Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young people - workshy, or a wee bit canny?

238 replies

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 20:35

Inspired by a spirited discussion in the Scottish highlands.

A local cafe owner (late forties) was bemoaning his staffing situation to another forty something man, who was buying a coffee with his daughter. I was waiting for mine.

”I’m understaffed - can’t get the workers. I’m paying them 20% above minimum wage but the 18-30 generation don’t want to work - they’d rather sell drugs or be on benefits’.

The chap he was talking to said :

‘oh really - yeah it’s terrible that, they just don’t have the ethic’.

At this point I (another forty something) interjected, and said :

“Well, can we really blame them? Vast swathes of them have been disenfranchised through the cost of housing. They don’t see a path to a stake in society any more”

He said “Utter bollocks - I worked hard and they don’t want to”. The other guy agreed.

Then another guy (again forty something 😂) started agreeing with me, saying he sees it in the corporate world that it’s the sorted 50 somethings who bought cheap houses who are the workshy ones cruising along.

I agreed - imho, no point in working unless you get £100k. Only then can you hope to match the lifestyle of a retail worker from the past”

All the while a young person was waiting for her coffee looked very non pleased and the cafe owner apologised saying “not all young people obviously”

AIBU to think the young are right to “lie flat” and not bother if things don’t change?

OP posts:
Simonjt · 20/08/2022 07:13

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 20:58

I genuinely don’t think it’s worth bothering working unless you’re paid £100k per year in parts of the south east of England anymore.

If you earn that, then you may just be able to comfortably afford to fund

  • housing (500k round here for a half decent house, let’s say you have 100k deposit, then a 400k mortgage would cost around £2k p/m)

  • kids (always pricey)

  • pension /retirement (bung in 20% of salary into a defined contribution and you should have a decent fund)

to a reasonable level. because after saving for retirement, you’ll have around £4K p/m net on £100k. And already half of that is going on housing.

if not, you can only pick at best 2, and probably only one of those three things. Might as well be on benefits and get as much of your time back as possible - it’s the rational choice.

I’ve never earned that much, I live in zone 1, I’m a parent, I own a property, I’ll have a good pension when needed. Until very recently my income was our only income, I had a new car, I had holidays abroad.

SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 07:12

Lilypickles1 · 20/08/2022 07:09

@MintJulia

I would also argue, this isn’t a problem of THIS generation, but the previous generation…. Where was the parenting ?! Yes some common sense and initiative wouldn’t go amiss but actually a parent could help guide their children through this.

You’re right.

I’m guiding one of the kids towards a career where it pays £250k+. They are totally capable of getting on the path and milking the corporate teat.

the others who probably won’t get there because they aren’t as interested or scientifically minded I’ll be guiding towards benefits or enjoying pursuing the arts if things don’t change.

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 07:10

The only consensus we all had - cafe owner, supportive of him gent, me and the other bloke was that the states meddling has got us into this situation through making work not pay.

OP posts:
Lilypickles1 · 20/08/2022 07:09

@MintJulia

I would also argue, this isn’t a problem of THIS generation, but the previous generation…. Where was the parenting ?! Yes some common sense and initiative wouldn’t go amiss but actually a parent could help guide their children through this.

Londonnight · 20/08/2022 07:05

My 21 yr old works really hard. He has had part time jobs since he was 16. He works full time now, then more hours if they are short staffed. He is also doing a full time uni course.

I work on an NHS ward, we have a 19 yr old who comes in for bank shifts alongside her full time job.
I hate the generalisation of young people that they are work shy and don't pull their weight.

SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 07:05

Heatherjayne1972 · 20/08/2022 07:00

I wonder if the cafe owner in the original op had factored in that his employees put up with a lot of crap from customers

tbh you couldn’t pay me enough to work in retail or hospitality
I certainly wouldn’t do it for nmw

To be fair to him he was insisting that he was upping wages beyond inflation just to try and get people - he was paying more than minimum wage. But he still said that wasn’t enough. And it probably isn’t

I think he should be looking squarely at Global monetary policy and govenments of all tie colours fiscal policies over the last 40 years for the answer to why we’ve come to this point, not blaming young people.

OP posts:
Lilypickles1 · 20/08/2022 07:04

I think it just seems like they aren’t ‘working as hard’ as their money isn’t working as well for them… my parents bought their home earning approx £50k, 20 odd years ago. To buy that house now you’d need to be earning atleast 200k, I can promise you now the same jobs do not pay ANYWHERE near that. It’s sad.

Heatherjayne1972 · 20/08/2022 07:00

I wonder if the cafe owner in the original op had factored in that his employees put up with a lot of crap from customers

tbh you couldn’t pay me enough to work in retail or hospitality
I certainly wouldn’t do it for nmw

Mintchervilpurslane · 20/08/2022 06:59

But many of those just starting out in UK cities today are living in shared houses with rent so high they will never be able to save enough for a mortgage

I lived in shared accommodation in London for a decade from 1985 to 1995 working in a creative industry. There was never any way I was going to afford a house of my own even back then. We even endured the poll tax briefly! When I eventually got married we could just about afford a mortgage jointly on a small two bedroom flat outside of London, above a noisy garage. It was only after eight years of living very frugally in the flat that we could eventually afford a house in our late thirties/early forties and felt secure enough to have DC. And that is still our house now two decades on.

So yes, we were privileged to be able to get on the housing ladder eventually but it wasn't as easy as some people like to make out. I do very much feel for young people today, particularly with the environmental issues that we are facing, but many of the young people of my acquaintance are choosing to skip the decade living in shared accommodation to live with their parents instead, presumably bc that allows them to save too. I wasn't able to work and live with parents BC they lived very rurally where there were literally no jobs except those related to agriculture. And while I was renting a shared room in London there was no way I could save money, I only just scraped by from pay cheque to pay cheque.

Charlize43 · 20/08/2022 06:53

I feel really sorry for the young. As well as the poor economic future, they have global warming / environmental change to worry about.

Also IMO, the disparity between the rich & poor seems to be getting greater and greater.

SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 06:50

KweenieBeanz · 20/08/2022 06:46

I've said it before and I'll say it again. The salary you offered was not high enough.
28k + benefits was a London graduate starting salary 16 years ago?
Why would you only be offering 30k now? You got poor quality candidates because the salary is poor. Are you offering 10% more than you were offering for the same post last year? If not, why not, when cost of living has increased by 10%?

Completely concur. My first job - not in London - as a grad was 24k twenty two years ago.

I graduated without any significant debt, and housing whilst getting expensive compared to three years previously, was still obtainable for reasonable salary multiples.

If I was a grad now, I’d want at least 40k, with a plan of action to get to £100k within 4-5 years.

Otherwise, no uni, min hours and benefits it is 👍

OP posts:
KweenieBeanz · 20/08/2022 06:46

MintJulia · 20/08/2022 06:05

I've recently recruited for a junior post, (London, 30k + benefits) would suit a new grad or possibly a 2nd jobber. I had a shortlist of 12, all marketing graduates, initial interviews by video call.

Eleven were hopeless. There's no other word for them. One couldn't tell me what her degree had been about, at all. One told me he really wanted to do something else and as soon as an opportunity came up, he'd be off. One interviewed in pink pjs with hearts on and hadn't even brushed her hair.. Another introduced me to her cats and said she liked staying at home and cooking. Most of them hadn't looked at our web site, done basic prep or prepared any questions. These were business graduates not 16yos. One boy was enthusiastic but not right for the post and we subsequently hired him for something else. In the end I hired a 2nd jobber we got chatting to in a pub.

My impression was that they want to work, but have no idea what is expected. I suspect lockdown has hit a lot of students who don't have business people for parents. There seemed to be so much basic work they hadn't done.

I've said it before and I'll say it again. The salary you offered was not high enough.
28k + benefits was a London graduate starting salary 16 years ago?
Why would you only be offering 30k now? You got poor quality candidates because the salary is poor. Are you offering 10% more than you were offering for the same post last year? If not, why not, when cost of living has increased by 10%?

SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 06:31

Badgirlriri · 19/08/2022 23:51

Didn’t Happen of The Year Awards

It happened! 😂

We all enjoyed it too. I have proof it happened as well. I sent my partner to go and wind up the cafe owner more and she recorded it.

He had toned down a bit the second time.

OP posts:
Caspianberg · 20/08/2022 06:06

It’s definitely much harder now to leave home and start work and living independently. A starter salary is a struggle to pay rent and bills in many areas.

Young people will and do stay home much longer. But this isn’t always possible. So those earning £2k a month but alone v someone supported by family will really struggle in comparison.

But I think the mentality of commuting hours, working long late days, lots of overtime is now shifting. Younger People now say 9-6pm in office is fine, but no way are they going to do hours every evening overtime for free, and this should be correct. It should be life has a work and family balance, not just work work until you retire or die.

MintJulia · 20/08/2022 06:05

I've recently recruited for a junior post, (London, 30k + benefits) would suit a new grad or possibly a 2nd jobber. I had a shortlist of 12, all marketing graduates, initial interviews by video call.

Eleven were hopeless. There's no other word for them. One couldn't tell me what her degree had been about, at all. One told me he really wanted to do something else and as soon as an opportunity came up, he'd be off. One interviewed in pink pjs with hearts on and hadn't even brushed her hair.. Another introduced me to her cats and said she liked staying at home and cooking. Most of them hadn't looked at our web site, done basic prep or prepared any questions. These were business graduates not 16yos. One boy was enthusiastic but not right for the post and we subsequently hired him for something else. In the end I hired a 2nd jobber we got chatting to in a pub.

My impression was that they want to work, but have no idea what is expected. I suspect lockdown has hit a lot of students who don't have business people for parents. There seemed to be so much basic work they hadn't done.

KweenieBeanz · 20/08/2022 05:53

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 21:58

Do you not think that it’s appropriate to work up to that £100k though, and have the slips to do the job well?Surely you don’t think every school leavers should just be able to walk into a £100k job even if they can barely spell their own name, and the only other option is not working?

TBH I’m disinclined to believe it when people say these conversations where several random strangers in public joined in with these insightful and articulate statements. Did everyone stand up and clap afterwards?

You have no idea what it's like now. It's bl00dy hard to 'work your way up' the salaries are crap and employers just will not pay decent wages. I've been 'working my way up' for 15 years, despite a good degree from one of the top unis and a lot of hard work in 15 years I've managed to get from 18k, to 34k. Sorry but that's crap.
I get excellent performance reviews, do typically 3-4 years in a job before looking for a promotion, but in that 15 years the highest cost of living raise I've ever had was 1.7%. inflation has been MUCH higher every year, so the real value of my wage has been slashed. My 34k SHOULD be around 50k, or even higher. And employers wonder why they are struggling to recruit?!?? Oh and in that same time, my once good pension terms have been altered to give me a far poorer pension, while the contributions I'm expected to make have over time, doubled in percentage. Fabulous! Hard work is doing wonders for me!!!

Riverlee · 20/08/2022 05:26

Most of the young people I know have jobs.

KickAssAngel · 20/08/2022 03:52

Upthread someone said that many people have to spend 30-40% of their after tax pay on housing, as if that is astronomically high. Isn't that the norm? I always thought that the goal was 1/3 each for housing, bills and spending, and if you have any left over that covers savings.

I do think that a lot of us have normalized quite a high standard of living and expect to have the money for a phone, new clothes, nights out etc. My first mortgage was a bargain at a fixed rate of 15% interest. The deposit was tiny compared to today's but the monthly payments were over 50% of our take home pay. We lived an incredibly frugal lifestyle as a result.

Some young people are getting into the property ladder, otherwise we'd see a collapse of house prices. If all young people are unable to buy property then the market will adjust.

onlythreenow · 20/08/2022 03:14

Self sacrifice made sense back when you worked hard for the company, and it looked after you. I personally won't sacrifice myself for a company that will replace me without a second thought tomorrow.

But no-one is talking about "self sacrifice". Any company will replace their staff without a second thought btw - do you seriously think that at any time in history employers have been devastated when their staff leave? It also works the other way - how many seriously give much consideration to their employer when they leave for another job? However, that is not what is being discussed here. There are lots of brilliant young people starting out in the workforce, but there are a certain number who think they can start at the top, avoid doing anything they don't want to do, think some tasks are beneath them etc. In other words, they seem to think they shouldn't have to do what their employer is PAYING them to do, and the concept of starting at the bottom and learning your way up is foreign to them.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/08/2022 01:24

My comment was to the person who said we had v difficult times in the past also

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/08/2022 01:21

But, even through those difficult times, people could afford to buy a house on an average or even low wage. They could afford to have children. They could afford to look after those children themselves for the most part if they wanted to and didn’t feel forced back to work FT when their baby was only 6 months old.

yes, people had to make cutbacks on day to day living for some periods of time, but they had a decent roof over their head and had their family unit.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 20/08/2022 01:00

I can see why young people don't want to work for him if he holds them in such contempt 🤷‍♀️

Badgirlriri · 19/08/2022 23:51

Didn’t Happen of The Year Awards

Scrapologist · 19/08/2022 23:50

Few are overjoyed to go in to work every day. It's common to feel you're not fairly compensated and to be somewhat dissatisfied with your lot in life, but what's the alternative? You still have to support yourself (or you should), even if you know you'll never be able to afford everything you'd like. If you won't even try to win success for yourself by doing more than the bare minimum, you shouldn't expect sympathy from anyone else, regardless of your generation, your upbringing, the housing market, etc.

Octomore · 19/08/2022 23:28

A person on £100k today can afford a better lifestyle than a retail worker in the 90s. That's a fact and I'm flabbergasted that you think otherwise.