Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 out of ten children in poverty

188 replies

Gilead · 20/08/2022 09:45

Come from families where at least on parent is employed. 40% of UC claimants are working families BUT Sunak blames those on Welfare for inflation and he wants to cut benefits by at least £1000 per annum.
AIBU to think that the Tories are trying to create a two tier state?

OP posts:
Changethesign · 20/08/2022 22:09

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 21:27

Way more nutritious than a fucking frozen Iceland pizza actually.

This is the problem- excuses excuses excuses - I give up. You can lead a horse to water and all that. Good luck 👍

If this wasn’t about such a serious issue - children in poverty then I would laugh at this comment as it’s so out of touch with reality. You really have NO idea do you.
Yes, potatoes and tomatoes may be more nutritious than an iceland pizza but when you’re living in poverty and don’t have the space to grow veg or the means to do so and can’t wait for them to grow because you need to feed your dc NOW of course you’re going to pick the Iceland pizza 🤦‍♀️

miserablecat · 20/08/2022 21:30

DH grows vegetables. We have a vegetable patch and a greenhouse. During the winter we don't get very much, in the summer we get a glut of tomatoes, lettuce, beans etc. We freeze tomatoes and beans. Sometimes DH plants things and they are a disaster.Sometimes they get eaten by insects or birds. DC eat very few of the vegetables.
It's not nitpicking to say that this is not possible for a lot of people on low incomes

  • you need space and suitable soil/compost to grow
  • you need time (and suitable facility) to water the plants regularly and pick/harvest at correct time.
  • you need to store or freeze some when you (inevitably) get too much to eat in one go.

The unreliability and unequal production means its not a simple swap for simply buying what you need/what you like to eat. In reality it's a hobby for DH and nice to have, I'm not sure how much money it saves. (We rarely buy tinned tomatoes for half the year and use those we've frozen but I'm not convinced this would be a significant saving)

AntlerRose · 20/08/2022 21:29

I actually love growing veg but I dont think it saves money. Possibly my salad leaves and herbs are cheaper.. My allotment is £17 a year rent but some years are better than others. Last year all my tomatoes got blight.

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 21:27

Way more nutritious than a fucking frozen Iceland pizza actually.

This is the problem- excuses excuses excuses - I give up. You can lead a horse to water and all that. Good luck 👍

Gilead · 20/08/2022 21:25

Fucking hell, grow your own veg, yeah tomatoes and potatoes are really nutritious with nothing else. Other people have pointed out about space but what if you have a really good haul, but can’t afford a freezer, what a waste.
Your circumstances allowed you to do what you’ve done @GurningGolfer , but people have differing circumstances and are not able to manage. Try not to judge everyone’s achievements by your own successes.

OP posts:
Frequency · 20/08/2022 21:22

My cherry tree was planted 6 years ago. It is still maturing. We get a couple of handfuls of cherries per year. Hardly enough to make any negligible difference to our weekly food bill.

Given what my dog plants and the returns he gets for his effort, I'd say you need a fair-sized garden and a significant amount of time to see a return great enough to drastically lower your food bill.

Fruits tend to have higher yields but they take a year or two to mature. Out of all the fruit we've planted the only ones that produce a decent amount of fruit are the raspberries and brambles. Even the mature pear tree only yields a few dozen pears per season.

And salad fruits like cucumbers and tomatoes need to be grown in greenhouses. Are we suggesting that people on UC can afford to have relatively decent-sized greenhouses built?

I don't know who first thought up the "grow your own" as a solution to food poverty but they really don't have a fucking clue and are obviously not a farmer or gardener.

talkingdeadscot · 20/08/2022 21:09

I can't believe this sort of rubbish is still being touted. We know that benefits have been reduced over the years, we know UC was brought in to 'reduce the benefit bill' and 'stop people lazing on benefits', we know thousands of disabled and sick people have lost out (and died in case you forgot) because the safety net has been shredded over the years. We also know that if you work even 1 hour on a zero hours contract you're counted as employed and that you can also be made to work for your unemployment benefits. Despite all this, it's still benefit claimants being lazy. Honestly, what happens when it's your turn?

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 21:06

Just to add you don't need to buy seeds to grow stuff. Plant a cherry tomato/potato/lettuce base etc you'll grow new ones! Some education wouldn't go amiss clearly if people think it's easier to live off pizza. Also most fruit and veg can be eaten RAW! Shocking I know.

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 21:04

Blossomtoes · 20/08/2022 20:48

Genuinely, grow your own veg

Genuinely, let them eat cake! How do you grow vegetables if you haven’t got a garden?

You lot love nitpicking don't you. What a silly response 🙄 next time I'll add a disclaimer 'if you have a garden/are able to garden/can afford a few fucking seeds'

So pathetic.

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 21:00

Changethesign · 20/08/2022 20:01

Some may not have a garden or even a small outside space. The cost of seeds / plants may be out of reach for them or they may be time poor and unable to garden sadly or not physically able 😞

You're really nitpicking.

Frequency · 20/08/2022 20:53

You can grow your own veg in a grow bag/plastic containers but you need the initial outlay and enough space. It's not really gonna work in a one-bed council flat.

Plus the cost of multiple containers, bags of compost, and seeds will be out of reach for people trying to live off the £70 p/w you get on UC. Compost isn't cheap. My dog fancies himself a gardener. It cost me £150 to build and fill a digging trough for him to stop him from attempting to plant veg all around my lawn.

You could do it cheaper, of course, but it's still a hefty initial outlay for someone who cannot afford to eat that week.

Community gardens are a good idea but very few places have them.

Blossomtoes · 20/08/2022 20:48

Genuinely, grow your own veg

Genuinely, let them eat cake! How do you grow vegetables if you haven’t got a garden?

AndSoFinally · 20/08/2022 20:43

When childcare for a 0-3 year old is some people's entire wage that might be why only one parent is employed.

But that shouldn't be an option. It's not like the cost of childcare is a secret?! It's not on to say working isn't worth my while, so I'll stay home and claim benefits instead. If you can work and pay your own childcare, then that's what you need to do, even if it means you're not left with much 🤷🏻

Notlosinganyweight · 20/08/2022 20:31

There are some real dicks/Tory bots on this thread tonight.

I love the way they reduce poverty down to simply not being arsed in spite of evidence on this thread that some people have really complicated circumstances. Their overwhelmed tiny minds clearly can't process anything that requires critical thinking. No wonder the basic soundbites of the Tory party appeal. Its the party of the stupid and ignorant and the world knows it.

AndreaC74 · 20/08/2022 20:24

AngelinaFibres · 20/08/2022 16:40

I have taught many, many children where no one ,in several generations of the family, has ever worked. In some areas it is the norm. To an outsider it looks like a desperately pointless way to live. If you have been brought up like that, and no one ever gets up and goes out to work, then you have no idea that there is a different way. The girls get to 16, get pregnant, and that's that. The cycle continues.

Thats actually extremely rare.

the numbers back up its not widespread at all.
Grayling said 4 gens, no one could find a single family that had occurred in.

research-training-centre.sps.ed.ac.uk/generations-of-worklessness-a-myth-that-wont-die/

Numerous studies point this out.

Notlosinganyweight · 20/08/2022 20:21

ClocksGoingBackwards · 20/08/2022 09:56

We already have a tiered state, there’s no need for the tories to try and create one.

I also think the point made by another poster on here recently is relevant to your OP - it doesn’t make sense to focus on the fact that 40% of claimants are working families when they are still significantly under employed.

If 7 out of 10 children in poverty only have one working parent, why isn’t the other parent employed? The reasons for that matter.

When childcare for a 0-3 year old is some people's entire wage that might be why only one parent is employed.

I've stayed employed FT throughout, but because I was able to work flexibly and minimise costs, I can see why some people wouldn't.

Frequency · 20/08/2022 20:15

@Kendodd I would love to see that meal plan and the cost of cooking since the cheaper meals are normally the ones that require a lot of cooking and stewing.

Frequency · 20/08/2022 20:07

And if you don't have a garden? Or space for grow bags?

We're okay, atm in terms of having the budget to buy fresh food. I'm not sure how long that will last with the sharp price increases we are seeing.

I was using the above as to why poverty might factor into weight gain. I missed the deleted post but from the replies, I'm guessing someone thought that the people in the food bank line were too big to be truly poor and therefore must be spending all their money on takeouts instead of budgeting like the hardworking folk have to?

And you have to consider the cost of cooking the meals. It takes a fair bit longer and costs a fair bit more to stew an offcut of beef and roast some homegrown veg than it does to whack a pizza and chips in the air fryer for 10 minutes. Most people on a low income are on pay-as-you-go meters. You can give them all the homegrown veg you want and lentil/bean-based recipes but if they only have £1.35 worth of gas left for the week they're not gonna spend it whipping up a lentil and cauliflower curry when they can cook a pizza for a fraction of the cost.

Kendodd · 20/08/2022 20:06

Frequency · 20/08/2022 19:26

Considering the cost of fresh produce vs frozen beige crap I dare say most people would struggle to eat fresh, healthy, low-fat foods on UC.

I can feed a family of four for £2.25 a meal at Iceland;

1 frozen pizza
1 bag of frozen chips
1/4 bag of mixed veg

I'm a decent cook, brought up on homecooked meals of traditional northern meat and two veg type things including typical; budget-friendly dishes like stews, bubble and squeak and panacalty. I'd struggle to create a healthy, calorie-friendly, budget-friendly meal plan for less than £2.25 a meal that didn't use a lot of power to cook.

£2.25 to feed a family of four!
Can't remember which Tory it was who said you only need 30p per head.

Kendodd · 20/08/2022 20:01

Gilead · 20/08/2022 16:04

By the way, would like to add, I’m on benefits, I don’t drink, smoke, take drugs other than those prescribed (22 a day), no tattoos. I’ve had a McDonald’s coffee today, is that allowed?
FFS You are allowed a treat on benefits, if that’s a bottle of wine, or an occasional trip out or takeaway it’s no one else’s bloody business. 😡

No, I don't think a £2 coffee is allowed OP.
Even if you were working 45 hours a week in a care home on top of cleaning jobs and school runs, apparently a take away coffee would be unreasonable and your poverty would be entirely your own fault due to such frivolous spending.

Changethesign · 20/08/2022 20:01

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 19:56

Genuinely, grow your own veg. I dug up a section of our garden threw some seeds in and done! Potatoes grow really well and easily.

Some may not have a garden or even a small outside space. The cost of seeds / plants may be out of reach for them or they may be time poor and unable to garden sadly or not physically able 😞

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 19:56

Frequency · 20/08/2022 19:26

Considering the cost of fresh produce vs frozen beige crap I dare say most people would struggle to eat fresh, healthy, low-fat foods on UC.

I can feed a family of four for £2.25 a meal at Iceland;

1 frozen pizza
1 bag of frozen chips
1/4 bag of mixed veg

I'm a decent cook, brought up on homecooked meals of traditional northern meat and two veg type things including typical; budget-friendly dishes like stews, bubble and squeak and panacalty. I'd struggle to create a healthy, calorie-friendly, budget-friendly meal plan for less than £2.25 a meal that didn't use a lot of power to cook.

Genuinely, grow your own veg. I dug up a section of our garden threw some seeds in and done! Potatoes grow really well and easily.

Frequency · 20/08/2022 19:26

Considering the cost of fresh produce vs frozen beige crap I dare say most people would struggle to eat fresh, healthy, low-fat foods on UC.

I can feed a family of four for £2.25 a meal at Iceland;

1 frozen pizza
1 bag of frozen chips
1/4 bag of mixed veg

I'm a decent cook, brought up on homecooked meals of traditional northern meat and two veg type things including typical; budget-friendly dishes like stews, bubble and squeak and panacalty. I'd struggle to create a healthy, calorie-friendly, budget-friendly meal plan for less than £2.25 a meal that didn't use a lot of power to cook.

Gilead · 20/08/2022 18:27

I’m overweight, it’s my meds, although not being able to walk doesn’t help.

OP posts:
Gingerkittykat · 20/08/2022 18:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

62% of the adult population in the UK are either overweight or obese so it stands that a high proportion of foodbank users will also be overweight. Just because someone is overweight does not mean that someone is struggling to buy food that week.

I'm assuming you are proposing letting people starve till they are a normal weight?