Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Manager has refused mileage claim - AIBU?

162 replies

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 00:33

I work in the community and so submit my mileage expenses each month. I tend to write my visits in before I do them otherwise I worry I will forget - this is clearly not a good strategy due to what has happened below and I will now do them retrospectively.

I submitted my July mileage and my manager rejected it on the basis that there was one entry that was incorrect - a face-to-face visit had been changed to an online one and I had forgotten to delete the entry - she had seen that it was a Teams meeting in my diary. I apologised and deleted the entry and resubmitted it. I have only just noticed that the mileage for the whole month (a substantial amount) has been rejected again.

Is she allowed to do this? Obviously I was at fault for not deleting the other entry when the meeting was changed to an online one, but AIBU to think she's wrong to not pay my mileage for the rest of the month now the incorrect entry has been deleted? How should I raise this with her?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 20/08/2022 20:02

can I ask who suggested you do it off Google? What does the company procedure say? Even though it was a genuine mistake, its a teeny red flag that you do your mileage claim before you have actually done the mileage. As a retired NHS community services manager, I too would have had to audit your claim and check it against your diary and would have been rolling my eyes at the extra work.

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 19:54

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 18:52

@SolasAnla will she tell me if I’m being investigated?

Its unlikely that you are being investigated. Unless you work in a blame culture org if your manager is doing her own unofficial spot checks or if it has been officially flaged for an audit she is unlikley to say anything unless a check shows there is more than one instance which needs to be queried.

Even then if there were small errors its a management decision on the economic value of any actions around the errors.
The only "but if" is if the company have a contractual obligation which they prove via the claims eg on in person meetings or eg if the cost is rechargeable

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 19:08

"I'm so cross she didn't even tell me that she'd refused it. Do you think I could contact her over the weekend about it? I'm leaving this job in 2 weeks so I don't really care if it pisses her off tbh!"

I'd definitely drop this attitude, though. You made the mistake, not her.

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 19:06

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 18:48

@letmechangetheatmosphere not a significant amount - certainly not worth their while investigating - and I’m fairly certain it’s never happened before but you have worried me now! What might they do if I work the last two weeks (I only have one working week left, the last week is annual leave)?

I wouldn't worry about it, per se.

But for me personally I'm very forgetful - diagnosed ADHD, there is no way I'd be able to remember to photo my mileage on my dashboard before and after every single journey as others here do and as works for them , esp with kids to drop off on the way to school etc all of their stuff to remember too.

So it would make me worry that I may have done it before if I was in your shoes - but that's because the system you use wouldn't work for me. If you think it genuinely worked for you, e.g. it's not very often that a physical meeting would have been replaced by a teams one then you're probably fine. Only you know the likelihood it could have happened before, if you are a bit scatty and might have done it before I'm just saying in your shoes I'd probably hope she had auditing my mileage on her to do list and might not get round to it in the next 2 weeks.

notasillysausage · 20/08/2022 18:57

OP, I am sure it will be ok. I would just email your manager on Monday asking if there was an issue with the resubmitted claim? I wouldn’t message over the weekend to be honest.

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 18:52

@SolasAnla will she tell me if I’m being investigated?

OP posts:
wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 18:48

@letmechangetheatmosphere not a significant amount - certainly not worth their while investigating - and I’m fairly certain it’s never happened before but you have worried me now! What might they do if I work the last two weeks (I only have one working week left, the last week is annual leave)?

OP posts:
SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 18:30

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 18:10

@Endlesslypatient82 ok but my question was how I raise this with her, not have I committed fraud

Call her on Monday morning, after giving her 10 min for morning coffee.
Then say you noticed that the claim was not processed, and what do you need to do resubmit the existing claim or input a duplicate.

SolasAnla · 20/08/2022 18:27

Underscore21 · 20/08/2022 15:24

Do you work for an NHS Community trust? Is it the sel system?
If so, you're only allowed to submit once /twice a month. You may have to wait until 1st Sept to submit again.
I'm quite amazed that your manager has enough time to check all your journeys against your diary. Wow! She must have a lot of time on her hands.

All employees who approve financial expenditure have an obligation to follow their employers policy which will normally involve some level of checks.
If a manager fails to follow the policy they themselves could facing discipline and be sacked if the carelessness results in the misappropriation of funds.

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 18:23

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 18:10

@Endlesslypatient82 ok but my question was how I raise this with her, not have I committed fraud

How much was it and are you certain that you've never messed up like this before? Reason I ask is because if you only have 2 weeks to go it'd possibly be worth writing the money off and just getting out of there without a disciplinary.

SquigglePigs · 20/08/2022 18:18

letmechangetheatmosphere · 20/08/2022 09:17

"Quite apart from anything else, how can you know what your mileage will be before you have made the journey? Even regular journeys can unexpectedly deviate from the planned route and so vary from the normal mileage."

I've always just put in the shortest return journey via google maps, I've never claimed extra if my route has been diverted do people really do this? How are they measuring their diversions is there software that can do this (genuine question).

@letletmechangetheatmosphere I note my start and end mileage for a journey and claim based on that.

Otherwise if you're working it out afterwards you can get Google to add extra points into a route and do it that way.

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 18:10

@Endlesslypatient82 ok but my question was how I raise this with her, not have I committed fraud

OP posts:
Endlesslypatient82 · 20/08/2022 17:36

Johnnysgirl · 20/08/2022 16:03

I more or less told him to approve the claim or else. Tosser.
Or else what?

Yes I’m curious too!

Endlesslypatient82 · 20/08/2022 17:34

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 17:29

i can’t believe how many people are accusing me of fraud for one mistake.

@gatehouseoffleet yes often the journeys are longer due to roadworks, road closures etc but I think the way my manager checks mileage to know we’re claiming the right amount is to do it by Google maps, otherwise surely I could do a journey that was 1 mile according to Google maps but claim it was 3 miles because of traffic or something even if it wasn’t? Now that would be fraudulent!

Op
The facts that we can be sure of as posters who don’t know you from Adam are….

YOU say that you should have changed the way you did your expenses

YOU made a mistake

Your manager has taken not accepted your other expenses. Presumably she wants to do some digging.

so based on the facts, it’s not unreasonable to presume fraud, as clearly your manager - you does know you, may suspect

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 17:29

i can’t believe how many people are accusing me of fraud for one mistake.

@gatehouseoffleet yes often the journeys are longer due to roadworks, road closures etc but I think the way my manager checks mileage to know we’re claiming the right amount is to do it by Google maps, otherwise surely I could do a journey that was 1 mile according to Google maps but claim it was 3 miles because of traffic or something even if it wasn’t? Now that would be fraudulent!

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 20/08/2022 16:03

I more or less told him to approve the claim or else. Tosser.
Or else what?

gatehouseoffleet · 20/08/2022 16:01

Actually you probably should claim in advance so you are not out of pocket having to buy petrol before you've been given the money but of course it's not ideal if a meeting is cancelled or changes to remote after you've claimed.

I don't know why employers think their employees should give them interest free loans.

Fortunately I don't have to drive for work, and very rarely incur any sort of expense for my employers - in my experience most employers do all they can to wriggle out of paying claims, but you make one mistake and it must be fraud. Yeah right.

gatehouseoffleet · 20/08/2022 15:57

Quite apart from anything else, how can you know what your mileage will be before you have made the journey? Even regular journeys can unexpectedly deviate from the planned route and so vary from the normal mileage

surely in that instance the journey would be longer?

In the real world people make mistakes and not everyone assumes everyone is trying to defraud them all of the time. It must be exhausting being a manager who has no trust in their staff. Why did you recruit them if you don't trust them?

I had an argument years ago with my boss who said I should have gone on the motorway instead of the A road which would have been 2 miles less. I more or less told him to approve the claim or else. Tosser.

SundayTeatime · 20/08/2022 15:32

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 13:39

@Quveas i am leaving very soon anyway so it wouldn’t really be in their interests to dismiss me

That doesn’t follow at all.

kitcat15 · 20/08/2022 15:32

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 20/08/2022 08:09

Sadly, what you were doing, completing time-sheest/mileage etc, before actually doing the work/mileage, was fraudulent.
So your boss, or the accounts department, may well be auditing the rest of your claim for that month (or indeed, all of your previous claims), which they would be obliged to do.
If you are a registered professional, i would suggest ypu get in touch with your union as a pre-emptive strike
And be prepared to explain to your next employer if your current one passes this info on

Are you for fucking real??
I don’t for one second think my manager ever checks my mileage….she often approves it seconds after I submit it….she wouldn’t give a shiny shite about an error like OPs….at the end of the day I always exceed my mileage claims with road works…I’m NHS….and this has always been the case for the 25 years I’ve worked in the community….fucking ridiculous post🙄

Underscore21 · 20/08/2022 15:24

Do you work for an NHS Community trust? Is it the sel system?
If so, you're only allowed to submit once /twice a month. You may have to wait until 1st Sept to submit again.
I'm quite amazed that your manager has enough time to check all your journeys against your diary. Wow! She must have a lot of time on her hands.

Johnnysgirl · 20/08/2022 15:06

She clearly thinks you're taking the piss, and have only been discovered once.
Who writes their mileage in advance?

Quveas · 20/08/2022 15:03

Novum · 20/08/2022 14:55

It rather depends what the employer wants to do, though, doesn't it, @Quveas ? If they just want to disallow such claims, fine. If they want the employee charged with fraud, they will need solid evidence of intent, beyond reasonable doubt. If they want to sack her, they will need evidence of intent on a balance of probabilities. But simply establishing that she did something which is explicable as a one-off mistake won't get the employer far in terms of justifying either course of action.

I believe that is exactly what I said.

Quveas · 20/08/2022 15:02

wonderingwanderer2 · 20/08/2022 13:39

@Quveas i am leaving very soon anyway so it wouldn’t really be in their interests to dismiss me

That entirely depends on them though. I am only pointing out the options available, not whether they will exercise them or not. If they were to find some more errors, they may disagree with you on what is in their best interests. You'd equally think that it was odd that a manager "happened" to notice that your claim and your diary didn't match - coincidence perhaps? Where I work we have to "spot check" 1 in 10 claims submitted to us, so perhaps it was just serendipity that yours was picked. It's not that I don't believe you just made a mistake - which some people here seem to think is the case if anyone dares to disagree with their opinion - but that the employer doesn't have to see things the same way anyone here does. And employment law has a much lower bar to prove than criminal law.

Novum · 20/08/2022 14:55

It rather depends what the employer wants to do, though, doesn't it, @Quveas ? If they just want to disallow such claims, fine. If they want the employee charged with fraud, they will need solid evidence of intent, beyond reasonable doubt. If they want to sack her, they will need evidence of intent on a balance of probabilities. But simply establishing that she did something which is explicable as a one-off mistake won't get the employer far in terms of justifying either course of action.