Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry for posting here - is this normal potty training ?

81 replies

jtrai · 20/08/2022 13:07

Sorry to post here, but I'm desperate and can see there are other unanswered posts about this kind of thing in the correct section...

I've just become serious about training my two and a half year old girl. Before this, she's had the odd half a day without a nappy OR when I can see she's having a pee or a poo, I have on occasion taken her nappy off and put her on the potty.

Now I'm trying it properly with no nappy at all. We are on day three of no nappy during the day.

She keeps holding in her pee for a really really long time. Yesterday all day really. She eventually went on the floor and I picked her up mid stream and put her on the potty and gently told her, we do pee pee in the potty. I then praised her for doing so. She cried a bit and didn't want to.

Today she's been holding on to her pee again. She starts crying and touching herself down there and fidgeting. So I remind her to go on the potty or sometimes take her there and she starts crying and refuses.

Earlier it got so bad that she was leaking and holding on to it so much. So I put her on the potty and she was crying again. I was reassuring her. A little bit of pee went in because she could not hold it. I praised her and we went together to empty the potty in the toilet. She likes this part and she loves flushing.

I knew she wasn't finished so I tried sitting her on the toilet and she again was crying. I then put her on the potty again, she cried and didn't want to sit. Then she peed herself while standing up and was crying. I reassured her and put her on the potty again. But by this time she had finished. She cried and told me she was all wet. She clearly didn't like being all wet. I reassured her and dried her and told her she's doing really really well and I'm proud of her.

Is this actually normal ?

It's like she doesn't want to do it at all. I'm afraid a few times when she had her nappy off in the past and wet herself my mum may have scolded her a bit, but I'm not sure if that's actually true.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
glowingtwig · 20/08/2022 22:24

Following for the comments! about to try again with Milky Way chocolate stars after two failed attempts at 2y 4 months and 2y 6 months...

DD is now 2y 10 months.. Health visitor advised don't even bother til nearly 3.

OceanbreezeSun · 20/08/2022 21:29

I made the mistake of thinking dd was ready when she was about 20 months old - she actually used the potty a few times herself but after a few days, started holding wees in till her stomach was bloated and uncomfortable. When I asked her if she needed a wee, she just said she wanted a nappy on, then she would do a huge wee within seconds once I put one on.

We tried again when she started being consistently dry through the night for longer then a month. Dd was potty trained within 5 days and has only had one accident since. She was coming up to 2.6 years and just got it.

We used one of those toddler toilets (basically a mini portable toilet, it had a flusher on it and a toilet roll holder - you can remove the seat to fix onto ‘adult’ toilets when you are out and about too)
My dd didn’t like her potty but the mini toilet was a winner!

Agree that perhaps the reason children seemed to be trained earlier ‘back in the day’ was more to do with parents wanting them out of the cloth nappies. I know that was my mums motivation anyway. She said she always tried to get us potty trained over the summer, using a laid back approach, bare bums, towels down on the carpets (lots of accidents) but we ‘all got there in the end’

I don’t think 2.5 is too early op & it’s not late either. There really is no magic number. Potty training shouldn’t be stressful for the child imo and I personally don’t think it should take ages to train either. If a child is taking a long time to get it or is having accidents for ages afterwards, they were probably not ready.

IggityZiggity · 20/08/2022 20:46

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 20/08/2022 13:18

She doesn't sound ready to me, 2.5 is still really young for potty training

Is it?

HeyDuggeesFavouriteSquirrel · 20/08/2022 20:43

I'm afraid I don't have advice but I want to give solidarity and say my son is doing the same thing. He's just turned 3 and I started trying to potty train him a few weeks ago.

He would hold his wee in all day. Literally from when he woke up until 7pm when he just wouldn't be able to hold it any long and he's get extremely anxious and distressed. This went on for ten days and I just couldn't put him under the stress for any longer and I was so worried he'd get an infection. I got similar advice that he wasn't ready and put a nappy back on.

I read three books so like you I was prepared but unfortunately children don't always follow the rules of a book. Similar to you I've been given the advice give him a chocolate button, give him a sticker, let him choose his pants, try the big toilet rather than the potty. As he's a boy try standing rather than sitting.

Unfortunately this advice won't work for a child that won't wee at all!

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 20/08/2022 19:55

PumpkinGhoul · 20/08/2022 19:48

Also with my DD I got her involved with picking out her big girl knickers to make the whole process exciting rather than stressful

Yes to this 👆

My daughter couldn't wait to wear her dinosaur knickers!

PumpkinGhoul · 20/08/2022 19:48

Also with my DD I got her involved with picking out her big girl knickers to make the whole process exciting rather than stressful

Beefilm · 20/08/2022 19:47

I also disagree thar she isn't ready. If she can hold on, she has awareness of what it feels like to need to empty the bladder and has the control to hold it.

