Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to Refuse Friends Coming to Stay Without Causing Offence

157 replies

TheFlyingFox · 20/08/2022 11:48

Since this is the topic of the month, probably because its holiday season, I wondered what other peoples' thoughts were on this.

I've recently had a visit from a friend, her OH and their adopted teenage son for 8 days. They were really nice guests, respectful, courteous and polite and we had a nice time. They asked to come well in advance and we had plenty of time to prepare. I have no issue with them. Even so, its quite hard going having another family living in your home for that long, but again not a problem as I know them well (apart from the teenager who was a little moody at times, but again not all that bad).

We live outwith the UK in a country which is popular for holidays.

But its my childhood friend I really want to see. I would love for her to get a break and stay on her own but there seems no possibility of that, even though her OH is perfectly happy to look after their kids on his own.

Anyway, I accept I cannot change her mind on this. However, on leaving friend suggested quite heavily that they come for another holiday in 9 or 10 months time, this time bringing their 9 year old foster daughter with them (different country, different rules on fostering/adoption). Without putting too fine a point on it, this child is quite disturbed and suffers from behavioural difficulties. We have a small farm with lots of animals and pets, of whom I am very fond. I have no idea how unpredictable the child's behaviour can be. She can have tantrums involving screaming and damaging things and seems to demonstrate attention seeking, dramatic behaviour. My friend admits this and that she has behavioural problems. I don't want to sound melodramatic, but I'm really worried that there might be a slight risk that the child might do something to one of my animals, and I would never put them at risk. I just don't want to do it, and I don't know how to say it without damaging the friendship or sounding unwelcoming.

They are all city people and I have to watch them carefully around the animals/farm so that they don't put themselves at risk anyway - found friend in with the cows petting them while they were eating their hard feed for instance on the last visit! Nothing malicous in it on their part, but they don't quite realise that animals can be dangerous or alternatively, easily harmed, by someone doing something wrong that they think is harmless.

I just don't want to host the child at all. I'd love to see my friend on her own (which her very helpful, laidback OH would happily facilitate) or her and her OH together, but not their kids. I'm a bit mmnn about how my willingness to initially host friend and then her OH too (first visit was friend on her own, second was friend with her other friend whom I didn't know, third visit was friend and her OH and last visit was friend and most of her family).

I'd really love to spend time with friend alone, even for just a couple of days, just her and me, but she's turned into bloomin' Mother Theresa and its just not possible any more.

OP posts:
TheFlyingFox · 20/08/2022 15:15

rookiemere · 20/08/2022 15:10

It's a shame that your friend seemingly only comes as a full unit now with her DH and DCs.

I've had this with my cousin. Prior to her meeting her DH we spent loads of time together just the two of us, but now she will only meet with him and has no interest in just the two of us doing something together. Her DH is certainly not controlling ( we're all late middle age) and goes on frequent business trips so it would be perfectly possible to meet up then, but it's been made very clear to me that she doesn't want to, and it hurts a bit.

So I think there's a bit of that going on as well. You can't force her to come alone so I do think going down the line of stating the farm is unsuitable for DCs is the way to go if she mentions it again.

Yes, this is it. Friend had no interest in children for years and now has done an about turn and doesn't separate her life from them. I don't think she is aware of this and just assumes everyone shares the same interest in them as she does. The OH is fine and her adopted son is now at an age where he wants to stay with his friends rather than his parents, but her foster child only became part of the family quite recently so its a bit of a surprise as I had assumed that, like most people of our age, she would be enjoying some child free time now. Its great what she's doing, although even she is not too sure whether its for her long term. I think she is feeling her way on this one.

I think its a shame when women sort of lose their independent selves but realise its a part of life and the different ways that people develop. I just never thought that this friend would be the one who went down that route.

OP posts:
CrappyJob · 20/08/2022 15:15

I think you need to focus on the safety aspect.

'While I would love to see you, I feel like our farm isn't a safe place for foster daughter. I've heard about too many serious accidents involving children at farms, and we would be devastated if anything was to happen. Once she's older and more settled, we would love to have you all. In the meantime, how do you feel about the two of us having a weekend together?'

Scepticalwotsits · 20/08/2022 15:11

I would echo the try and spend time with just them approach, if the push for while family always deflect to say that’s great hotel x is good. unless this friend is a real CF and may just turn up on your doorstep

rookiemere · 20/08/2022 15:10

It's a shame that your friend seemingly only comes as a full unit now with her DH and DCs.

I've had this with my cousin. Prior to her meeting her DH we spent loads of time together just the two of us, but now she will only meet with him and has no interest in just the two of us doing something together. Her DH is certainly not controlling ( we're all late middle age) and goes on frequent business trips so it would be perfectly possible to meet up then, but it's been made very clear to me that she doesn't want to, and it hurts a bit.

So I think there's a bit of that going on as well. You can't force her to come alone so I do think going down the line of stating the farm is unsuitable for DCs is the way to go if she mentions it again.

