Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 out of ten children in poverty

188 replies

Gilead · 20/08/2022 09:45

Come from families where at least on parent is employed. 40% of UC claimants are working families BUT Sunak blames those on Welfare for inflation and he wants to cut benefits by at least £1000 per annum.
AIBU to think that the Tories are trying to create a two tier state?

OP posts:
mydogisthebest · 21/08/2022 09:16

@Gilead it seems it depends where you live as to whether you get pushed to find work.

When I was 60, not in great health, I found myself out of work and went to claim benefits. The job centre were telling me to apply for jobs that were 2 bus journeys away (I don't drive) and would take over an hour to get to and often quite manual jobs which I would not have been capable of doing.

I only signed on for 2 months and they made me feel lazy and useless. They kept on and on about jobs that I just would not have been able to do. This was when I was living in Essex.

I now live in East Midlands. I have neighbours who have 4 children aged 12 to 3 months. They are both 30, left school at 17. Mum has worked 2 years since leaving school, dad has worked 5. He has not worked for the last 7 years. They can both drive, they have 2 cars so no problems getting to a job.

They tell people that they don't want to work. They think my DH is crazy to still be working at 65. The woman actually said that the reason my DH looks so old is because he has worked too much!

They manage to run 2 cars, feed 4 children plus 2 dogs and 3 cats because he works cash in hand doing delivery driving for a takeaway and doing gardening, decorating and other handyman work during the day.

The job centre don't push him to find work. There is plenty of work where we live.

My next door neighbour recently signed on and because he said he was depressed because his job sacked him they said they won't push him to find a job so not to worry!

whiteroseredrose · 21/08/2022 09:03

Frequency · 20/08/2022 16:23

Low-income families are still entitled to UC/WTC/CTC when both parents are full-time employed.

I got around £40 p/w UC when I was in two full-time positions and neither was NMW. One was slightly more per hour (£9.50) and one was salaried at £17.5k p/a.

But isn't it awful that two, full time working adults don't bring in enough money to live properly.

Effectively employers can get away with underpaying because the Government will step in.

We've allowed housing prices to become extortionate with daft policies too.

Not many moons ago families could manage on one working income. Why have successive governments allowed things to deteriorate so badly?

ScootyAlan · 21/08/2022 08:53

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/08/2022 01:25

What about carers? If you're caring full time - and full time for some carers is pretty much 24/7 - you can't work plus you're saving the country a lot of money.

Absolutely! Carers get paid PENCE per hour. PENCE.
They can't strike. The pitiful carers allowance they are given is taxed as a wage, and counted against benefits, when they've usually given up a decent job to care for their charge. Official carers get paid a proper wage. My toryscum MPs response to this? Suck it up buttercup. Proper carers are fully trained. He thinks unpaid carers can't wipe a butt, or change an ng tube? Hoist someone immobile?

ilovesooty · 21/08/2022 02:35

If you're working full time and so poorly paid you're having to claim top up benefits when are you going to find time to do extra courses even if you're eligible for them?

DdraigGoch · 21/08/2022 02:29

Maybe the 20 quid a week will stop some smoking or gambling
It won't. Remember that Scotland tried minimum alcohol pricing? Instead of cutting back on drinking, those who were addicted just cut back on other things, even to the detriment of their children.

Florenz · 21/08/2022 02:15

newfriend05 · 20/08/2022 23:21

I'm sorry but UC is £328 a month !, and that is for food, Electric , Gas , water everything apart from rent unless you pay the bedroom tax which you have to pay as well so how how can that be cut.. Who is their right mind would wanna live on just that is the Tories picking on trying to keep the rich rich again

Nobody should want to live on UC.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/08/2022 01:25

hattie43 · 20/08/2022 23:31

I think when household budgets become more and more squeezed it always opens the discussion about benefits .

Personally I don't think any healthy working age person should be allowed benefits for a prolonged timescale . The welfare state was there to support those in a period of need not be an income replacement for life . The only people who should be on long term benefits are the disabled and pensioners .

What about carers? If you're caring full time - and full time for some carers is pretty much 24/7 - you can't work plus you're saving the country a lot of money.

Gilead · 21/08/2022 01:23

@jcyclops it’s odd it was definitely about this morning. Check on me, I’ve been around these parts for a good many years and don’t usually balls things up. Always apologise when I do. Also freely admit to being a Labour Party member.

OP posts:
Frequency · 20/08/2022 23:51

You can get free courses if you're on a low income but you still have to be available for f/t work so the courses cannot be more than 16 hours a week. You must leave the course if offered a job that does not work around the course and it's reliant on there being useful courses in your locale as you must be local to get the grant.

There are also free online courses but these really aren't worth the paper they are not written on. They won't help anyone become employable.

And, as another poster pointed out, you can only get funding if you don't already have a level 3 or higher qualification, so that useless GNVQ in Media Studies you did when you were 16 means you cannot retrain.

There is the option of OU but that option is open to everyone not just those on a low income.

Rosebel · 20/08/2022 23:46

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 12:40

They don't needs funds! If you're on benefits you have access to tons of free courses or options to retrain. But you have to be arsed to actually properly look into it all.

I don't think the courses are free but even if they are what are you supposed to do with your children while you train?
People on benefits or where only one person is working can't afford childcare,
It's not as easy as you make ou6

GreenLunchBox · 20/08/2022 23:45

AndSoFinally · 20/08/2022 20:43

When childcare for a 0-3 year old is some people's entire wage that might be why only one parent is employed.

But that shouldn't be an option. It's not like the cost of childcare is a secret?! It's not on to say working isn't worth my while, so I'll stay home and claim benefits instead. If you can work and pay your own childcare, then that's what you need to do, even if it means you're not left with much 🤷🏻

Oh, ok. Thanks for the words of wisdom 😂

GreenLunchBox · 20/08/2022 23:43

Kendodd · 20/08/2022 20:06

£2.25 to feed a family of four!
Can't remember which Tory it was who said you only need 30p per head.

That was 30p Lee 🤪🙄🤔

hattie43 · 20/08/2022 23:31

I think when household budgets become more and more squeezed it always opens the discussion about benefits .

Personally I don't think any healthy working age person should be allowed benefits for a prolonged timescale . The welfare state was there to support those in a period of need not be an income replacement for life . The only people who should be on long term benefits are the disabled and pensioners .

newfriend05 · 20/08/2022 23:21

I'm sorry but UC is £328 a month !, and that is for food, Electric , Gas , water everything apart from rent unless you pay the bedroom tax which you have to pay as well so how how can that be cut.. Who is their right mind would wanna live on just that is the Tories picking on trying to keep the rich rich again

jcyclops · 20/08/2022 23:20

Gilead · 20/08/2022 23:10

Absolutely nowhere in the report you have linked, or other reports of the same event, does Sunak say he wants to cut UC by £1000/year.

Gilead · 20/08/2022 23:12

I absolutely judge anyone wanting to cut benefits. Equally I can judge on past performance, he’s chancellor and he has us more in debt than ever, with inflation running at a fifty year high whilst the rest of Europe is recovering.

OP posts:
Gilead · 20/08/2022 23:10

part of the speech

OP posts:
Ligglepiggle · 20/08/2022 23:09

Consideration needs to be made for one parent families, I earn too much to receive any help whatsoever but if my income was split across 2 people I would get at least child benefit. I appreciate not everyone’s NRP will be as useless as mine but I do every minute of childcare outside of work every pick up and drop off - it does seem unfair

Frequency · 20/08/2022 23:05

Where are all these better-paid jobs coming from?

I live in the NE and there are no better-paid jobs. The vast majority of jobs are in care, retail, and manufacturing. The few office jobs there are generally NMW or slightly above.

All of which would still entitle most couples both working f/t to some element of UC/WTC/CTC etc.

Hungryharriet · 20/08/2022 23:02

I do think those that are truly in need of benefits could do more to better their situations such as making use of free courses and qualifications etc that are open to those on UC and other benefits in order to get into better paid more. Perhaps he's trying to push those that can work to motivate themselves to achieve more and provide more for their families

Animal Farm stuff. Just work harder and all will be well. And what are these people supposed to live on while they're studying? Universal credit doesn't even begin to cover the increase in the cost of living.

jcyclops · 20/08/2022 22:56

Sorry - typo - So most UC recipients would get £1200 extra this year

Gilead · 20/08/2022 22:54

I’m lucky enough to have a garden (worked until too disabled to do so). I said on a thread the other day that I grow my own veg, but I’m also lucky enough to be in a position to make jam with my fruit and freeze my veg. Honestly @GurningGolfer , it’s not excuses it’s reality, a reality that you are unwilling to accept despite evidence.

Moving on from that there are community gardens springing up where I live, and I’m hoping to get the council to donate land here and there for fruit trees, bushes and some decent beds.

OP posts:
jcyclops · 20/08/2022 22:53

@Gilead What is it that gives people the right to be so judgmental ?

Yet you are prepared to judge Sunak based on your own made up story of him wanting to cut benefits by £1000/year.

There are absolutely no reports, even in the left wing press, of him saying this in a speech yesterday (as you claim) nor at any other time recently. If you can link to any media report of him saying this then please do so.

The temporary £20/week Covid uplift ended in October 2021, after he had extended it from April 2021. This is the only "£1000 cut" you can find any news about, and it is all from last year. This was always a temporary measure that was going to end, just as furlough payments did.

In November 2021 he reduced the Universal Credit taper rate by 8 percentage points and increased the work allowance by £500/year. These changes meant over 2m people working and receiving UC received an average increase of £1000/year. It also meant around 600,000 workers who did not get any UC became newly entitled to some payments.

In April 2022 all UC was increased by 3.1%

In May 2022 he announced all UC recipients would receive an extra £650 this year on top of the £400 that everyone would receive, and also the £150 rebate through council tax. So most UC recipients would get £1250 extra this year.

You can say that all this is nowhere near enough for the hard times that are coming, but you should not make up your own facts.

Kendodd · 20/08/2022 22:51

@GurningGolfer
I'm sure you mean well but really, just grow your own veg to save money on food is like saying- just get solar panels to cut your power bill (except solar panels do actually save money (eventually)). I read a study a while ago, and heard on radio 4 that in a normal garden, for an average person, growing veg does not save money. It's a hobby. A lovely hobby, you clearly enjoy, and nothing nicer than home grown and cooked food but it's not going to solve the UK Tory poverty crisis.

RunningSME · 20/08/2022 22:40

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 21:00

You're really nitpicking.

Nitpicking? I earn double the national average wage and receive CMS that equal to an additional NMW salary and still couldn’t afford a garden.

sorry to bother you with pathetic details @GurningGolfer