Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think HV is talking rubbish and babies can't be overweight?

140 replies

IdiotSandwich05 · 20/08/2022 18:05

Hi all.

DS is two months old and, according to his HV, overweight. He weighed 6lbs 12oz at birth (born at 37 weeks), at six weeks was 12lbs 10oz, and when I weighed him at baby clinic yesterday was exactly 15lbs. So yes a chunky monkey but I was pleased with this! He is EBF.

The HV insinuated I was overfeeding him and shouldn't 'feed him every time he cries'. I don't! She also mentioned him being at increased risk of obesity ect. Basically making it seem like I'm doing something wrong. This is my first time BFing and I thought it was going well! Neither me nor DP nor our daughter are overweight.

DS is also 63cm long which is on the 99th percentile, so to me that means he's big but in proportion rather than overweight. He is healthy, happy, and meeting all his millstones. He goes 2-3 hours between feeds in the day and 3-4 hours at night, so it isn't like he's feeding constantly. And even if he was, I thought you couldn't overfeed a BF baby?

Am I BU to think HV is talking out of her rear? He's not even solids yet, so how

OP posts:
OhFatty · 20/08/2022 20:55

My eldest daughter was a chunky little thing, and I was told the same. She’s 23 now and (unlike everyone else in our family) is teeny! She’s 5’2 and just under 7 stone. I think your HV is talking bollocks

allabouttheviews · 20/08/2022 20:51

Iusyje · 20/08/2022 20:48

What is ebf? I know bf = breast feeding. But the e? Surely not electronic bf.

Exclusive breastfeeding. As in no formula or any other type of food or drink.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 20/08/2022 20:51

Iusyje · 20/08/2022 20:48

What is ebf? I know bf = breast feeding. But the e? Surely not electronic bf.

Exclusively Breast feeding. So just breast milk no formula at all.

wibblewobbleball · 20/08/2022 20:49

Haven't you already got a thread on this?

Iusyje · 20/08/2022 20:48

What is ebf? I know bf = breast feeding. But the e? Surely not electronic bf.

liquoricecravings · 20/08/2022 20:48

You can't overfeed a breastfed baby. There are studies to show it helps prevent being overweight when you're older as they learn to stop feeding when they're full whereas it's tempting with a bottle to encourage baby to have the last couple of ounces and they can miss the feeling full cues.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 20/08/2022 20:42

Your body makes what your baby needs once feeding is established. Anything over what they need would reappear. She is an idiot, I would speak to the practise manager/GP if I were you OP

Murdoch1949 · 20/08/2022 20:33

Blimey you are breastfeeding your baby precious, highly nutritious food, well done to you. I would ignore the HV and keep on doing what you are doing. I would be worried if this HV is saying the same to other mums as it could lead to them restricting their feeding. Anyone would think you were giving the babe chips & gravy, not unknown! Maybe she thought she may get a confession out of you. Just keep on giving him what is best until you start weaning. Within a year of crawling & toddling he'll be a skinny minny, you see.

GreenLunchBox · 20/08/2022 20:18

pointythings · 20/08/2022 18:21

You can't overfeed a BF baby. My two were absolute chunks when little, grew into tall slim children.

Same here
Both mine were EBF and got so chunky. Had literal rolls 😍🤣
Both now 6'2/6'3 and very slim, fit and healthy

VeronicaFranklin · 20/08/2022 20:14

In my opinion most HV talk absolute shit and I'm shocked most are trained nurses....

Two weeks ago the HV came to see me and my 2 month old baby, she'd noticed I'd been to GP for my baby's constipation on my record and I said yes, I've put her onto comfort milk which is specific for colic and constipation (says on front of tin) as GP recommended...

Her response 'sometimes anti-constipation milk can actually make them more constipated, like how anti-depressants can make you depressed'

I just stared at her blank and decided not to listen to one more word that came out of her mouth.

She also told me I shouldn't pay any attention to the recommended feed amounts on the tin as in her words 'it is written by the manufacturers so you buy more milk and money in their pockets'

She recommended that instead of feeding my 8 week old baby every 3/4 hours the recommend amount, to actually feed her on demand and in which case 'always have a bottle ready just incase' - which if I did this 1. I would def overfeed her as she has colic so would likely take feed every time she cries and 2. I would go through tins of milk like no one's business!

Mad how I've seen 3 different HV and all have advised me differently on different things. No consistency whatsoever.

Your baby is not overweight, being EBF he will only take what he needs and he he happy and healthy that is all that matters so pay no notice.

alotoftutus · 20/08/2022 20:13

I had the opposite with my premature low birth weight baby. My HV actually told me I should spread butter onto my nipples so my then newborn son would eat it with his milk and fatten up 🤣🤣🤣 That was the last weighing appointment I ever took him to!

Honestly even if your baby was overweight how on Earth do you put a breastfed baby on a diet - they take what they need!
She sounds quite ridiculous. Carry on doing what you are doing. Breastfeeding and being a new mum is hard enough with this nonsense. Encase you haven't been told today - you are doing an amazing job - go you!!!

Changethesign · 20/08/2022 20:11

Foxglovers · 20/08/2022 20:03

Omg. As everyone is saying you cannot over feed and exclusively breastfed baby! The composition of breast milk changes all the time - you should feed them whenever they want it!! I’ve breastfed all of mine until 2.5!!

My mil is constantly on at me that ‘fat is fat regardless of the source’ telling me to stop bf as dd is so big but the HV is fine about it as the benefits to breastmilk outweigh being on the bigger side

pbdr · 20/08/2022 20:10

My daughter was born at 37 weeks on the 25th centile for weight, and then put on 1lbs in weight (also EBF) every week for the first few months of her life until she was on the 98th centile. I was also made to feel terrible about this and accused of over feeding her, until her length was measured and it turned out she was on the 98th centile for length too. So she was perfectly in proportion, and if I had restricted feeds as I was advised to to keep her on the 25th centile for weight she would have ended up significantly underweight for her length.

You cannot overfeed an EBF baby. If your baby is telling you that he is hungry, believe him.

Juniperjungle · 20/08/2022 20:10

She's talking absolutely rubbish as usual. Where the F these people get their training I've no idea. Keep feeding him whenever he wants it (any time he cries is absolutely fine!!) and enjoy your baby. I recommended looking at 'Milk and Moon'. Congratulations 🎊

alotoftutus · 20/08/2022 20:10

@TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY hi from another home educating, co sleeping, and all the not quite so normal things mum lol 👋

Eggmcmuffin · 20/08/2022 20:09

Ignore. My baby was a chunk and I had a lovely health visitor who told me she was perfect and she'd even out and no, you can't overfeed a breast fed baby.

HappyHappyHermit · 20/08/2022 20:09

I only had the two planned HV visit and didn't bother with the dropping in for weigh ins. As long as I could see my daughter was growing steadily and feeding plenty I felt happy she was doing well. Trust your instincts and keep doing what you are doing as it sounds like he is growing well.

GretaVanFleet · 20/08/2022 20:07

Genuine question

How do you know that you can not overfeed a breastfed baby?

DottyLittleRainbow · 20/08/2022 20:04

Well done on EBF and your baby’s weight gain!! Ignore the HV and carry on.

hewouldwouldnthe · 20/08/2022 20:04

Heavens. DS was about the same weight at birth but by 5 months has wristlets and rolls and rolls of fat flesh. He looked like he was on steroids. Ebf until 6 months. He started walking at 9 months and became a stick insect which he still is today with zero interest in food, unless its a sweet.
Ignore her.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 20/08/2022 20:03

DuchessofAnkh77 · 20/08/2022 19:37

I think half the problem is loads of people lie....(i'm not saying you do!)....I bet she hears it all the time people who say they are breastfeeding as it is possible to overfeed a formula fed baby..but not an EBF one.

A bottle fed baby will just puke it up or refuse it if they don't want it. I presume if they want more you just give it. 🤷‍♀️

Foxglovers · 20/08/2022 20:03

Omg. As everyone is saying you cannot over feed and exclusively breastfed baby! The composition of breast milk changes all the time - you should feed them whenever they want it!! I’ve breastfed all of mine until 2.5!!

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 20/08/2022 19:59

iamloading · 20/08/2022 19:02

Exactly the same happened to me. My daughter was three weeks early (induced) and was teeny. Once born she saw my boobs and went for it. She was absolutely enormous, not even particularly long just and absolute rolly polly barrel.
The HV kindly told me that "you can't overfeed an EBM baby but look at her."
Everyone said she would lose it when she crawled. She didn't (plus was v late to crawl and roll because she had so much bulk to heave up!)
However once she started running it dropped off and now at 4 she looks like any other child that never stops moving!
So ignore her totally!

Not EBF but this reminds me of my 6 month old. Rolling over is like turning a big lorry around a corner. Quite funny to watch sometimes!

User8273738273737 · 20/08/2022 19:59

Dogscanteatonions · 20/08/2022 19:55

Fucking health visitors can be shit. Mine said to me on finding out I intended in breastfeeding past 12 months - 'aren't you worried about the damage you'll do to him and his teeth?'

🤦🏻‍♀️😡
HV should be worried about damage I’d do to her teeth if she’d said this to me

Pixie2015 · 20/08/2022 19:59

I got told similar till I said I was EBF - then I was told that’s great and given a goodie bag as only breast feeding that morning!!!! As a doctor working with children myself I wasn’t impressed!