Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think truss will be a disaster for uk?

265 replies

Ilovemycatalot · 20/08/2022 13:50

All the polls say she is ahead of sunak but I’m dreading her getting into power. Can anyone think of any positives as I’m struggling. I’m not that keen on sunak but given the choice I’d much rather him.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 29/08/2022 23:09

I notice with interest that a Wikipedia edit which references Liz Truss as having a "clear sharp mind" has been rejected with the reasoning that "Liz Truss has never demonstrated a clear sharp mind in her life."

Blossomtoes · 29/08/2022 17:25

Festoonlights · 29/08/2022 08:42

Don’t be ridiculous. Labour handed over the reins with empty coffers in the middle of the financial crash of 2008 or did you conveniently forget that fact? It took ten whole painful years to get the country back into shape and then covid happened.

The rewriting of history on here is ludicrous.

Particularly the rewriting of history in this post. Austerity was purely ideological, there was plenty of money - Osborne and Cameron just didn’t want to spend it. If only the Libdems had jumped the other way in 2010, how different things would have been.

Sporty2022 · 29/08/2022 17:12

John Major understand economics, he was chancellor of the exchequer.But in 1990, the country was different to today. We’ve just had Brexit, a pandemic.. So can’t really compare.

Actually a lot of what Major said made sense when in came to many things.

People on benefits were pretty much left alone too.

Id rather have him back then the two potential leaders, Truss is favourite to win.

And the next GE is two years away.

None of the old Tories can believe what has happened to their old party.

Alexandra2001 · 29/08/2022 09:17

Festoonlights · 29/08/2022 08:42

Don’t be ridiculous. Labour handed over the reins with empty coffers in the middle of the financial crash of 2008 or did you conveniently forget that fact? It took ten whole painful years to get the country back into shape and then covid happened.

The rewriting of history on here is ludicrous.

Labour lost in 2010, not 2008, their fiscal plans for the banks were supported by the Tories.
The coffers were not empty at all, GDP was still almost 2 trillion, tax revenue still around 800 billion, the money to bail out the banks was mainly borrowed, the note left by Burn, was part of a long standing "joke" going back decades.

12 years of austerity and every single thing they said they would improve has got worse, often a great deal worse.

Austerity lasted far too long and is at the root cause of most of our problems, no other european country carried it on for so long & that is solely down to the Tories who are now more right wing than RN or the Freedom Party.

Cornettoninja · 29/08/2022 08:50

plus the silence is deafening that you can’t specify anything to defend your assertion,

Cornettoninja · 29/08/2022 08:49

Festoonlights · 29/08/2022 08:42

Don’t be ridiculous. Labour handed over the reins with empty coffers in the middle of the financial crash of 2008 or did you conveniently forget that fact? It took ten whole painful years to get the country back into shape and then covid happened.

The rewriting of history on here is ludicrous.

You think the country was ‘back in shape’ when covid hit?

the (global) financial crash explains depleted funds don’t you think? What do you think our funds look like now? Do you think we’re well placed to get through the next impending crash caused by chinas property bubble bursting?

Face it, the tories have been in power for over a decade and literally nothing has improved, in fact many areas (healthcare, water, education, logistics) are worse directly caused by the fact they’ve been neglected or wrung dry to fund mates projects.

We’re a failed state.

Festoonlights · 29/08/2022 08:42

Cornettoninja · 29/08/2022 08:33

he was not perfect but he cared a lot about social care, levelling up, green energy etc - none of those things are remotely conservative

what’s your reason for believing he cared about any of these things? All of these areas are tangibly worse following twelve years of tories and his premiership.

if he does/did genuinely care then at best he’s just plain incompetent.

Don’t be ridiculous. Labour handed over the reins with empty coffers in the middle of the financial crash of 2008 or did you conveniently forget that fact? It took ten whole painful years to get the country back into shape and then covid happened.

The rewriting of history on here is ludicrous.

Novum · 29/08/2022 08:37

Sporty2022 · 28/08/2022 22:55

I’m praying Sunak wins only because Truss terrifies me.

But weirdly, I still wouldn’t be surprised if the Tories get back into power at the next GE.

Remember they won the 1992 election even after being so unpopular after a decade of Thatcher, poll tax etc etc.

1992 isn't really comparable. Major was reasonably competent, particularly in terms of finance, and his policies were beacons of humanity when compared with Truss's.

Cornettoninja · 29/08/2022 08:33

he was not perfect but he cared a lot about social care, levelling up, green energy etc - none of those things are remotely conservative

what’s your reason for believing he cared about any of these things? All of these areas are tangibly worse following twelve years of tories and his premiership.

if he does/did genuinely care then at best he’s just plain incompetent.

Endlesssummer2022 · 29/08/2022 08:12

‘The Tory party is nothing but UKIP in disguise now. The ERG disaster capitalist headbangers are totally in control, and it bears no resemblance to the Tory party pre-2010.

The likes of Heseltine and Hurd would struggle to get selected as candidates today. And I think it's appalling that just 160,000 people are choosing the next PM. I'd like to see a rule that if the party of government changes leader, they have to have a general election within 90 days of taking office, so that we all get a say.This will be the 3rd time in just over 6 years that we've had a PM imposed on us by the Tory party.’

Well said @LakieLady . Spot on.

LakieLady · 29/08/2022 08:02

Anothernamechangeplease · 20/08/2022 14:39

I am more than happy to "own" the fact that I wanted Boris out, and I wouldn't want him back under any circumstances. He was patently unfit for public office.

It is possible to believe this, while also believing that Truss will be a disaster. If she is truly the best that the Tory party has to offer, then let's have a general election and get someone better into office, rather than settling for a lying, incompetent narcissist because that's the best that the Tories can do.

The Tory party is nothing but UKIP in disguise now. The ERG disaster capitalist headbangers are totally in control, and it bears no resemblance to the Tory party pre-2010.

The likes of Heseltine and Hurd would struggle to get selected as candidates today. And I think it's appalling that just 160,000 people are choosing the next PM. I'd like to see a rule that if the party of government changes leader, they have to have a general election within 90 days of taking office, so that we all get a say.This will be the 3rd time in just over 6 years that we've had a PM imposed on us by the Tory party.

LakieLady · 29/08/2022 07:46

Tiani4 · 20/08/2022 13:57

She'll be great for the country if everyone dislikes her and votes Labour next year!!
I just hope she doesn't do much damage in the meantime

Excellent way of putting a positive spin on a looming disaster!

I just wonder how much damage she'll manage to do in the next 18 months or so before the next GE though. She's bad enough as foreign secretary, after her snidey comment about Macron the other day. France is a NATO ally, for fuck's sake.

Alexandra2001 · 29/08/2022 07:34

Festoonlights · 29/08/2022 07:25

You all wanted Boris gone, and I am said at the time and I will say it now, he will be replaced by a far more right wing PM and it is wrong to remove him, he was not perfect but he cared a lot about social care, levelling up, green energy etc - none of those things are remotely conservative.

Those very same posters screaming for Boris to go will be the same ones suffering the most. And no, I doubt it will help Labour. Labour are splitting quietly or not so quietly in two, by the time we reach pre election stages there will be open warfare between the LP and the unions/far left. We pretty much have no one to vote for now folks. In some ways we might end up unified, in one homeless mass. Literally.

No Bojo cared about talking about these things e.g. his SC bill did and does nothing for retainment or recruitment of social care staff.. which is more money.

Green Energy? he removed incentives to insulate homes and for heat pumps, he also blocked on shore wind.

Levelling up? done nothing..

Womens rights, 12 years of the Tories have seen these slashed.

Though why you think none of these V important policies are remotely conservative, is rather worrying.

BJ had no political ideology or morals, so he could be extreme right or left...

Arguable whether Truss is far right, based on most of her political life, she is more to the Left than Corbyn....

Festoonlights · 29/08/2022 07:25

You all wanted Boris gone, and I am said at the time and I will say it now, he will be replaced by a far more right wing PM and it is wrong to remove him, he was not perfect but he cared a lot about social care, levelling up, green energy etc - none of those things are remotely conservative.

Those very same posters screaming for Boris to go will be the same ones suffering the most. And no, I doubt it will help Labour. Labour are splitting quietly or not so quietly in two, by the time we reach pre election stages there will be open warfare between the LP and the unions/far left. We pretty much have no one to vote for now folks. In some ways we might end up unified, in one homeless mass. Literally.

derxa · 29/08/2022 07:12

Novum · 20/08/2022 14:51

Has his faults? Constant lying, lawbreaking, corruption, channelling large government contracts to his mates, totally cocking up on PPE and care homes during the pandemic, cocking up on vaccines after the initial rollout, appointing a cabinet of bigots and incompetents? Getting us into a situation where our fuel costs have risen exponentially more than those in Europe?

