Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never set foot in a baby group again?

132 replies

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 12:34

Why oh why do they have to be so clicky?
Just braved one with my 3 year Old and 5 month old and literally got stared at as I walked in by the other mums all sat round a big table but no one said a word other than the lady who took my money for the group 😳 AIBU to think you'd at least make someone knew feel welcome?

OP posts:
Randomthoughts992 · 19/08/2022 13:23

honestly i felt like that too unti i found out that everyone was feeling like that, like wondering why no one would talk to them so i started actively seeking out people and chatting and suddenly the whole dynamic changed and we all started talking

17caterpillars1mouse · 19/08/2022 13:22

It definitely depends on the group.

I've attend 4 over the years (not including paid for activities)

  1. Was very cliquey and chaotic. Nobody watching their toddlers, so no intervention when your child got pushed over by another or hit in the face.
  1. A bit cliquey in the sense most people seemed to know each other and had older children at school together. People were friendly, but after several months they were all still acquaintances, not friends
  1. Lovely small group, very welcoming and friendly but also alot of grandparents so didn't really make any friends
  1. Lovely small group, met one of my best friends there. I've also made good friends with the lady who runs in and am now helping her out since my DC no longer attends
NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 13:22

@Neverfullycharged so it was less baby more toddler/kids group so plenty of stuff for DS and DD just tagged along as usual 😂

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 19/08/2022 13:20

Strawberrypudding · 19/08/2022 13:11

Really shocked that people are trying to blame the OP for this. It's incredibly hard for some of us to approach a bunch of strangers.

Groups like this should be welcoming to all. I would have hated this and don't blame OP at all for refusing to go back.

Cliquey people you should all be ashamed of yourselves.

I don't think people are blaming her, just pointing out that there can be miscommunication.

I went to one that I found hard. The lady running it had been doing it for years, probably didn't want to anymore, but had no one to pass it on to. I was a new mum and not confident. I didn't know what to do. The children who'd been there more just got on with it, without their mums.

I think the established mums vaguely think the new person will come and sit round the table with them. The new mum sticks near her children. The established mums are too tired and fed up to make an effort!

I didn't have a table at mine, specifically to stop the whole sat with your backs to the children and everyone else. Makes it much easier to be friendly!

Skinnermarink · 19/08/2022 13:20

fuck groups like that honestly, give them organiser feedback on to why you won’t be giving them your money anymore.

i have a baby and I’ve been a nanny to babies and toddlers so I’ve been to a hell of a lot of groups, some are lovely, Im pleased to say the other scenario is the exception.

funnily enough when I’ve hit a cliquey one as a nanny, where’ve I’ve no skin in the game, I just waltz around not giving a shit about their stupid small minded high school ways and it really perturbs them. Or I deliberately make a huge fuss of a new member that they ignore, or sit in the spot on the mat one of them is saving for their friends on purpose.

Shits them up a bit and makes me laugh. That behaviour has no place in an adult environment.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 19/08/2022 13:13

I'm sorry you had a crap morning OP; not what you need when presumably you wanted company and a bit of adult conversation.

I think it depends really. For one, most people there are probably knackered and / or preoccupied with their own kid - so sometimes basic niceties can go out the window. Some may also misread you (not anyone's fault). And yes, some may be cliquey.

Pure anecdote but I'd occasionally find groups cliquey with my first, but never now - because I have twins, and it's mandatory for everyone in the room to come over and ask if they're twins and whether they're identical Grin. Weirdly I think it's just such an obvious conversation starter that somehow I think other people just unthinkingly do it. And then offer to help, because invariably I'm carrying them under my arms like sacks of potatoes. Sometimes, in normal circumstances, people just can't think what to say.

Neverfullycharged · 19/08/2022 13:12

Honestly, it’s a bit of a MN ‘thing’ to hate baby groups. It depends whether you’re going with the aim to make lifelong friends or just to do something nice with the children (somewhere dry!)

Groups do differ massively for different ages. I promise I’m not just being pernickety with language, but was it an actual baby group (most specify for non walkers.) If so, that might explain lack of interaction with your three year old. It is hard at that stage because what’s suitable for the baby isn’t for the three year old. It might be worth trying to find toddler groups - they are more used to having babies in tow.

IglesiasPiggl · 19/08/2022 13:12

You need to try a few to find your tribe. I went to some lovely ones, but they weren't the first I tried. A couple I went to had a really odd vibe so I just chalked it up to experience and didn't go back to those.

Strawberrypudding · 19/08/2022 13:11

Really shocked that people are trying to blame the OP for this. It's incredibly hard for some of us to approach a bunch of strangers.

Groups like this should be welcoming to all. I would have hated this and don't blame OP at all for refusing to go back.

Cliquey people you should all be ashamed of yourselves.

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 13:09

@ihatebojo that sounds like such a lovely playgroup!

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 19/08/2022 13:08

I ran one for years and always went out of my way to help people settle in.

But

Sometimes you aren't sure whether someone has been before, and feel stuck between offending them for not remembering them, or failing to welcome them when they are new.

There can be a mismatch between what the people already there expect you to do, and what you expect them to do.

Some regulars get fed up of making an effort with new people, week after week, who never come back. They'd rather just make the most of their hour with the people they already know, and only make an effort when you make an effort or look like you are staying.

Next time, introduce yourself, say it's your first time, and ask who the leader is. You can tell them if you want help getting to know people/feel a bit anxious.

It's much easier to respond to people/help them when they give you a lead.

ihatebojo · 19/08/2022 13:07

Oh goodness. This thread makes me sad. I ran playgroups for 7 years and loved it. I went to a cliquey one which I hated so when I had the chance to do my own, I jumped at it.

I always made the adults their first drink. I always gently nudged more experienced group members to go and engage with newer members.
I also used to organize a monthly night out.

So many friendships (adults and children) were formed, including important ones for me too. I was very sad when my time came to an end (youngest went to school so I went back to work), and sadly the group is now closed.
The friendships have continued though, and I love seeing photos of people still continuing to be parts of each other's lives.

fairgame84 · 19/08/2022 13:03

They were bloody awful when DS17 was a baby and I've no intention of doing any when DD is born.
So cliquey and unfriendly.

PuddingBear · 19/08/2022 13:03

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 13:01

For those asking I did smile and say hello but didn't get a response and then my DS takes a while to warm up in new situations so wanted me right by him playing and all the other mums were sat round a table together away from the toys.
I've been to friendlier groups but they don't run in the holidays so pushed myself to try this one.

So from their point of view it will have looked as though you weren’t interested in getting to know them as you stayed away from them.

luxxlisbon · 19/08/2022 13:03

So you didn’t speak to anyone but you are annoyed that they didn’t go out of their way to speak to you? And it’s only them in the wrong?

The reality is some women go to baby groups to meet people, some are their just to focus on their baby, others attend with a friend as a play date. I have been each of those people at different times.

If you want to make friends it’s on you to put yourself out there. You can’t passively sit back and blame others.

This actually annoys me, this “clique” thing is only put on women and it isn’t even cliquey it’s just different expectations. Dads don’t expect to go to the park and meet a bff just because they both have kids but women seem to think having a child can hold a friendship.

Baby groups vary, some have many different people each week and you can’t tell who is an ‘existing’ member and who is new if you don’t religiously attend.

These women are all tired and just trying to do the best. If you want to be included you need to step out of your comfort zone.

Badger1970 · 19/08/2022 13:02

I'm a normally confident person but taking my grandson to one group actually reduced me to tears. I've never met such an unfriendly group of people in my life, and I actually posted this on their FB page. Walking into a group for the 1st time takes huge effort, a lot of new mums feel really vulnerable and it made me very cross! A smile and eye contact costs nothing.

undecided112 · 19/08/2022 13:01

Absolutely hate baby groups. Despise them. So cliquey and reminds me of being back in high school.

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 13:01

For those asking I did smile and say hello but didn't get a response and then my DS takes a while to warm up in new situations so wanted me right by him playing and all the other mums were sat round a table together away from the toys.
I've been to friendlier groups but they don't run in the holidays so pushed myself to try this one.

OP posts:
Maireas · 19/08/2022 12:58

Did you make the effort to chat to people? Did you initiate conversation?
There's no point being passive, if you think this would benefit your children, try again.

cookiecreammmpie · 19/08/2022 12:55

It's a bit of both, if you go in and don't speak or appear approachable, people won't talk to you. I've attended a few different toddler groups over the years and I didn't really find them cliquey. People just talked to whoever they were sat near or didn't talk to anyone and were there for their children to play, not to make friends themselves. There were a few women that only spoke to a few select other women but I think it's worth giving it a bit longer before you decide to write it off.

StaunchMomma · 19/08/2022 12:54

Yeah, I hated them too.

Better off paying for an actual block of activities as they are more structured.

HangOnToYourself · 19/08/2022 12:50

I managed 10 minutes at one and then had to leave, I had a panic attack when I got outside (I was going through a particularly difficult time and suffer with social anxiety though so probably not the most balanced view).

Funkyslippers · 19/08/2022 12:45

I went to my fair share of unfriendly ones. One I distinctly remember was when myself and another lady were new and the woman running it invited the other lady to join in with a group of mums who knew each other but ignored me! I messaged the group on Facebook to let them know just how unfriendly I found it, especially as they were boasting about how friendly and welcoming the group was!

I'd definitely try another one, with a friend if possible, but if you go on your own, focus on your LO. Make smalltalk with someone else on their own. They're not all bad!

PuppyMonkey · 19/08/2022 12:45

I attended a toddler group for about two years before anyone actually spoke to me properly or asked me basic information like my name. I did try and strike up conversation and occasionally had an interaction about something our little ones were doing - but then the other mums would literally turn their chairs or turn their backs on me. There’s something weird about some toddler groups in some areas I think.

I moved home to another area for my second and that toddler group couldn’t have been more pleasant!

Atmywitsend29 · 19/08/2022 12:45

YA(definitely)NBU.