Way back when I potty trained mine, I don't recall them being able to do this. Potty training was several days of being on high alert all the time, no clothes on below the waist, a potty to hand at all times, and desperately rushing to get it under the child when I saw signs of them wanting to do something. And yes, lots of accidents, but always some wee in the potty. If anything, it almost sounds as though you have left it longer than you should.

I can't suggest anything that hasn't been said already. I recall generally it was better to move on to the proper toilet as soon as possible, and bribery worked wonders. In my children's case, a chocolate button for every wee in the right place, but you could use any treat that you think might help.

Don't give up! Have you tried maybe weeing with her? You on the loo, her on the potty. Make a game of it, or say something like we'll do a wee together, who can wee first?

awwbiscuits · 20/08/2022 19:47

It's worth giving it a go, I had to try 3 times with her before she 'got' it (and do have issues with withholding now so I feel your pain). But I read this book to her in one of our breaks - which was the last 'break' we had before she got it. So I took the pressure off, and read the book to her, and then she was ready to try again because she wanted to be like meekoo - she could press the buttons while on the toilet so she had the same sounds as well!

PumpkinGhoul · 20/08/2022 19:46

Another thing to try is if your DD is holding in her pee is to try her every hour to go to the loo just tell her potty time not wee or poo time and try and get her to sit on it see if she will happily sit on there for five mins if not try building it up.
Try distractions like books reward chart anything to encourage.
Plenty of potty books with pictures for her even you tube has the princess polly potty training cartoon video that you could watch with her.

If you are still struggling and she's back in nappies every time you need to change her take her to the bathroom to change her nappies if she's had a poo tip it out of nappy and get her to flush the toilet that way she can see for herself what she needs to do.

There's another app worth downloaded on your own phone poo goes to poo land it's an interactive one helps ease anxiety of going to the loo was a godsend for my DS.

jtrai · 20/08/2022 19:42

awwbiscuits · 20/08/2022 19:39

There's a book called Meekoo and the big red potty that my dd loved. We read it (at her request) nightly for weeks - it's got a button to press that makes noise etc. in fact she's 5 now and still sometimes asks for it.

Might be worth reading it to her and seeing if it resonates ?

Sounds good! She has one, but it doesn't make a sound ! Anything to get her interested. Although part of me fears she knows all about it, but for some reason doesn't want to do it right now. Maybe I pushed too hard and too soon.. she's had her potty since she was 1. I've been talking to her about it for so long. Maybe too long.

OP posts:
awwbiscuits · 20/08/2022 19:39

There's a book called Meekoo and the big red potty that my dd loved. We read it (at her request) nightly for weeks - it's got a button to press that makes noise etc. in fact she's 5 now and still sometimes asks for it.

Might be worth reading it to her and seeing if it resonates ?

Dammitthisisshit · 20/08/2022 19:26

It sounds like you’re being lovely and patient with all her accidents, which is great.
but she doesn’t sound ready. When she’s ready it will be much easier.

Emelene · 20/08/2022 19:22

Read the Oh Crap potty training book. I disagree that she “isn’t ready” - that book advocates training between 20 and 30 months. It sounds like she can hold her wee well which is a step towards potty training. You sound like you’re both doing a good job.

SnackSizeRaisin · 20/08/2022 19:21

It's not that she doesn't understand though in this case. That advice is for children who are having accidents, not for those who are so distressed that they refuse to urinate all day. Continuing to apply the same pressure will not make her suddenly feel comfortable to urinate in the potty.

Perfect28 · 20/08/2022 19:20

I'm surprised people say this is too young.

SnackSizeRaisin · 20/08/2022 19:18

This child clearly doesn't need reminding every half hour and I don't think keeping her bare bottomed is likely to be helping either. Unless she's one of those toddlers who likes being naked. She is aware and capable. She just doesn't like something about the process, whether it's being watched, the pressure, being told what to do, the lack of privacy or autonomy. Or the potty itself.
This is being worsened by you trying to force her into the potty - she knows she is disappointing you every time and must be feeling really uncomfortable as well.
You have to put her in charge and stop trying to control her. So just pretend to yourself that she's in nappies until she has actually wee'd. Then either change her or reward her.
But first take a break for a couple of weeks. Then try again with clothes on. Less stressful too as the clothes absorb most of the wee!

sammysal · 20/08/2022 18:28

Disagree with all the people saying abandon. It's a big thing to learn and will take a bit of perseverance- more than 2 days. Try and keep stress free but the idea that a child will just get it / not get it after 2 days is a myth. See where you're at in a week. If she's making incremental progress stick with it.

