Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this normal for a 3 year old?

64 replies

Everestt · 19/08/2022 20:00

Hi all

I am wondering if this is normal 3 year old behaviour or not. Most of the time she is very lovely and kind. But everyday recently there has been some part of the day where she is being very difficult.

  1. She keeps having mighty tantrums over very small things. She kicks, screams, slaps out and try’s to headbutt me.
  2. she throws things all around the room.
  3. She wants to have everything her way and gets very upset if it isn’t.
  4. She asks for something and when I give it her she said she doesn’t want it and throws it.
  5. She asks for something and then says ‘no not that one’
  6. If her food is cut up or if there’s a tiny piece that has broken off something she gets upset and asks for a ‘better one’
  7. If something is not done a certain way she will have a melt down about it.
  8. She keeps running off from me when we are out even though I have told her many times it is dangerous but she seems to find it funny.
She pretty much gets really upset if things are not exactly how she wants them and it is very hard to rationalise with her.

Is this normal for her age?

OP posts:
PurpleFlower1983 · 19/08/2022 22:26

Yes, that c

Stupidlydupidly · 19/08/2022 22:24

Blev2022 · 19/08/2022 20:06

My HV said when they hit 3 their tantrums are fewer but make up for that in intensity.

I have a 3 year old girl. Yes to most. Was so stressed earlier because I gave her a babybel. She HAS to open it herself but if she accidentally snaps it in half its the end of the world 🥹 she also got really upset because I tied her laces and the loops were too small...
Oh and if daddy tries to fasten her carseat she kicks and screams asking me to undo it and do it again myself 😅 she's perfectly lovely apart from that 🥲

Opening her Babybel is EVERYTHING to my 3 year old, too!

And OP - yes - totally normal!

Abouttimemum · 19/08/2022 22:20

DS definitely had a frustrating phase like this when he turned 3, he’s 3.5 now and is generally fine, although I think that is mostly because I can usually see if coming and end it before it’s even started. Most of his nursery group are the same.

i give him power without really giving him power and alongside solid boundaries seems to make it all easier for his emotions to deal with. Also, no chinks in the parental armour, DH is on the same page.

I do think it’s a normal phase but if it feels in your gut that it’s not right then you’re right to seek guidance.

PrincessLeia77 · 19/08/2022 22:20

No I'd speak to a paediatrician this sounds exhausting for you both and needs to be managed it she'll be behaving this way at school. I have three children, one of whom is ASD and none of them behave like this. Been around and worked with children for years, this is either bad behaviour that needs to be nipped in the bud or she is ADHD and needs help and support. Don't let it carry on, at least speak to a paediatrician for advice

Kanaloa · 19/08/2022 22:10

With things like biscuits and food being ‘broken’ too I’d just tell mine ‘don’t eat it if you don’t want it’ and then go back to talking to one of their siblings or just ignore any further mention of it. If they don’t eat it chuck it in the bin. Sometimes I think joining in the drama is the absolute worst thing you can do.

Kanaloa · 19/08/2022 22:08

Having worked with kids for years, I’d say it’s perfectly normal/expected for a 3 year old to be naughty. However, it’s also normal for a 3 year old to smack their friends, if you know what I mean? As in, it’s not unusual or exceptionally bad behaviour, but it’s also not acceptable and has to be dealt with/stopped. With the running off I’d invest in a backpack leash. Remove the chance to be ‘funny’ and break the habit of running off from you. A lot of the things (asking for something then saying no, whinging over a chipped biscuit) I’d just ignore. For smacking in tantrums I would just say put her somewhere safe and move away, and ignore until she is calm enough to discuss.

Newuser82 · 19/08/2022 22:03

Namechanger965 · 19/08/2022 21:51

Yep completely normal. They do get more reasonable in a year or so.

If her food is cut up or if there’s a tiny piece that has broken off something she gets upset and asks for a ‘better one’

This drives me insane. The amount of times I’ve smushed a broken banana back together is ridiculous. DD2 is 2 and had a 20 minute tantrum the other day because I took the banana out of the skin and apparently she wanted it ‘like a monkey’. But only half of it, not the whole thing. She wanted half took off to eat separately. Took half an hour just to figure out how she bloody wanted to eat the thing.

Oh goodness mine will only eat a banana "like a monkey" 🙈.

Newuser82 · 19/08/2022 22:03

@awwbiscuits worth a go, thanks!

Namechanger965 · 19/08/2022 21:51

Yep completely normal. They do get more reasonable in a year or so.

If her food is cut up or if there’s a tiny piece that has broken off something she gets upset and asks for a ‘better one’

This drives me insane. The amount of times I’ve smushed a broken banana back together is ridiculous. DD2 is 2 and had a 20 minute tantrum the other day because I took the banana out of the skin and apparently she wanted it ‘like a monkey’. But only half of it, not the whole thing. She wanted half took off to eat separately. Took half an hour just to figure out how she bloody wanted to eat the thing.

Pamparam · 19/08/2022 21:45

Identical to my 3 yo!

awwbiscuits · 19/08/2022 21:38

Newuser82 · 19/08/2022 21:10

My three year old is definitely like that in some aspects. In fact I try to avoid building things out of Lego with him as he will ask me to make say a car, I'll try and make a car and he will get all upset as "it's not right". 🙈.

He was trying to draw a picture of himself the other day, I told him to draw a circle for the head, he did so but then cried as "that wasn't a head". The same thing when I drew a circle!

He tried to stick food (eg breadsticks) back together if they have snapped and gets upset when it doesn't.

I tell his older brother he will get more reasonable when he gets older.😂

This may not work but it did with my dd - if she breaks something (breadstick, crayon etc). I say ooooo! Now you have two! And she has always just said 'oh yeah!'

Keiki · 19/08/2022 21:38

Definitely terrible 3s not 2s in this house too. That sounds exactly like my day.

SummerInSun · 19/08/2022 21:33

Agree with PP who said that three is way worse than two - they should call them the terrible threes, not the terrible twos.

HerMajestyTheQuern · 19/08/2022 21:32

Totally normal, my youngest, recently turned 3 is all about the drama, if he’s not happy everyone has to know about it.

Today we’ve had to re-put on his socks 3 times as they were ‘wonky donky’ Wouldn’t eat his gingerbread man as it’s leg was already broken - cue a fountain of tears because he didn’t have a gingerbread man to eat.

It’s just endless kicking off with him, he feels everything very deeply. On the plus side I’ve never had better hugs off anyone, he puts his whole self into them 😍

Newuser82 · 19/08/2022 21:30

Everestt · 19/08/2022 21:23

@Newuser82 mine does that too. She will ask me to build something and say ‘No, not like that. Like this’ 😂

I find it quite infuriating. I wonder why he keeps getting the Lego out as nothing is ever how he imagined it 😂. Poor boy!

Newuser82 · 19/08/2022 21:30

KevinTheKoala · 19/08/2022 21:28

100% normal. My 3 year old even likes to control the way I say goodnight - "no mummy, have to say see you in the morning" and god forbid I give her the purple plate instead of the pink one, it's like the world is ending! She's generally a very easy going child by when the mood strikes her she throws almighty tantrums.

Oh yes, mine also wants his plate and cup to match, so if he has the blue plate he wants to have the blue cup, if he has the pink one then wants the pink cup. Goodness they are funny.

KevinTheKoala · 19/08/2022 21:28

100% normal. My 3 year old even likes to control the way I say goodnight - "no mummy, have to say see you in the morning" and god forbid I give her the purple plate instead of the pink one, it's like the world is ending! She's generally a very easy going child by when the mood strikes her she throws almighty tantrums.

Everestt · 19/08/2022 21:23

@Newuser82 mine does that too. She will ask me to build something and say ‘No, not like that. Like this’ 😂

OP posts:
Fairygarden1992 · 19/08/2022 21:20

Yes normal. It does get better I promise

Turnoffthelight · 19/08/2022 21:18

Sounds just like my 3 year old. They can be awful!!!

SynchroSue · 19/08/2022 21:10

We are in the midst of this hell too with our very wilful just turned 3yo who has started to lash out and scratch/pull hair when tantrum-ing. It’s driving me insane. A (helpful..) older friend told me that she remembered her dcs as having the terrible twos, the troublesome threes AND THEN the fing awful fours. So, I’m glad that I’ve another 2years of this sht to deal with ….

Newuser82 · 19/08/2022 21:10

My three year old is definitely like that in some aspects. In fact I try to avoid building things out of Lego with him as he will ask me to make say a car, I'll try and make a car and he will get all upset as "it's not right". 🙈.

He was trying to draw a picture of himself the other day, I told him to draw a circle for the head, he did so but then cried as "that wasn't a head". The same thing when I drew a circle!

He tried to stick food (eg breadsticks) back together if they have snapped and gets upset when it doesn't.

I tell his older brother he will get more reasonable when he gets older.😂

SquigglePigs · 19/08/2022 21:04

Yes, sadly completely normal. My DD hit the worst of it at about 3yrs 6m and now we're a few months further on and she's already starting to settle back down. The tantrums are still there but they're much shorter lived, or are just a brief whine rather than a full on tantrum.

Everestt · 19/08/2022 21:04

Thank you everyone. Very reassuring. Yes I would say her tantrums are less often now she has turned 3 but definitely bigger tantrums when she does have them. She was very very upset earlier because she wanted to ride her scooter on the road and not on the path and I wouldn’t let her of course!

I read the ‘cutted up pear’ thread @LittleBearPad it made me laugh 😁very familiar

OP posts:
Pebblebeach15 · 19/08/2022 20:58

if you had not have given her age and only the list of behaviour I would have said .... yup , that post is about a three year old . Hang on in there , it does get better .