Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do people think about rail strikes?

409 replies

ITUnurse · 20/08/2022 17:21

I cannot find any threads on the rail strikes / opinion of them.

I personally do support the strikes. We in the NHS will face a similar struggle shortly. I support the rights of workers to strike. Conditions at the moment are dire.

However, if England is so right wing and strikes aren't supported and the Tories continue to be voted in. I've not seen much public support online except from a few and I'm at risk of being in an echo chamber.

Ultimately if England is so under the thumb of the tories, I'm not sure what the long term solution is. The rest of the UK doesn't return the Tories in such numbers.

If you don't support strike action, what do you think the rail workers, NHS workers etc should do? We've already got people leaving enmasse. It's difficult to comment on the conditions of a job you don't work in and nurses regularly get gaslighted on here I am genuinely concerned as to what is going to happen to the public sector of the UK with this right wing stranglehold.

Thanks

OP posts:
SirMingeALot · 11/12/2022 13:39

Alexandra2001 · 11/12/2022 08:10

How does that work then?

The employers and the RMT had a compromise deal, 10% over 2 years (so less than half the rate of inflation) but the Govt torpedoed that.

Health Unions calling for pay talks with Govt (will call off strikes)... Govt refusing... & have refused any talks on pay from the very beginning.

Both unions willing to meet in the middle....

Funny you call for respect but also say you would laugh in the face of no compulsory redundancies.... more management double speak...

On the inflation argument, we ve very low pay rises right now, but inflation out of control.. caused in the main, by energy prices, supply issues and companies determined to keep profits as high as pre Ukraine/Covid.

Agreed.

DdraigGoch · 11/12/2022 13:34

Metabigot · 11/12/2022 10:35

No company should be forced to agree to a no compulsory redundancies teem as it will limit their ability to fit resource to need/ demand.

That's my view anyway, but I realise how businesses work and it honestly feels like quite a few in here don't get that.

When it takes 15 months to train staff then you can't be short-termist anyway.

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 11/12/2022 11:25

The problem is professionals who work for the rail networks, nhs, teaching, police, firebrigade, ambulances and all other essential areas are struggling to have a decent standard of living and it's just not fair.

These are people who really genuinely contribute to society

As an NHS worker myself I wholeheartedly believe we should all be earning enough to live reasonable and not be worried 😟

Metabigot · 11/12/2022 10:35

No company should be forced to agree to a no compulsory redundancies teem as it will limit their ability to fit resource to need/ demand.

That's my view anyway, but I realise how businesses work and it honestly feels like quite a few in here don't get that.

Fishwifer · 11/12/2022 08:21

I support strikes. Workers have had their earnings decimated for decades. Enough is enough.

It's clear that the democratic process/politicians aren't solving the real issue (the rich poor divide getting worse) and for that reason I support more stringent methods.

We (many industries) should have been striking years ago.

Too many cuts. Too much overwork. All while those at the top take a bigger and bigger slice of the profit.

(I don't work in the railways btw, just a user of them. Too expensive for me to use every day but the problem is not most of the lower down workers!)

Alexandra2001 · 11/12/2022 08:10

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 23:22

Hear hear . I work in this field ( restructuring/ corporate axe welding). Its never nice to put someone out of a job but you need to prune the structure/ resource to maintain the business most effectively.

Better that than it fails and everyone out of a job.

I've recently been working with a public sector client and its hard work as the unions obviously just want thr best for their members and don't really care about the success of he business if that doesn't favour their members.

But if they say they want a guarantee of no compulsory redundancies in any negotiations I will laugh in their face.

Management need to be able to have thr right to manage, negotiations should be respectful of both views and aim to meet in the middle not unions throw multiple strikes at Xmas because they didn't get their full way.

How does that work then?

The employers and the RMT had a compromise deal, 10% over 2 years (so less than half the rate of inflation) but the Govt torpedoed that.

Health Unions calling for pay talks with Govt (will call off strikes)... Govt refusing... & have refused any talks on pay from the very beginning.

Both unions willing to meet in the middle....

Funny you call for respect but also say you would laugh in the face of no compulsory redundancies.... more management double speak...

On the inflation argument, we ve very low pay rises right now, but inflation out of control.. caused in the main, by energy prices, supply issues and companies determined to keep profits as high as pre Ukraine/Covid.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 23:22

MilkyYay · 10/12/2022 07:44

I support strikes for inflation pay rises.

