Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never set foot in a baby group again?

132 replies

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 12:34

Why oh why do they have to be so clicky?
Just braved one with my 3 year Old and 5 month old and literally got stared at as I walked in by the other mums all sat round a big table but no one said a word other than the lady who took my money for the group 😳 AIBU to think you'd at least make someone knew feel welcome?

OP posts:
Howappropriate · 19/08/2022 14:35

Looking back I had wrong expectations of baby groups. I had an idea that I'd be making friends, arranging walks in the park with other mums etc. To he honest, that never happened- I didn't have one "Mum" friend until my son went to school. At the time I felt I had done something wrong. Looking back, it was absolutely fine. I had work, other friends so I wasn't lonely all the time, just felt a bit of a wierdo always walking about on my own with the buggy.
I'd advise you to adjust your expectations. Take it as a goal to get out of the house, and to access new toys and a bigger space for your child to play (it's OK to bring on the floor playing- your child will settle in). Enjoy a coffee, vaguely smile and work on being unconcerned. If it's an OK group, after a few weeks short conversations will start naturally. If it's not an OK group, you can leave.
Or don't bother going back, and look for another when you feel like it.
The notion of what your supposed to do as a parent is very negative. If I had another I would understand there's many ways to bring your child well, and baby groups aren't important as long as your child is loved and paid attention to!
Also a lot of the friendships are either women who went to school together, or kind of surface friendships that are all about having children thr same age. You aren't missing out, although social anxiety in that situation is very normal x

Dalaidramailama · 19/08/2022 14:35

Who cares? You don’t need to talk to them. I went to plenty with mine when they were younger. The most affluent groups being the clickiest and the groups in deprived areas by far the friendliest. I wasn’t there to make friends I was there to watch my baby/toddler have fun and it added structure and routine to our day.

Honestly OP don’t let them put you off going back.

FatBettyintheCoop · 19/08/2022 14:29

Strawberrypudding · 19/08/2022 13:11

Really shocked that people are trying to blame the OP for this. It's incredibly hard for some of us to approach a bunch of strangers.

Groups like this should be welcoming to all. I would have hated this and don't blame OP at all for refusing to go back.

Cliquey people you should all be ashamed of yourselves.

Why?

Another perspective…

Presumably every one of those other mums at the playgroup will also have had a first time experience too. Why did they stay and keep returning week after week if it’s such a horrible group?

Also, they’ve probably paid a nominal fee to attend a baby group with their babies and probably look forward to grabbing an hour for a coffee and a natter with ‘Jane’ and ‘Trish’ whilst their children play. Perhaps they’re painfully shy too and don’t have the confidence to talk to a complete stranger.

The only people at fault here are the people meant to be running the group. They’re the ones who need to put plans into place to welcome new people. However, with most volunteer led groups, the group dynamic depends on the social skills of the individual volunteers and obviously this varies enormously. You’ll probably find that the people running the play groups are the ones who end up involved in the PTA and Brownies etc.

I used to run a baby & toddler group when I had my toddler DS. I organised weekly rotas so that members had a job such as welcoming new members, making drinks, organising snacks for the children, setting up and tidying away etc. It ensured that everyone contributed something and it wasn’t left to the same two people every week and allowed me to spend a bit of time playing with my DS too. However, for some people this was too formal and they just wanted a space to come and chat where they didn’t have to actively do anything.

When you go clothes shopping, you don’t try on one item and then leave declaring all shops are useless as they only sell the wrong size or style? There’s no right or wrong way but surely you’d try several groups rather than dismissing them all out of hand as ‘cliquey’ and blaming complete strangers for not meeting your specific needs?

mycatisannoying · 19/08/2022 14:29

Always found them a lifeline. Some groups were better than others of course, but overall a really good experience.
I'm Scottish but my first two children were born down South. I actually much preferred the English ones.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 19/08/2022 14:28

My DS is 17 now but I still remember the trauma of baby/toddler groups!

One church led group was the worst. I tried talking to a group of women but they completely blanked me and DS and moved their DC away from us. Funnily enough DS then ended up in the same year group at school as 3 of those 'babies' and I ended up becoming really good friends with one of the mums. I mentioned the baby group recently and she said she loved the group and definitely didn't notice any of the cliquey behaviour I described!!

TooManyPJs · 19/08/2022 14:28

I think all the people trying to say groups of mums aren't cliquey are the mums who are are generally not left out of cliques! Or ones who just happened across the friendly groups!

Mum groups can be super cliquey (the school playground seemed to be the worst ime) but the outside groups did really vary. I'd keep trying some other groups as I found some really nice friendly ones.

Having been bullied at school I have no time for such childish behaviour as an adult, so don't go back there. Just try some other groups til you find the friendly ones! Best of luck.

Rosehugger · 19/08/2022 14:25

I think it's really hard to go to these things on your own. Much nicer if you know one or two people already. Also often there is an established group who know each other and aren't bothered about making friends with newcomers- it's not horrible cliqueyness, it's just that people just go to catch up with their mates, are often knackered and can't be arsed. When I went there were four or five of us going to the same one, as a sort of continuation from NCT classes. Then I met other mums who they knew and so on. I can't exactly say that I was looking round the room and wondering whether someone was on their own - between chatting and watching what DD was up to it's not something I would have done. But if someone came over and started chatting of course I would not have been deliberately unfriendly.

AliceW89 · 19/08/2022 14:23

Toddler groups >> baby groups in my experience. Maybe it’s a combination of parents just finding their groove a bit more by that stage and being a bit more relaxed…or the fact the kids are interacting with each other (read: trying to bash each other round the head and steal biscuits)…but I have found it much easier to chat and socialise with others. I didn’t find baby groups unfriendly as such, but it didn’t strike me as a place people came to make friends and chat, where as our local church toddler groups/stay and plays definitely do.

Skinnermarink · 19/08/2022 14:21

There’s a church group I go to specifically because it is quiet and has a huge safe room for the baby to tear about in which we don’t really have at home. I actually like to just sit with my coffee and watch him for a bit without the endless ‘no DS dont touch/bite/eat/lick/climb that!!’

But the lovely retired church lady who helps to run it is convinced I must be desperately lonely and is always bringing people over to talk to me. They can’t win sometimes 😂

cinnamonbiscuit · 19/08/2022 14:20

I do get where you’re coming from OP. I think an issue with baby groups is that many of the mums there are feeling anxious, lonely, exhausted etc and some may be dealing with pnd/pna, and this can create a bit of an atmosphere sometimes. That combined with however you’re feeling as you walk in can make it really difficult to approach a group and can make it all seem 10x worse than it should be.

I started one with my 3 month old as we came out of lockdown last year and everyone was in a bit of a state so it wasn’t fun at all at first, but I persevered because I don’t drive so had limited options, and eventually we both loved it.

Maybe just try a few until you find one that’s at least bearable. Might be good if a brand new class starts that you can jump on and find/make your own friendship group, and then make a point of including any new people!

ApathyMartha · 19/08/2022 14:17

I started a conversation with someone whose child was playing next to mine. Within minutes her friend was over being very cold towards me and talking exclusively to her friend. Surprised she didn’t piss on her and mark her territory. I used to go but didn’t make much effort to talk to people. I was there to have time with my baby. Fuck ‘em if they have to be part of the herd.

KangarooKenny · 19/08/2022 14:16

talknomore · 19/08/2022 12:35

yep, felt that 22 years ago in several baby groups, never went back again

Me too.

FlyingSaucerss · 19/08/2022 14:12

This is why I never went to baby groups and I think some of the posters on here would act exactly the same given they are trying to blame the op she did say hello and they didn’t respond, honestly that’s not ok! I wouldn’t go again.

spirit20 · 19/08/2022 14:05

I think any group who doesn't actively go out of their say to at least say hello to a new member is quite unfriendly.

MsTSwift · 19/08/2022 14:05

Some are awful. Try other ones. I remember feeling lonely and pushed out. Then went to one and met some now dear friends. Our toddlers about to get their gcse results none are still friends but we still are! Just met for coffee today!

Milkywaychocolate · 19/08/2022 13:58

@Badger1970 that's awful 🙁

NotQuiteUsual · 19/08/2022 13:54

I much preferred the church run ones. Always so welcoming, lots of the retired parishioners lending a hand and gleefully cooing over the kids. Very little judgement, but lots of support. Even women who were so shy and quiet on the school run would talk in those groups.

Mascia · 19/08/2022 13:53

I never particularly liked play groups.

When one of my kids was little I did manage to find a group of lovely women I clicked with, but I generally find these groups hard work.

Not even because of the people there - they’re all different - but because of the group dynamics.

One is trying to be sociable and get to know new people (which can be a bit of a challenge in itself), while at the same time keeping an eye on a small child, so your attention is constantly divided, you can’t relax and end up feeling awkward (at least I did).

In other situations I actually quite like talking to different people though.

KyaClark · 19/08/2022 13:42

Neverfullycharged · 19/08/2022 13:12

Honestly, it’s a bit of a MN ‘thing’ to hate baby groups. It depends whether you’re going with the aim to make lifelong friends or just to do something nice with the children (somewhere dry!)

Groups do differ massively for different ages. I promise I’m not just being pernickety with language, but was it an actual baby group (most specify for non walkers.) If so, that might explain lack of interaction with your three year old. It is hard at that stage because what’s suitable for the baby isn’t for the three year old. It might be worth trying to find toddler groups - they are more used to having babies in tow.

I've hated baby groups for far longer than I've been on Mumsnet.

Peonyperfection · 19/08/2022 13:38

Please don't take it personally. It's just how it is sometimes. They are all so different so it's good to try a few and see what works for you. Find some that do a free trial session and don't commit to a block booking if you can help it. Some groups where people dip in and out (instead of going every week are usually quite friendly), usually the free ones, like at libraries. Outdoor activities like country parks are maybe less social but you keep busy. I found arriving early helped as it meant you could talk one-on-one to people at the beginning.

Freysimo · 19/08/2022 13:30

Many years ago I moved to a new area and went to a toddler group with my three year old son. My son went to play with the other kids, but no one spoke to me except one lovely lady. We live miles apart now but we're still good friends 40 years later. I have never forgotten her kindness.

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 13:29

@picklemewalnuts thank you! ☺️

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 19/08/2022 13:27

I guess I'm just saying, don't take it personally OP!

I tried hard not to let mine feel like that for newbies, but sometimes you just miss the mark.

That said I'm sure there are awful ones out there! Don't give up though, there will be one that you like.

luxxlisbon · 19/08/2022 13:26

Strawberrypudding · 19/08/2022 13:11

Really shocked that people are trying to blame the OP for this. It's incredibly hard for some of us to approach a bunch of strangers.

Groups like this should be welcoming to all. I would have hated this and don't blame OP at all for refusing to go back.

Cliquey people you should all be ashamed of yourselves.

But the exact same goes for the other people there. We, the OP included, have no idea who was new in the group, who has been once or twice or who goes every week. Many of them could find it just as difficult to approach a stranger.
At the end of the day you are in control of your own life and you do need to take responsibility for getting what you want in life, it won’t just come to you and that includes friendship.
Sometimes at a baby group it’s my only day off work and I am there solely to spend time with my baby.
Others I’m at the end of my tether and have been up all night, maybe I just want to speak to the friend I have attended with and no use my 1 small break in the day to make small talk with a stranger I may never see again.
Or maybe I am hoping to meet friends but can’t quite find a way to strike up conversation, the one woman on her own seems to be very focused on her child and they are different ages so I’m not sure what to speak about, plus she hasn’t said hi so I think maybe she isn’t wanting to chat.

None of those things are cliquey, nor is anyone in particular “bad” or at fault.

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 13:24

@picklemewalnuts appreciate the alternate perspective ☺️

OP posts: