Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Manager has refused mileage claim - AIBU?

162 replies

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 00:33

I work in the community and so submit my mileage expenses each month. I tend to write my visits in before I do them otherwise I worry I will forget - this is clearly not a good strategy due to what has happened below and I will now do them retrospectively.

I submitted my July mileage and my manager rejected it on the basis that there was one entry that was incorrect - a face-to-face visit had been changed to an online one and I had forgotten to delete the entry - she had seen that it was a Teams meeting in my diary. I apologised and deleted the entry and resubmitted it. I have only just noticed that the mileage for the whole month (a substantial amount) has been rejected again.

Is she allowed to do this? Obviously I was at fault for not deleting the other entry when the meeting was changed to an online one, but AIBU to think she's wrong to not pay my mileage for the rest of the month now the incorrect entry has been deleted? How should I raise this with her?

OP posts:
letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 09:22

dribblewibble · 20/08/2022 09:20

@letmechangetheatmosphere I take photo of the miles on my car at the beginning and end of the journey when I remember. Sometimes I forget.

Interesting! I'd never remember to do that but I can see why you would if you were doing long journeys. Last job I was in was a small charity and my base was home so I was logging several daily journeys of only about 5 or 10 miles each, wouldn't have been worth my while photographing everything.

Endlesslypatient82 · 20/08/2022 09:21

You recognise your process is not ideal

i suspect she is pissed off

talk. To. Her. Reassure her that you will adjust your process and request payment of the mileage due to you

dribblewibble · 20/08/2022 09:20

@letmechangetheatmosphere I take photo of the miles on my car at the beginning and end of the journey when I remember. Sometimes I forget.

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 09:19

Re: fraud, I worked with someone who was fired for doing exactly this. Filling out overtime sheets ahead of overtime worked and then not deleting hours that never went ahead.

It was a repeat course of action, which they discovered on investigating her. Honestly OP I hope you haven't made this mistake before as they'd be right to look into it.

dribblewibble · 20/08/2022 09:19

Yeah where I am your claims would have to be audited now.

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 09:17

Quveas · 20/08/2022 08:15

And if I were the manager of an employee who had submitted a mileage claim for a journey they didn't take I would be suspending their claims until a full audit of every claim they had made had been completed. But I am "petty" like that...

It was no doubt a genuine mistake by the OP but they really aren't in a strong position here. There is no defence for making a false claim. They may have been in the habit of filling in the mileage before they made a journey, but that is (as the OP accepts themselves) entirely wrong. Quite apart from anything else, how can you know what your mileage will be before you have made the journey? Even regular journeys can unexpectedly deviate from the planned route and so vary from the normal mileage.

A polite request about her claim(s) is in order, and nothing more. People have been disciplined or dismissed for this kind of mistake, and claiming expenses you haven't incurred is a serious matter.

"Quite apart from anything else, how can you know what your mileage will be before you have made the journey? Even regular journeys can unexpectedly deviate from the planned route and so vary from the normal mileage."

I've always just put in the shortest return journey via google maps, I've never claimed extra if my route has been diverted do people really do this? How are they measuring their diversions is there software that can do this (genuine question).

MajorCarolDanvers · 20/08/2022 09:13

Do you think I could contact her over the weekend about it?

If she works over the weekend yes then contact her.

Otherwise don't. No need for you to behave badly even if she is.

toomuchlaundry · 20/08/2022 09:11

I’ve always had to do mileage claims retrospectively.

RedWingBoots · 20/08/2022 09:05

@Completelyovernonsense what part of it is fraud by the employee, which can lead to the owners and senior employees of the company being convicted of fraud by HMRC if fraudulent claims are passed on to them you don't understand?

Plenty of employees in different roles have to wait 4-8 weeks to be reimbursed for travel expenses.

If you cannot afford to wait that long to be reimbursed then you need to find a different job.

Oh and mileage claims rarely fully cover fuel costs especially now.

Fleur405 · 20/08/2022 09:02

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:09

Sadly, what you were doing, completing time-sheest/mileage etc, before actually doing the work/mileage, was fraudulent.
So your boss, or the accounts department, may well be auditing the rest of your claim for that month (or indeed, all of your previous claims), which they would be obliged to do.
If you are a registered professional, i would suggest ypu get in touch with your union as a pre-emptive strike
And be prepared to explain to your next employer if your current one passes this info on

Based on the information the OP has given this is definitely not fraud - if they were to refuse to pay her legitimate expenses or dismiss her she will have a claim against them (I’m a lawyer and I deal with quite a lot of fraud cases - it’s entirely different to forgetting to update a form one time)

Agree with others though that in the circumstances they may want to do a review just to confirm that it wasn’t part of a consistent practice of inflating the claims. Many people do get away with expenses fraud due to lax approval/audit procedures.

Completelyovernonsense · 20/08/2022 08:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

Whattodoaboutworknow · 20/08/2022 08:35

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 01:10

@RoomOfRequirement @LondonQueen it's in my contract that I should be paid for mileage. I haven't raised it with her yet as I only noticed this evening after working hours. I'm so cross she didn't even tell me that she'd refused it. Do you think I could contact her over the weekend about it? I'm leaving this job in 2 weeks so I don't really care if it pisses her off tbh!

No absolutely do not contact her for crying out loud. Chill your beans and wait till Monday.

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:33

and @XelaM , the OP stated she always did this so it was not a 'genuine mistake'. She was commiting fraud and the company can be penalised:

'companies battling mileage fraud can be a hefty fine from HM Revenue and Customs (HRMC) on the tax owed on these fraudulent expenses. If HMRC investigate expenses and discover mileage fraud, your company could be fined up to £3,000 per employee in the UK'.

So, OP was acting criminally. But do tell, which crimes do you see as 'mistakes' and which crimes really are crimes?

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 20/08/2022 08:32

Sorry. Wrong thread, no idea how I did that

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 20/08/2022 08:31

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Narcheska · 20/08/2022 08:25

XelaM · 20/08/2022 08:15

Dramatic much 🙄

It was one genuine mistake that the OP corrected

No it’s not. In my work place it would count as possible fraudulent behaviour. All the claims would need to be audited to make sure it was a genuine mistake not a pattern that handy be noticed before. Anyone could claim it was a honest mistake when caught out.

in my workplace it’s done online and it clearly says in very big red lettering you are entitled to claim
mileage only for the distance from
your place of work to the destination. Not home to destination because if you were coming to work as normal
you wouldn’t get paid mileage for that journey.

we had one person move departments who tried claiming mileage from home to destination so they were audit when I picked it up. Turns out they’d been doing it a lot but they didn’t have anyone to audit they’re claims in Previous position due to understaffing so they’d just got used to getting away with it.

I’m not saying OP is lying and it wasn’t a genuine mistake but their claims might be checked as part of that mistake

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:21

XelaM · 20/08/2022 08:15

Dramatic much 🙄

It was one genuine mistake that the OP corrected

Not dramatic, it was technically fraud, so if her manager was minded to do so, s/he could take it further.
You may think such 'petty' crime is reasonable, others do not.

Quveas · 20/08/2022 08:19

XelaM · 20/08/2022 08:15

Dramatic much 🙄

It was one genuine mistake that the OP corrected

No. The OP says it was one genuine mistake. The employer is not obliged to accept that answer. Losing ones job is very definitely possible, and it's not remotely overdramatic to think that the employer will be making sure that there have been no other genuine mistakes. FWWIW, I do know of someone who lost his job over "one genuine mistake" on his mileage claim - admittedly they were looking for an excuse, but the employer dismissed and the dismissal was ruled fair.

mumda · 20/08/2022 08:15

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:09

Sadly, what you were doing, completing time-sheest/mileage etc, before actually doing the work/mileage, was fraudulent.
So your boss, or the accounts department, may well be auditing the rest of your claim for that month (or indeed, all of your previous claims), which they would be obliged to do.
If you are a registered professional, i would suggest ypu get in touch with your union as a pre-emptive strike
And be prepared to explain to your next employer if your current one passes this info on

I overheard one of the finance people in our office moaning that we don't fill the expenses form before we arrive and hand it in with the return journey filled in. I think that'd be wrong. Even though we know we get expenses there and back. In my mind you should complete the journey first.

PollyPeePants · 20/08/2022 08:15

It's probably just a system thing and you'll have to delete the wrong entry, update the. Claim and submit again.
That's how ours works anyway.
There would be no way for the approver to approve without the claim being updated and resubmitted.
But yeah, as PPs have said, ask her.

Quveas · 20/08/2022 08:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

And if I were the manager of an employee who had submitted a mileage claim for a journey they didn't take I would be suspending their claims until a full audit of every claim they had made had been completed. But I am "petty" like that...

It was no doubt a genuine mistake by the OP but they really aren't in a strong position here. There is no defence for making a false claim. They may have been in the habit of filling in the mileage before they made a journey, but that is (as the OP accepts themselves) entirely wrong. Quite apart from anything else, how can you know what your mileage will be before you have made the journey? Even regular journeys can unexpectedly deviate from the planned route and so vary from the normal mileage.

A polite request about her claim(s) is in order, and nothing more. People have been disciplined or dismissed for this kind of mistake, and claiming expenses you haven't incurred is a serious matter.

XelaM · 20/08/2022 08:15

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:09

Sadly, what you were doing, completing time-sheest/mileage etc, before actually doing the work/mileage, was fraudulent.
So your boss, or the accounts department, may well be auditing the rest of your claim for that month (or indeed, all of your previous claims), which they would be obliged to do.
If you are a registered professional, i would suggest ypu get in touch with your union as a pre-emptive strike
And be prepared to explain to your next employer if your current one passes this info on

Dramatic much 🙄

It was one genuine mistake that the OP corrected

pinkstripeycat · 20/08/2022 08:14

Clearestblue:

OP has already said it was updated, resubmitted and rejected

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:09

Sadly, what you were doing, completing time-sheest/mileage etc, before actually doing the work/mileage, was fraudulent.
So your boss, or the accounts department, may well be auditing the rest of your claim for that month (or indeed, all of your previous claims), which they would be obliged to do.
If you are a registered professional, i would suggest ypu get in touch with your union as a pre-emptive strike
And be prepared to explain to your next employer if your current one passes this info on

MrsLargeEmbodied · 20/08/2022 07:59

you need to ask her, simple, perhaps there is another error