtTonsillitisFromAFriendsKid · 21/08/2022 11:11

Not the point of the threat at all but I adore how AmEnglish uses entree for main meal, I just think it's really cute.
Also off topic, I have a friend from France who referred to the main as plat de résistance. Loved it!

Fuuuuuckit · 21/08/2022 11:08

MrsR87 · 20/08/2022 21:02

UK secondary teacher here. All of the schools I am involved in are nut free.

Same here,no nuts on the menu at any of the last 3 schools I've worked at. My last school was also halal.

My dc school is completely nut-free due to serious allergies.

A friend worked in US high schools in the 2000s, she often reminisces about carrots and beans being sprinkled with sugar to entice the teens to eat them

UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:55

Holidaydreamingagain · 21/08/2022 09:32

I’m just amazed schools aren’t nut free. I don’t know of a single school, state or private which allows nuts on site

I know! I didn't think any school child got to enjoy a peanut butter sandwich! It seems to vary by area.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:53

SummerLobelia · 21/08/2022 09:01

It's an independent school I should say which is why they can do compulsory school dinners I expect.

When Infant universal FSM came in I know some Infant schools tried to do compulsory school meals but there was a lot of opposition.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:52

SummerLobelia · 21/08/2022 08:57

I am in the south of England and our school is both nut and seed free (so people can't bring in hummus for example as a snack- the sesame seeds).

The school though has compulsory school meals for everyone, no packed lunches with a single exception I can think of (that I personally know of I mean) for a child who had so many allergies that her diet was exceptionally restricted and it was too risky for her to even go into the dining room.

DS1 has an anaphylactic peanut allergy.

I look at alot of youtube videos about school meals. It started because my older DS has alot of sensory issues around food and I was looking for ideas for meal plans that he might be able to cope with. It is another stereotype I am sure but I like the French school meal videos as they are really serious about what they feed children - The Michael Moore one was very interesting (the link should come up below).

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=school+meals+in+france

Thank you for that I'll have a look.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:50

Lemonyfuckit · 21/08/2022 08:20

Why do Americans call main courses entrees? Entree means starter in French. What do Americans call starters?

They call a starter an 'appetizer'.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:47

NoBarrelOfLaughs · 21/08/2022 06:42

I’m a Brit living on the West Coast, and this is our breakfast & lunch menu. It’s ok, my child eats it 2-3 days out of the week. The breads, buns, pizzas, muffins and tortillas are always whole grain or brown bread, which isn’t mentioned, and there’s always fruit and veggies and a small salad bar, as much as they like. There’s a sweet treat most days, which bothered me until I saw it, a cookie is the size of a ritz cracker, so I don’t worry too much about a tiny dessert.
In our school district, everything is free for everyone regardless of income, so free breakfast and lunch, and has been for about four years. They also had pick up spots for meals during lockdown, which I know some families used and appreciated.

Thank you for that information. I think free breakfast and lunch for all is great.

Especially on the breakfast menu, things I didn't recognise. What is a 'sunrise stick' (I think it was)? And a 'sun butter cup'? And I suppose the other thing that stands out is the ubiquitous chocolate milk!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:36

BritWifeInUSA · 21/08/2022 05:42

I don’t have children but I’ve just looked at our school district website and the menus for this month. It’s not the greatest but it’s not bad either. Everything is served with a side salad, a portion of fruit and a serving of milk. Seems to be similar to what’s offered in UK schools in terms of variety and cost.

Yes, it sounds pretty similar.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:33

agedasiago · 20/08/2022 23:56

There will be a LOT of variation. My experience is in Massachusetts (USA) where breakfast and lunch are currently free (fully subsidised) for all students.

Breakfast is typically at least cold cereal, granola, etc. with milk, yoghourt, fresh fruit, muffins, bagels, toast, cheese, spreads, juice, milk, etc. Maybe more hot/fresh cooked things in a larger school, a small school may only have take-away boxes or bags.

For lunch, where I am there is a main dish (with a veggie option - may be separate or a version, like "assorted calzones" where some are meaty and some are meat-free) plus a "deli station" (DIY sandwiches) and a salad bar. Then there will be at least one steamed fresh vegetable, some kind of starch like potato or rice or noodles, and fresh fruit. Drinks are water, milk (has to be fat free or 1% but includes flavoured milks) and fruit juice. In the high school (age 12+) there are vending machines with juice, energy/sports drinks, sparkling and still water, iced tea, American lemonade, etc. - but Coke, etc. is not allowed.

I don't think the main dishes are all that healthful - it's a lot of chicken, beef (almost no fish or seafood, and I think no pork or ham), burgers and fries, calzones, pizza, pasta "casserole" things, DIY tacos, various "bowls", etc., and they repeat a lot. But the sides are well thought out and nutritious and the deli and salad bars are really nice. I've never heard of anything spoilt or burnt; it just wouldn't be served. Everyone involved in school meals has to have a state-administered children's nutrition and health certification. There are state standards on nutritional balance, calories, etc.

There's also a cool "farm to school" program, Harvest of the Month, which is done state-wide, where they focus on one local crop every month (pumpkins, peaches, cranberries, cucumbers, wild rice, etc.) The cafeteria serves dishes made with that crop locally-grown, there are posters and info sheets and stickers and such, and the high school does an optional informational session for the students with someone like a local farmer, chef, etc. about that item, and students have a chance to share recipes, photographs, creative writing etc.

Thank you for all that information. I like the sound of the deli station!

It's interesting the vending machines have energy drinks but not Coke. I'm not sure high schools here have vending machines anymore but we did when I was at school. There was a fizzy drink one and a chocolate bar one and I remember spending all my lunch money in them sometimes!

I'm glad to hear there is no spoilt or burnt food! The farm to school programme sounds really good.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:26

MuffinMcLayLikeABundleOfHay · 20/08/2022 22:48

 No.

Like @TeacupDrama drama has already said, it's not good practice to have a nut ban on schools. It's not recommended.

I think it might be a case of our schools being a bit behind with the times. When I was pregnant with my first it was recommended that you didn't eat nuts in pregnancy and didn't introduce them to your DC til a certain age (can't remember what it was.)

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:22

viques · 20/08/2022 22:41

If I ever have the misfortune to be reincarnated as a child I hope I am Japanese because Japanese school lunches look amazing.

They do don't they? Although I have to say I liked the look of lots of the lunches!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 10:20

savoycabbage · 20/08/2022 22:29

Nut bans in all the schools and nurseries here. If your DC takes something in with nuts they are not allowed to eat it (if it is spotted).

It's that 'if it's spotted' that is the problem and gives a false sense of security.

How can so many schools just flagrantly ignore the advice of Anaphylaxis UK? I'm glad my dd went to schools that followed the guidance.

Yes, that makes sense. At nursery it was fine as there was only a handful eating lunch. This was where an item was removed from her lunch. But her Primary has over 1000 DC so I'm not confident it could be spotted. I mean everyone I know is very used to no nuts and sticks to it but in the nursery situation I had done it by mistake.

OP posts:
Holidaydreamingagain · 21/08/2022 09:32

I’m just amazed schools aren’t nut free. I don’t know of a single school, state or private which allows nuts on site