Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young people - workshy, or a wee bit canny?

238 replies

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 20:35

Inspired by a spirited discussion in the Scottish highlands.

A local cafe owner (late forties) was bemoaning his staffing situation to another forty something man, who was buying a coffee with his daughter. I was waiting for mine.

”I’m understaffed - can’t get the workers. I’m paying them 20% above minimum wage but the 18-30 generation don’t want to work - they’d rather sell drugs or be on benefits’.

The chap he was talking to said :

‘oh really - yeah it’s terrible that, they just don’t have the ethic’.

At this point I (another forty something) interjected, and said :

“Well, can we really blame them? Vast swathes of them have been disenfranchised through the cost of housing. They don’t see a path to a stake in society any more”

He said “Utter bollocks - I worked hard and they don’t want to”. The other guy agreed.

Then another guy (again forty something 😂) started agreeing with me, saying he sees it in the corporate world that it’s the sorted 50 somethings who bought cheap houses who are the workshy ones cruising along.

I agreed - imho, no point in working unless you get £100k. Only then can you hope to match the lifestyle of a retail worker from the past”

All the while a young person was waiting for her coffee looked very non pleased and the cafe owner apologised saying “not all young people obviously”

AIBU to think the young are right to “lie flat” and not bother if things don’t change?

OP posts:
slowquickstep · 19/08/2022 22:42

50 something here, i had it so easy it seems, mortgage payments doubled in a year when interest hit 18%. I struggled to keep our house and was lucky to walk away from it without losing the shirt off my back. Later i was a divorced single Mum and had to work 3 jobs to keep a roof over my teenagers heads. Not all 50 year olds are cruising and living it up. Many many 50+women find themselves traded in for a younger model and are struggling to pay the rent.

greyinganddecaying · 19/08/2022 22:42

Hmm - I've come across a couple of things recently that make me wonder

-someone just finished training to work with kids, but is going to put off getting a permanent job for a couple of years as dealing with the kids impacted by covid will be too challenging

  • different person saying that they're only going to do the bare minimum in their college course and if they fail they'll just tell people they've passed (in an industry that often doesn't check on qualifications)

Worrying if that's a trend.

MichelleScarn · 19/08/2022 22:38

What do you do in the Highlands for over £100k or is that the job you're waiting for?

CherryGenoa · 19/08/2022 22:36

My children are teens. The young today are no more work shy than previous generations. Maybe the cafe owner hasn’t realised but the nature of work has changed, lockdowns accelerated this and I notice a general preference amongst the young to be ‘your own boss’.

My younger teen during the pandemic, learned to do web design and SEO, which is less physical effort and shorter, more flexible hours than catering work, which he did try but didn’t enjoy. He is working on a website for a new startup at the moment. He doesn’t charge much as he’s still learning and building a reputation but he loves doing it and works from our home, so his costs are low.

One of my oldest’s former classmates makes a very decent living selling photos and videos on Only Fans. She makes much more money doing this than working in the profession she spent five years training to do, and earns as much in an hour as a cafe worker would in a day. I appreciate this is probably exceptional.

Another pair of friends of my son have set up a holiday let cleaning service to milk all the local Airbnb owners. They charge £15 an hour and have more work than they can handle.

My point is that none of these teens would choose to work in a cafe, but none are workshy. They all work really hard but want to do what they love and or get paid better.

I agree young people are screwed at the moment, but they will remould the system more in their favour when they are numerous enough as a group and old enough to outvote older brexiteers. They will likely forge closer ties to Europe once more.

Bluebells12 · 19/08/2022 22:35

goshy · 19/08/2022 20:38

I think the young have been shafted personally & they should be angrier about it

They will be. They just aren’t in charge yet. You think they’re going to be paying our pensions 30 years from now? I don’t.

mindutopia · 19/08/2022 22:33

I work with young adults (university aged) and the ones I see definitely aren’t workshy (obviously these are the ones going to uni). But no different to my generation, it’s tough to work and be in full time education.

Dh has several employees in his business ranging from 17 to about 60. It’s the ones over 30 who moan the most and call in sick for banging a toe on something. The ones who are 17-25 are keen and hardworking and take direction and want to learn, etc.

Crikeyalmighty · 19/08/2022 22:33

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet - I totally see where you are coming from- we work in a 'sexy' industry that young people used to kill to get into. It's not hugely well paid when you start out but there are better paid jobs in it after 4 or 5 years solid experience . We are finding that most of the younger staff struggle to get out the student mentality- want to work from home when there is little track record to go on for reliability and struggle with 5 days a week consistency and can't cope with being told what they need to be doing and deadlines. This is in creative fields.

I know myself so many who seem to want to work for 10 months just to save up to go travelling again- it's as if they think 'travelling' is a 'career' - particularly common in those from middle class backgrounds who have been to Uni.

I think there are many reasons for this- overindulgence by some parents. Lack of feeling that they will ever be able to afford a place of their own- rented or bought (particularly acute in south east and south west) mentally not planning for progressing - because again what's the point- you can't save up when paying colossal rents and wages are the same as 20 years ago.

From my 20 months in Copenhagen I learnt a few things that I think would help. I think we need to build and develop a lot more decent quality part buys in areas people want to live , houses as well as flats, or buy up a great deal of private housing of all types and convert it to social housing at council house levels of rent. I think all this living in shared houses for years and years is creating an infantilised work force.

Personally I don't think working from home 5 days a week works well for many young people under 28 - I can see totally why people with young families like it - particularly women or older and proven professionals with a track record- but I think many younger people find it hard to stay motivated and I've noticed rather a lot of 'going missing' in the day time .

There are some really hard working and entrepreneurial young people out there- but they are from my experience not in the majority these days - certainly not in the south, maybe it's different further north where there is at least more chance of renting a flat/house or buying something modest but ok

Anyone who doesn't quite get the sheer stupidity of things in London/Home Counties/Bristol/bath /brighton etc- I suggest you do a Rightmove search on 2 bed flats and 3 bed semis to buy and rent and you will see the issue.

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 22:33

shinynewapple22 · 19/08/2022 22:12

I don't even know anyone who earns £100k - people of
any age - aside from some of our managers - none of my friends' families do.

Actually this thread is goady bollox IMO.

My point is 100k ain’t shit. It’s crap.

It’s only 66k after tax, and that’s before you’ve put some away fro retirement. Then you’ve got to spend £1-2k on housing p/m. 1k for something utterly crap, 2k gets you something half decent.

then you have to pay for transport because there ain’t no way you can afford housing near the actual place of work that pays the £100k gross. No, you want housing there - better earn £300k.

then there’s food, kids, and energy. Forget going out because taking a family out costs about £65 quid at fucking pizza express these days. £65 out of net salary

All you have to look forward to is a cheeky break up to lock lomond in a cheap air Bnb once a year.

well worth the hassle. Not.

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 22:27

TirisfalPumpkin · 19/08/2022 22:21

Generational comparison and ‘who had it harder’ olympics are part of life. ultimately every generation had it hard in their own way. I’m a millennial and I’m glad I didn’t have to live through the winter of discontent or rationing or this ‘ice on the inside of the window’ business everyone keeps talking about. (Wait a few months, right?)

I do think some of my generation are doomers and don’t think critically. ‘I will never own a house.’ End of thought process. Might require some creativity and flexibility but it’s doable. My first house was £75k in my economically depressed northern home town and my neighbours were drug dealers, but still. That’s why it’s a property ladder. And they had a lovely dog.

The ‘ladder’ starts at 200k round here. For a piece of absolute shit.

Thats two hundred thousand shitty pounds Sterling.

Good luck with that on minimum wage.

Because - and this might blow your mind - there are services round here that pay that to people. Care, retail etc.

OP posts:
TheFairyCaravan · 19/08/2022 22:26

What a load of crap.

Both my sons got jobs within weeks of their GCSEs finishing. They kept them on all through A levels, doing extra work in the school holidays. DS1 left his the day before he went in the army, DS2 left his the week before he went to university.

Once DS2 got to university he got a job in Spoons. He worked there as often as he could as well as doing his ward placements because he was doing a nursing degree. He never took his full holidays from university, he always worked in the pub.

His first job was in A&E. He volunteered for every course that was going. If there was pleas for staff to go in to cover he’d go. He’s a charge nurse now, and is doing his masters alongside his full time job and he’s renovating his house. He, also, does teaching in the hospital. That chap has an amazing work ethic. He always has. He’s never been afraid of hard work.

DS1 works his arse off too. He’s on Summer leave atm, but has been in work this week to do a couple of days cover. He volunteers to go here, there and everywhere in all weathers. He hates sitting around and sees it as his duty to offer rather than wait to be told.

It annoys me so much when people slate young people. In one breath we get told youth unemployment is going down then in the next we’re told they’re lazy bastards who don’t want to work. It can’t be both.

savehannah · 19/08/2022 22:25

We as a household earn way less than 100k and have three kids, a house we own (mortgage), a car, a pension. We are by no means rich but we are not struggling either.
Also as others said, I'd be very surprised at anyone being able to walk straight into a 100k job, people who earn 100k in the main will have worked their way up to that.

Kendodd · 19/08/2022 22:21

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 22:05

I’ve posted on several threads about this, as we have just stopped recruiting interns and apprentices due to poor work ethic.

Dont know about you but I’m staggered by the level of entitlement, coupled with a total inability to accept constructive criticism - even if it’s ‘oh just so you know we say “Good morning, My Workplace Industries, Gen-Zedder speaking” rather than just “‘Ello?”’. They take it REALLY badly, even had a couple get up and leave with the first minor comment then the next day I’ve got an angry mum on the phone asking why I ‘screamed’ (it’s always screamed, I don’t scream) at her DD 🙄.

Also find that, despite being very clear about the role expected, they think they’re above making tea for meetings, setting up meeting rooms, doing basic tasks etc. I never do anything like get them to take dry cleaning out (like I had to when I was in their position) or book personal appontments but I do expect them to find a meeting room when I say I’ve arranged a meeting. The sheer fury of having to do a menial task, when they’ve been told they’re amazing because they have a degree, astounds me. Don’t get me started on the conversation policing in the office.

They aren’t willing to start at the bottom and work their way up. I don’t know why. I have my theories. But yes ‘challenging’ is absolutely the right word.

Do you think that if you've had several young new starters just walk out it might be you who's the problem, not them?

TirisfalPumpkin · 19/08/2022 22:21

Generational comparison and ‘who had it harder’ olympics are part of life. ultimately every generation had it hard in their own way. I’m a millennial and I’m glad I didn’t have to live through the winter of discontent or rationing or this ‘ice on the inside of the window’ business everyone keeps talking about. (Wait a few months, right?)

I do think some of my generation are doomers and don’t think critically. ‘I will never own a house.’ End of thought process. Might require some creativity and flexibility but it’s doable. My first house was £75k in my economically depressed northern home town and my neighbours were drug dealers, but still. That’s why it’s a property ladder. And they had a lovely dog.

J0y · 19/08/2022 22:17

I work hard btw (gen x) but i have a copy of Tom Hodgkinson's ''How to be Idle'' on my shelf. Excellent book. Really made me think. Although he's not suggesting doing nothing and signing on, but he's not recommending becoming a wage ''slave'' either. I am still a wage slave but I took something from the book. ie not to outsource my entertainment to netflix. I still do that actually but I'm aware I'm doing it and I have artistic projects on the go.

shinynewapple22 · 19/08/2022 22:12

I don't even know anyone who earns £100k - people of
any age - aside from some of our managers - none of my friends' families do.

Actually this thread is goady bollox IMO.

Octomore · 19/08/2022 22:11

sst1234 · 19/08/2022 21:57

Every generation has had something to complain about.

Postwar youngsters could say they were left to pick up the pieces of previous generation’s war.

In the 60s, de industrialization began, boomers coming of age and entering a crowded jobs market, and youngsters found themselves again having to adjust to the market. Not to mention the threat of Cold War getting hot.

70s were particularly tough with massive inflation, crippled economy, everyone has heard the stories.

80s generation lived through it thinking were about to be nuked any minute.

In the 90s, they saw their parents losing their homes during the recession and were thinking that ozone depletion would mean the world would end in a few years.

The noughties brought the financial crisis, people losing their jobs and housing already expensive.

Those youngsters sat back now thinking it’s never been harder, will be wishing telling a different story in 20 years time.

I think this is bollocks. I came of age in the late 90s /early 00s, and the feeling then was one of optimism. There was no sense rhat young people of that era were particularly hard done by, not at all. Most young people I knew had disposable income for trips away etc. Life expectancy was rising, with young people expecting to live longer healthier lives than their parents and grandparents. There were economic issues, but not on the current scale. Wages were much higher relative to the cost of living (and have stagnated for the past 15 years or so while inflation has eroded purchasing power).

Current times are very, very different. The negagive impact of climate change is now a reality, not a hypothetical future. This and many other things means that things feel far less optimistic.

J0y · 19/08/2022 22:11

I think there is a percentage of people who are unemployable. They're just so unappealing to employers and they make no attempt to change that.

But there's another percentage who feel shamed for being unemployed when they have tried to find a job but don't have the right experience, can't ''perform'' at interview, don't have a degree (even though the job doesn't require it), they're too old, they're too unattractive, they don't have a car and can't drive to where the jobs are.... Employers and recruitment agents get away with their biases and discriminations meaning it's always the same demographic left depressed about being unable to find a job. The govt should be making sure that this can't happen, that companies can't hire only young people, or only people who already had a job.

shinynewapple22 · 19/08/2022 22:08

If we are talking generalisations here ..... my DS, his GF, all his friends (apart from one) and the DC of all of my friends all have jobs and are hardworking.

A couple of those in their mid-late 20s have managed to save for a deposit for a house. Admittedly they have stayed living at their parents home whilst saving, but all of them have paid some housekeeping as none of the families are well off (not breadline either, more average wage). House prices are also fairly cheap here in comparison to some other places - but I'm just showing a different side to the story .

Speedweed · 19/08/2022 22:06

I don't agree with the 100k point, because that's about consumerism which is like a moving mirage (you'd earn 100k and still feel like it wasn't enough, you deserve a bigger house etc etc).

But your point about house prices being so out of reach for even the hardest working, most frugal, relying on parental help, minimum wage worker is a good one, because those individuals won't feel obligated to be part of society in a way other generations have and that is a big risk - the social contract is breaking up, and that means a more unstable society is coming.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 22:05

Dancingwithhyenas · 19/08/2022 21:55

I’m a millennial who manages gen z staff. It’s definitely a wild, wild experience. They have a very different attitude to work. Perhaps it’s growing up watching us not get on the housing ladder (SE) and pay vast amounts in rent. As millennials we grew up thinking if we worked hard and went to uni, life would work out. So I very much see where their ideas and frustration comes from!

But from a management point of view, it’s let’s say…. challenging. We have more international staff than ever before, mostly due to work ethic.

I’ve posted on several threads about this, as we have just stopped recruiting interns and apprentices due to poor work ethic.

Dont know about you but I’m staggered by the level of entitlement, coupled with a total inability to accept constructive criticism - even if it’s ‘oh just so you know we say “Good morning, My Workplace Industries, Gen-Zedder speaking” rather than just “‘Ello?”’. They take it REALLY badly, even had a couple get up and leave with the first minor comment then the next day I’ve got an angry mum on the phone asking why I ‘screamed’ (it’s always screamed, I don’t scream) at her DD 🙄.

Also find that, despite being very clear about the role expected, they think they’re above making tea for meetings, setting up meeting rooms, doing basic tasks etc. I never do anything like get them to take dry cleaning out (like I had to when I was in their position) or book personal appontments but I do expect them to find a meeting room when I say I’ve arranged a meeting. The sheer fury of having to do a menial task, when they’ve been told they’re amazing because they have a degree, astounds me. Don’t get me started on the conversation policing in the office.

They aren’t willing to start at the bottom and work their way up. I don’t know why. I have my theories. But yes ‘challenging’ is absolutely the right word.

onlythreenow · 19/08/2022 22:05

Why should the young make more effort when their chances of ever owning a home or achieving real financial security are increasingly small, unless they’re lucky enough to have very rich parents. Even if they do, the future’s not looking particularly bright for western societies or global stability, not to mention climate change. Might as well coast along and enjoy life while they can.

So the current generation of young people are the only ones who have ever gone through tough times? Grow up! Incidentally, while I did own a home once a marriage breakdown has led me to being 63 and with no chance of ever owning property again - should I just adopt the same attitude and "coast along"? Owning your own home is not a right, and why should your employer suffer because you can't be bothered putting in any effort? Do you seriously believe that everyone bought a house several generations ago? My grandparents rented all their lives without this sense of entitlement that people seem to have these days.

Some of you would do well to study history and see just how tough some people had it.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 19/08/2022 22:05

50 somethings? I'm 50 something and when I bought my first house (after living with the in-laws for 18 months) interest rates shot up to 18%. Both of us worked full time and the best we could afford was a 2up 2down in a run down area. All our bits of furniture were either 2nd or 3rd hand and we didn't have a landline or washing machine for the first 2 years. This was in the 1990's.
I think youll find it was the 60+ (so called boomers)to who prospered.
we had a number of friends our age who bought a few years earlier who lost their homes when interest rates went up so high. It was an awful time.

sst1234 · 19/08/2022 22:01

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 20:58

I genuinely don’t think it’s worth bothering working unless you’re paid £100k per year in parts of the south east of England anymore.

If you earn that, then you may just be able to comfortably afford to fund

  • housing (500k round here for a half decent house, let’s say you have 100k deposit, then a 400k mortgage would cost around £2k p/m)

  • kids (always pricey)

  • pension /retirement (bung in 20% of salary into a defined contribution and you should have a decent fund)

to a reasonable level. because after saving for retirement, you’ll have around £4K p/m net on £100k. And already half of that is going on housing.

if not, you can only pick at best 2, and probably only one of those three things. Might as well be on benefits and get as much of your time back as possible - it’s the rational choice.

Not worth bothering with what?

If you don’t bother, how do you live? Pick some £50 notes from the magic money tree every morning?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 21:58

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 20:58

I genuinely don’t think it’s worth bothering working unless you’re paid £100k per year in parts of the south east of England anymore.

If you earn that, then you may just be able to comfortably afford to fund

  • housing (500k round here for a half decent house, let’s say you have 100k deposit, then a 400k mortgage would cost around £2k p/m)

  • kids (always pricey)

  • pension /retirement (bung in 20% of salary into a defined contribution and you should have a decent fund)

to a reasonable level. because after saving for retirement, you’ll have around £4K p/m net on £100k. And already half of that is going on housing.

if not, you can only pick at best 2, and probably only one of those three things. Might as well be on benefits and get as much of your time back as possible - it’s the rational choice.

Do you not think that it’s appropriate to work up to that £100k though, and have the slips to do the job well?Surely you don’t think every school leavers should just be able to walk into a £100k job even if they can barely spell their own name, and the only other option is not working?

TBH I’m disinclined to believe it when people say these conversations where several random strangers in public joined in with these insightful and articulate statements. Did everyone stand up and clap afterwards?

sst1234 · 19/08/2022 21:57

Every generation has had something to complain about.

Postwar youngsters could say they were left to pick up the pieces of previous generation’s war.

In the 60s, de industrialization began, boomers coming of age and entering a crowded jobs market, and youngsters found themselves again having to adjust to the market. Not to mention the threat of Cold War getting hot.

70s were particularly tough with massive inflation, crippled economy, everyone has heard the stories.

80s generation lived through it thinking were about to be nuked any minute.

In the 90s, they saw their parents losing their homes during the recession and were thinking that ozone depletion would mean the world would end in a few years.

The noughties brought the financial crisis, people losing their jobs and housing already expensive.

Those youngsters sat back now thinking it’s never been harder, will be wishing telling a different story in 20 years time.