Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Manager has refused mileage claim - AIBU?

162 replies

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 00:33

I work in the community and so submit my mileage expenses each month. I tend to write my visits in before I do them otherwise I worry I will forget - this is clearly not a good strategy due to what has happened below and I will now do them retrospectively.

I submitted my July mileage and my manager rejected it on the basis that there was one entry that was incorrect - a face-to-face visit had been changed to an online one and I had forgotten to delete the entry - she had seen that it was a Teams meeting in my diary. I apologised and deleted the entry and resubmitted it. I have only just noticed that the mileage for the whole month (a substantial amount) has been rejected again.

Is she allowed to do this? Obviously I was at fault for not deleting the other entry when the meeting was changed to an online one, but AIBU to think she's wrong to not pay my mileage for the rest of the month now the incorrect entry has been deleted? How should I raise this with her?

OP posts:
Quveas · 20/08/2022 14:52

Novum · 20/08/2022 14:40

No, it is you who are making up the facts. The only information we have is that it was an inadvertent error. You are the one who has suddenly decided that OP is lying.

Yes, the employer needs to check, as normal good audit practice. But that does not mean that OP has committed fraud.

I have been very clear that I am not saying that. The only fact available is that the OP claimed a payment for mileage they did not do. I have been very clear that I am not saying they did (or did not) do that intentionally. I have never accused the OP of lying. I have not implied that. I have clearly set out the legal position in respect of employment. The employer does not have to prove intent or fraud. That is a fact. They only have to prove that the employee claimed a payment to which they had no right.

balalake · 20/08/2022 14:47

Talk to your manager, not email, Teams message or text message. Far more chance of it being resolved quickly.

Endlesslypatient82 · 20/08/2022 14:46

Yes, the employer needs to check, as normal good audit practice

op should brace herself for a full audit of all her previous expenses, which may well stop her in her tracks! 😂

Endlesslypatient82 · 20/08/2022 14:44

You are the one who has suddenly decided that OP is lying.

it does rather look like her manager also suspects so too!

Novum · 20/08/2022 14:40

Quveas · 20/08/2022 11:18

You do not know that. You are making up facts to fit your scenario. There is actually only one fact. The OP claimed mileage for a journey that they did not make. The OP says it was a mistake. We have no evidence whether it was a mistake or a conscious effort. But oddly, sometimes people do take conscious efforts to fiddle their expenses. So the employer is entitled, if they so wish, to audit all the claims the OP has made to see whether this was the only "human error" they made. In which case the employer may accept it was human error. But they are not required to. They could just as easily see it as fraud and discipline or even dismiss. They probably won't since the OP is leaving anyway - but if they find a pattern of such "human errors" they (a) may decide to discipline or dismiss, (b) might decide to update the reference they provided, or (c) may take legal action and/or call the police.

As a manager who holds budget authorities, I am not allowed to "guess" at whether somebody makes a human error or not. I am required to audit their activities, and depending on the scenario I may have to involve our internal auditors or finance officers. That applies to everyone. Not just the employees that I don't like, aren't leaving, or whatever other personal circumstances they have. Even handed. Not heavy handed. Which part of taking financial responsibility are you struggling with?

No, it is you who are making up the facts. The only information we have is that it was an inadvertent error. You are the one who has suddenly decided that OP is lying.

Yes, the employer needs to check, as normal good audit practice. But that does not mean that OP has committed fraud.

Novum · 20/08/2022 14:32

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:09

Sadly, what you were doing, completing time-sheest/mileage etc, before actually doing the work/mileage, was fraudulent.
So your boss, or the accounts department, may well be auditing the rest of your claim for that month (or indeed, all of your previous claims), which they would be obliged to do.
If you are a registered professional, i would suggest ypu get in touch with your union as a pre-emptive strike
And be prepared to explain to your next employer if your current one passes this info on

No, it wasn't fraudulent. To constitute fraud, it would have to be intentional.

TiaraBoo · 20/08/2022 14:10

Just contact your manager on Monday and ask for the reason the claim was rejected so you correct any errors. If she rejected it incorrectly then you can then just resubmit, or if there is an error you can correct it.
Don’t overthink it.

Twentypast · 20/08/2022 14:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

It's quite usual to "shell out" for fuel costs upfront. I've claimed mileage in my last 4 jobs over 20 years and never been able to claim mileage in advance. We claim at the end of the month.

Upontherooftops · 20/08/2022 14:03

Absolutely email the manager or payroll and ask why it has been rejected. It is likely that your claims are being reviewed to check it was a one off mistake and not systematic fraud. I checked an employee's back claims once as I noticed she'd claimed mileage for a trip when she was off sick and the audit of her claims did in fact reveal that she had been ripping off the company for months claiming for cancelled meetings, claiming double or triple distance, meetings while on hols or sick, claiming when she'd shared someone else's car and her manager had been signing off without checking anything. She was sacked and the manager was given a warning. This is why companies check, an honest mistake will be revealed to be an honest mistake and be fine.

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 13:45

Lineala · 20/08/2022 12:38

No. For fraud to exist there needs to be intention. That is missing in this scenario.

A pattern of behaviour could be used to estabilshed intent so that is why a single instance can trigger an audit and a delay in payment.
More likely the OP the processing missed cut off.

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 13:40

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 12:30

Ok cba to get into the fraud thing but it definitely was a one off and I am not in the habit of making fraudulent claims. Would I not be told that I am being audited if I am? I am surprised she has rejected the resubmitted claim without telling me.

No, you would not be told if you were being audited. Misspoken words could result in a liability or tip you off giving you an oppertunity to interfere with any investigation.
The fact that you are leaving makes any audit more urgent as the company would see it as leaving them a small window to recover overpayments.
Plus if you work in a job where you have access to clients homes or workplaces they would also be concerned if they offered an character reference to your new employer.

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 13:39

@Quveas i am leaving very soon anyway so it wouldn’t really be in their interests to dismiss me

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 20/08/2022 13:17

Friend writes hers on sheet that she keeps in her car OP then ticks them off as she does each journey. Means she doesnt forget and it double checks as she ticks each one off

Quveas · 20/08/2022 13:01

Lineala · 20/08/2022 12:38

No. For fraud to exist there needs to be intention. That is missing in this scenario.

You do not know that. You know that the OP says that. And I am not suggesting it isn't true. I am suggesting, based on experience, that few people admit to things they intentionally did wrong, at least in the first instance. I am also pointing out that in employment the legal requirements are very different to criminal law. In employment the employer only requires a "reasonable belief" of something not evidence of it. So if the employer formed a reasonable belief that the employee claimed expenses to which they are not entitled (which they did!) then that is sufficient for a fair dismissal. So the requirements for the employer to act are not missing. Whether there is evidence sufficient for a criminal test is a very different thing - but if an audit found that the error was part of a pattern then that may be enough to prove intent.

comedycentral · 20/08/2022 12:53

Could you have made any previous errors too? Do you keep a copy of what you submit? I think they are auditing.

tigger1001 · 20/08/2022 12:45

I wouldn't be surprised if the full claim is being audited to ensure it is correct.

That's just good practice from the business point of view. That's not saying that the incorrect journey wasn't an honest mistake. It's just ensuring that the claim is correct and the company are not paying out incorrectly.

It is also possible that the amended claim form missed the deadline for payment.

Just speak to the manager on Monday and ask

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 20/08/2022 12:40

For fraud to exist there needs to be intention. That is missing in this scenario
As far as we've been told by the OP. So you can't say for sure.

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 20/08/2022 12:38

I think you've opened yourself up to a whole load of stress by submitting a false claim. You will likely get your mileage eventually, but probably will undergo a full audit of all expenses before it's paid. As PP has pointed out, sometimes it's not an innocent mistake so the company must investigate fully.

Lineala · 20/08/2022 12:38

Quveas · 20/08/2022 11:18

You do not know that. You are making up facts to fit your scenario. There is actually only one fact. The OP claimed mileage for a journey that they did not make. The OP says it was a mistake. We have no evidence whether it was a mistake or a conscious effort. But oddly, sometimes people do take conscious efforts to fiddle their expenses. So the employer is entitled, if they so wish, to audit all the claims the OP has made to see whether this was the only "human error" they made. In which case the employer may accept it was human error. But they are not required to. They could just as easily see it as fraud and discipline or even dismiss. They probably won't since the OP is leaving anyway - but if they find a pattern of such "human errors" they (a) may decide to discipline or dismiss, (b) might decide to update the reference they provided, or (c) may take legal action and/or call the police.

As a manager who holds budget authorities, I am not allowed to "guess" at whether somebody makes a human error or not. I am required to audit their activities, and depending on the scenario I may have to involve our internal auditors or finance officers. That applies to everyone. Not just the employees that I don't like, aren't leaving, or whatever other personal circumstances they have. Even handed. Not heavy handed. Which part of taking financial responsibility are you struggling with?

No. For fraud to exist there needs to be intention. That is missing in this scenario.

justasking111 · 20/08/2022 12:37

Keep a sheet in the car enter mileage at time of set off and arrival. Do it correctly each time.

Having said that with the price of fuel I wonder if folks are out of pocket at the moment

dribblewibble · 20/08/2022 12:34

But I bet you weren't told to fill in your claim before you did the journey.

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 12:32

Re doing the mileage on Google maps this is how I was advised to do it when I started the job.

OP posts:
wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 12:30

Ok cba to get into the fraud thing but it definitely was a one off and I am not in the habit of making fraudulent claims. Would I not be told that I am being audited if I am? I am surprised she has rejected the resubmitted claim without telling me.

OP posts:
wellobviouslyyoucan · 20/08/2022 11:48

Why would you fill in your mileage claim before you've done the journey? It's quite odd.

SparrowsNest · 20/08/2022 11:20

Narcheska · 20/08/2022 07:36

Not sure how your system works but as part as my role I check and approve mileage for my bosses direct employees (I’m EA) if you’d submitted something and I’d caught out a mistake where your claimed for a journey that didn’t happen even when resubmitted it would be rejected because I’d be required to do a full audit.

Not suggesting you did do it on purpose and hope you didn’t get checked because honest mistakes happen but it would flag our systems and I’d have to do a full audit of your current claim and then possibly look at old claims just to be sure

Same process in my workplace. Came to my attention that someone had claimed mileage for a journey when I knew for a fact they had used the pool car. (I was the subsequent booking). Their mileage claim had come to me to authorise as their manager was on leave. Said it was a mistake and they had entered the journey in advance but swopped to the pool car last minute due their own vehicle being blocked in. I rejected the claim and referred it back to their manager to follow up on their return. Unfortunately the subsequent audit revealed that this wasn't an isolated incident. Mistakes do happen but unfortunately so do fraudulent claims.