Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never set foot in a baby group again?

132 replies

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 12:34

Why oh why do they have to be so clicky?
Just braved one with my 3 year Old and 5 month old and literally got stared at as I walked in by the other mums all sat round a big table but no one said a word other than the lady who took my money for the group 😳 AIBU to think you'd at least make someone knew feel welcome?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JoanCandy · 23/08/2022 10:20

I always hated them, OP exactly for the reasons you’ve stated.
I took my DD to things like story time at the library as it took the focus off having to try and chat to disinterested parents.
It gets better once they start school, you’ll soon get chatting to other parents when you’re waiting to pick them up at the gates.

Crikeyme · 23/08/2022 10:15

I first took my daughter to a group when she was about to turn one, as everything I fancied doing had previously coincided with naps or feeding. It was a group called Chatterbox, a little like Sing & Sign, and was run by a qualified speech therapist - you turned up and paid on an ad hoc basis.

That first session was daunting on paper - we sang songs together to help with the signs we were learning, had a coffee break and got some toys out for the kids, then cleared up for a final few songs. What made a massive difference was having a really relaxed, friendly leader, who ran the singing activities as a circle on the floor - no huddles or groups, just everyone together. We all had an activity to focus on, and lots of laughs when a child escaped into the middle of the circle, plus it was great to see our kids enjoying and participating in the songs and actions. By the time we had coffee, everyone was relaxed, and got chatting naturally as the kids played together; I got talking to a few mums who knew each other from another group, because our kids were playing in the same area, and the next week they all greeted me and asked how my week had been. The second session was the week of my daughter’s birthday, and everyone sang happy birthday. Within a few weeks, I was going for coffee afterwards with the mums I’d met, and they became my first ‘mum’ friends. We’re still in touch on Facebook, although our kids all ended up going to different schools.

i won’t say there weren’t less friendly parents there, or that there weren’t children there who were pushers, biters, smackers etc, but on the whole the mood was relaxed and it was easy to steer my daughter away from annoying situations. The group leader gave us some great activities to do, that brought real benefits, and her friendly attitude dictated the tone of the group.

Please don’t dismiss all groups on the basis of one awkward hour. The number of people saying they tried once and never bothered with any other groups is amazing - why would you give up on something you want to do, or that benefit your child, so easily? (That’s a general ‘you’, not specifically the OP). There are literally thousands of groups out there, with millions of individual parents - not one big clique determined to cold-shoulder you. As others have said, some people may be so new they don’t realise you’re also a newbie - they may be waiting for you to welcome them! Some people will be barely functioning and not have the mental space to make smalltalk or realise you need help. Some might be just as shy as you, but if you’re not approaching people it’s not fair to expect them to, either.

I hope everyone who wants to go to a group gets what they want from it - whether that’s lasting friendships or simply a space to be out of the house with more space for their child to play with new toys.

BooSaidTheGhost · 23/08/2022 09:41

Sorry that was in response to the poster who said they ran a baby group and looked after the newbies! The reply button didn't work for whatever reason.

BooSaidTheGhost · 23/08/2022 09:37

This sounds great! As with many groups/social situations, it will contain a mixture of introverts, extroverts, some new, some old, some loud, some quieter and so on. I agree partly that you get out what you put in, but it’s narrow minded of others to assume that someone more on the introverted side is passive or disengaged. We’re all different and approach social situations differently. A good facilitator or group leader has a role to play in helping create an environment where everyone can feel comfortable and welcomed. Things like making people a cup of tea, introducing them to a couple of other mums with things in common in that first session etc.

Heartrate · 23/08/2022 08:09

I loved them, they definitely got me through those years. However, not all toddler groups are equal.

I found the cheaper ones in poorer areas much friendlier. I know, stereotype, but that's how it was for me. The church ones were the best because there was usually a volunteer organiser who introduced you to a few people. The profit making ones with a "purpose" (e.g music or gym, rather than just meet and play) in affluent areas least friendly and frankly a bit competitive even at that age.

I made really good friends, but always with other people who attended alone, I never managed to break into an established group. I hated it when e.g. friends from an NCT group attended together and stuck together, that didn't seem in the spirit of the thing to me.

I ways volunteered to help with making the tea/ tidying the toys and at any fund raisers. That gives you an easy way to strike up conversation.

Pegasushaswings · 23/08/2022 08:01

I have found most groups are very cliquey too, you just have to do it for your DC and pretend you haven’t noticed you are being ignored! I moved to a new area with a 1 yr old and found a nice local group but pretty much all the others were full of mums that all knew each other already or were the fashionable set, neither of which I fitted into. It’s very lonely.

neverbeenskiing · 23/08/2022 07:49

The people who will miss out are your DC, so YABU. Give it another try.

