Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do people think about rail strikes?

409 replies

ITUnurse · 20/08/2022 17:21

I cannot find any threads on the rail strikes / opinion of them.

I personally do support the strikes. We in the NHS will face a similar struggle shortly. I support the rights of workers to strike. Conditions at the moment are dire.

However, if England is so right wing and strikes aren't supported and the Tories continue to be voted in. I've not seen much public support online except from a few and I'm at risk of being in an echo chamber.

Ultimately if England is so under the thumb of the tories, I'm not sure what the long term solution is. The rest of the UK doesn't return the Tories in such numbers.

If you don't support strike action, what do you think the rail workers, NHS workers etc should do? We've already got people leaving enmasse. It's difficult to comment on the conditions of a job you don't work in and nurses regularly get gaslighted on here I am genuinely concerned as to what is going to happen to the public sector of the UK with this right wing stranglehold.

Thanks

OP posts:
Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:11

All the 100% strike supporters, please tell me where the money is coming from.

Increased taxation for public services, leads to inflationary spiral and this is what happened in the 70s.

Increased prices for services like RM.and Rail means people who use those services either find alternatives reduce frequency of use or lose more money to pay the extra

It's not gonna come from CEos bonuses in a million years!!

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 18:52

Luxurysleuth007 · 10/12/2022 07:47

Absolutely support them and anyone else who has to take such action due to not being paid appropriately.

Yeah but where is the money coming from? It wil lead to increasing rail fares, great!

Already a family ticket Manchester to London is £175 and its a lot fir most families.
If it was 250 or so it wouldn't be an option for me personally and I'm average income.

MarshaMelrose · 10/12/2022 18:16

Tadpoll · 10/12/2022 07:23

The people arguing for ticket office closure, are you aware for people that don't really do technology, they can print out route plans and timetables, sort out advance tickets that are otherwise only available online and the refund process is fairly straightforward if you need one. They can also tell you when the ticket is valid and by which route. Or if your railcard expires or is lost, replace it in 10 minutes. Tell you that you can use an off-peak ticket on the next train, when the machines still think it's peak time. Realise that there's a few of you in your group but paying separately and tell you that if you pay together, you'll get a discount. They also notice if a ticket would end up cheaper overall including the cost of a Railcard and suggest you buy one.

I’d love to know which alternative universe this happens in…

Yeah, I mean I love the ticket guy in my local station - when he's there. But he sells tickets and gives train times - not always correctly. The idea that he'd do calculations on group permutations and finds me cheaper tockets fills me with surprise. As it would him, too, to be honest!

Luxurysleuth007 · 10/12/2022 07:47

Absolutely support them and anyone else who has to take such action due to not being paid appropriately.

MilkyYay · 10/12/2022 07:44

I support strikes for inflation pay rises.

However i think they need to separate out the issue of modernisation. Continuing to demand that staffing never change is absurd and wont allow railways to survive. I don't agree with the way they are blocking driver operated doors, ticket office closures etc. These technology improvements allow railways to operate at lower cost which keeps fares down. As long as people are compensated fairly, i don't have a problem with genuine redundancies where a role is no longer required.

A job isnt guaranteed for life. There needs to be programmes to help people retrain.

lightisnotwhite · 10/12/2022 07:39

No I don’t support them especially over Christmas. That’s a really mean spirited way to get what you want. It’s not hurting commuters who are their bread and butter but families and friends who want to spend Christmas together.

No one in the public sector should be getting a pay rise. Inflation is a bloody nightmare. It’s evident their are major problems in the NHS but it clearly needs refitting for the 21st century not more money thrown at whoever shouts loudest.

Tadpoll · 10/12/2022 07:31

SherbetDips · 10/12/2022 07:28

I don’t support them, the people they want to hurt don’t care and they are instead hurting the hardworking public.

Agree.

I do actually think there’s an element of spite in this too though.

I honestly couldn’t in all conscience strike knowing that I am preventing people seeing their loved ones at Christmas, workers getting to their jobs in a cost of living crisis and teenagers getting to school after 2 years of Covid.

When will they realise the impact of this?

SherbetDips · 10/12/2022 07:28

I don’t support them, the people they want to hurt don’t care and they are instead hurting the hardworking public.

Tadpoll · 10/12/2022 07:23

The people arguing for ticket office closure, are you aware for people that don't really do technology, they can print out route plans and timetables, sort out advance tickets that are otherwise only available online and the refund process is fairly straightforward if you need one. They can also tell you when the ticket is valid and by which route. Or if your railcard expires or is lost, replace it in 10 minutes. Tell you that you can use an off-peak ticket on the next train, when the machines still think it's peak time. Realise that there's a few of you in your group but paying separately and tell you that if you pay together, you'll get a discount. They also notice if a ticket would end up cheaper overall including the cost of a Railcard and suggest you buy one.

I’d love to know which alternative universe this happens in…

Tadpoll · 10/12/2022 07:22

How are computers going to assist disabled passengers btw?

I’ve never seen staff assisting a disabled passenger.

Our station doesn’t even have rumble strips or ramps from one platform to the other - the only way is over the steps. Completely inaccessible.

Ticket office is rarely open either and everyone somehow manages. We just don’t rely on people to be there. It’s a commuter station too.

YetiTeri · 10/12/2022 07:00

Itsoktogiveup · 09/12/2022 23:15

I don’t support the rail strikes, I think they should do them Japan style where the rail workers refuse to charge people money for travelling, so the company still loses the £££££ but travellers can still get to their jobs and other essential services aren’t hit.

(Tbh pretty much all the rail workers I’ve ever met have been rude power trippy and unhelpful, the sort of people who the police would reject, certainly our local station master is overpaid whatever he’s getting. Shuts ticket office when he feels like it so he can sit round the corner smoking and pretending he can’t see the queue of people missing their train because the office is shut. I look forward to the day when computers run trains! I don’t know what they’re striking about this time and haven’t bothered to check so I doubt it’ll get them much sympathy. I use Southern who’ve been striking on and off for years, we’re used to it.)

Whatever the rail strike is supposed to achieve, it won’t.

The NHS is a completely completely different issue, mostly full of wonderful people working way over their contracted hours in horrific conditions, successive governments have deliberately underfunded it to create pressure for an American style system and then treated them like shit during the pandemic and something has to be done. I’m not convinced strikes are the answer, I’ve held a job in the past where it was illegal for me to strike and I expect the government will simply extend that to NHS workers.

If they followed your advice they'd have a criminal record as that's illegal under current laws.

How are computers going to assist disabled passengers btw?

GooglyEyeballs · 10/12/2022 01:46

I think they have every right to strike, and it's appalling that salaries don't cover the cost of living. I also thing the cost of living is a wider issue though and sympathise with those who are frustrated with the strikes. The strike hasn't affected me but I think the state of this country, and the poverty, the discrepancy between the rich and the poor not only in lifestyle but also in fair ess and rules is utterly insane.

MarshaMelrose · 10/12/2022 01:34

Im not against rail strikes but I don't think they're being effective which is why Lynch is having to increase them. Even during normal working, it's common to not have trains turn up so I'm used to inconvenience.
Ultimately, passengers will end up having to pay higher prices to compensate for losses. Always the public that lose out.

Itsoktogiveup · 09/12/2022 23:15

I don’t support the rail strikes, I think they should do them Japan style where the rail workers refuse to charge people money for travelling, so the company still loses the £££££ but travellers can still get to their jobs and other essential services aren’t hit.

(Tbh pretty much all the rail workers I’ve ever met have been rude power trippy and unhelpful, the sort of people who the police would reject, certainly our local station master is overpaid whatever he’s getting. Shuts ticket office when he feels like it so he can sit round the corner smoking and pretending he can’t see the queue of people missing their train because the office is shut. I look forward to the day when computers run trains! I don’t know what they’re striking about this time and haven’t bothered to check so I doubt it’ll get them much sympathy. I use Southern who’ve been striking on and off for years, we’re used to it.)

Whatever the rail strike is supposed to achieve, it won’t.

The NHS is a completely completely different issue, mostly full of wonderful people working way over their contracted hours in horrific conditions, successive governments have deliberately underfunded it to create pressure for an American style system and then treated them like shit during the pandemic and something has to be done. I’m not convinced strikes are the answer, I’ve held a job in the past where it was illegal for me to strike and I expect the government will simply extend that to NHS workers.

Liervik · 09/12/2022 22:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for privacy reasons.

daisychain01 · 23/08/2022 08:29

^ to @Sobaridiot comment

daisychain01 · 23/08/2022 08:29

Laughingravy · 22/08/2022 23:26

Disappointed maybe.
Like Oscar Wilde once said there are some who “know the price of everything and the value of nothing”

It isn't delusional (and shouldn't be thus minimised) to expect utilities to be there for the benefit of the majority of the citizens of a country. And so it was thus before public transport became a profit-making machine, according to a capitalist ideology - what is clear is that there needs to be a re-set, back to a nationalised public service. That will be challenging to achieve, but if we stay stuck in the same groove, nothing will improve.

Competition, incentives towards profit only, isn't working, so these strikes could just tip the balance towards a system that works for the majority. Mostly it will mitigate the greed and lack of accountability that has been allowed to persist for far too long.

Laughingravy · 22/08/2022 23:26

Sobaridiot · 22/08/2022 18:50

As I said, and you either ignored or missed, the railways, despite our politicians best efforts, is a public transport system and should foremost be service. It shouldn’t be seen as just another business and the profit motive shouldn’t be upper most.

You really are delusional if you actually believe this.

Disappointed maybe.
Like Oscar Wilde once said there are some who “know the price of everything and the value of nothing”

trytopullyoursocksup · 22/08/2022 19:48

I support the strikes. I wish more workers were unionised and could strike and therefore negotiate more effectively. Every striker is doing it for their whole union but in a way they're doing it for everyone else too. None of us benefit from a race to the bottom. We can't all work for the best pay and conditions but if some unions are working to keep standards off the absolute floor it's good for all of us.

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 19:39

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 19:30

The Swiss have the best by many measures. Certainly not the cheapest though, they put an enormous amount of public subsidy into it.

Off topic but my mum went around Switzerland by train in the 1950s before she started her nurse training.

I ve used the French and Swedish railways, they were very cheap.

You re a rail buff aren't you, so i wont argue with you!!! lol!

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 19:39

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 19:14

My cousin is a former barrister and she says the last 10 years has seen a dramatic fall in convictions for all crimes and a real terms fall in funding for legal aid and removal of entitlement.

Not too mention pay.

25% of criminal aid Barristers have left that sector in the last 5 years, with an avg wait of 18months before a case gets to trial, 3 years for rape.

But even if we accept you re right and the situation developed 20 or 30 + years ago... the Tories have been in for over 12 years and have done nothing, nothing at all to improve matters, its getting worse and worse.

But even if we accept you re right and the situation developed 20 or 30 + years ago
That's not quite what I said. I said that the situation had been developing for several decades. The criminal justice system has been dysfunctional for a long time, focusing on the rights of the offender at the expense of the victim. Politicians of all hues have been to blame - both Theresa May and Sadiq Khan have been responsible for the plummeting stop-and-search rates in London, which has resulted in a huge increase in violent crime. Courts are far too soft (possibly encouraged to be so by the MoJ because of the lack of prison spaces). Police officers are hampered by an avalanche of paperwork, one heaped up by every new government.

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 19:30

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 19:22

Under privatisation, yes its a business, in most of Europe, its seen as a service first.

Who has the best and also the cheapest railways?

The Swiss have the best by many measures. Certainly not the cheapest though, they put an enormous amount of public subsidy into it.

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 19:22

Sobaridiot · 22/08/2022 18:50

As I said, and you either ignored or missed, the railways, despite our politicians best efforts, is a public transport system and should foremost be service. It shouldn’t be seen as just another business and the profit motive shouldn’t be upper most.

You really are delusional if you actually believe this.

Under privatisation, yes its a business, in most of Europe, its seen as a service first.

Who has the best and also the cheapest railways?

Alexandra2001 · 22/08/2022 19:14

DdraigGoch · 22/08/2022 16:56

This sorry state of affairs has been developing for decades, spanning multiple colours of government.

My cousin is a former barrister and she says the last 10 years has seen a dramatic fall in convictions for all crimes and a real terms fall in funding for legal aid and removal of entitlement.

Not too mention pay.

25% of criminal aid Barristers have left that sector in the last 5 years, with an avg wait of 18months before a case gets to trial, 3 years for rape.

But even if we accept you re right and the situation developed 20 or 30 + years ago... the Tories have been in for over 12 years and have done nothing, nothing at all to improve matters, its getting worse and worse.

Sobaridiot · 22/08/2022 18:50

As I said, and you either ignored or missed, the railways, despite our politicians best efforts, is a public transport system and should foremost be service. It shouldn’t be seen as just another business and the profit motive shouldn’t be upper most.

You really are delusional if you actually believe this.