To say nothing of appointing a known sexual molester to a position of power and then sending out his ministers to tell a succession of inconsistent lies for him.

Can you name any politician at cabinet or shadow cabinet level who has anything approaching that track record?

Nicola Sturgeon

the80sweregreat · 29/08/2022 06:56

People I know don't seem too concerned about the higher bills yet, not sure why. Maybe they know the 400 is coming and many are in credit over the summer. A few have head in the sand attitude too. I don't know any business owners though and a few friends have had inheritances recently and seem to be doing alright.
I worry about my own children who have modest homes to run, but they don't seem too worried ( yet) one is in a flat share , so that helps
They are too busy working and they can manage (for now. ) I'm hoping it won't become a big problem for them in the future.
I think this situation hasn't hit many people yet.
(I'm certainly worried about it though and haven't had any inheritances and never will)
Plus many have had help already from the government , so maybe that's tied them over too
I wonder how schools will fare once they go back with these bills. I think winter looming may be a game changer though.
Truss feels that tax cuts is the way forwards snd it looks like she'll win next week.
Have to see what happens.

Sporty2022 · 28/08/2022 22:55

I’m praying Sunak wins only because Truss terrifies me.

But weirdly, I still wouldn’t be surprised if the Tories get back into power at the next GE.

Remember they won the 1992 election even after being so unpopular after a decade of Thatcher, poll tax etc etc.

Sporty2022 · 28/08/2022 22:53

The poll tax was so unpopular as mentioned, that John Major got rid of it even after he won a GE.

Yet these energy bills are going to be so much more worse than the poll tax was. So why aren’t more people getting angry about this?

Elodie09 · 28/08/2022 21:15

I am going to try and use as little energy as possible@GreenLunchBox

I do take your point but I wonder if people are just too exhausted and worn out to stand up to this outrageous price hike?
The energy companies are supposed to help with a payment plan if you are struggling to pay your bill. They are going to need a heck of a lot of staff to help with that this winter!

GreenLunchBox · 28/08/2022 20:59

Elodie09 · 28/08/2022 20:52

In Margaret Thatcher's time I believe 17 million people refused to pay the poll tax. Who is making a fortune out of this cost of living crisis , along side of the Energy companies? Enough really is enough now.

If we don't pay the energy bills they'll cut us off, so it's different to the poll tax. They couldn't put 17M people in jail, which is all they had to bargain with

Elodie09 · 28/08/2022 20:52

In Margaret Thatcher's time I believe 17 million people refused to pay the poll tax. Who is making a fortune out of this cost of living crisis , along side of the Energy companies? Enough really is enough now.

Elodie09 · 28/08/2022 20:40

We might have to get out there on the streets!

GreenLunchBox · 28/08/2022 19:54

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2022 19:50

Seems Liz Truss fuels bills on her second home are being paid by the taxpayer, so at least she's consistent about no handouts. So I'd trust Tories to be hypocritical and cruel, yes. But then isn't that what this country needs ? Remember she's on record as believing we are a load of workshy scroungers. Not really sure why there's any surprise about the lack of plans for helping us. It's not like we deserve it, is it ?

I agree

This is all very surreal. They're literally not even hiding how they are. Is it that we are so controlled by the media that as long as Murdoch et al say Tories good, Labour bad Joe public will vote them in no matter what?

We basically have to wait for the newspaper generation to die out

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2022 19:50

GreenLunchBox · 28/08/2022 19:39

But they trust the Tories 🙈🤣

Seems Liz Truss fuels bills on her second home are being paid by the taxpayer, so at least she's consistent about no handouts. So I'd trust Tories to be hypocritical and cruel, yes. But then isn't that what this country needs ? Remember she's on record as believing we are a load of workshy scroungers. Not really sure why there's any surprise about the lack of plans for helping us. It's not like we deserve it, is it ?

GreenLunchBox · 28/08/2022 19:39

the80sweregreat · 28/08/2022 19:33

I can see the tories getting in again too.
People don't trust the Labour Party.

But they trust the Tories 🙈🤣