This is nonsense. Baby groups are supposed to be for the benefit of the Mum rather than the baby who doesn't know what's going on, and no child has ever been traumatised by not going to one. I went to them with my first, because I thought I was supposed to, and hated every minute. So with my second I didn't bother. Instead we went to the park, the library, galleries, childrens museums, there are lots of opportunities for babies and toddlers to interact with others outside of these groups. He's now a very happy, confident, sociable little boy who loves people. Give it another try if you want to, OP but don't feel you have to.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 23/08/2022 07:47

Just to add I wasn't from the area and not long moved there and that with my Irish accent and the group soo stuck together. So as others have said an activity group structured is best and more enjoyable than a group of women just sitting around chatting. Look up what is going on in your area in library also, story time, art stuff for kids. Dancing ones are great and good fun but am sure it has all changed since my son was small but at the school did make some lovely friends from all walks in life.

GraceandMolly · 23/08/2022 07:45

Posts like this do my head in. Mums at groups aren’t clicky. Some might be just as shy as you are. Go and start a conversation and stop expecting everyone else to do the work for you.

“How old’s your little one? Have you been coming here for long? What other groups do you do? Have you tried… soft play?
Does anyone else find that as soon as you make a cuppa and decide to sit down, baby wakes up from the nap” it doesn’t matter what you say, someone needs to start a conversation somehow.

LGBirmingham · 23/08/2022 07:42

NancyJoan · 23/08/2022 07:09

someone always comes on these posts and says, well did you make an effort to start a conversation with the group? Who does that 😂 they’d look at you like you were mad. Interrupting a group of cliquey women is never going to go well if they don’t have the self awareness to say hi in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️

Who does that? Me. ‘Do you mind if I join you?’ and then sit down and introduce yourself/ your baby. Ask where they live, ask about their kids, ask how long they’ve been coming to the group.

Yes me too! While that is when I'm not otherwise engaged with a toddler. Sometimes I don't have the chance to talk to adults. And sometimes I'm not in the headspace to start all the conversations. I think I'm lucky in Birmingham though as people are genuinely incredibly friendly in this city. If you talk to them they will always talk back.

People tend to stick to those they know when they're a bit shy in my experience.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 23/08/2022 07:40

I lived in London for years when my son was little, he's an adult now and went to a few and yes some groups stuck together and did not even bother with their kids just there to yap. Tried a few times and am fairly outgoing or was then so found a lovely little group a dance group for kids/toddlers and my son loved it and the mums mainly black women were just so friendly to me and made me so welcome and had a lovely time there. Would hate to be going through all that again. I would try going to a few different ones and even swimming etc and you may find your tribe. It really depends on the area and the groups as some places they just stick to themselves. Hope you have better luck next time but did find lovely mum's in school and they were great.

ReginaFalangeee · 23/08/2022 07:35

YANBU OP. I walked out of one in tears with my first born.

I’m on baby no 2 now and am absolutely dreading doing the baby group thing again (probably won’t tbh)

Having said that despite most of the groups I went to first time around being cliquey, I did managed to make a one or two good mum friends from them who I still meet up with. That was probably more down to the fact our tots ended up going to the same nursery more than the baby groups though.

RedHelenB · 23/08/2022 07:35

NumberSixteen · 19/08/2022 12:34

Why oh why do they have to be so clicky?
Just braved one with my 3 year Old and 5 month old and literally got stared at as I walked in by the other mums all sat round a big table but no one said a word other than the lady who took my money for the group 😳 AIBU to think you'd at least make someone knew feel welcome?

Did you start any conversation? I didn't know a soul when I had my dd1 but 20+ years on I'm still really good friends with 4 of them. I did have to talk to them though, and break into groups a bit rather than hover round the edges.

GirlOfTudor · 23/08/2022 07:20

Have never seen appeal of baby and toddler groups, personally. If you weren't welcomed, don't waste your time returning. Give some feedback to the organiser, as I'm sure you're not the first person to attend once because if this reason.

NancyJoan · 23/08/2022 07:09

someone always comes on these posts and says, well did you make an effort to start a conversation with the group? Who does that 😂 they’d look at you like you were mad. Interrupting a group of cliquey women is never going to go well if they don’t have the self awareness to say hi in the first place 🤷🏻‍♀️

Who does that? Me. ‘Do you mind if I join you?’ and then sit down and introduce yourself/ your baby. Ask where they live, ask about their kids, ask how long they’ve been coming to the group.

Dizzywizz · 23/08/2022 06:45

Well done for trying @NumberSixteen , I remember how nerve wracking it was (mine are 10 and nearly 8 now 🤣). Try another one - rhyme time at library if you have one is good, as it’s not all about chatting, it’s led by someone. I remember a couple where people weren’t friendly or were cliquey, but then some others I tried were great.

Floatyunicorn · 23/08/2022 06:40

I remember going to a playgroup with my LO a few years ago, a church run one.
I got there and the old ladys doing tea and coffee welcomed me, but the mums were completely rude and abrupt, my smiles or hello were never acknowledged, i went to sit down to be told i couldnt sit there.
A child snatched a few toys off my LO and nothing was said or done, then at circle time for songs, a woman sat bolt in front of me so i was looking at her back!!
I told LO we had to go early as we had to be somewhere, proceeded to get in my car and burst into tears. I never returned.
Was very relieved when LO started nursery so i never felt i had to go groups again.

withaspongeandarustyspanner · 23/08/2022 06:32

Always hated them. I endired them for my eldest three. I met a few people - I vaguely know some of them still. Some of them turned out to be not very nice women (behaved like those girls at school who left you out, you know, even when you had quite established friendships with others). I tried to maintain friendships because of my children, but the children behaved exactly like their mothers, so I decided it was all a waste of time and didn't bother with any groups for my youngest.

My experience was exactly like Motherland 😁

keeprunning55 · 23/08/2022 00:37

It sounds like these groups haven’t changed in years! I felt compelled to join the when my 1st dc was born & often left feeling lonelier than when i arrived-which is saying something!
By the time I had my 3rd dc, I realised that i didn’t need to go in order for me or my dc to socialise & felt a sense of relief.
I liked library time and some organised clubs like baby gym a little more.

Orphlids · 23/08/2022 00:02

Baby groups vary so much. I go to one religiously, because everything about it is just lovely. No cliques. It’s really cheap and cheerful. The women who go are a real mixed bag - different social backgrounds and approaches to parenting, but everyone is so friendly.

But I tried another group, which makes a big song and dance in its advertising about how it’s so supportive and is all about solidarity, no judgement etc and it was horrible. I’m a confident person, so initiated conversation when I arrived. The mums I tried chatting to had waved at me as I’d arrived, but quickly informed me they’d mistaken me for their friend, after which they physically turned their backs on me, and didn’t speak to me again. Except for one, who took the time to inform me it was my fault her DC had run away from her (we were at an outside venue) because I had been playing chase with my DS and hadn’t realised her DC had been running along behind us. I still get cross thinking about the hypocrisy of it.

surreygirl1987 · 22/08/2022 23:57

Oh some can be like that but not all. I found the best ones were ones where there was an activity of some sort so you could focus on that if nobody wanted to talk to you! Forest school type stuff was great, and I loved Busy Lizzy (exercise classes where you take your kids along)... met some great friends doing that and I'm super socially awkward and introverted!

celticprincess · 22/08/2022 23:37

I loved baby groups but I’m one of those annoying people that will talk to everyone - I’ve irritated the school mum clique as well as they like to ignore me but I often go over and make a point at joining in!! Our local health service ran a meet a mum group for those who just had babies. Was very structured with weekly topics. It ran for about 6 weeks. Over that time we ended up sitting kind of near the same people each week and just got chatting. All nervous first timers. Once the group ended various smaller groups formed and the small group I had sat with all signed up for a few different paid baby classes - baby sign, a sure start group, those type of things. Again they were quite structured sessions and small in numbers too and parent drinks and biscuits were often provided and we would chat. We stayed quite close friends for a while and had mum nights out but people started going back to work so drifted apart and met up less frequently. Tried again second time around but it was harder with a toddler in tow as some of the baby groups didn’t allow toddlers or were at awkward times for nursery pick up. I did go to a few less structured toddler groups which I enjoyed less and felt a bit manic but did often arrange to go with one of the original baby group mums. If I went on my own it was harder to penetrate the cliques but I would persevere.

just a warning. The school playground crowd can be worse!! Depending on your working pattern and child care arrangements or can be harder and much more cliquey than baby and toddler groups ever were.

Ginandtonics · 22/08/2022 23:34

I tried them 26 and 23 years ago. Unfriendly and cliquey and I did try very hard. Think adults too knackered to bother with someone they don't know and it was also incredibly competitive. As I was an older mum, had both kids in my 40s, I didn't fit in at all and probably wasn't what they wanted to associate with. I still have close friends from back then but not from mother and baby groups. Don't feel bad OP these often aren't welcoming friendly places. X

PollyPingit · 22/08/2022 23:26

I hated baby groups, I was suffering from PND and really struggling to try and do my best for dd, those groups made things feel so much worse I still come out in a cold sweat thinking about them 10 years later! It’s not the end of the world if you miss them OP do not beat yourself up. I had the backs turned and was totally ignored by mums who years later at school were suddenly friendly when they realised who I am married to.

Summerfun54321 · 22/08/2022 23:07

The toddler groups I found to be so dull and awful. I enjoyed activities where there was something to laugh about or talk about apart from children such as mum and baby choir or buggy fitness or something like that - a structured group rather than a floaty sit around and look awkward session with the kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread