Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this too harsh?

59 replies

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 19/08/2022 20:21

I have absolutely had it with my 6 year old the last month or two. He has been hard work for years, on and off (sometimes we go through lovely periods) but this feels worse than before. His rudeness, disrespect and attitude are off the scale, and I see him turning into someone unpleasant and unlikable.

One of these traits is always wanting to be first/his way/wanting to control the game or activity. I see it with his younger sister, but also with friends. Constantly whinging “nooo/I want that toy/I don’t want to watch this” etc and being quite manipulative with it.

I feel like all I’ve been doing is reprimanding him recently. I saw him forcing his own way on his younger sister earlier and I told him exactly what he was doing, and how I had seen him do it with his friend earlier in the week, and that no one will want to play with him if he carries on - that he’ll end up with no friends.

I often do this. Now that he’s in bed of course I’m reflecting that he’s only 6, he’s so young, it feels very cruel and I’m so sad for him. But tomorrow when the moods, rudeness and entitlement starts, I’ll be doing just the same.

I honestly feel like I don’t like him, and that he is unlikeable.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ihavechangedmyname54321 · 21/08/2022 07:34

Thank you @cunningartificer , all good advice. I was hard work as a child, very stubborn and argumentative, and still carry a lot of these traits as an adult. I’m getting my comeuppance in the form of DS!

OP posts:
cunningartificer · 20/08/2022 17:24

I think you're right to be concerned and a good parent to be trying to deal with it, but it struck me when you said you feel like you're arguing like siblings. I think this is perhaps the issue. Though he's irritating you, you have to be the grown up and be calm so as to model for him how we behave when things don't go our way.

It can be helpful in this kind of situation to actually model your thought processes for him. Don't say things like "you made me angry" (not saying you would!) but take him through step by step. So describe the action, explain the feeling, ask what he's going to do.

So for example, "when the toys are left out like that it means they might get lost or damaged unless they're put away. You took them out but you won't put them away. I find that frustrating as I don't think you would really want them lost or damaged. What can we do about this? " if he answers "you put them away" then you go back to the start and just repeat, emphasising that he took them out. Don't say "it's not my job" he needs to work that bit out himself. Initially you feel like a bit of an eejit repeating yourself in the weird calm voice but it really works to take the bite out of it, and it's really hard to argue with it. Each section gets repeated until he gets it. Make it clear you're frustrated by the situation not by him. Couple this with natural consequences--you can't do other fun things or play with him if this isn't done first, how sad, but that's just how it is, and you will help him work out the process.

Also try and "catch him being good" and praise specifically for when he gets it right. He's only six, and sometimes a time out and a cuddle will do a lot to take the heat out of a situation. Often I've suggested we leave a situation where we're not getting anywhere, sit down with a cup of tea and a drink for them, then go back to it like diplomatic negotiators after a break! Once they realise that you won't forget it, but you're not going to lose your rag, giving in stops being such a big deal. Good luck!

Fairislefandango · 20/08/2022 13:19

Is this “just 6” or is this bratty behaviour?

It's both. You need to base your reactions to your son on the outcome you want to have, not on your feelings of annoyance and resentment at his behaviour.

Telling him he'll have no friends etc is the wrong thing to do. You risk cementing his behaviour patterns by making him feel like this is how he is and that everyone will hate him. He is only 6. If he does something violent or really awful, then more serious reprimands are needed. But for the kind of behaviour you describe, you need to guide more gently.

imnotthatkindofmum · 20/08/2022 12:49

Also most kids are twats between the ages of 6 and 10. It's a massive learning curve of social behaviour during that time. It's tedious but you're not alone!

imnotthatkindofmum · 20/08/2022 12:48

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 20/08/2022 12:46

@imnotthatkindofmum your message has made my day, thank you so much; DD’s friends are all twats 😆my DS’ friends are, in fact 95% of his class seem to be pretty unlikable.

Today is a new day, I’m going to try and be less rageful about the rudeness especially, just a brief reprimand and then turn away. I have found myself getting into arguments with DS as if he’s my sibling, not my child.

Lol your welcome!

It's hard not to argue when they're so argumentative! I also have a 13 year old and a 15 year old. It's not that different, the arguments are more about being lazy!

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 20/08/2022 12:46

@imnotthatkindofmum your message has made my day, thank you so much; DD’s friends are all twats 😆my DS’ friends are, in fact 95% of his class seem to be pretty unlikable.

Today is a new day, I’m going to try and be less rageful about the rudeness especially, just a brief reprimand and then turn away. I have found myself getting into arguments with DS as if he’s my sibling, not my child.

OP posts:
imnotthatkindofmum · 20/08/2022 08:27

I think you're doing the right thing. My daughter, 8, is a whinger and crier when she doesn't get to do what she wants. Some if her friends round here won't play with her any more. tbh they're also twats so I'm not sad about it! But it's given me the perfect opportunity to illustrate the consequences of her actions.

I spoke to her teacher about it and he just said she was sensitive but I told him not to put ok with it as we don't at home!

Kids need guidance from adults or they'll repeat the same inappropriate behaviours

Bb16103 · 20/08/2022 08:19

@ihavechangedmyname54321 i absolutely understand about the manipulation & I didn’t like myself for thinking it, like ‘wtf how can he be sly he’s only 6’ but it’s definitely there. He’s admitted some things he’s said to his mum to get his own way which had her in tears thinking she was a bad mum & she caved & let him have what he wanted, she didn’t tell me this but he did quite matter of factly tell me when the same strategy hadn’t worked out on me. He said quite casually ‘well I guess you really don’t love me then because when I said that to mummy she cried & let me have it, I do it all the time’ and it was so calculating, it’s the only time I’ve ever really told him off strongly & I was a bit frightened of him to be honest that he could do this at age 8 & have his poor mum crying just to get his own way. I’d seen it with other kids but that was a shock. She’s his biggest advocate & doesn’t deserve that, I thought mummy would be the one person he would always be kind to & it scared me a bit that she wasn’t beyond his tactics. I don’t really have any advice I’ve tried it all, from massive praise to boost his self esteem thinking maybe he felt inadequate & had to be the boss, to really trying to involve him in daily decisions thinking maybe he feels lack of control & it manifests in this way, rewarding & making a big fuss when he’s managed to play without it turning into the SteveShow (not his name) lots of one on one time with his dad & I’d take his brother & then we’d swap, blending him more with other kids because I blindly thought he’d eventually ‘get it’ & learn how to build friendships if I left him to it but watched from a distance in case the other kid gets upset. I’m making him sound a bully but it’s not that, I can’t put into words other than almost pathological need to have everything & everyone his own way. He did make a friend for a bit but he got very jealous when they had another friend. The warning of not doing things or going home if he can’t be nice doesn’t seem to phase him but at any gathering there could be 10 children & I hate to say it, it’s always him that would flip the board game or demand we leave because he’s bored when really it’s just the other kids aren’t doing what he tells them. I’m so sorry none of this is helpful but please know yours isn’t the only child like this & it doesn’t mean he’s a monster, it’s difficult to manage when the other side of them is kind & sweet natured & you know they have all the potential there but just this extra side of them.

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 20/08/2022 07:54

Sorry to hear your DS is similar @acquiescence . A lot of what you’ve said about yours rings true. DS was the eldest grandchild, and he’s the eldest amongst my group of friends, by quite a way. So there were a few years where he was top dog, centre of attention, you name it. He was born, then a few years, and then at the same time as DD he has quite a few cousins similar age and younger, and the same in my group of friends. So if we have gatherings with either family or my friends, he’s always the eldest by a good 3 years. Which I appreciate is dull and tricky because toddlers need a lot more attention. He’s very bright too.

It’s hard to say about school. He isn’t hugely sociable I wouldn’t say, as he has a small group of friends who he’s had since nursery and reception, and he sticks to all or one of them at play times. The feedback I get is that they encourage him to play with others but he is usually with at least one of this small group, and I do wonder is it because he’s confident he can lead them a bit. I see them play together at the park or play dates and he’s not always really bossy, or if he says let’s do this one friend might say no and DS does huff a bit but it never ends in a big drama. One of his friends in particular though is hugely competitive with everything and I think some of this has rubbed off, though I don’t like to blame another child because DS has always had his own agenda a bit.

OP posts:
ihavechangedmyname54321 · 20/08/2022 07:31

@Bb16103 I agree you sound like a lovely mum/step mum/partner of your DSS dad! Luckily my DS doesn’t tantrum as such, so I think a lot of it has slid because he doesn’t throw a wobbly to get his own way. He’s just, bossy. And sometimes the other child lets him be in charge so I haven’t gotten involved. However it’s stepped up a gear the last few months, as has his general rudeness and attitude. To me he feels very clever, quite sly, sneaky and manipulative. Which sounds an awful thing to say but it’s what I see, I know him well!

@MrsAvocet thank you for your insights as a coach, it’s useful. DS is actually ok as far as I can see in a genuine sports’ setting - he’s not sporty really at all but goes to football training and they play mini matches. During these matches he’s pretty happy to prance around, not getting near the ball but applauding if a team mate does! And on sports day he was perfectly fine with not being first in any of the races, but he did get very upset when his friend (frenemy more like) went on and on about how DS’ House was last of all of them. So I don’t think he’s wholly unusual but it’s a very undesirable trait (his Frenemy is very undesirable overall but that’s another thread!).

OP posts:
acquiescence · 20/08/2022 07:17

I have a 6 year old who behaves in this way fairly often but not all of the time. He can be very rude and entitled, seems to think he is the top dog in the house. He is very bright and our first born so I think we have probably brought a lot of this on.

One thing I would wonder is - does your son actually behave like this with friends and at school or is it more an issue at home? Mine doesn’t exhibit this behaviour with his friends, is mostly able to take turns and share and feedback from school is that he is very sociable with lots of friends. I feel it’s a bit of a ‘restraint collapse’ symptom- the bad behaviour comes out at home where he is most comfortable. I do feel he has an underlying ‘nasty streak’ and I worry about this as he moves through school.

We also struggle with discipline and consequences. We try to use natural consequences (you tipped the toys out and wouldn’t put them away, I have to do it now so we don’t have time to do xyz) and we do use time out sometimes when he is rude and angry and not responding to verbal instructions.

I would be cautious with the ‘your friends won’t want to play with you’ as this could be quite shaming and not do anything to reduce behaviour. I completely empathise however and have certainly said unhelpful similar things on occasion.

Following for any advice on strategies!

Bb16103 · 20/08/2022 06:54

@lemmein thank you so much for your kind words, that’s so kind of you to take the time. Please don’t worry, I don’t call myself his step mum but not because I don’t like him or anything sinister! It’s only that he has a pretty fab mum already & I’ve never wanted to push a relationship on them that they didn’t chose or ask for. Mums husband (pretty wonderful, she’s picked a good one) is referred as step-dad but he brings other children to the mix which I think makes it seem a bit more family unit. I think it would have really hurt mums feelings having this other woman using part of her title.
(No disrespect to anyone who is an official step mum, I’m not saying there’s a right or wrong way)!

lemmein · 20/08/2022 03:15

@Bb16103 you sound like a wonderful 'step-mum' to your husbands boy; he's very lucky to have you, and his mum and dad supporting him...lovely post. I don't have any words of wisdom to help your boy but just wanted to acknowledge your post, your feelings for your dss shine through your words 😊

(only used '...' as you didn't use the word step-mum - didn't want to be presumptuous)

MrsAvocet · 20/08/2022 03:05

I'm no expert, but I coach children around this age and a bit younger in a sport and would say this kind of behaviour is fairly common. I have a couple of little boys in my current group who always want to be first or be team leader and can get quite upset if they don't get to be in charge or don't win every time. I've coached similar girls in the past too, but I would say that more often it's boys.

I would say that most children have these tendencies to some degree but some seem to learn to take turns, share etc more quickly than others. To be honest, I think learning those kinds of things are probably the biggest benefit of organised sports and activities at that age, rather than the actual sport itself.
Of course I have a couple of natural advantages when it comes to behaviour management - I only have to do it for an hour at a time and I'm an adult authority figure who isn't Mum or Dad - so it's much easier for me.
I do think it is a normal developmental stage that most children go through to some degree but also that it needs to be managed, both for the benefit of others and ultimately for the child themselves. I generally stick to pretty basic stuff - praise good behaviour, ignore bad provided its safe to do so, and distract, distract and distract again! And be consistent. Make the expectations clear and the consequences immediate, predictable and fair. For me, if I can't distract a child who is misbehaving I usually them calmly that they need to go to sit with their parents until they have calmed down and are ready to join in again and follow the rules. I never shout but I don't give in to tantrums either. Obviously I appreciate its not so easy when you are the parent though!
Something else I have found helpful is to give alternatives and time frames and to speak positively rather than tell them "no". So instead of just saying "no, you can't go first every time" or "its not your turn to be leader" I might say "Mary is going first this time, then Freddie, then it's your turn" or " Suzie is team leader this week but I want you to be in charge of collecting the cones in at the end". And I make sure that they do get their fair share of going first. It can be tempting to always put the child who is constantly jumping up shouting "Me! Me!" to the back to teach them a lesson but I don't think that's fair. I think they need to learn that they are not more important than everyone else but they are just as important.
As i say, I appreciate that coaching is not parenting but there might be something there that helps a bit. I don't think you are unreasonable to want to address your son's behaviour but I also think he sounds fairly typical of lots of children his age so I wouldn't worry too much at this stage.

hangrylady · 20/08/2022 01:32

XelaM · 19/08/2022 20:37

Wtf?

He's 6!!! It's a good thing he's assertive and confident. Better than if it were the other way around. You are definitely being unreasonable

Wrong. So wrong. If this behaviour isn't addressed he won't have any friends. OP, 6 is old enough to teach them and YANBU.

Bb16103 · 19/08/2022 23:49

I feel so horrible saying this but reading your post is like describing my husbands eldest. He is a sweet loving boy & I worry so much about this side of his personality, from an outsider he’s exhausting & not many children want to play with him, which is so upsetting because I am certain this bothers him even if he acts aloof about it.

His lovely mum has tried so hard to make him friends with her friends children & he does do well enough mostly with these kids as they’ve known him from birth & know what he’s like, but he is from another child’s point of view probably quite hard work & also they don’t go to his school which is where I worry about him the most, because we aren’t there all day to remind him that it’s not his turn or to let other people have a say. He does seem to take it in when we have talks about letting other children have a turn & not to be resentful of other kids winning but especially now he’s older (11) it’s a lot harder to excuse a kid having a long whine at best, or a massive tantrum at worst for not winning / not getting the best one / not having the iPad someone else is playing on / not queuing up for the third time for the ride he wants & letting someone else pick the next ride.we had some dreadful scenes when he was too young to regulate these emotions but it’s improved a lot with age, there’s not really howling or snot involved now if you say no, just sulking. He’s not horrid to other kids apart from little brother at times & I put that down to normal siblings.

He doesn’t seem to grasp how to play fairly & it keeps me awake at night worrying if he’ll ever get invited to a sleepover (and if he’d be invited back by the parents for that matter). he can genuinely be so kind & lovely & I think that’s what makes me so sad about it all, I know he could be a lovely friend if he didn’t put people off by being so controlling. I don’t want to say bratty but that’s the best word really for how it must come across to other people. He’s really not a nasty boy in any way but he’s very ‘I want’ and it’s with everything, he’s less able to get his own way with brother now they’re getting older.
He seems to believe in the divine right of first-borns & it’s really unsettled him that little bro doesn’t always give in & immediately hand over the remote control / move because he wants that chair / swap drinks because his looks better / you get my drift.

At one time I was sure he must be autistic & definitely excused a lot of this thinking that must be it, but I was wrong, he’s not.
Younger brother is so much easier, just an absolute joy of a child to have around, incredibly popular & even tempered. Little brother takes after mum in that regard she is very sociable & likeable too, my husband is more shy & they put it down to the eldest taking after him but this seems quite different from being shy. He’s a really good kid in so many ways & I wouldn’t call it a personality flaw but it’s certainly not a personality asset.

I’m not his parent but I am really worried for his teenage years ahead, I desperately want him to make a friend I feel a bit sick thinking about him going through school spending all break times alone because if other kids avoid him now then what will it be like in 2 years. & just for him to grow up not feeling always like he got the crap second prize because that’s how he seems to see life if it isn’t 100% his way.

bridgetreilly · 19/08/2022 23:38

I would never ignore rudeness.

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 19/08/2022 22:36

Thanks for taking the time to list those points @ChristOnABikeAsYouLike. This is where I struggle with my DS as I have wondered in the past about his maybe being wired differently. But he’s never had quite enough to warrant being worried…no meltdowns to speak of, no sensory issues outside of the norm, no delays, nothing particular about routines.

But bratty is the key word. And if there is someone being difficult at a family gathering say, 95% of the time it’s him. He’s the eldest so has no one to play with really (several younger cousins the same age as DD) so it’s difficult to know if it’s truly him or if it’s because he is bored/feels left out/babies and toddlers are more straight forward. He is ok if an adult is giving him their full attention, for example playing board games with him. He seems to need a lot/constant stimulation or he gets too boisterous, loud and silly. He’s not reckless or destructive with things though, I can fully trust him around roads, he always stops and waits to be told to cross, and he knows not to mess with anything that belongs to DH or I in the house.

His concentration in groups isn’t great. Fine when sat at tables quietly doing work, but not at carpet time.

OP posts:
Intimissimi · 19/08/2022 22:29

Following this with interest as my son is the same and I feel horrendous that I don't like his personality most of the time.

ChristOnABikeAsYouLike · 19/08/2022 22:28

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 19/08/2022 22:04

@ChristOnABikeAsYouLike that’s interesting, what signs did you notice?

@bloodyplanes yes to me it feels very very bratty. I just wish I knew how to deal with it without constantly feeling like I’m putting DS down, as that’s only going to damage his self esteem further.

So many to list. But many of the signs you share in your post were present in my son. Bratty is definitely a word that's been banded about by a few people.

Excessive and OTT meltdowns and tantrums. Nothing is ever enough, can go on and on and on. Socially domineering and bossy, very argumentative, has to have his own way otherwise everyone is being unfair to him. Unable to maintain longlasting friendships. Obsessive and impulsive. Had delayed speech development causing major frustration and anger for him, but when it finally kicked in he's never known when to shut up, he can talk forever - but also has an odd occasional stutter where you can tell his brain his working faster than his mouth can keep.up with. He struggles to 'get to the point' and what could be said in a simple sentence is drawn.out over a long story. He doesn't know his own strength and speed and physically hurts people unintentionally. Has no filter and just says what he thinks even if it's hurtful and very tactless and fails to appreciateit if he's hurtful, but equally takes things other people say to him out of context and is easily offended. Lacks focus and concentration. Finds loud noises distressing and needs ear defenders in class (only just been allowed those), cannot follow rules - if you say "don't do that" he does it. Challenges, quizzes and interrogates everyone about everything. Has sensory issues and can't wear layers of clothes, wears totally inappropriate clothing for the climate which results in tantrums and meltdowns when told to change. Struggles with tying laces still, has trouble eating with a knife and fork and eats as messily as he did when he was a toddler. He collects and hoards anything and everything. Becomes attached to the trivialst of items and panics if he can't find them, but is so messy and untidy that this happens a lot. Has compulsions to be destructive and is drawn to making mess with things he finds nice to touch or has nice colours (I now have to be careful with toiletries and bath & body products I buy as he can't help himself)

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 19/08/2022 22:26

@Soproudoflionesses it didn’t seem judgey to me, it’s more me genuinely begging for tips as I’m clueless!

All of those natural consequences we do - DS is actually not too bad at losing a board game with me or DH (might be different with a friend, I don’t know. He was certainly fine with not coming first in sports day) but if he was fussing we would stop the game.

He’s not sporty (although an excellent bike and scooter rider) and I think he knows this as when his friends are playing football he’ll come up with an excuse to stop playing, or a reason to strop and refuse to play.

OP posts:
Soproudoflionesses · 19/08/2022 22:20

Sorry didn't mean that to sound judgy - was more 🤨at people saying it is his age so tuen a blind eye.
My friend's dd has since been diagnosed with adhd - they don't let her off the hook though. They manage it by giving her consequences so if she is going to strop if she doesn't win a game, no game is played. They don't pander to it basically and insist on good manners etc. It is better than it was but l know sometimes my friend struggles. Having said that, the dad can be a stroppy dick sometimes so l think some of it is learnt behaviour.

ihavechangedmyname54321 · 19/08/2022 22:13

I would love some tips on what to say to reprimand him!

Anything better than “if you keep bossing everyone around no one will want to play with you” etc. Something a bit kinder but still firm.

OP posts:
ihavechangedmyname54321 · 19/08/2022 22:12

@justasmalltownmum yes Dad in his life,
we are together. We bicker which I’m sure doesn’t help but he is a very hands on dad.

OP posts:
Soproudoflionesses · 19/08/2022 22:12

My friend's dd was like this at 2, 4, 6 and is 9 now - not got many friends at school and is very hard to like.

I would def reprimand him op and to people saying he 's only 6 - he won't always be 6 so needs to be taught he can't always have his own way!!