Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think HV is talking rubbish and babies can't be overweight?

140 replies

IdiotSandwich05 · 20/08/2022 18:05

Hi all.

DS is two months old and, according to his HV, overweight. He weighed 6lbs 12oz at birth (born at 37 weeks), at six weeks was 12lbs 10oz, and when I weighed him at baby clinic yesterday was exactly 15lbs. So yes a chunky monkey but I was pleased with this! He is EBF.

The HV insinuated I was overfeeding him and shouldn't 'feed him every time he cries'. I don't! She also mentioned him being at increased risk of obesity ect. Basically making it seem like I'm doing something wrong. This is my first time BFing and I thought it was going well! Neither me nor DP nor our daughter are overweight.

DS is also 63cm long which is on the 99th percentile, so to me that means he's big but in proportion rather than overweight. He is healthy, happy, and meeting all his millstones. He goes 2-3 hours between feeds in the day and 3-4 hours at night, so it isn't like he's feeding constantly. And even if he was, I thought you couldn't overfeed a BF baby?

Am I BU to think HV is talking out of her rear? He's not even solids yet, so how

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 23/08/2022 08:57

Ages ago now, but I remember a friend being told by the HV to treat her 2 month old baby ‘like an alcoholic’ 😱 and restrict his feeds. He was just a big, hungry baby. Pleased to say she ignored her.

I had a nephew the same - bottle fed - at 2 months he was getting through 2 full bottles per feed. Now in his late 40s he’s fit and active, as always, and has never been remotely overweight.

ImEasyLikeSundayMorning · 21/08/2022 15:05

Merryoldgoat · 21/08/2022 14:05

@ImEasyLikeSundayMorning

I have no doubt there are excellent health visitors but I also know from experience there are terrible ones and some just not very good ones.

Only one HV has ever been of any use whilst my children were babies.

Only HCPs and Teachers seem to suggest that it’s not possible to come across a poor example of a person in their profession.

I come across rubbish accountants all the time.

I wasn't suggesting anything of the sort 🤨

I was suggesting that many many areas are not sending out HV's for the 6-8 week review so it might have been someone totally unqualified in healthcare.

Either she had a shit HV, or a shit nursery nurse.

I was simply pointing out that the latter might have been more likely given the current circumstances but should complain.

What you took from my post was quite literally not written there at all.

mamabear715 · 21/08/2022 14:27

She's an idiot. Crack on doing just what you are doing! xx

CecilyP · 21/08/2022 14:25

And I would add that as there doesn’t seem to be a definition of overweight in a baby, the NHS BMI calculator only starts at 2, OP could ask the HV what she is using to say the baby is overweight.

RidingMyBike · 21/08/2022 14:06

Some of the views on this thread! Confused

It is possible to overfeed a baby, but it's unusual, however they're fed. Bottle fed babies push the teat out or sick it up, you're not just pouring milk into them! More likely to be a result of making up the formula so it's too concentrated. But it's unusual.

Likewise with an EBF baby. Breastmilk isn't perfect, some mums make milk with the nutrients in less than optimum amounts, leading to the baby taking more and gaining too much weight. Some babies have a metabolic or other problem so they don't get the satiety feeling and keep feeding. Some mums have oversupply so the baby takes too much milk. There's more about it here:
kellymom.com/bf/normal/weight-toomuch/
Research into excessive weight gain in EBF babies:
www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/jpem-2017-0028/html?lang=en

But these are unusual. The problem is likely to be dubious weighing by a clueless HV. Or maybe someone who isn't even qualified. If they genuinely thought there was a problem then the baby should have been referred to paeds.

Merryoldgoat · 21/08/2022 14:05

@ImEasyLikeSundayMorning

I have no doubt there are excellent health visitors but I also know from experience there are terrible ones and some just not very good ones.

Only one HV has ever been of any use whilst my children were babies.

Only HCPs and Teachers seem to suggest that it’s not possible to come across a poor example of a person in their profession.

I come across rubbish accountants all the time.

CecilyP · 21/08/2022 14:00

DancingBeanstalk · 21/08/2022 10:48

EBF babies fed only from the breast cannot be overweight.

Babies fed from a bottle (breast or formula) can absolutely be overweight.

People say this all the time but what does it actually mean in terms of what can be measured? Overweight for older children is based on height/weight ratio, or it’s BMI in adults So what is overweight for a baby? Is there a maximum that no breastfed baby has ever attained which has been attained by a bottle fed baby? If so, is it published anywhere? Otherwise ‘EBF babies fed only from the breast cannot be overweight’ just sounds like a mantra.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 21/08/2022 13:51

Ignore her. Some HVs are obsessed with babies’ weight. FWIW my EBF Gds was a real roly-poly Michelin Man baby - he soon lost it once he started running around and now 6 is tall without an ounce of chub. Might add that he did lose some baby chub when very ill with bronchiolitis (ICU twice). IMO babies need some reserve chub because they can lose it alarmingly quickly if they’re ill.

ImEasyLikeSundayMorning · 21/08/2022 13:48

OP, I doubt that was an HV.

I expect it was a nursery nurse or at a push, a staff nurse.

There's a national shortage of HV and I know for us, we'll do the new birth visit and then ask the nursery nurse to do the 6-8 week review.

