Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think HV is talking rubbish and babies can't be overweight?

140 replies

IdiotSandwich05 · 20/08/2022 18:05

Hi all.

DS is two months old and, according to his HV, overweight. He weighed 6lbs 12oz at birth (born at 37 weeks), at six weeks was 12lbs 10oz, and when I weighed him at baby clinic yesterday was exactly 15lbs. So yes a chunky monkey but I was pleased with this! He is EBF.

The HV insinuated I was overfeeding him and shouldn't 'feed him every time he cries'. I don't! She also mentioned him being at increased risk of obesity ect. Basically making it seem like I'm doing something wrong. This is my first time BFing and I thought it was going well! Neither me nor DP nor our daughter are overweight.

DS is also 63cm long which is on the 99th percentile, so to me that means he's big but in proportion rather than overweight. He is healthy, happy, and meeting all his millstones. He goes 2-3 hours between feeds in the day and 3-4 hours at night, so it isn't like he's feeding constantly. And even if he was, I thought you couldn't overfeed a BF baby?

Am I BU to think HV is talking out of her rear? He's not even solids yet, so how

OP posts:
CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 21/08/2022 07:18

My EBF baby looked like she'd been blown up with a bicycle pump at around that age. She had rolls on her rolls. She is now 9 and strong, slim and healthy. No issues at all.

DaisyJoy1 · 21/08/2022 07:05

It's really well known that it's literally impossible to overfeed an exclusively breastfed baby and I would NEVER not breastfeed my crying newborn. I never had a HV but from what i have seen on Mumsnet they seem massively incompetent and giving out false information and just making mistakes and making everyone stressed

GretaVanFleet · 21/08/2022 07:02

Thank you for answering @BoffinMum

SparkyBlue · 20/08/2022 22:50

OP he is obviously thriving. I had this but with a bottle fed baby. He was premature and very unwell in the nicu with feeding issues for a couple of weeks after he was born . Well when he got the hang of it my goodness he then loved his bottles. I remember when he was about three months old being told he was overweight. I just laughed it off.

RidingMyBike · 20/08/2022 22:44

It's also normal for an EBF baby to gain weight faster than a formula fed one in the first months. Could be what's happening here?
kellymom.com/bf/normal/weight-toomuch/

I didn't find the weighing clinics very helpful and they were frequently fly cancelled anyway (opposite problem as had low supply) so got my own scales and weighed at home.

Merryoldgoat · 20/08/2022 22:43

This is why I stopped going to the HV. They were. Utterly useless and full of bollocks.

Mine was 11lb and 60cm at birth. Unsurprisingly he continued to be massive. They just couldn’t seem to accept it.

IsThereALimitToTheLengthOfUsernames48Characters · 20/08/2022 22:40

Mine were both ebf. When I look back at photos of DS1 in particular, he was like a space hopper! Luckily I had a fantastic HV, who was very knowledgeable and never made stupid, ignorant comments about his weight. DS1 is 14 now and of an extremely slim build.

BoffinMum · 20/08/2022 22:25

The height/weight charts were originally based on white, bottlefed babies. They have tweaked them in recent years but they measure a population, not individuals, so always need interpretation.

I never took my offspring to baby clinics - if they were growing out their clothes sensibly and looked alert etc that was fine by me,

eatyourcrustspls · 20/08/2022 22:02

I'm a HV. You cannot overfeed a BF baby. Both of mine were chunks and EBF. Ignore.

We aren't all battle axes Grin

kitcat15 · 20/08/2022 21:55

Thedogscollar · 20/08/2022 18:27

My dil's HV told her that her 11 month old son should be walking and his leg creases aren't equal and told her to take him to the GP to get this checked!!

As a midwife and trained NIPE practitioner I know this is rubbish as we don't look at leg crease now. I did infact check my grandsons leg creases with his mums consent they were completely equal and he is very happily walking around the furniture and crawling without any leg lag. She also marked him down as being unable to pick up a pea. He obviously wasn't in the mood that day as he has very good hand eye coordination and picks up the tiniest crumbs to finish a biscuit.

Your baby sounds perfect keep doing what you're doing and ignore the HV.

Hv in.my area look at leg creases and leg length at 1buear review to check for hip displacement
.....children are then referred on to gp if their is an issue... your area sounds very lax🙄

watingroom2 · 20/08/2022 21:54

I honestly don't think they understand how centiles work - my friend was 'praised' for her son being 99th centile .. and I was lambasted for my DD being 2nd centile.

My dd was 99th for height (so super skinny) also EBF... she is now a healthy sized teen - my friends son is also a healthy sized teen!!

Honestly - they always had a go so I started refusing to take her to be weighed (I was told I wasn't doing it right as her weight was so low (never an acknowledgement that a baby at 99th centile height had to be getting enough food or they would not grow!!)..

