Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do people think about rail strikes?

409 replies

ITUnurse · 20/08/2022 17:21

I cannot find any threads on the rail strikes / opinion of them.

I personally do support the strikes. We in the NHS will face a similar struggle shortly. I support the rights of workers to strike. Conditions at the moment are dire.

However, if England is so right wing and strikes aren't supported and the Tories continue to be voted in. I've not seen much public support online except from a few and I'm at risk of being in an echo chamber.

Ultimately if England is so under the thumb of the tories, I'm not sure what the long term solution is. The rest of the UK doesn't return the Tories in such numbers.

If you don't support strike action, what do you think the rail workers, NHS workers etc should do? We've already got people leaving enmasse. It's difficult to comment on the conditions of a job you don't work in and nurses regularly get gaslighted on here I am genuinely concerned as to what is going to happen to the public sector of the UK with this right wing stranglehold.

Thanks

OP posts:
BrookeDavisQueen · 22/08/2022 17:34

Bluebells12 · 22/08/2022 10:10

I don’t support the rail strikes. We live in a country where many essential workers have to commute, the strikes punish ordinary workers and play into the hands of the government who want to demonise unions. Also, rail salaries are not bad for what is a pretty easy job, you can’t compare it to the high levels of training, infection risk and resilience required in the NHS. I get the problem with train guards, I want train guards, but striking won’t help. Let’s face it one day trains will all be fully automated with no driver or staff and security will be provided by cameras and help buttons. I don’t have a problem with moving in that direction.

If the rail drivers etc really want to strike they should at least do it Japan style where they continue to deive the trains but refuse to sell/inspect tickets / man barriers. That way the rail company doesn’t get its profit but customers can still travel.

(I would renationalise rail for sure. Doesn’t make any sense to privatise an industry where there’s no competition. “Oh, the train to Glasgow is rubbish, I’ll get the train to Folkestone instead.”)

I do support the barristers strike over legal aid. Doesn’t cause problems for ordinary people and they’re right that the government is basically destroying access to justice for the poor.

I wouldn’t support an NHS strike because people are already dying while they wait for medical help, slowing it down further would literally kill people. Striking will not change government policies just give them an excuse to sell off chunks of the NHS to American investors.

The answer to all this is less incompetent politicians. I wish more bright people would go into politics instead of leaving the field clear for the dregs.

The Tories made that form of strike illegal.

Madwife123 · 22/08/2022 16:58

FunnyBeaux · 22/08/2022 01:10

If everyone would leave, pay would have to rise.

Do you realise that that kind of negotiation happens daily all over the country. An employee thinks they should be paid more, so they ask for a raise and tell their boss that if they don't get it they leave. This literally happens all the time.

@FunnyBeaux

The NHS is in the midst of the biggest staffing crisis they have ever faced due to those leaving. Are the government fixing this by increasing wages? No instead they sit back and let hundreds of avoidable deaths happen due to lack of staffing. Don’t pretend for one second that leaving does anything to help wages under a Tory government desperate to see it fail so they can push privatisation.

Laughingravy · 22/08/2022 16:56

Sobaridiot
"So all these reasons are completely logical from a business perspective. What is striking meant to achieve? Try and get the company to change their minds and stick with the 'old ways'? Why would they? It would be foolish for the business."

As I said, and you either ignored or missed, the railways, despite our politicians best efforts, is a public transport system and should foremost be service. It shouldn’t be seen as just another business and the profit motive shouldn’t be upper most. To close the majority of booking offices will deny a sizeable percentage of the population access to what is supposed to be a public service.

As for workers deciding if maintainance schedules risk safety. Well when getting your car maintained would you prefer to trust a mechanic, an accountant or a share holder? But heck what do the guys and gals on the ground know about anything, they’re just workers.

In some cases it may make sense to do track inspections overnight due to traffic levels. But imagine if either you or your partner got a letter saying from now on, like it or not, it’s permanent nights or the sack. Oh and I forgot to say, no extra pay for doing it.

But really you just come across as being deliberately obtuse about all this

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 16:56

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 16:02

Under which party has this sorry state of affairs arisen?

More generally, since Boris Johnson, Brexit and CV, this country seems to be falling apart.

The latest is an all out Barristers strike, 8 days of limited imports into the UK, 18% inflation and £24,000 tuition fee's.

This sorry state of affairs has been developing for decades, spanning multiple colours of government.

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 16:54

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 15:58

What services are worse?

Once again, Wales is not run as a separate country, so comparisons with a Labour Westminster Govt are pointless.

CT is not clear cut, those areas that are better off, tend to have lower CT because the council has less poorer people needing help, be that CT support, social services or funding social care/care home placement.

Healthcare, education, transport... And if it were the case that it's all Westminster's fault, then services here would only be equally bad, not significantly worse than those across the border.

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 16:02

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 15:36

Hardly any rapists get arrested in the first place, never mind make it to court.

Under which party has this sorry state of affairs arisen?

More generally, since Boris Johnson, Brexit and CV, this country seems to be falling apart.

The latest is an all out Barristers strike, 8 days of limited imports into the UK, 18% inflation and £24,000 tuition fee's.

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 15:58

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 13:08

That doesn't explain why many of our public services are measurably worse than those in England.

Incidentally, my county council is run by a Tory-led coalition. I've no complaints about how it's run, the roads are in a reasonable state of repair and I never find my bins overflowing. Council tax is lower than neighbouring counties too.

What services are worse?

Once again, Wales is not run as a separate country, so comparisons with a Labour Westminster Govt are pointless.

CT is not clear cut, those areas that are better off, tend to have lower CT because the council has less poorer people needing help, be that CT support, social services or funding social care/care home placement.

mojokoloko · 22/08/2022 15:38

@Dotjones

Your solution to striking, eg withdrawing of labour on planned days with a clear negotiation process to prevent it, is that everyone quits their jobs. You're saying you disagree with people withdrawing their labour temporarily and instead they should withdraw their labour permanently. This is a much more destructive action than strike action. Think about it.

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 15:36

Blossomtoes · 22/08/2022 15:06

And no one is going to release rapists

Unfortunately that could be a side effect of the barristers’ strike. Not that I think it should be a deterrent, the amount junior barristers are paid is shocking.

Hardly any rapists get arrested in the first place, never mind make it to court.

Mrsorganmorgan · 22/08/2022 15:13

I wish I could go on strike! I am an unpaid carer.

Blossomtoes · 22/08/2022 15:06

And no one is going to release rapists

Unfortunately that could be a side effect of the barristers’ strike. Not that I think it should be a deterrent, the amount junior barristers are paid is shocking.

Natsku · 22/08/2022 15:00

I can't help but feel if it were their child who was denied lifesaving treatment because doctors were on strike, or whose rapist was released from prison because prison officers were on strike, or whose region was destroyed in a nuclear power plant catastrophe because the technicians were on strike, they'd have a different view.

Medical staff going on strike does not prevent lifesaving treatment happening, they make sure that there is enough staff for essential purposes but for example things like elective surgeries won't happen. Or they strike in certain areas and not others so patients are moved to a different hospital that isn't in the strike area.
And no one is going to release rapists or allow nuclear accidents either. Don't be ridiculous.

Wouldloveanother · 22/08/2022 14:01

To everyone saying not to strike - what are the alternatives?

LadyWithLapdog · 22/08/2022 13:58

Dotjones I can only assume you never worked in your life. Such rubbish you spout. Go back up the chimneys, kids.

Dotjones · 22/08/2022 13:51

I oppose strikers, nobody should be allowed to strike if it damages service levels. If people aren't happy with their job or conditions they should just resign. That way one of two things will happen, they'll be replaced by someone prepared to do the job for that pay, or the employer will have to improve the offer to attract people.

I wholeheartedly agree that pay rises should have the same triple lock guarantee that pensioners get, but it should be for ALL workers, not just those who shout the loudest or cause the most disruption.

I suppose a compromise could be that people continue to be allowed to strike, but unions and their members are financially liable for problems the strike causes. That way strikes would be seen as a last resort rather than the primary option. A benefit of this would be that those strikes which cause the most harm would prohibitively expensive for the strikers, the prospect of personal financial ruin for union members might make them consider whether it's worth striking over or perhaps they should just find themselves a different job.

I don't understand the mentality of those who say they wholeheartedly support the right to strike. I can't help but feel if it were their child who was denied lifesaving treatment because doctors were on strike, or whose rapist was released from prison because prison officers were on strike, or whose region was destroyed in a nuclear power plant catastrophe because the technicians were on strike, they'd have a different view.

Striking is mob rule. Maybe it feels good but mob rule is always doomed to fail.

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 13:20

Let’s face it one day trains will all be fully automated with no driver or staff and security will be provided by cameras and help buttons.

That might happen on Crossrail and other new projects. It will never happen on most of the existing lines, you will always need a member of staff onboard in case of emergency because cramped Victorian tunnels don't lend themselves well to passengers evacuating themselves unaided.

(I would renationalise rail for sure. Doesn’t make any sense to privatise an industry where there’s no competition. “Oh, the train to Glasgow is rubbish, I’ll get the train to Folkestone instead.”)

Yes and no. The whole thing of having multiple operating companies competing directly with each other was a daft idea when the duplicate lines that would have allowed it were pruned in the 1960s. There is still some internal competition, as Avanti's service is appalling at the moment you might prefer to go with LNER from Kings Cross to Glasgow instead. The belief that railways hold a monopoly hasn't added up for years anyway, rail is in competition with airlines, coaches, and private cars.

I'd sooner see the railway turned into a vertically-integrated system. Doesn't have to be one massive company, it could be divvied up on a regional basis. The important thing should be that the infrastructure and trains share common management so that everyone is pulling together.

It needs more independence too. BR was handed its annual sum of money by the Treasury and largely left to get on with the job, which it did a reasonable job with the limited resources provided once it had a chance to organise itself. Under so-called privatisation on the other hand, Whitehall is micro-managing the railway to an impossible degree, every expense over £500 needs to be rubber-stamped by central government, even though the admin costs of doing this often exceeds the cost of whatever spare part they were buying in the first place.

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 13:08

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 09:39

Wales isn't a separate country and is subject to many UK wide policies that effect its health service, not least primary care, training, pay and retention

That doesn't explain why many of our public services are measurably worse than those in England.

Incidentally, my county council is run by a Tory-led coalition. I've no complaints about how it's run, the roads are in a reasonable state of repair and I never find my bins overflowing. Council tax is lower than neighbouring counties too.

gatehouseoffleet · 22/08/2022 11:37

train drivers, signallers and a whole host of technical and maintenance staff take years to train and learn their patch

This is the key thing really. Being a train driver is very hard. I've seen a description of what signallers do on the "Secrets of the London Underground" programme and oh my goodness they deserve every penny they get!

They're already getting rid of ticket offices by very rarely having them open. You're more likely to win the lottery than find my local ticket office open. It would probably be a better use of staff to do away with guards on trains; do away with ticket office staff and have staff on stations who can sell tickets if people need help and can't use the ticket machines (which are much better than they were, and sell most tickets now), and provide help for the disabled. The disabled are continually ignored and don't get their booked assistance - the RMT could actually strike about that! Guards don't provide a presence on late night trains as they hide away in their little boxes, so that is not a reason to keep them either.

I am not well enough informed to have a view on the inspection/maintenance intervals etc.

Notplayingball · 22/08/2022 11:02

*hasn't happened!

Notplayingball · 22/08/2022 11:02

Laughingravy · 22/08/2022 00:57

My partner is ex railway and still has mates on the railway, this is his take on it all. In some ways it's a shame that the argument about pay is happening at the same time as sweeping changes to working practices and T&Cs as it muddies the water.

To begin with there is an aim to close all ticket offices except at big mainline stations because 'everyone buys online now'. The 1000s of staff will simply be discarded to save money, totally overlooking the fact that the railway is a public service for all and not just those with a smartphone.

Secondly it is proposed that all service and maintenance intervals be extended. So monthly inspections will become every other month and so on. This is a potential major safety issue and solely aimed at saving money. Many current NR trackside employees will be made redundant and the work contracted to companies who will pick up and drop cheap agency workers as it suits.

Lastly - and a bit complicated - track walk inspections are done in daylight with a look out man to protect the men working. NR aim to scrap this method and do all the inspections overnight, temporarily closing a section of line to check it. To achieve this the lineside workers will forced to agree to a new contract and will have to do a minimum of 38 weeks of nights. Or they'll just ship in agency staff on lower pay and poor conditions of service.

My only concern about these strikes is the Tories will use them to justify changing laws to prevent withdrawal of labour. Its their go to when someone does something they don't like.

Oh yes and the PP who's never seen a guard or ticket inspector on a train in ten years - calling total BS on that one.

Finally to the PP suggesting striking should be illegal and workers should just quit if they are unhappy. That's all well and good if its a job you can pick up in a morning but train drivers, signallers and a whole host of technical and maintenance staff take years to train and learn their patch. In a way it would serve that PP right if they did ban strikes and these people walked away. Cheap agency staff your way out of that one....

Look out doesn't happen and has happened for years in Scotland.

Notplayingball · 22/08/2022 11:00

DdraigGoch · 21/08/2022 23:46

Any TA earning less than £18k is not on full-time hours. I'm not sure that there are many TAs who work anti-social hours either, nor are responsible for the safety of 1,000 people.

Exactly 🤦🏻 the two jobs are hardly comparable.

Notplayingball · 22/08/2022 10:58

Sobaridiot · 21/08/2022 22:49

No. I think rail workers wages are far too high for what they do.

Yes, teachers/nurses/doctors/police need pay rises desperately but considering the public purse is finite...rail workers are not the most deserving by far.

All this is going to do is push rail fares up and rail travel is not worth the cost it is at the moment, let alone if prices increase. I think the rail workers striking have got it petty cushy actually, and they won't quit and get another job because they won't find one that pays so well for little skill.

Okay, £24-26k is way too high for a railway salary. Of course it is.....

Blossomtoes · 22/08/2022 10:37

I’m not going to base my voting decisions on whether or not MPs are encouraged to turn up on picket lines. You may well have a devolved Labour government in Wales, it’s still subject to the spending decisions and legislation of the Tories in Westminster so its hands are tied.

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 22/08/2022 10:32

But also again wales do have a Labour Government and we are not OK

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 22/08/2022 10:31

Blossomtoes · 22/08/2022 10:21

This labour Governemnt seem to be just slightly poorer Tories

What Labour government? We haven’t had one for 12 years. We have absolutely no idea what the next one will be like. The thing that’s certain is that it won’t be any worse than this Tory one.

Alright love. Labour Party.

We do. Because the Labour leader has told MPs not to go to picket lines....the lead or the Labour Party

The Party created for the unions and workers to have a voice.

It may not be worse. But I no longer have hope it will be better.