Look in your red book, it should say.

But either way, I would inform the HV service because it's such awful information and advice.

GreenLunchBox · 21/08/2022 13:35

The reason you can't overfeed a EBF baby is because it's natural, perfect food.

Think about if adults ate as mother nature intended: just food that came out of the ground or sea and wasn't processed. If all you ate was fish and veggies (with nothing added to it) you wouldnt physically be able to overeat and become overweight

The reason we overeat is because we have manipulated food so that it has that moreish ratio of fats to carbs. Nobody would binge-eat teaspoons of sugar but chocolate- yes. Would you binge-eat plain white bread? No: if that was all there was to eat you'd stop when no longer hungry. But add butter to it and it's addictive.

ElspethTascioni · 21/08/2022 11:07

Babies can be overweight - but not BF ones. Ignore…

Starlightstarbright1 · 21/08/2022 11:05

My ebf baby looked like a sumo wrestler...
He grew up looking like a drainpipe.. now a teen his is broad and slim.

Hv said i was feeding him.gold top so they weren't concerned

DancingBeanstalk · 21/08/2022 10:48

EBF babies fed only from the breast cannot be overweight.

Babies fed from a bottle (breast or formula) can absolutely be overweight.

PolishingCandles · 21/08/2022 10:42

She's talking rubbish.
As long as the baby is happy and thriving then continue as you are and take no notice of her.

Rinatinabina · 21/08/2022 10:35

DD was a massive baby (formula fed after 6 weeks), DH definitely overfed her, she was genuinely just a little ball). Normal healthy weight according to NHS BMI calculator now at 2.5. I really worried over it when a doctor mentioned it to me but she’s fine.

Chubbiest baby I have ever seen was ebf (literally rolls on rolls), totally normal weight now (was so impressed with her mum though). They grow so fast and their weight drops rapidly when ill so no I wouldn’t be worrying about changing anything. At 2 months as well, it’s ridiculous.

loveisanopensore · 21/08/2022 10:33

GretaVanFleet · 20/08/2022 20:07

Genuine question

How do you know that you can not overfeed a breastfed baby?

Because they just stop when they're full.
With a bottle you can encourage them to finish what's left, this over rides the natural fullness instinct. Though with a little baby they're more than likely to puke the excess back up.

loveisanopensore · 21/08/2022 10:27

Yogagrandmum · 20/08/2022 18:21

I believe the health visitors are well trained and know what they are talking about. Does everybody not see the amount of fat people children and babies there are around nowadays?

Your belief is wrong.
I had a fantastic HV first time round. For my second we had ones who couldn't do maths, didn't have any idea of normal infant feeding or sleeping and a very odd woman who criticised my toddler's drawings.
GPs are also woefully uninformed about breastfeeding and their advise is more based on opinion.

NatMoz · 21/08/2022 10:16

My baby was born at 6lb 11 like yours and at 8 months still isn't 15lb!! She was weighed on Tuesday and is 14lb 10oz. I would be very happy with your chunky boy

mycatisannoying · 21/08/2022 10:11

Absolute rubbish. Honestly, some of these so-called professionals are in the wrong job.
They could actually do so much emotional damage to a new mum with PND.

ReginaFalangeee · 21/08/2022 10:09

My HV said the exact same thing to me.Apparently I was over feeding my EBF baby and should cut down feeds. My eyes nearly rolled out my head ha ha!

My little girl was always on the 97th percentile. She was a chunky little monkey and loved her milk. She’d want fed every 2 hours and if I didn’t feed her she’d scream and cry. So I fed her because I assumed she must need it.

By the time she was ready to wean at 6 month she was very quick to drop milk feeds and was good eater once she got the hang of things. Her weight really evened out when she started crawling and being more mobile too.

I never did cut down the milk feeds and just let my baby decide what she needed naturally. She is now a perfectly health 2 year old and all her little baby rolls have gone.

caffeine99 · 21/08/2022 09:20

You are doing amazing and the HV is talking rubbish. No such thing as overfeeding an EBF baby. The HV mentioned risk of obesity but actually, you breastfeeding is already reducing the risk of both that and of future diabetes risks.

Keep on doing what you're doing and ignore her.

BoffinMum · 21/08/2022 09:05

Sorry that should have said ff

BoffinMum · 21/08/2022 09:05

I just wanted to mention that it is technically possible to overfeed a bf baby if you deliberately and repeatedly feed them formula with too many scoops of milk powder in there, and/or other supplementary contents added to the formula itself, but I imagine you would need to be pretty purposeful about it.

Sarah8719 · 21/08/2022 08:41

Don’t listen to her. My little girl was massive as a baby and I can’t tell you how long I worried about it for. I was so scared I was over feeding her and it was my fault she was fat. She sounds like your little one, yes quite chunky but also tall.
anyway she’s 2 now and is still really tall (around 97th centile) but is thin as a rake. Once they start moving it falls off them. Please don’t worry like I did!

HappinesDependsOnYou · 21/08/2022 07:18

Google can you over feed breast fed babies and show her the NHS page where at the top it says do not worry you cannot over feed a breast fed baby and tell her that her employer appears to disagree with her opinion

Swipe left for the next trending thread