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 20/08/2022 18:27

Just to add, my eldest HATED being bare bottomed. As soon as we put him in underwear, he was much more willing to try. I think being naked just felt weird and of course when he'd seen us go he knew that pulling pants down was part of the routine.

I read Oh Crap and was convinced ... had to ditch it completely and change to pants, sitting on the potty with a video or book every hour or so, sticker reward when he went etc. He was 2y 3m.

I've just trained my 2y 7m old twins with same method, they got it in a couple of weeks. I don't think it's early. But after a negative experience (we had a failed attempt at 2 with eldest) I would leave it for a few weeks at least and try a different approach next time. New potty too maybe? The ones that look like mini toilets were a hit with mine.

WestIsWest · 20/08/2022 18:09

I also thought the Oh Crap Potty Training book was very good. I agree with PP’s to leave it for a couple of months and try again. I’d put her on the potty very regularly, I think the book might even say every half an hour at first.
I think if you persevere now she’ll just carry on being upset about it. The last thing you want is for her to start holding her poo as well because that can cause all sorts of problems.

mathanxiety · 20/08/2022 18:05

I used a book by Nathan Azrin and Richard Foxx, called Toilet Training in Less Than a Day. I found it really great.

There is YouTube video called something like 'Azrin Foxx toilet training method' that you could look at.

If you're able to devote a good bit of time (a few weeks) to priming your child through play activities and conversation beforehand, then a few very intense training days when you don't do much else aside from training (you do not go out to the shops or anywhere else), and you feel gung ho enough to end night time nappies too, I highly recommend the method.

I think your child has absorbed your anxiety around potting, but not the idea that the potty is the place to pee.

I would stop immediately and wait a few months. Toilet training is the first time a parent actively tries to teach a child a new habit and the skills that go with it. It is therefore the first time a parent comes face to face with the fact that the child is a completely separate person. You know this deep down but the full implications become very real as you embark on training. If nothing else, the Azrin and Foxx book and method will give you confidence and a sense that you know what you're doing.

crochetcrazy1978 · 20/08/2022 18:04

Would lining the potty with a nappy help? Sometimes they don't like the sound or splash back

PeacefulInTheDeep · 20/08/2022 18:04

She sounds just like my DD when we first tried. She could hold it for hours, knew she needed to go, but seemed frightened of letting go. On the third day, after stress levels rising each day, I took the advice of kind MNers and went back to nappies. We put the potty away, didn't talk about it, and took all the pressure off.

2 months later we got home from holiday at 3pm, took her nappy off, showed her the potty (without giving the option of the toilet) and she went without fuss. That was 6 weeks ago, not one accident since, and she's dry at night too. She's just turned 2.5.

My advice would be to take the pressure off and try again in a couple of months. She's learnt a lot, and you haven't lost anything, she's just not quite ready yet.

SnackSizeRaisin · 20/08/2022 17:59

For goodness sake stop taking her to the potty when she doesn't want to. You both need a break!

jtrai · 20/08/2022 17:59

SnackSizeRaisin · 20/08/2022 17:57

Stop pressurising her to go and definitely never take her to the potty against her will. She can hold on so she's physically ready but it's easy to put them off. Maybe as well she would prefer the toilet. I would put her back in nappies for a few weeks then start again. Get a toilet seat and step that she can use herself. Get a sticker chart and some sweets. One morning put her in pants and show her the toilet set up and explain that when she need to pee or poo go and do it in the toilet. Get her to sit on the toilet for a decent reward eg a sweet and sticker. Explain that she will get a sticker every time she sits on the toilet and 2 for doing something in it. Then go about your normal day and don't mention it again. If she does sit on toilet give big reward. If not and she wets herself get her to change herself with your help but don't make any particular comment. Most likely you will get a few accidents and then she will work it out. You need to relax and let her learn. You can't force her.

I have the toilet thing as well and the chart... I last tried a little bit maybe a month ago...

OP posts:
SnackSizeRaisin · 20/08/2022 17:57

Stop pressurising her to go and definitely never take her to the potty against her will. She can hold on so she's physically ready but it's easy to put them off. Maybe as well she would prefer the toilet. I would put her back in nappies for a few weeks then start again. Get a toilet seat and step that she can use herself. Get a sticker chart and some sweets. One morning put her in pants and show her the toilet set up and explain that when she need to pee or poo go and do it in the toilet. Get her to sit on the toilet for a decent reward eg a sweet and sticker. Explain that she will get a sticker every time she sits on the toilet and 2 for doing something in it. Then go about your normal day and don't mention it again. If she does sit on toilet give big reward. If not and she wets herself get her to change herself with your help but don't make any particular comment. Most likely you will get a few accidents and then she will work it out. You need to relax and let her learn. You can't force her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread