Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 out of ten children in poverty

188 replies

Gilead · 20/08/2022 09:45

Come from families where at least on parent is employed. 40% of UC claimants are working families BUT Sunak blames those on Welfare for inflation and he wants to cut benefits by at least £1000 per annum.
AIBU to think that the Tories are trying to create a two tier state?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EngTech · 21/08/2022 16:34

Come the GE, you and like minded people, will have an opportunity to vote for a party which will sort these kind of problems or promise to sort them out 😳😳

Use you vote wisely 👍👍👍

Rosesandstars · 21/08/2022 16:30

Yeah, most Tories do not interact with people who are living in poverty, haven't lived in poverty and benefit from other peoples' poverty.

Also they can always rely on poor people turning on each other (e.g. trying to work out who truly deserves measly benefits or trying to blame others for not working hard enough) rather than turning on the super wealthy tax evaders!

Blossomtoes · 21/08/2022 16:19

Did anyone say that?

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 15:57

It's not a race to the bottom

No one said it was but it is incorrect to say that benefits haven't gone up and won't go up again in April 🤷‍♀️

GreenLunchBox · 21/08/2022 15:05

Endlesssummer2022 · 21/08/2022 14:53

What do you expect? Sunak loves and admires California where the gap between the rich and poor is so extraordinary it has to be seen to be believed.

Tech bros in multimillion dollar mansions in the same state as Skid Row. Silicon Valley surrounded by crackheads in tent cities. The rich just drive by the ‘losers’ and pay them no attention.

I will bet a lot of money Sunak’s billionaire FIL also drives buy beggars in India without a second thought also.

The fact Sunak keeps repeating the story that his parents came here with ‘nothing’, worked really hard and became millionaires also tells me he doesn’t register the fact they were upper caste and educated with contacts and experience in running business.

He probably believes people are poor because they don’t work as hard as him or his parents and therefore it’s their fault so why should they get any state support.

Liz Truss also believes people are poor because they are lazy. Yet as long as these two wrap themselves in a flag and shout ‘woke’, the same people these slights are aimed at will still enthusiastically vote for Tories even if it means eventually there is no state support and their kids end up as meth heads in tent cities or bankrupted so can’t afford healthcare, clinging to God, hoping their neighbours will sew quilts and do bake sales to help pay for cancer treatment like in America.

Absolutely this.
He trots out that tiresome story time after time about how hard everyone worked for him to get where he is today and how grateful he is. Ignoring the fact it's having money and contacts that allowed him to get to where he is. Fuck off, Rishi.

GreenLunchBox · 21/08/2022 15:01

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 13:21

@Blossomtoes

It's still a bigger pay rise than most of those in employment are getting. Public sector workers have been offered 2-3% on average. Hence why their TUs are balloting for strikes.

It's not a race to the bottom

ClementineAugustus · 21/08/2022 14:59

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:28

The families I work with can’t get appropriate childcare and they are also physically exhausted they need full support it’s heartbreaking.

Why not, don't the poorest get subsidised childcare so they can work?

When children have SEN it can be incredibly hard to get appropriate childcare. Even if it’s possible these are parents who are up most of the night so even with suitable childcare they wouldn’t be in any position to get up and go to work they need that time to rest

Endlesssummer2022 · 21/08/2022 14:53

What do you expect? Sunak loves and admires California where the gap between the rich and poor is so extraordinary it has to be seen to be believed.

Tech bros in multimillion dollar mansions in the same state as Skid Row. Silicon Valley surrounded by crackheads in tent cities. The rich just drive by the ‘losers’ and pay them no attention.

I will bet a lot of money Sunak’s billionaire FIL also drives buy beggars in India without a second thought also.

The fact Sunak keeps repeating the story that his parents came here with ‘nothing’, worked really hard and became millionaires also tells me he doesn’t register the fact they were upper caste and educated with contacts and experience in running business.

He probably believes people are poor because they don’t work as hard as him or his parents and therefore it’s their fault so why should they get any state support.

Liz Truss also believes people are poor because they are lazy. Yet as long as these two wrap themselves in a flag and shout ‘woke’, the same people these slights are aimed at will still enthusiastically vote for Tories even if it means eventually there is no state support and their kids end up as meth heads in tent cities or bankrupted so can’t afford healthcare, clinging to God, hoping their neighbours will sew quilts and do bake sales to help pay for cancer treatment like in America.

5128gap · 21/08/2022 14:01

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 13:21

@Blossomtoes

It's still a bigger pay rise than most of those in employment are getting. Public sector workers have been offered 2-3% on average. Hence why their TUs are balloting for strikes.

Its a bigger percentage, but a much smaller amount of money, and until we are charged for our essential expenditure as a percentage of our income, the amount of money concerned is the only thing that is meaningful.

jcyclops · 21/08/2022 13:22

Gilead · 21/08/2022 01:23

@jcyclops it’s odd it was definitely about this morning. Check on me, I’ve been around these parts for a good many years and don’t usually balls things up. Always apologise when I do. Also freely admit to being a Labour Party member.

Thank you - That's fine. I was attacking your statement because it was untrue, and not because I may or may not disagree with your favoured political narrative. I hate it when facts are bent or simply works of fiction.

Sunak's statements during the event included:
"I strongly believe that part of the answer to this problem is being much tougher on our welfare system. If there are hours to do, and if there’s a job going, people should have to take the job as opposed to just being able to stay on benefits. That’s the change I want to bring… and it’s good for the economy because it’ll ease inflation."

People may or may not agree with him, but for people such as Peter Stefanovic to say these statements mean "Rishi Sunak blames people on benefits for high inflation" is a massive over exaggeration. He is actually saying that people on benefits could be part of the solution to high inflation if more of them were to work, or if those already working were to work longer. If Sunak had said "Recently, we are having to deal with several wildfires, and getting firefighters quickly to these fires is essential to bringing the situation under control" it doesn't mean that he is blaming firefighters for the wildfires.

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 13:21

@Blossomtoes

It's still a bigger pay rise than most of those in employment are getting. Public sector workers have been offered 2-3% on average. Hence why their TUs are balloting for strikes.

Gilead · 21/08/2022 13:18

Benefits went up by 3% this year. There is absolutely no guarantee that the amount will fall in line with inflation next year.

OP posts:
AntlerRose · 21/08/2022 13:15

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:28

The families I work with can’t get appropriate childcare and they are also physically exhausted they need full support it’s heartbreaking.

Why not, don't the poorest get subsidised childcare so they can work?

If a child has disabilities (which is often why a family is poor as its hard to hold down employment) there isnt actually much childcare available. So you have situations where a family is awarded funding respite but none exists or social services agree to fund a PA but you advertise for years and no one applies
Very few special schools have
before or afterschool clubs. Lots of what is availabe is run by charities and is for respite not work. So you bid for slots each holiday and may be lucky to get 4 random days across the whole 6 weeks or one afterschool slot a week.

I actually only have 12 hours a week my 13 year old is not at home as there is a shortage of SEN school places too.

Blossomtoes · 21/08/2022 13:11

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:43

@Blossomtoes

So benefits are going up by 10% next year?

If they go up in line with inflation - which is what you said - then yes. Still fuck all.

jcyclops · 21/08/2022 12:51

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:24

Are benefits not going up in line with inflation in April? That's a bigger pay rise than a lot of people in work will get.

Benefits are expected to increase in April 2023 by at least the inflation (CPI) figure from September 2022. This is expected to be over 10%.

RunningSME · 21/08/2022 12:49

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:33

Many of the women had become mothers very young, been given council housing, been able to claim a decent enough amount of benefits to get by, had had pretty alright lives considering they’d never really had much ambition for anything else. Like I say - not bad people, just human, and with human flaws. But pretending that it wasn’t an active choice for a lot of them is disingenuous.

I know a few of these from school. They often didn't have many other choices though as they were usually the ones who left school with no or few exam passes.

What happens to them when the kids grow up and the benefits and maintenance stop? I know of 2 women who had children in their late teens and then have had another at 40 to keep the child related benefits. They are still going to financially screwed when they hit their late 50s though, when the child they had at 40 grows up and the benefits and maintenance stop again.

They then become carers for their parents so you’ve got emphysema due to a lifetime of bloody smoking at the taxpayers expense.

I mean it’s no life don’t get me wrong I’m not bloody jealous but these people exist

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:43

@Blossomtoes

So benefits are going up by 10% next year?

Blossomtoes · 21/08/2022 12:35

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:24

Are benefits not going up in line with inflation in April? That's a bigger pay rise than a lot of people in work will get.

No it isn’t. Ten percent of fuck all won’t touch the sides.

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:33

Many of the women had become mothers very young, been given council housing, been able to claim a decent enough amount of benefits to get by, had had pretty alright lives considering they’d never really had much ambition for anything else. Like I say - not bad people, just human, and with human flaws. But pretending that it wasn’t an active choice for a lot of them is disingenuous.

I know a few of these from school. They often didn't have many other choices though as they were usually the ones who left school with no or few exam passes.

What happens to them when the kids grow up and the benefits and maintenance stop? I know of 2 women who had children in their late teens and then have had another at 40 to keep the child related benefits. They are still going to financially screwed when they hit their late 50s though, when the child they had at 40 grows up and the benefits and maintenance stop again.

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:28

The families I work with can’t get appropriate childcare and they are also physically exhausted they need full support it’s heartbreaking.

Why not, don't the poorest get subsidised childcare so they can work?

ShelfyMcShelfface · 21/08/2022 12:24

Are benefits not going up in line with inflation in April? That's a bigger pay rise than a lot of people in work will get.

5128gap · 21/08/2022 12:12

GurningGolfer · 20/08/2022 12:33

I've struggled at times with all the huge bills like any normal family, have dipped into savings and then put back in when I can. Worked hard to get promotions and spent money in doing so. Just being a responsible adult I guess, I don't drink or smoke, have sky TV, expensive phones etc it's all about the right priorities. I dont understand why some people plead poverty and 'can't afford to feed their kids' yet have all the above. It needs tackling. Maybe the 20 quid a week will stop some smoking or gambling or wasting money in mcds or Costa etc or maybe it'll be the straw that breaks the camels back and encourages them to retrain . I dont know but something needs doing - people are far too reliant on the state these days and calling for change - make your own change.

People are actually far less reliant on the state these days.
In my life time, I've seen 60 year old women able to retire and rely on the state for a pension.
I've seen elderly people able to rely on the state to provide care, while retaining their assets.
I've seen people able to rely on the state for eye care, prescriptions and dentistry, a GP who will see them without a month wait and ambulances that arrive in time to save their lives.
To rely on the state to provide their children with milk at school. To go to university, relying on the state to pay their fees, and living costs.
To rely on the state to provide an immediate income if they dont work, with top ups on request for unexpected expenses and to provide long term income if they are sick.
Reliance on the state these days is the lowest I can recall, given there's so little left to rely on, and it hasn't done a thing to help or 'motivate' people escape poverty. All its resulted in is a decline in basic quality of life, higher incidences of child poverty and people relying on charity to eat.

mydogisthebest · 21/08/2022 11:40

Changethesign · 21/08/2022 09:26

I would bet there are factors they aren’t telling you as this isn’t typical if both can work unless one or both is a carer or they have a disability themselves they may just not want to say? Or maybe he is self employed and declaring the cash jobs ?

He is definitely not self employed and declaring the cash.

It seems unlikely either have a disability. He, as I said, is doing manual work and she cleans the house, gardens, walks the dogs, drives to and from the school. Of course she has the excuse of the children as to why she can't or won't work.

They have said a few times that people that work are mugs and that no way would they work set hours, days etc. He only really works between 10am and 3pm. My DH offered him work a while ago and he turned it down saying he was not prepared to work the hours DH wanted him to or register as self employed

Seymour5 · 21/08/2022 09:40

@newfriend05 £328 for four weeks is for a single person under state pension age. Unless that person has a disability they aren’t getting benefits for, it should only be a stopgap between jobs. I live in an area where unemployment has traditionally been high, and there are lots of vacancies. Unskilled? Volunteer and get some skills. There is help available from a variety of organisations to complete applications, and for basic qualifications. The charity shop where I volunteer (I’m old) has helped some ‘never worked’ develop the skills and confidence to find paid jobs.

Of course people who have genuine barriers to working should get help, I’d advocate for more generous disability benefits and far more support for carers.

Changethesign · 21/08/2022 09:26

mydogisthebest · 21/08/2022 09:16

@Gilead it seems it depends where you live as to whether you get pushed to find work.

When I was 60, not in great health, I found myself out of work and went to claim benefits. The job centre were telling me to apply for jobs that were 2 bus journeys away (I don't drive) and would take over an hour to get to and often quite manual jobs which I would not have been capable of doing.

I only signed on for 2 months and they made me feel lazy and useless. They kept on and on about jobs that I just would not have been able to do. This was when I was living in Essex.

I now live in East Midlands. I have neighbours who have 4 children aged 12 to 3 months. They are both 30, left school at 17. Mum has worked 2 years since leaving school, dad has worked 5. He has not worked for the last 7 years. They can both drive, they have 2 cars so no problems getting to a job.

They tell people that they don't want to work. They think my DH is crazy to still be working at 65. The woman actually said that the reason my DH looks so old is because he has worked too much!

They manage to run 2 cars, feed 4 children plus 2 dogs and 3 cats because he works cash in hand doing delivery driving for a takeaway and doing gardening, decorating and other handyman work during the day.

The job centre don't push him to find work. There is plenty of work where we live.

My next door neighbour recently signed on and because he said he was depressed because his job sacked him they said they won't push him to find a job so not to worry!

I would bet there are factors they aren’t telling you as this isn’t typical if both can work unless one or both is a carer or they have a disability themselves they may just not want to say? Or maybe he is self employed and declaring the cash jobs ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread