Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think HV is talking rubbish and babies can't be overweight?

140 replies

IdiotSandwich05 · 20/08/2022 18:05

Hi all.

DS is two months old and, according to his HV, overweight. He weighed 6lbs 12oz at birth (born at 37 weeks), at six weeks was 12lbs 10oz, and when I weighed him at baby clinic yesterday was exactly 15lbs. So yes a chunky monkey but I was pleased with this! He is EBF.

The HV insinuated I was overfeeding him and shouldn't 'feed him every time he cries'. I don't! She also mentioned him being at increased risk of obesity ect. Basically making it seem like I'm doing something wrong. This is my first time BFing and I thought it was going well! Neither me nor DP nor our daughter are overweight.

DS is also 63cm long which is on the 99th percentile, so to me that means he's big but in proportion rather than overweight. He is healthy, happy, and meeting all his millstones. He goes 2-3 hours between feeds in the day and 3-4 hours at night, so it isn't like he's feeding constantly. And even if he was, I thought you couldn't overfeed a BF baby?

Am I BU to think HV is talking out of her rear? He's not even solids yet, so how

OP posts:
BarnacleNora · 20/08/2022 19:01

I am reduced to tears of laughter when Timehop rows up a certain period in my DS2's life because he's just circular. Just this massive massive round baby with flipper feet, great paws for hands and basically no knees just creases. He was EBF and fortunately my HV team are exceptionally well trained in breastfeeding and infant nutrition in general (I know because I went on to work for them and had the training myself).

Your baby is fine. Ideally they'd be finding their line on the centile chart and following that line but it really doesn't matter whereabouts that line is (50th, 70th or 99th as my baby was) as long as they're consistently following it. And no, you can't overfeed an EBF baby

JustLyra · 20/08/2022 19:00

Yogagrandmum · 20/08/2022 18:21

I believe the health visitors are well trained and know what they are talking about. Does everybody not see the amount of fat people children and babies there are around nowadays?

Health visitors should know what they’re talking about.

Sadly many of them are massively ill informed.

DoubleHelix79 · 20/08/2022 18:59

HVs seem to vary greatly in terms of quality of training and general ability. I've met some very helpful and knowledgeable ones but also some who gave me false or at least misleading or oversimplified information.

At the 1 year check for DC1 for example the HV simply added up points on a checklist, made no mention of the fact that babies vary a lot in reaching milrstones and said she was very concerned about her inability to walk yet. A simple look on the NHS website, (or indeed a browse on any parenting forum) would be enough to know that many perfectly healthy babies walk much later. If I had been a less confident parent I'd probably have wasted GP time for absolutely no reason.

While I don't completely ignore any medical advice I generally do some reading using reputable sources or sometimes relevant research papers. Cochrane reviews are very useful if you ever want to go into A LOT of detail on a topic.

Blev2022 · 20/08/2022 18:59

I don't agree with this. I got told my son was overweight and he emotionally eats (...?) Based on nothing other than he was 99 centile for both weight and height at 11 months, but was when he was born. I got told to feed him less, I ignored. As predicted as soon as he's started walking hes leaned out.

Saying it to someone EBF and a baby so young is just complete nonsense to me.

slowquickstep · 20/08/2022 18:56

I have yet to come across a HV that spoke any sense.

IdiotSandwich05 · 20/08/2022 18:54

@margegunderson I was induced due to reduced movements and faltering growth (he'd consistently been on the 90th percentile on scans until 36 weeks when he dropped to the 50th). I was having growth scans because his sister was growth restricted. He looked quite gaunt at birth because he was very long but didn't weigh much in comparison, so I agree that I think he was always meant to be big and is catching up now!

OP posts:
Musmerian · 20/08/2022 18:54

Absolute nonsense and dangerous advice. I’d make a complaint as this kind of stuff can cause all kinds of problems. I had the opposite with DC three - told that it’s not possible to eat enough to EBF 6 month old baby. I ignored and didn’t bother going back but wish I’d complained.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 20/08/2022 18:54

He sounds like a very bonnie baby, congratulations you are doing an amazing job. X

JennyForeigner · 20/08/2022 18:53

A HV tried this on us, with our 91st percentile for length son. Absolute bullshit, they all go nicely toddler shaped when they start standing and using those muscles.

SH23B · 20/08/2022 18:52

I've found most health visitors give their personal opinion rather than any sort of actual facts.

I had a weaning visit from one who, when I advised my intention to start finger foods at six months, was quite horrified and said baby led weaning is just the name of a book and not a real thing. And the only way to wean is by freezing single pureed veg in ice cube trays and giving one at a time. Yeah, I didn't do that....

Pinkflipflop85 · 20/08/2022 18:50

Yogagrandmum · 20/08/2022 18:21

I believe the health visitors are well trained and know what they are talking about. Does everybody not see the amount of fat people children and babies there are around nowadays?

SIL is a HV and she had said herself that she knows very little about breastfeeding. They don't get any training around it.

IdiotSandwich05 · 20/08/2022 18:49

@JaninaDuszejko No, he's my second. Funnily enough his sister was tiny and struggled to gain weight!

Thank you all, I do think I'll just stop having him weighed for now. I'm not concerned at all.

OP posts:
Thecaravan · 20/08/2022 18:47

I kind of feel like maybe I did overfeed DD1 who was EBF. I would switch breasts quite quickly and I think she got a lot of foremilk and not so much hind milk. So she fed for a long time and regularly and went from 50th to 90th percentile quite quickly, although also above average length. With DD2 I left her on one breast for a whole feed then switched for the next feed and felt like she stayed fuller for longer. She has consistently been on the 10th to 15th percentile but is also much shorter.
So basically my anecdata story counts for shit 😆 carry on feeding your beautiful baby!

Doseagullstasteoffish · 20/08/2022 18:45

I’m a neonatal midwife and in my opinion its not possible for babies to overeat. Particularly not EBF babies - your health visitor is talking out her rear, which is quite common unfortunately.

Ithinkitsenoughnow · 20/08/2022 18:44

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 20/08/2022 18:34

opt out they are bringing nothing to your life but stress
hvs are optional,but they dont tell people this,
so many think you "have to"have them
the amount ive had tell me they went along with it under duress

ive never had one and ive 2 kids

my 2nd son was massive at birth 10lb10oz and 29 inches(yes really no exaggeration)he was a very greedy baby from bottle one and was on 11 oz then by 6 weeks 16 ounces every hour and half.(hes 5ft 7 now and 11st 7 at 12)

i know now its down to disabilities(he has many complex ones) but he would put on 4-5 pounds a month and was on full solid meals by 6 months,no baby food or puree,from then on hes on 6-7 full adult size meals and 8-12pints of while milk as his appertite is massive

i opted out with son 1as i knew i would get grief because of the liferstyle choices i was going to follow attachement/gentle parenting and chosing to cosleep and chose home education so no childcare or nursery i knew hvs dont like alternitive lifestyles so i opted out

if i took him to weighing classes they would have blow their top as he wouldnt have fillowed any charts and i never wanted or needed their textbook advice and from litrelly first weigh from coming out he was well over the 100 percent centile,they even checked twice to make sure

Are you educating him yourself?

margegunderson · 20/08/2022 18:37

At that length and weight he was underweight at birth and is catching up surely?

avocadotofu · 20/08/2022 18:37

You definitely can't overfeed a breastfed baby. My son went from the 25 to 75 centile and he's a totally healthy weight now at nearly 4.

autienotnaughty · 20/08/2022 18:36

My ebf baby gained quickly over first 6m then settled was chunky for a few months but then slimed down when he started crawling. Ebf can not be over fed. Keep doing what your doing.

InChocolateWeTrust · 20/08/2022 18:35

I don't really think it's possible to over feed a breastfed baby, especially not if he is only feeding every 2-3 hours.

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 20/08/2022 18:34

opt out they are bringing nothing to your life but stress
hvs are optional,but they dont tell people this,
so many think you "have to"have them
the amount ive had tell me they went along with it under duress

ive never had one and ive 2 kids

my 2nd son was massive at birth 10lb10oz and 29 inches(yes really no exaggeration)he was a very greedy baby from bottle one and was on 11 oz then by 6 weeks 16 ounces every hour and half.(hes 5ft 7 now and 11st 7 at 12)

i know now its down to disabilities(he has many complex ones) but he would put on 4-5 pounds a month and was on full solid meals by 6 months,no baby food or puree,from then on hes on 6-7 full adult size meals and 8-12pints of while milk as his appertite is massive

i opted out with son 1as i knew i would get grief because of the liferstyle choices i was going to follow attachement/gentle parenting and chosing to cosleep and chose home education so no childcare or nursery i knew hvs dont like alternitive lifestyles so i opted out

if i took him to weighing classes they would have blow their top as he wouldnt have fillowed any charts and i never wanted or needed their textbook advice and from litrelly first weigh from coming out he was well over the 100 percent centile,they even checked twice to make sure

JaninaDuszejko · 20/08/2022 18:33

Friend of mine was told this about her EBF baby (DC3). Luckily friend is a GP and just ignored. How does your HV propose you reduce the milk an EBF baby gets? It's nonsense.

Also, I'm guessing this is a PFB? I went (far too) regularly to get DC1 weighed but with DC2 and DC3 once they regained their birthweight I only had them weighed at the routine appointments. Much less stressful.

Thedogscollar · 20/08/2022 18:32

Yogagrandmum · 20/08/2022 18:21

I believe the health visitors are well trained and know what they are talking about. Does everybody not see the amount of fat people children and babies there are around nowadays?

They might be well trained but you just cannot over feed an EBF baby and as a HV she should know this.

Sometimes a little common sense as well as some academic knowledge puts things in perspective.

LilacSky95 · 20/08/2022 18:31

You cant overfeed a BF baby!

Thedogscollar · 20/08/2022 18:27

My dil's HV told her that her 11 month old son should be walking and his leg creases aren't equal and told her to take him to the GP to get this checked!!

As a midwife and trained NIPE practitioner I know this is rubbish as we don't look at leg crease now. I did infact check my grandsons leg creases with his mums consent they were completely equal and he is very happily walking around the furniture and crawling without any leg lag. She also marked him down as being unable to pick up a pea. He obviously wasn't in the mood that day as he has very good hand eye coordination and picks up the tiniest crumbs to finish a biscuit.

Your baby sounds perfect keep doing what you're doing and ignore the HV.

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 20/08/2022 18:27

Babies can be on a higher weight centile, but you cannot physically overfeed an EBF baby.

Please ignore. But also if you're able to, please complain. You have the sense to know better. But someone else may not and risk stopping feeding on demand or quit breastfeeding altogether. She needs retraining!