Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young people - workshy, or a wee bit canny?

238 replies

SwanBuster · 19/08/2022 20:35

Inspired by a spirited discussion in the Scottish highlands.

A local cafe owner (late forties) was bemoaning his staffing situation to another forty something man, who was buying a coffee with his daughter. I was waiting for mine.

”I’m understaffed - can’t get the workers. I’m paying them 20% above minimum wage but the 18-30 generation don’t want to work - they’d rather sell drugs or be on benefits’.

The chap he was talking to said :

‘oh really - yeah it’s terrible that, they just don’t have the ethic’.

At this point I (another forty something) interjected, and said :

“Well, can we really blame them? Vast swathes of them have been disenfranchised through the cost of housing. They don’t see a path to a stake in society any more”

He said “Utter bollocks - I worked hard and they don’t want to”. The other guy agreed.

Then another guy (again forty something 😂) started agreeing with me, saying he sees it in the corporate world that it’s the sorted 50 somethings who bought cheap houses who are the workshy ones cruising along.

I agreed - imho, no point in working unless you get £100k. Only then can you hope to match the lifestyle of a retail worker from the past”

All the while a young person was waiting for her coffee looked very non pleased and the cafe owner apologised saying “not all young people obviously”

AIBU to think the young are right to “lie flat” and not bother if things don’t change?

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 08:49

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/08/2022 08:22

I don’t believe it happened that way either, I think you just wanted to present your opinion in a fancy way.

But in the unlikely event it is true, and what you’ve said about your partner is true, then I’m going to ask you - what is wrong with you both?! You said your OH to film a woman at work without her consent, and, by your admission, ‘wound her up’.

Hope she told your partner to fuck up. It would be insanely condescending to English-plain to a business owner in the Scottish Highlands who clearly has more nouse in her little finger than you do in your whole body, and tell her she should be paying her staff £100k whilst moaning about a perfectly reasonable sandwich.

I call BS. Big time

I’m a bloke. The cafe owner was a bloke. The two other people in the initial conversation were blokes.

My partner is female and she did a sterling job of going up there and winding him up.

She played the part of someone who also ‘despairs of the workshy youth’ - it didn’t take much more than a comment of ‘what’s wrong with young people today’ to send him off on another rant about them and again he ended up needing to apologise to another poor teenager waiting for a coffee 😂😂😂

This is the sort of thing I enjoy doing - who gives a shit?! It’s fun!

OP posts:
Dotcheck · 20/08/2022 08:48

OP,
you’ll guide your child towards benefits? How about Only Fans, if you think it’s so marvellous. I mean, why shouldn’t the bright youth of today ignore their brain when they can focus on their tits and ass?
And you don’t find that depressing?

SaintHelena · 20/08/2022 08:43

Owning a house - I worked for the nhs in the early 70s qualified and full time - own a house hahahahahahah. Didn't cross my mind. Couldn't afford a holiday away, just about ran a car. And that was in rural Scotland.
I do accept that house prices are ridiculous now and rents through the roof but the constant complaining .......... we are due a readjustment - perhaps it will happen soon.

SaintHelena · 20/08/2022 08:35

There seems to be no clear action on drug dealing / taking.
It feels as if eveyone is resigned to doing nothing about it. Wish they'd come up with a policy to try to fix it.
Our local paper (in Scotland) has the usual court cases of drunkenness, fights, threats, drink driving - nothing on drugs, unless they are tried elsewhere.

CherryGenoa · 20/08/2022 08:30

Hmm, well wages haven’t kept up with the cost of housing that’s for sure.

Wages vs house prices

SaintHelena · 20/08/2022 08:29

J0y · 19/08/2022 22:17

I work hard btw (gen x) but i have a copy of Tom Hodgkinson's ''How to be Idle'' on my shelf. Excellent book. Really made me think. Although he's not suggesting doing nothing and signing on, but he's not recommending becoming a wage ''slave'' either. I am still a wage slave but I took something from the book. ie not to outsource my entertainment to netflix. I still do that actually but I'm aware I'm doing it and I have artistic projects on the go.

What about outsourcing your entertainment to MN😂

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/08/2022 08:23

KweenieBeanz · 20/08/2022 06:46

I've said it before and I'll say it again. The salary you offered was not high enough.
28k + benefits was a London graduate starting salary 16 years ago?
Why would you only be offering 30k now? You got poor quality candidates because the salary is poor. Are you offering 10% more than you were offering for the same post last year? If not, why not, when cost of living has increased by 10%?

I think you’d be hard pressed to find anywhere that offered a 10% pay rise this year. It is how it should work but it doesn’t sadly

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/08/2022 08:22

SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 06:31

It happened! 😂

We all enjoyed it too. I have proof it happened as well. I sent my partner to go and wind up the cafe owner more and she recorded it.

He had toned down a bit the second time.

I don’t believe it happened that way either, I think you just wanted to present your opinion in a fancy way.

But in the unlikely event it is true, and what you’ve said about your partner is true, then I’m going to ask you - what is wrong with you both?! You said your OH to film a woman at work without her consent, and, by your admission, ‘wound her up’.

Hope she told your partner to fuck up. It would be insanely condescending to English-plain to a business owner in the Scottish Highlands who clearly has more nouse in her little finger than you do in your whole body, and tell her she should be paying her staff £100k whilst moaning about a perfectly reasonable sandwich.

I call BS. Big time

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/08/2022 08:17

KweenieBeanz · 20/08/2022 05:53

You have no idea what it's like now. It's bl00dy hard to 'work your way up' the salaries are crap and employers just will not pay decent wages. I've been 'working my way up' for 15 years, despite a good degree from one of the top unis and a lot of hard work in 15 years I've managed to get from 18k, to 34k. Sorry but that's crap.
I get excellent performance reviews, do typically 3-4 years in a job before looking for a promotion, but in that 15 years the highest cost of living raise I've ever had was 1.7%. inflation has been MUCH higher every year, so the real value of my wage has been slashed. My 34k SHOULD be around 50k, or even higher. And employers wonder why they are struggling to recruit?!?? Oh and in that same time, my once good pension terms have been altered to give me a far poorer pension, while the contributions I'm expected to make have over time, doubled in percentage. Fabulous! Hard work is doing wonders for me!!!

Well that’s your experience and I’m a few years older than you it that’s not my experience at all, nor of anyone I know. Obviously it depends on the industry you work in but £34k by your mid-30’s is pretty normal for a career path.

id be earning more had I not had children - I know it’s controversial to say this but that was my choice and I was aware that as a result I missed out on opportunities as when they were tiny. I wanted to work PT and leave on time every day with no worries or stress - the opportunities I missed out on would have made that very hard.

garlictwist · 20/08/2022 08:09

mindutopia · 19/08/2022 22:33

I work with young adults (university aged) and the ones I see definitely aren’t workshy (obviously these are the ones going to uni). But no different to my generation, it’s tough to work and be in full time education.

Dh has several employees in his business ranging from 17 to about 60. It’s the ones over 30 who moan the most and call in sick for banging a toe on something. The ones who are 17-25 are keen and hardworking and take direction and want to learn, etc.

My DH reports the opposite. He runs a business and has a wide range of ages. He says the under 25s are the ones he struggles with the most - they are emotional, lack resilience and are very unreliable and struggle with taking instructions.

And he is 33 so not exactly ancient!

BogRollBOGOF · 20/08/2022 07:55

I'm wondering if staff shortages might bring back a return of "the Saturday Job" which disappeared around the Millenium, I think due to concerns about CRB/ DBS checks for employing u18s and the introduction of minimum wage.

When I did work experience in 1996, many of my classmates retained "Saturday jobs" from their placement or at least got a foot hold in. We were 15/16. Those opportunuties are much harder to come by, but are good for developing young people's skills and work ethic and are good for filling less desirable peak time hours that adults don't want.

There is a generational culture where many parents expect little of their children, plus increased educational pressure. But not all students get high grades, and waft into top universities then into high paying occupations, and society sets many young people up for a fall. I don't think that they're lazy, just not well set up to transition into functioning adults.

Apparently "why bother" is a growing attitude in young people around the world, especially where they've been shafted heavily by lockdown/ restrictions for prolonged periods. It's a growing issue in China. Why bother with hot-house schooling when you'll just get locked into your home for months regardless.

Anewdayanewdawn · 20/08/2022 07:50

It’s true there is a whole load of young people who don’t want to work for lower wages, not while they have bank of mum and dad or can still live at home anyway.
But where are they going to start? Hey aren’t going to walk into a job paying £40k without any work experience whatsoever are they?
I recruit, and I will hire the person with work experience - including summers at McDonalds or waiting tables - over the guy who didn’t have to…

fyn · 20/08/2022 07:49

I am in the 18-30 to generation and don’t at all recognise description to be honest in anybody I know. We all had Saturday jobs, I worked in a shop and did a daily paper round, worked through uni (and was the first year paying £9k) lambing in the spring and doing milking/waitressing in term time.

Every single one of my friends had a decent grad job well before we graduated. Maybe if the shop owner wants decent employees he should pay more than £10 an hour! When I was pregnant and 26 we had to move across the country, I temped as a PA for £25 an hour where I did the odd bit of admin, organised the ladies online returns and walked the dogs. Now I have children I have a job that lets me work from home, pick my hours and take my children to work for £15 an hour. Why would I be running myself ragged for £10 an hour in a cafe?

TheWillow · 20/08/2022 07:45

SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 07:12

You’re right.

I’m guiding one of the kids towards a career where it pays £250k+. They are totally capable of getting on the path and milking the corporate teat.

the others who probably won’t get there because they aren’t as interested or scientifically minded I’ll be guiding towards benefits or enjoying pursuing the arts if things don’t change.

What's the job?

Sally090807 · 20/08/2022 07:36

When I left school and was working my goal was to save for a house deposit. The bank loan for a mortgage was three times your single annual wage or double your joint wage. If the same applied today and you’re on minimum wage then you’ve absolutely not a hope in hell of getting a mortgage and I’m sure that’s demotivating.

berksandbeyond · 20/08/2022 07:35

"No point in working in case you get 100k"

How do people expect to get to that? Surely you work your way up to a high salary with experience and promotions and career moves along the way.

I am in my early 30s and I wouldn't say this is indicative of myself or my peers but maybe that's the company I keep.

Namenic · 20/08/2022 07:31

it’s weird the 100k salary thing.

Yes, house prices are v high, and kids need to be aware of all of this from a young age, so they can think about what careers might give them the lifestyle they are happy with (I discuss this with my 8 year old). But I’m sure there are multiple strategies for getting there. Eg can they live at home for extended period to save money then move outside london? Could they work abroad for a few years to save money? Are there remote working jobs to save on commuting costs and also live in cheaper area - with good internet? Could they save money to aim to retire abroad to a place with decent healthcare but where cost of living is lower?

Simonjt · 20/08/2022 07:27

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 23:24

£10 for a sandwich and a coffee is extremely reasonable!

That covers not only the food, staff wages but also the heating, maintenance, facilities, , water and lighting

TBH OP I’m not sure what kind of country you’re expecting the UK to be when £10 for a sandwich and coffee is considered a ‘Rob’ but entry level jobs should be £100k. That’s not a sustainable model!

My thoughts exactly! It is basic economics and shouldn’t be a surprise to the OP.

Vicliz24 · 20/08/2022 07:24

Sugarplumfairy65 · 19/08/2022 22:05

50 somethings? I'm 50 something and when I bought my first house (after living with the in-laws for 18 months) interest rates shot up to 18%. Both of us worked full time and the best we could afford was a 2up 2down in a run down area. All our bits of furniture were either 2nd or 3rd hand and we didn't have a landline or washing machine for the first 2 years. This was in the 1990's.
I think youll find it was the 60+ (so called boomers)to who prospered.
we had a number of friends our age who bought a few years earlier who lost their homes when interest rates went up so high. It was an awful time.

This . We had no carpets for 3 years and I still have a chest of drawers that I was given in the late 80s today . There was absolutely nothing left in the pot after paying the mortgage and the bills .

ElleryQueen · 20/08/2022 07:22

‘there's something very British about wanting everyone to suffer equally’

Oh god this is SO true. Sadly. I really don't get it. If someone can explain why this is the case I'd be very grateful!! 😄

SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 07:21
  • I guarantee the poster that said they have all 3 are over 45.
OP posts:
SwanBuster · 20/08/2022 07:20

Simonjt · 20/08/2022 07:13

I’ve never earned that much, I live in zone 1, I’m a parent, I own a property, I’ll have a good pension when needed. Until very recently my income was our only income, I had a new car, I had holidays abroad.

😂 yes, thank you for proving my point exactly!

My own dad - one good but unspectacular salary (well less than the equivalent of £100k today) brought up two kids wanting for nothing, paid off house in 7 years, ended up with £1m pension pot + another £250k outside!

He knew the economic circumstances he was living in were a fantasy though and wasn’t myopic. Totally recognised that this was shafting his children.

OP posts:
Endlesssummer2022 · 20/08/2022 07:19

‘there's something very British about wanting everyone to suffer equally’

Very true. This is why we have Brexit and why we’re about to get the worst Prime Minister (Truss) this country has ever seen. She embodies spite. Our shores are encircled by sewage, our infrastructure is falling apart but many people are ok with this as long as others don’t have more than them.

ElleryQueen · 20/08/2022 07:16

Of course young people are shafted in this country, with regards to housing especially. I'm amazed anyone can't see that. But it hasn't been easy for quite a long time. Generalisations can be both helpful and unhelpful. I'm 53 and privately rent in London, and 45% of my salary goes on rent. It sucks. My partner and I are devastated we didn't buy property in our youth but it felt beyond our reach even in the 1990s, when property prices were rising pretty fast. We felt prices 'couldn't possibly' keep rising and so waited. 🤦‍♀️

Snog · 20/08/2022 07:15

All governments deliberately keep house prices high. In the UK we have only built housing on 2% of our land and that includes the gardens. If governments approved building on a further 1% of land we would very quickly have enough houses for everyone and the price of houses would fall considerably.

No government, lib lab or Tory will do this.