TheFlyingFox · 20/08/2022 15:09

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 15:02

My point is that it is fine to not want to have visitors but to say it is because of the foster child being a risk to animals is just silly and mean and ill informed. And as an ex foster carer I know If one of my oldest and closest friends said that I would have been devastated.

You're clearly not reading my replies because I answered you above and pointed out that it is because this child has behavioural difficulties. Without going into too much detail, even my friend doesn't even know the full extent of them because she is still being assessed. My concerns would be exactly the same whether she was a foster child or not. However, the foster child description is relevant because this is a new arrangement which has only been in place for little over a year.

And please stop insulting me as its really rude.

OP posts:
Brigante9 · 20/08/2022 15:06

I don’t think the OP’s friend is ‘reaching out for support’-how have you extrapolated that?! She seems to think she can come to the farm and stay for 8 days, which is frankly way too long.

Having been on a farm for years, I would absolutely agree that young kids who aren’t used to big animals (even those who are!) are a bloody pita. I’ve had to tell kids not to play sword fight near the animals who were frankly terrified of the sticks being waved near their heads.

I got absolutely fed up of ‘tourists’ meandering onto the farm and asking to stroke the animals, even one (I think she was the au pair) asking if her charge could ride one of the extremely expensive privately owned horses-it wasn’t a riding school. When told no, she tried to insist because the child was ‘bored’.

TheFlyingFox · 20/08/2022 15:06

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 15:02

My point is that it is fine to not want to have visitors but to say it is because of the foster child being a risk to animals is just silly and mean and ill informed. And as an ex foster carer I know If one of my oldest and closest friends said that I would have been devastated.

Again, Jane Doe, please read this because it is really concerning that you are claiming to work in social services and you are unaware of UK Government advice concerning children on farms. Please read it and stop asking me repetitive questions that have already been answered. Also please stop insulting me and calling me vile names. I have already done plenty for my friend with regards to providing holiday accommodation and its perfectly reasonable to draw the line where I am no longer comfortable with it.

www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg472.pdf

OP posts:
GoneWithTheWine1 · 20/08/2022 15:06

I would just say "do you fancy having a girls weekend just us two instead?" If she says no just reply "that's a shame, maybe next time!" And leave it at that avoiding giving her reasons. YANBU.

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 15:04

No I don’t live in the town- I live in the countryside surrounded by animals including two horses on my own attached paddock (not mine and my children have never harmed them)

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 15:02

My point is that it is fine to not want to have visitors but to say it is because of the foster child being a risk to animals is just silly and mean and ill informed. And as an ex foster carer I know If one of my oldest and closest friends said that I would have been devastated.

Mintchervilpurslane · 20/08/2022 15:01

Just say it doesn't work for you ATM as you have had quite a lot of visitors recently and you need to focus on your own projects. Then stay silent. Don't apologize or explain further. No one is obliged to offer free holiday accommodation even if it is for a close friend!

pinkyredrose · 20/08/2022 15:01

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 14:54

I am genuinely baffled at what this ‘animal welfare’ issue is.
This is a supervised nine year old girl.
The livestock are going to be in fields or pens. Do you think she is going to randomly jump over a fence at attack a pile of sheep or cows?
And with regards to cats- they have claws and will quickly use them if threatened. Dogs also bite.
So what exactly are we taking about here?
This is bonkers.
There are several working farms open to the public close to where I live and they don’t seem to have this issue with thousands of visitors.
If you don’t want to have this vulnerable child stay fine- but you can’ refuse without causing hurt, rejection and offence.

I'm guessing you live in a town? A cursory Google will give you plenty of examples of children pestering/injuring livestock and/or being injured in return.

BlueKaftan · 20/08/2022 15:01

You keep using the word bonkers because you don’t agree with the valid points being made in support of keeping the child away from the farm. But the OP has a responsibility to safeguard her animals as they are her responsibility. She doesn’t know this child so of course she is wary of a potential visit. She should be wary of all visits from children.

TheFlyingFox · 20/08/2022 15:00

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 14:54

I am genuinely baffled at what this ‘animal welfare’ issue is.
This is a supervised nine year old girl.
The livestock are going to be in fields or pens. Do you think she is going to randomly jump over a fence at attack a pile of sheep or cows?
And with regards to cats- they have claws and will quickly use them if threatened. Dogs also bite.
So what exactly are we taking about here?
This is bonkers.
There are several working farms open to the public close to where I live and they don’t seem to have this issue with thousands of visitors.
If you don’t want to have this vulnerable child stay fine- but you can’ refuse without causing hurt, rejection and offence.

Dear Jane Doe

You sound terribly confused on this, which is concerning considering that you claim to work in the social services field. Might I suggest that you read the UK Government advice which clearly lists the steps farmers take when making their farms open to members of the public or even uninvited visitors, such as creating play areas, putting up warning signage, etc.

Given that this is a small private farm not open to the public, I don't want to carry out a risk assessment or go this considerable trouble and expense. We have no near neighbours with children so there is no point.

I also don't have sheep? And no, the animals aren't permanently stuck in fields or "pens"?

You do have some strange ideas. I think you really would benefit from reading the advice from the UK Government that I linked above. It gives many examples of accidents which answer the questions that you keep asking me.

OP posts:
howdidigethere · 20/08/2022 14:59

I think it's your place your rules. You don't have to accommodate various combinations of her family if you're uncomfortable with it. She may take offence, she may not agree with you about the risks but in your home and business you need to make the right decisions for you. Hopefully, your friendship will survive.

Mintchervilpurslane · 20/08/2022 14:58

I am sure the op's friend is trying to do her best for her foster daughter but op is under no obligation to host when she doesn't feel comfortable doing so. Nobody is! Note it is the friend inviting herself and others, for eight days at a time, she is not politely waiting for an invitation!

category12 · 20/08/2022 14:58

It's all very well going on about how dangerous farms are etc etc, but OP has had children to visit before, this friend's children in fact, so suddenly turning round and saying oh no it's too dangerous is going to look like an excuse.

Just be honest, OP. Don't seek to justify it beyond "sorry mate, I just don't feel up to having everyone, but would love to have you on your own sometime".

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 14:54

I am genuinely baffled at what this ‘animal welfare’ issue is.
This is a supervised nine year old girl.
The livestock are going to be in fields or pens. Do you think she is going to randomly jump over a fence at attack a pile of sheep or cows?
And with regards to cats- they have claws and will quickly use them if threatened. Dogs also bite.
So what exactly are we taking about here?
This is bonkers.
There are several working farms open to the public close to where I live and they don’t seem to have this issue with thousands of visitors.
If you don’t want to have this vulnerable child stay fine- but you can’ refuse without causing hurt, rejection and offence.

pinkyredrose · 20/08/2022 14:54

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 14:14

All sounds like crap excuses and total ignorance of children coming through the care system. You sound horrible.
An empathetic and good friend would have their friend and foster child together for a couple of days. I don’t see that the issue is other than you can’t be arsed.

She's living on a farm, she's not a SEN child carer.

AchatAVendre · 20/08/2022 14:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

From the UK Government website: www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg472.pdf

"Agriculture has one of the highest fatal injury rates of any industry in Great Britain, but is the only high-risk industry that has to deal with the constant presence of children. Farms are homes as well as workplaces, and visitors, including children, may also be present on farms.

Children and young people up to the age of 18 are regularly killed and injured on
farms, either because they are working on the farm or because they are playing there.
The ways in which children are killed varies little from year to year. The most
common causes of death and major injury in the last decade were:

â–  falling from vehicles;

â–  being struck by moving vehicles or objects;

â–  contact with machinery;

â–  driving vehicles;

â–  falls from height;

â–  drowning and asphyxiation;

â–  poisoning;

â–  fire;

â–  contact with animals.

The children who died were:

â–  being carried as passengers on agricultural plant and machinery;

â–  not under proper adult supervision;

â–  working/helping around the farm;

â–  playing unsupervised; or

â–  trespassing."

And

"Vehicles and machinery - These present the greatest risk to children and are probably the areas of farm life most attractive to older children. The following are risks for which there are specific legal duties.

It is illegal to allow a child under 13 to ride on or drive agricultural selfpropelled machines (such as tractors) and other specified farm machinery while it is being used in the course of agricultural operations or is going to or from the site of such operations.

It is illegal to allow a child under 13 years old to be carried on a tractor, selfpropelled agricultural machine, or a machine or implement mounted on,
towed or propelled by a tractor or other vehicle, including a machine or
agricultural implement pulled by an animal, usually a horse"

BlueKaftan · 20/08/2022 14:46

Your animals aren’t there for the amusement of your friends and their children. They’re massively entitled if they don’t understand that. Animal welfare must come before hurt feelings.

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 14:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 14:33

This is meant to be one of your oldest friends!! I could understand if it was an acquaintance but not a very good friend. I personally treat my oldest friends like family. I honestly just can not imagine ever telling a close friend their foster child wasn’t welcome.
And for reference- if this foster child was as unstable as you seem to think to the point that she is going to harm animals- she is highly unlikely to be in a foster placement but instead in childrens home.

TheFlyingFox · 20/08/2022 14:33

Janedoe82 · 20/08/2022 14:28

In fact in my twenty plus years in the field I have never heard of a nine year old girl attacking or harming livestock. What exactly do you think she would do??? You are nuts.

Well, to give but one example, my friend recently had to get the vet out due to an emergency while her horse suffered from choke due to the lollipop that a visiting kid gave to him, which he swooped up in one go and swallowed mostly whole. I've read two reports of children killed by tractors this summer alone. I won't go into details.

Again, someone who claims to have experience with all sorts of things from farms, to social care, to horses, actually needing the dangers explained to them? Not at all plausible in the slightest, despite your multiple postings on this thread.

OP posts:
godmum56 · 20/08/2022 14:33

she may well have been a good friend but stuff changes and it sunds like she has other priorities...friends for a reason, friends for a season and all that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread