Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young people - workshy, or a wee bit canny?

238 replies

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 20:35

Inspired by a spirited discussion in the Scottish highlands.

A local cafe owner (late forties) was bemoaning his staffing situation to another forty something man, who was buying a coffee with his daughter. I was waiting for mine.

”I’m understaffed - can’t get the workers. I’m paying them 20% above minimum wage but the 18-30 generation don’t want to work - they’d rather sell drugs or be on benefits’.

The chap he was talking to said :

‘oh really - yeah it’s terrible that, they just don’t have the ethic’.

At this point I (another forty something) interjected, and said :

“Well, can we really blame them? Vast swathes of them have been disenfranchised through the cost of housing. They don’t see a path to a stake in society any more”

He said “Utter bollocks - I worked hard and they don’t want to”. The other guy agreed.

Then another guy (again forty something 😂) started agreeing with me, saying he sees it in the corporate world that it’s the sorted 50 somethings who bought cheap houses who are the workshy ones cruising along.

I agreed - imho, no point in working unless you get £100k. Only then can you hope to match the lifestyle of a retail worker from the past”

All the while a young person was waiting for her coffee looked very non pleased and the cafe owner apologised saying “not all young people obviously”

AIBU to think the young are right to “lie flat” and not bother if things don’t change?

OP posts:
Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:27

If you can't hear how massively out of touch you must have sounded, telling people living in the Highlands that £100k was a crap salary, the bare minimum that a young person should earn to have a good life, I have no words!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 23:26

Also when we are facing yet another energy cap rise which means MORE people (and countless children) will be plunged into poverty, I really can’t be on with people moaning that a £100k salary isn’t enough.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 23:24

£10 for a sandwich and a coffee is extremely reasonable!

That covers not only the food, staff wages but also the heating, maintenance, facilities, , water and lighting

TBH OP I’m not sure what kind of country you’re expecting the UK to be when £10 for a sandwich and coffee is considered a ‘Rob’ but entry level jobs should be £100k. That’s not a sustainable model!

silentpool · 19/08/2022 23:23

I'm not young but it's futile having loyalty to a company. If you drop dead at your desk, they will just replace you. I work my hours and leave on time. If I didn't, they would keep chipping away at my work-life balance.

The more you give, the more they expect and for what reward? Wages haven't kept up with the cost of living and bonuses don't seem to trickle down to the masses.

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 23:21

Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:18

I don't care what the prices were. Talking about 100k salaries as being the bare minimum in the Highlands is massively ignorant.

Well, I think it is and was absolutely relevant.

like I said - it’s not just housing - you have to consider pensions, kids, and a relatively decent standard of living.

Again, to repeat myself - £100k is £66k after tax. It’s shit money.

the fucking cafe owner was charging £10 for a very, very crap sandwich and a small coffee. That’s the equivalent of £15 gross income.

Fucking right I need to be earning £100k gross not to feel robbed at those prices.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 23:20

Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:17

For example, my son had a very tough job in a restaurant kitchen this summer, he chucked it in as soon as he'd saved enough for something he wanted to do, no worries about letting the boss down or building his savings up for a rainy day...

Your son obviously had no notice period written into his contract.

How much notice do you think he'd have got from his boss if they'd needed to let him go? Zilch. Nada. Why the fuck should employees give more consideration to their employers than their employers give them?

Well it depends what you’re letting them go for.

Redundancy has very particular criteria.

Hiwever is they’re letting someone go because, for example, they stole or sexually harassed a colleague then why should the employer let them hang around? That’s a case of employees not giving much consideration to their workplace.

I mean IME if you work hard and keep your nose clean and put the effort in, your work will give back in the same way to you. Or at least decent workplaces will.

Loopyloopy · 19/08/2022 23:19

Also, I think that "hard working" is kind of over emphasised as a virtue.

Self sacrifice made sense back when you worked hard for the company, and it looked after you. I personally won't sacrifice myself for a company that will replace me without a second thought tomorrow.

We're not meant to do nothing but work. That's a product of the industrial revolution. Biologically, we are meant to lots of time resting and playing.

Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:18

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 23:16

Not really. I checked the house prices for the town I was in. They weren’t exactly cheap.

I would say someone on £12 p/h in the highlands still has about as much chance of feeling disenfranchised as someone in the south east of England.

A little less fucked is still fucked.

the only difference is the scenery was dramatically better.

I don't care what the prices were. Talking about 100k salaries as being the bare minimum in the Highlands is massively ignorant.

Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:17

For example, my son had a very tough job in a restaurant kitchen this summer, he chucked it in as soon as he'd saved enough for something he wanted to do, no worries about letting the boss down or building his savings up for a rainy day...

Your son obviously had no notice period written into his contract.

How much notice do you think he'd have got from his boss if they'd needed to let him go? Zilch. Nada. Why the fuck should employees give more consideration to their employers than their employers give them?

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 23:16

Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:13

Why on earth were you using SE England salaries/house prices etc. in a discussion about young people working in the Highlands? You must have sounded extremely out of touch, in your SE England bubble.

Not really. I checked the house prices for the town I was in. They weren’t exactly cheap.

I would say someone on £12 p/h in the highlands still has about as much chance of feeling disenfranchised as someone in the south east of England.

A little less fucked is still fucked.

the only difference is the scenery was dramatically better.

OP posts:
Titsywoo · 19/08/2022 23:15

godmum56 · 19/08/2022 20:51

I think you were all generalising like crazy

Agreed. Both my 15 and 17 year olds have worked 3 full days a week over the summer holidays to earn money and get extra experience. Not lazy at all. In fact none of the young people I know are. Know some very lazy adults though.

Crikeyalmighty · 19/08/2022 23:15

@Wbeezer Totally. I think a lot of them are lacking in attention to detail too and as you say are just working to save money to have time off or travelling. I also think lots think they will be ok with a bit of freelancing. Yep all well and good till your client doesn't pay you for 5 months or goes bust-- I think a lot of them need to wise up about creative industries and actually build up before slacking off! And I don't agree with the person saying who wants to put maximum effort in for minimum reward- sorry but in certain industries that's how you actually get on !!!

Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:13

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 22:59

I was on holiday there.

I have a job back home that pays more than that, but the point is I absolutely empathise with people earning much less, and understand absolutely any reluctance or hopelessness they feel.

Why on earth were you using SE England salaries/house prices etc. in a discussion about young people working in the Highlands? You must have sounded extremely out of touch, in your SE England bubble.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 23:12

hamsterchump · 19/08/2022 22:49

Unpaid internships I presume? Sorry no one wants to be your slave any more.

No, paid temporary internships with a view to getting postgraduates into the workplace. Apprentices tend to go to those aged 16-20 who maybe did sixth form (and IMO were harder workers than those older than them)

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 23:08

Kendodd · 19/08/2022 22:21

Do you think that if you've had several young new starters just walk out it might be you who's the problem, not them?

It’s them.

I don’t have this problem when we recruit normally, at all.

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 23:04

SunnyKlara · 19/08/2022 23:01

This experience us always rolled out on threads like this. And I'm sure it was hard.

But many of those just starting out in UK cities today are living in shared houses with rent so high they will never be able to save enough for a mortgage. Or if they can live with parents, they will be there a lot longer than the 18months you were in order to save the the 10s of thousands of pounds for a deposit required for a ftb flat (not the two up two down you could afford). And because the centralisation that has been going on for decades in UK companies, fewer and fewer people have a large employer in their locale that can provide job stability and career development, so fewer young people are able to get on their feet whilst living with parents and have to go where the work is.

And yes it is objectively harder for young people these days. In the mid 1990s the average house was 4'' average earnings. In 2020, it hit 8x average earnings. First time buyers take an average of 8 years to save for their first home. In London it is 11 years.

Also the second hand furniture virtue signalling also pisses me off. You didn't have ikea. Ikea is this generation's version of second hand (from a cost pov). In a rental market, you need furniture that is cheap, easy to build and turn back in to flat pack, and lightweight to transport when you move between rentals. My gran's 1930s dresser would not be suitable.

And, also, so what if it was hard for you back then? Surely we should be trying to make things better for our children's generation, not shrugging and saying "we had to suffer, so you should too". That is a very sad state of affairs.

And that's just housing. Before you even think about kids, pensions (need to save £300,000 pot for a 30k pension, whilst paying for student loans, kids and a massive mortgage), inflation... No wonder there is no optimism!

Agree with everything you say but in the recent past with annuity rates crushed, it was more like £1m in the pension pot for a 30k index linked pension with spousal cover.

£300k would buy you about £15k non indexed at best.

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 23:02

Dotcheck · 19/08/2022 22:59

One of my oldest’s former classmates makes a very decent living selling photos and videos on Only Fans. She makes much more money doing this than working in the profession she spent five years training to do, and earns as much in an hour as a cafe worker would in a day. I appreciate this is probably exceptional

Bloody Only Fans
That’s a whole other level of depressing

There’s nothing wrong with it.

She’s probably milking sub money from dirty old men who were gifted cheap housing. They are the only ones with disposable income.

Think of it as a rightful transfer of generational wealth from the undeserving to the entrepreneurial.

OP posts:
SunnyKlara · 19/08/2022 23:01

Sugarplumfairy65 · 19/08/2022 22:05

50 somethings? I'm 50 something and when I bought my first house (after living with the in-laws for 18 months) interest rates shot up to 18%. Both of us worked full time and the best we could afford was a 2up 2down in a run down area. All our bits of furniture were either 2nd or 3rd hand and we didn't have a landline or washing machine for the first 2 years. This was in the 1990's.
I think youll find it was the 60+ (so called boomers)to who prospered.
we had a number of friends our age who bought a few years earlier who lost their homes when interest rates went up so high. It was an awful time.

This experience us always rolled out on threads like this. And I'm sure it was hard.

But many of those just starting out in UK cities today are living in shared houses with rent so high they will never be able to save enough for a mortgage. Or if they can live with parents, they will be there a lot longer than the 18months you were in order to save the the 10s of thousands of pounds for a deposit required for a ftb flat (not the two up two down you could afford). And because the centralisation that has been going on for decades in UK companies, fewer and fewer people have a large employer in their locale that can provide job stability and career development, so fewer young people are able to get on their feet whilst living with parents and have to go where the work is.

And yes it is objectively harder for young people these days. In the mid 1990s the average house was 4'' average earnings. In 2020, it hit 8x average earnings. First time buyers take an average of 8 years to save for their first home. In London it is 11 years.

Also the second hand furniture virtue signalling also pisses me off. You didn't have ikea. Ikea is this generation's version of second hand (from a cost pov). In a rental market, you need furniture that is cheap, easy to build and turn back in to flat pack, and lightweight to transport when you move between rentals. My gran's 1930s dresser would not be suitable.

And, also, so what if it was hard for you back then? Surely we should be trying to make things better for our children's generation, not shrugging and saying "we had to suffer, so you should too". That is a very sad state of affairs.

And that's just housing. Before you even think about kids, pensions (need to save £300,000 pot for a 30k pension, whilst paying for student loans, kids and a massive mortgage), inflation... No wonder there is no optimism!

Dotcheck · 19/08/2022 22:59

One of my oldest’s former classmates makes a very decent living selling photos and videos on Only Fans. She makes much more money doing this than working in the profession she spent five years training to do, and earns as much in an hour as a cafe worker would in a day. I appreciate this is probably exceptional

Bloody Only Fans
That’s a whole other level of depressing

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 22:59

MichelleScarn · 19/08/2022 22:38

What do you do in the Highlands for over £100k or is that the job you're waiting for?

I was on holiday there.

I have a job back home that pays more than that, but the point is I absolutely empathise with people earning much less, and understand absolutely any reluctance or hopelessness they feel.

OP posts:
hamsterchump · 19/08/2022 22:59

Wbeezer · 19/08/2022 22:45

İ do think young people have a more transactional attitude to most things, ie. Anything they agree to do has to have something in it for them, if it doesn't they stop doing it (or refuse to start). They don't tend to do things out of duty or tradition or guilt even in the same way older people did.
For example, my son had a very tough job in a restaurant kitchen this summer, he chucked it in as soon as he'd saved enough for something he wanted to do, no worries about letting the boss down or building his savings up for a rainy day...
Lots of things don't seem worth the effort to them now and if they do make a real effort they are very cross if it doesn't result in something immediately quantifiable.
I've noticed it in my kids and in the young employees in the creative sector.
Maybe it's too much praise, or too many reward charts, or help with hard things. Not enough resilience.
Its obviously not universal but I think it's a general tendency.

Good, why would you want your son to be a foolish jobsworth? No one should worry about letting their boss down when almost all bosses wouldn't spare a single thought for them, especially someone bottom of the pile in the notoriously overworked and undervalued sector of hospitality. You pay minimum wage you should expect minimum effort.

Wbeezer · 19/08/2022 22:52

@Crikeyalmighty my experience of young people in the creative industries sounds similar to you and interestingly I was talking to a friend who is a chief exec in the NHS, they have a major problem with staff retention as young staff leave to work for agencies as they like to pick and choose shifts.
My oldest DS won't move out as he doesn't want to spend all his money on rent!

hamsterchump · 19/08/2022 22:49

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 22:05

I’ve posted on several threads about this, as we have just stopped recruiting interns and apprentices due to poor work ethic.

Dont know about you but I’m staggered by the level of entitlement, coupled with a total inability to accept constructive criticism - even if it’s ‘oh just so you know we say “Good morning, My Workplace Industries, Gen-Zedder speaking” rather than just “‘Ello?”’. They take it REALLY badly, even had a couple get up and leave with the first minor comment then the next day I’ve got an angry mum on the phone asking why I ‘screamed’ (it’s always screamed, I don’t scream) at her DD 🙄.

Also find that, despite being very clear about the role expected, they think they’re above making tea for meetings, setting up meeting rooms, doing basic tasks etc. I never do anything like get them to take dry cleaning out (like I had to when I was in their position) or book personal appontments but I do expect them to find a meeting room when I say I’ve arranged a meeting. The sheer fury of having to do a menial task, when they’ve been told they’re amazing because they have a degree, astounds me. Don’t get me started on the conversation policing in the office.

They aren’t willing to start at the bottom and work their way up. I don’t know why. I have my theories. But yes ‘challenging’ is absolutely the right word.

Unpaid internships I presume? Sorry no one wants to be your slave any more.

mondaytosunday · 19/08/2022 22:49

My son is 19. All his friends, classmates whatever, have been working since 16 every summer. My son got a part time job at 16 while at college, was made redundant during first lockdown, then got another job a week after shops reopened. Even his dope smoking friends all have jobs. Those about to go back to uni had jobs all summer. Those who took a gap year worked and worked and then self funded a bit of travelling.
It's bull that young people don't want to work. But a lot of casual service staff were from Europe and Brexit made many return home, which may explain some of the shortage.

Wbeezer · 19/08/2022 22:45

İ do think young people have a more transactional attitude to most things, ie. Anything they agree to do has to have something in it for them, if it doesn't they stop doing it (or refuse to start). They don't tend to do things out of duty or tradition or guilt even in the same way older people did.
For example, my son had a very tough job in a restaurant kitchen this summer, he chucked it in as soon as he'd saved enough for something he wanted to do, no worries about letting the boss down or building his savings up for a rainy day...
Lots of things don't seem worth the effort to them now and if they do make a real effort they are very cross if it doesn't result in something immediately quantifiable.
I've noticed it in my kids and in the young employees in the creative sector.
Maybe it's too much praise, or too many reward charts, or help with hard things. Not enough resilience.
Its obviously not universal but I think it's a general tendency.