However i think they need to separate out the issue of modernisation. Continuing to demand that staffing never change is absurd and wont allow railways to survive. I don't agree with the way they are blocking driver operated doors, ticket office closures etc. These technology improvements allow railways to operate at lower cost which keeps fares down. As long as people are compensated fairly, i don't have a problem with genuine redundancies where a role is no longer required.

A job isnt guaranteed for life. There needs to be programmes to help people retrain.

Hear hear . I work in this field ( restructuring/ corporate axe welding). Its never nice to put someone out of a job but you need to prune the structure/ resource to maintain the business most effectively.

Better that than it fails and everyone out of a job.

I've recently been working with a public sector client and its hard work as the unions obviously just want thr best for their members and don't really care about the success of he business if that doesn't favour their members.

But if they say they want a guarantee of no compulsory redundancies in any negotiations I will laugh in their face.

Management need to be able to have thr right to manage, negotiations should be respectful of both views and aim to meet in the middle not unions throw multiple strikes at Xmas because they didn't get their full way.

lightisnotwhite · 10/12/2022 23:05

DdraigGoch · 10/12/2022 22:03

Over the last thirty years, wages have dropped by a third in real terms. Enough is enough.

Bollocks. I’ve never been paid more than £30k my entire working life ( 36 years). Sometimes it’s felt like an absolute fortune and sometimes not, depending on; my age, having children, tax, being part of a couple, renting privately, renting through a HA and the pressures of job itself.
It’s relative.If your job relies on a long commute that you pay for, you’re worse off. By a lot but not true of people that WFH or get expenses.

Supermarkets Pat £10 ish an hour which is £19k. So many jobs pay less including local councils, TA’s, nursery workers etc. So what happens when these essential workers want more?

cyrila · 10/12/2022 22:07

I'm done with it. I'm self employed and if I don't work I don't get paid. To get to work by train takes me 25 mins. By bus nearly 2 hours and I need to leave at the crack of dawn to get there. I work in an industry that was decimated by the pandemic and I've just got back on my feet this year. I feel depressed and miserable because I can't see a way forward.

DdraigGoch · 10/12/2022 22:03

BahHumbug2022 · 10/12/2022 21:15

Yeah we know shareholders are the problem. So why aren’t they striking about that?

Of course you can’t expect your money to buy you the same if we have high inflation. That’s why it’s inflation. Bit Inflation is hard to live with. Interest rates rise, prices rise, life gets tough. If everyone gets higher wages, the prices go up to pay fir it. Inflation spiral. Ride it out and inflation slows and everyone gets back on with buying houses and spending in shops.

Over the last thirty years, wages have dropped by a third in real terms. Enough is enough.

DdraigGoch · 10/12/2022 22:02

Just to add, this is why TPE and Avanti (among others) are running such a poor service at the moment.

DdraigGoch · 10/12/2022 21:59

BahHumbug2022 · 10/12/2022 20:48

Well then they should leave. If the pay and conditions aren’t good enough theres a choice.That’s exactly why wages should increase - to attract staff.
People still got annual pay rises when the rate of inflation nothing . You can’t argue it both ways.

I don’t object to strikes in and of themselves but it’s objective has to be realistic and deliverable and obviously for the benefit of the public if it’s public service.

How many times does this have to be repeated? They ARE leaving. One TPE depot is down 60 drivers, through a combination of early retirements and poaching by the freight hauliers. The MD wants to raise wages and rebuild morale so that he can keep his staff but the government won't let him. A driver can hand in their three months notice and it'll take you 15 months to train their replacement.

I work for an operator which is controlled by a devolved government, not the DfT. We've got a steady stream of people joining from English TOCs as they get fed up with their treatment.

DdraigGoch · 10/12/2022 21:54

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:36

Do they influence the privatised company strikes?

I get your point for public sector but ain't gonna happen with tories

It might as well be public sector. The ERMAs basically leave the operators at the beck and call of the DfT. The government have orchestrated this, even the FT has called them out for it.

DdraigGoch · 10/12/2022 21:52

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:11

All the 100% strike supporters, please tell me where the money is coming from.

Increased taxation for public services, leads to inflationary spiral and this is what happened in the 70s.

Increased prices for services like RM.and Rail means people who use those services either find alternatives reduce frequency of use or lose more money to pay the extra

It's not gonna come from CEos bonuses in a million years!!

Germany spends 50% more on rail subsidies than we do. Switzerland spends double. If we're serious about looking after our planet then we should follow suit.

BahHumbug2022 · 10/12/2022 21:15

Yeah we know shareholders are the problem. So why aren’t they striking about that?

Of course you can’t expect your money to buy you the same if we have high inflation. That’s why it’s inflation. Bit Inflation is hard to live with. Interest rates rise, prices rise, life gets tough. If everyone gets higher wages, the prices go up to pay fir it. Inflation spiral. Ride it out and inflation slows and everyone gets back on with buying houses and spending in shops.

Alexandra2001 · 10/12/2022 20:59

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:30

Serious question, no one can answer it ?

Anyone?

So far, no one (workers) has had inflation busting pay rises.. yet inflation is over 11% and in some areas far higher e.g food 16%.

So whatever is driving inflation it is not pay rises (corporate greed perhaps? Tesco etc still making billions...) inflation will continue whilst Putin wages war and we cannot import cheaper energy...... we are decades away from enough nuclear or renewables to compensate.

But when energy prices do fall, i wonder how quickly other prices will fall too... answer: they won't.

Funny how, when inflation was 1 or 2% but train fares went up by 6% the argument that it would lead to less usage didn't seem to come from ministers lips...

Train fares can go up because petrol prices have gone up by 50% .. what is needed is better reliability... but a better question would be why the UK has the most expensive (by far) fares in Europe? and has done for years with profits going to shareholders overseas..

Liervik · 10/12/2022 20:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for privacy reasons.

BahHumbug2022 · 10/12/2022 20:48

camdenn · 10/12/2022 19:35

No one in the public sector should be getting a pay rise.

The alternative is that staff will leave. Leaving you in the position with the same amount as staff working as on strike days, enjoy “really mean sprit” all year round xoxo

Well then they should leave. If the pay and conditions aren’t good enough theres a choice.That’s exactly why wages should increase - to attract staff.
People still got annual pay rises when the rate of inflation nothing . You can’t argue it both ways.

I don’t object to strikes in and of themselves but it’s objective has to be realistic and deliverable and obviously for the benefit of the public if it’s public service.

Tadpoll · 10/12/2022 20:24

I find it interesting that a month or so ago these threads were overwhelmingly in support of the strikers.

Less so now.

NeedWineNow · 10/12/2022 19:54

lightisnotwhite · 10/12/2022 07:39

No I don’t support them especially over Christmas. That’s a really mean spirited way to get what you want. It’s not hurting commuters who are their bread and butter but families and friends who want to spend Christmas together.

No one in the public sector should be getting a pay rise. Inflation is a bloody nightmare. It’s evident their are major problems in the NHS but it clearly needs refitting for the 21st century not more money thrown at whoever shouts loudest.

This. For the first time in 3 years we have an Xmas without restrictions and what do the union's do? That's right fuck it up. And please don't cry me crocodile tears and say you regret inconveniencing the public. This is coordinated and political, so why won't you just admit it.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:46

Also Michelle Mone and Co would be a drop in thr ocean compared to millions of public sector workers even if they did as you suggest

Would you be happy with tax hikes and how much tax would you be willing to pay extra? £1000?.£5000?

I'd go a grand as I'm on decent money but many would find it extremely difficult at the current time.

Then they would want a pay rise to afford it

We all would

Inflation would spiral, its basic economics

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:36

Blossomtoes · 10/12/2022 19:32

Maybe the government could stop throwing money at its mates and make the likes of Lady Mone pay their fraudulent gains back.

Do they influence the privatised company strikes?

I get your point for public sector but ain't gonna happen with tories

camdenn · 10/12/2022 19:35

lightisnotwhite · 10/12/2022 07:39

No I don’t support them especially over Christmas. That’s a really mean spirited way to get what you want. It’s not hurting commuters who are their bread and butter but families and friends who want to spend Christmas together.

No one in the public sector should be getting a pay rise. Inflation is a bloody nightmare. It’s evident their are major problems in the NHS but it clearly needs refitting for the 21st century not more money thrown at whoever shouts loudest.

No one in the public sector should be getting a pay rise.

The alternative is that staff will leave. Leaving you in the position with the same amount as staff working as on strike days, enjoy “really mean sprit” all year round xoxo

Blossomtoes · 10/12/2022 19:32

Maybe the government could stop throwing money at its mates and make the likes of Lady Mone pay their fraudulent gains back.

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:30

Metabigot · 10/12/2022 19:11

All the 100% strike supporters, please tell me where the money is coming from.

Increased taxation for public services, leads to inflationary spiral and this is what happened in the 70s.

Increased prices for services like RM.and Rail means people who use those services either find alternatives reduce frequency of use or lose more money to pay the extra

It's not gonna come from CEos bonuses in a million years!!

Serious question, no one can answer it ?

Anyone?