In the end my OH took her and they were always so amazed a man was there not a comment was made (he was praised for helping me BF her - whereas I was told how awful I was ... work that out?!)

RedWingBoots · 20/08/2022 21:50

Stop taking your baby to be weighed.

I had a different issue but when a logical friend with children and a friend who worked in healthcare pointed out the same thing, I realised weighing babies without measuring their length/height is a crock of shite.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 20/08/2022 21:46

Yogagrandmum · 20/08/2022 18:21

I believe the health visitors are well trained and know what they are talking about. Does everybody not see the amount of fat people children and babies there are around nowadays?

Google is your friend here...

You can train someone all you like, but if they don't pay attention, or don't remember it, or decide that they know better, then you get dangerous bollocks like this being spouted.

Lilylovetulips · 20/08/2022 21:38

I had exactly the same thing with my baby and was accused of overfeeding by a doctor when he was 4 months old. He was a very chunky baby, 95th centile for height and weight. I will never forget what that doctor said to me and I still believe, 4 years later, that this is what led to my severe PND. That baby is now 4 years old, the tallest in his class and a strip of wind. 😁

I now have a 5 month old and he's the same weight and height as my eldest.... guess I just make chunky babies even though I'm petite!! 🤣🤣

Ignore it, you can't overfeed a baby. If they're hungry, feed them.

Bluedabadeeba · 20/08/2022 21:34

Report them and get a new HV. My paediatrician told me it's impossible! Total crap. I'm annoyed on your behalf. Imagine she says that to someone with less confidence that they're doing the right thing. It'd shatter them!

BoffinMum · 20/08/2022 21:30

I hope it isn’t a nursery nurse giving medical advice there - not being medically qualified she could get herself into massive hot water! I don’t think they should be running baby health clinics. Then again in a country where doctors’ receptionists blighthly feel free to diagnose and treat illness over the phone without consequence, maybe we shouldn’t be surprised.

Amortentia · 20/08/2022 21:30

Your HV is nuts. My ds was born at full term but only weighed 4Ib’s because a fault in the umbilical cord and placenta. By 6 weeks he’d doubled his weight and was extremely chunky until he was 1. The GP was thrilled with this and no one ever said it was a problem. Once he started walking the weight dropped off him and he has remained super skinny and is now a 6ft 19 year old.

An ebf baby is getting everything they need and worrying about extra weight on a body that is constantly growing is crazy.

Hunkydory99 · 20/08/2022 21:21

Super boobs (.)(.) well done to you both!! She’s talking total bullshit

Lemonpink88 · 20/08/2022 21:21

Are you sure you saw a health visitor and not a nursery nurse? Where I live their arnt enough health visitors to just do baby clinics, it’s run by nursery nurses here. I’d recommend you call up and as to speak to one of the qualified health visitors they are nurses or midwife’s by background so I guess can help you with better advise x

Shortkiwi · 20/08/2022 21:19

Bloody ridiculous HV! I breast fed all of mine on demand. They were chubby little things and I couldn’t have been more delighted and rewarded that I was totally nourishing them.

Flittingaboutagain · 20/08/2022 21:14

If he's on a high centile for length AND weight together, he is perfectly proportioned and is just not going to be a short adult that's all.

She clearly knows nothing about breastfeeding. You are doing great! Feed him whenever he asks for it!

My ebf baby went from 25th to 90th centile once we had tongue tie done and like yours both weight and length matched. She was predicted to be 5 7in- 5ft 8in as an adult at her one year review.

Fifife · 20/08/2022 21:07

My DD was 95 length centile at birth and 50 centile for weight. She's now 99 for height and 75 for weight at 9 years old. She was BF then FF and fed on demand for both. I don't think babies can be overweight until weaned and mobile. So I would say she's talking shite.

StrawberryQuartz · 20/08/2022 21:04

My HV told me it was impossible to overfeed a bf baby, and to always feed on demand. Sounds like you are doing wonderfully!

RidingMyBike · 20/08/2022 20:58

Whilst it is possible to overfeed an EBF baby it's a) rare and b) probably means there's a metabolic problem which needs looking into. So if she had concerns about that she should have referred you to a paediatrician.

She probably didn't plot the weight correctly on the chart, used scales with a dodgy calibration or can't work the chart full stop is more likely!

BoffinMum · 20/08/2022 20:57

Greta, there is a vast amount of research into breast milk composition, baby growth, and the later life outcomes of breastfeeding. It’s a very finely tuned symbiotic relationship between mother and baby, and the milk changes composition to ensure optimal growth over time. If babies were being overfed in some cases there would be a pattern of increased obesity later on - in fact the obesity risk is reduced.

Swipe left for the next trending thread