Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Manager has refused mileage claim - AIBU?

162 replies

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 00:33

I work in the community and so submit my mileage expenses each month. I tend to write my visits in before I do them otherwise I worry I will forget - this is clearly not a good strategy due to what has happened below and I will now do them retrospectively.

I submitted my July mileage and my manager rejected it on the basis that there was one entry that was incorrect - a face-to-face visit had been changed to an online one and I had forgotten to delete the entry - she had seen that it was a Teams meeting in my diary. I apologised and deleted the entry and resubmitted it. I have only just noticed that the mileage for the whole month (a substantial amount) has been rejected again.

Is she allowed to do this? Obviously I was at fault for not deleting the other entry when the meeting was changed to an online one, but AIBU to think she's wrong to not pay my mileage for the rest of the month now the incorrect entry has been deleted? How should I raise this with her?

OP posts:
Quveas · 20/08/2022 11:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

You do not know that. You are making up facts to fit your scenario. There is actually only one fact. The OP claimed mileage for a journey that they did not make. The OP says it was a mistake. We have no evidence whether it was a mistake or a conscious effort. But oddly, sometimes people do take conscious efforts to fiddle their expenses. So the employer is entitled, if they so wish, to audit all the claims the OP has made to see whether this was the only "human error" they made. In which case the employer may accept it was human error. But they are not required to. They could just as easily see it as fraud and discipline or even dismiss. They probably won't since the OP is leaving anyway - but if they find a pattern of such "human errors" they (a) may decide to discipline or dismiss, (b) might decide to update the reference they provided, or (c) may take legal action and/or call the police.

As a manager who holds budget authorities, I am not allowed to "guess" at whether somebody makes a human error or not. I am required to audit their activities, and depending on the scenario I may have to involve our internal auditors or finance officers. That applies to everyone. Not just the employees that I don't like, aren't leaving, or whatever other personal circumstances they have. Even handed. Not heavy handed. Which part of taking financial responsibility are you struggling with?

NoSquirrels · 20/08/2022 11:07

It’ll be an admin thing. I’m sure it’ll get sorted on Monday.

SundayTeatime · 20/08/2022 11:01

YABU.
contact your manager on Monday.
They will either be reviewing all your claims submitted, you’ve missed the cutoff time for claims to be paid out, your manager themselves is now in trouble, etc, and isn’t allowed to approve anything, all sorts of reasons.

Aprilx · 20/08/2022 11:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

I didn’t say it couldn’t happen, I said it isn’t normally a defence when you have signed and certified something. Do you not understand that finer point?

And actually no, I have never made a false expense claim. If that means I am perfect then I guess I am and no I am not exhausted by keeping my expense claims honest.

thunderandsunshine01 · 20/08/2022 10:49

I work in a finance department so I think YABU massively. There will have been a deadline to submit your expenses/mileage and anything incorrect should be corrected and paid the next month. I would have also chose to audit you as it is a major red flag that you were pre filling out your mileage sheets and there could have been many more gone unnoticed (which You would need to pay back, hence them not paying you any money until your audit is completed)

WhatALotOfAFussAboutNothing · 20/08/2022 10:47

Fairyliz · 20/08/2022 07:12

How do you know she has rejected it again, do you get paid with your salary and it’s not showing on payslip?
If so initial rejection may mean it missed the pay deadline and will be processed on next pay run.

This. I think the initial rejection due to the error means it has missed cut off for this months payroll and will be paid next month.

tenterden · 20/08/2022 10:45

Isn't it more likely that, given your slapdash approach to your expenses, manager has spotted another error, or something that needs clarification? Either that or there's a system requirement to resubmit the whole claim differently.

I would just wait until Monday and ask her.

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 10:42

liveforsummer · 20/08/2022 10:03

As I explained in my later post I wouldn't bother doing this for the kind of mileage I was claiming, interested that people do though.

But you go to the effort of Google mapping it - that takes longer. Miles add up quickly when it's lots of little journeys. I was more replying to your surprise about software being available though which isn't needed when you've got a basic function on your dashboard

I had to 'go to the effort' of google mapping it because that was the organisational policy for how mileage should be tracked.

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 10:40

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 10:20

Yes one system i used had a road map (eg google maps) you put in the office (current location) and where you were going to, it gave the different routes, you could pick and adjust the path of travel the system would then calculate the milage based on the rates × road distance.

Yes, that's exactly the system I used.

But, for example, one day there was a burst watermain and I had to a) run my engine stuck in traffic for 20 minutes and then b) follow a diversion round it that was temporary.

Using google maps retrospectively wouldn't help with the unexpected costs there. To be honest I just wrote stuff like that off.

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 10:20

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 09:17

"Quite apart from anything else, how can you know what your mileage will be before you have made the journey? Even regular journeys can unexpectedly deviate from the planned route and so vary from the normal mileage."

I've always just put in the shortest return journey via google maps, I've never claimed extra if my route has been diverted do people really do this? How are they measuring their diversions is there software that can do this (genuine question).

Yes one system i used had a road map (eg google maps) you put in the office (current location) and where you were going to, it gave the different routes, you could pick and adjust the path of travel the system would then calculate the milage based on the rates × road distance.

Completelyovernonsense · 20/08/2022 10:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

Oblomov22 · 20/08/2022 10:07

Don't contact her until Monday. She rightly will now need to double check it, and maybe all previous claims.

liveforsummer · 20/08/2022 10:05

If OP is telling the truth about the error then it's likely not to be fraud however at this stage the manager does not know that. Historical expenses will need checked to know.

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 10:03

Fleur405 · 20/08/2022 09:02

Based on the information the OP has given this is definitely not fraud - if they were to refuse to pay her legitimate expenses or dismiss her she will have a claim against them (I’m a lawyer and I deal with quite a lot of fraud cases - it’s entirely different to forgetting to update a form one time)

Agree with others though that in the circumstances they may want to do a review just to confirm that it wasn’t part of a consistent practice of inflating the claims. Many people do get away with expenses fraud due to lax approval/audit procedures.

While it is likely that the OP's error has resulted in the expense missing the payment cut off the company will have the right to verify that in-person meetings happened and do an audit on prior claims.

Another possibility is that if OP's manager leaves an unapproved claim sitting open that it automatically gets rerouted to the Managers manager, most online systems have that to prevent a build up of unapproved claims by lazy managers or where the manager is not available for some reason.

Nobody can say anything definite on error/fraud without looking at the company policy. Some companies who have had problems in the past have a zero tollerance on expense errors.
When I was involved in setting up a new expenditure system on of the things which was built in was a warning that it was the employees responsibilty to ensure that the claim was correct. Some senior managers were upset at the fact that while they could delegate the inputs and had some autoload from credit cards only their ID could submit the claim to prevent them pushing the responsibility of the error on to a junior.

liveforsummer · 20/08/2022 10:03

As I explained in my later post I wouldn't bother doing this for the kind of mileage I was claiming, interested that people do though.

But you go to the effort of Google mapping it - that takes longer. Miles add up quickly when it's lots of little journeys. I was more replying to your surprise about software being available though which isn't needed when you've got a basic function on your dashboard

Aprilx · 20/08/2022 10:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

When you submit expenses, you usually make a sign off that they are genuine expenses that you encountered on company business. As such, you cannot make the argument that it was an error. Same as signing anything, you need to check it properly, your signature is your word, that I didn’t read it / check it before signing is not normally a defence if something goes wrong.

Aprilx · 20/08/2022 09:56

XelaM · 20/08/2022 08:15

Dramatic much 🙄

It was one genuine mistake that the OP corrected

It isn’t at all dramatic. It was a fraudulent claim and it would be remiss of the manager to not check previous and future claims thoroughly, perhaps the supporting evidence was not sufficient in view of OPs memory lapses.

She should of course be reimbursed for the genuine trips once manager is satisfied, OP needs to ask the manager what is required to support a res mission of the expenses.

Completelyovernonsense · 20/08/2022 09:48

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

CrabbitBastard · 20/08/2022 09:41

Maybe you need to resubmit the whole claim, rather than correcting just the one mistake?

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 09:39

liveforsummer · 20/08/2022 09:35

I've always just put in the shortest return journey via google maps, I've never claimed extra if my route has been diverted do people really do this? How are they measuring their diversions is there software that can do this (genuine question).

My car is very old and basic but even it has a button that sets the mikes to zero so you can see how long each trip is. If you don't know how to do that on your car just check the hand book or Google it?!

As I explained in my later post I wouldn't bother doing this for the kind of mileage I was claiming, interested that people do though.

custardbear · 20/08/2022 09:38

I'd text her personally. You should have checked, but we all make mistakes

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 09:38

mumda · 20/08/2022 08:15

I overheard one of the finance people in our office moaning that we don't fill the expenses form before we arrive and hand it in with the return journey filled in. I think that'd be wrong. Even though we know we get expenses there and back. In my mind you should complete the journey first.

The "person in finance" should not work in finance.

  1. its fraud if the event never happens and there is no refund to the company
  2. is becomes taxable/NIable BIK for the employee and a HMRC auditors love to find this in an audit because if finance / HR are careless around payroll they are usually as careless around other financial transactions too.
liveforsummer · 20/08/2022 09:35

I've always just put in the shortest return journey via google maps, I've never claimed extra if my route has been diverted do people really do this? How are they measuring their diversions is there software that can do this (genuine question).

My car is very old and basic but even it has a button that sets the mikes to zero so you can see how long each trip is. If you don't know how to do that on your car just check the hand book or Google it?!

dribblewibble · 20/08/2022 09:33

Immaterialatthispoint · 20/08/2022 09:30

@letmechangetheatmosphere this is what your trip button is for.

the correct way to record mileage is to note the start on your odometer, and note the finish. Either by photograph, notation or trio meter.

I would use my Tripmeter but I've no idea how to in my new car 🤣🤣🤣

Immaterialatthispoint · 20/08/2022 09:30

@letmechangetheatmosphere this is what your trip button is for.

the correct way to record mileage is to note the start on your odometer, and note the finish. Either by photograph, notation or trio meter.