Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my sister to not walk around our house in states of undress!

157 replies

JenGin · 19/08/2022 10:53

My younger sister often stays with us for a few days at a time as she lives fairly far away and we like to spend time together and have always been a close knit family.

The last few times she's obviously getting more and more comfortable and has starting coming downstairs in the mornings and evenings wearing her, really quite skimpy, pj's. I guess they could be described as lacy hotpants and a crop top. She's now even go as far as strolling around in just her underwear after her shower!

I have no insecurities about my husband being interested in her or checking her out but for some reason I am finding it a bit uncomfortable. Am I being unfair to consider asking her to at least put on a dressing gown? The most I've said is along the lines of "aren't you a bit cold in just that?" but she obviously didn't see it as a hint and continues to do it.

Is it really too different to her being in a bikini when we're all at the beach or does it cross some sort of boundary? I know that if I did bring the topic up she'd laugh it off and tell me I'm being a prude and genuinely not understand what the problem is. Maybe it isn't a problem and it's something I need to get over? I just don't know.

OP posts:
gannett · 19/08/2022 14:29

Some MNers would truly have their minds blown if they spent much time in Germany or Sweden or some countries with healthier attitudes to the human body than Britain. The amount of pearl-clutching on this thread is ridiculous. Some of the language used... apparently she's "inflicting" her body on you? INFLICTING.

And of course there's the inevitable leap to "they're sleeping together, check their phones".

It seems no one's realised how hot it's been this month though? DP and I stayed with friends last weekend and everyone wore as little as they could decently manage - sports bra and running shorts for me. No one was doing it for attention, we were doing it because it was HOT.

Anyway. She's your sister. If you want her to put on a dressing gown surely it's easy to tell her. But she won't know you want her to unless you actually tell her. Until you do, it's not really unusual or out of line for her to dress skimpily in a heatwave among family.

TheBestBitch · 19/08/2022 14:29

Thefruitbatdancer · 19/08/2022 11:06

It's not about body shaming, this is about your sister inflicting her underwear & semi naked body on you & your family. You haven't asked to see it, she has decided to inflict her semi naked state on you. That's the difference & that's what people are deliberately avoiding to address. It's not about female empowerment, it's about having the social etiquette to dress & behave appropriately to the situation that you're in. I wouldn't turn up to an interview in a skimpy t shirt & shorts.

I agree with this. It's disrespectful and she shouldn't do it.

JenGin · 19/08/2022 14:28

NewYorkLassie · 19/08/2022 14:18

Comparing her attire to beach wear is not relevant. Women go topless on the beach all the time. I wouldn’t dream of going round to a mates house and sitting there with my tits out.

To throw a spanner in the works we have both sunbathed topless in front of each others husbands so that's clearly going to illicit "he's seen far more in the past" response from her 😂

But in all seriousness it is different. A beach and somebody else's house come with different social restraints/norms, in my opinion.

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 19/08/2022 14:27

TBH it smacks a bit of exhibitionism to me. I’m not saying she’s after your dh, but maybe she likes to feel that he’s admiring her assets.

Pps who say there’s nothing wrong with it, and accuse the OP of prudery, are IMO wilfully choosing to misunderstand the issue.

Cantstandbullshit · 19/08/2022 14:20

Dotjones · 19/08/2022 10:58

I don't mean to sound harsh but the problem is more your attitude to the shame of the human body than her walking around in her underwear. If she feels comfortable with little on, that's a good thing. People shouldn't be shamed into covering up, as you say, if she were at the beach you'd not bat an eyelid. She's comfortable with her body, good.

Really? You sound ridiculous. Your sister visits you in your marital home and it’s ok for her to be walking about in her underwear? Why don’t you all go full nude then?

NewYorkLassie · 19/08/2022 14:18

Comparing her attire to beach wear is not relevant. Women go topless on the beach all the time. I wouldn’t dream of going round to a mates house and sitting there with my tits out.

daisychain01 · 19/08/2022 14:15

the problem is more your attitude to the shame of the human body than her walking around in her underwear

there aren't enough eye-rolls for this comment Hmm

daisychain01 · 19/08/2022 14:13

Your house, your Roolz.

maybe remind your sister that you aren't both kiddies anymore living in your parents' house, you're adults so need to dress and behave like adults.

if she doesn't get that, then she shouldn't get to stay with you as she isn't being very respectful if you've asked her on numerous occasions to get dressed.

Mumspair1 · 19/08/2022 14:11

MajorCarolDanvers · 19/08/2022 12:03

3rd thread in trending telling women how to dress.

Have I gone back in time?

So you think it's ok to be walking around in your thong in someone else's house. Give over
Hmm

Mumspair1 · 19/08/2022 14:10

Dotjones · 19/08/2022 10:58

I don't mean to sound harsh but the problem is more your attitude to the shame of the human body than her walking around in her underwear. If she feels comfortable with little on, that's a good thing. People shouldn't be shamed into covering up, as you say, if she were at the beach you'd not bat an eyelid. She's comfortable with her body, good.

oh FGS. She can prance around in her underwear in her own home. You don't do that in someone else's home! Seriously, where are your manners?

StarlightLady · 19/08/2022 14:08

Sister being comfortable enough to walk around not wearing very much. Elsewhere on another thread a family member wearing a body suit without a bra (I thought they were made to be worn without bras!), do I detect a theme here?

Is there something in the air today?

Applesonthelawn · 19/08/2022 14:01

You are right to feel uncomfortable. It is not the norm in society for people to be naked (or close to) except intimate couples or small children in front of parents. Anything else is uncomfortable with good reason. It sets off alarm bells frankly, about her, not you.

Mammajay · 19/08/2022 13:50

A bikini on a beach is ok. Not if you walked into a department store. Just quietly tell her.

pigsDOfly · 19/08/2022 13:50

I'm really failing to see how what the OP's sister does in her own house or what someone would wear to the beach has to do with how you behave in someone else's house. Even family.

It's not appropriate to walk around in someone else's house in what amounts to very skimpy underwear.

Would it be acceptable to turn up to a funeral in a bikini because it's acceptable wear on a beach? No of course not. Certain clothes and behaviour is only acceptable in certain situations.

I walk around naked in my own house and in front of my daughter when she's staying at my house. If I stayed at her house I certainly wouldn't walk around naked or in my underwear because her DP is there.

Thinkingblonde · 19/08/2022 13:46

She knows exactly what she’s doing.

It’s inappropriate of her to walk around half dressed in someone else’s home. Yes a bikini top and bottoms are fine on the beach but not in someone else’s lounge.

ganvough · 19/08/2022 13:44

JenGin · 19/08/2022 13:25

I will do. We'll have a chat tonight and I'm sure it'll go fine, apart from perhaps a little bit of ribbing from her. I just wanted to see if I'm over reacting or being prudish. Judging by the mixed responses it was worth asking because there have been plenty of replies saying she should/can do what she's doing etc but I'd say the majority of replies echo what I think about it in terms of decency. I'd disagree with some regarding her motives but considering they're seeing this from an outsiders point of view without knowing my sister and our relationship that's completely understandable.

This is sensible.

The way to think about it is - if you weren't married to DH and he was a newish bf, would she think it ok? Or if you had a young son at home, would she think it ok? Clearly boundaries do change even for families. Nothing wrong or shaming about it.

JenGin · 19/08/2022 13:43

DonnyBurrito · 19/08/2022 13:35

Would she potter about in just her underwear if she and your husband were alone together in the house? And if so, I wonder how her own husband might feel about that?

It sounds like an unconscious power trip thing to me. That's why it's making you feel weird.

There hasn't been a situation where I've been out and it's just the 2 of them in the house alone but if that did happen then yes she would still be doing it, as in her mind she's just doing what she does regardless of who's there.

@CatherinedeBourgh You wouldn't be bothered if your sister was naked in front of your husband?? Wow...that would definitely be way too much for me but it just goes to show how differently people view nudity. I guess there isn't a right or wrong...more about social norms.

OP posts:
DonnyBurrito · 19/08/2022 13:35

Would she potter about in just her underwear if she and your husband were alone together in the house? And if so, I wonder how her own husband might feel about that?

It sounds like an unconscious power trip thing to me. That's why it's making you feel weird.

CatherinedeBourgh · 19/08/2022 13:27

Wouldn't bother me. Wouldn't bother me if my sister was naked in front of my husband, tbh.

Family is family. I expect my sister to behave at home as she does in hers.

And she does. It just happens to be leggings and baggy t-shirts for her (and me), we don't do sexy at home 😂

mam0918 · 19/08/2022 13:27

I use to live in a shared housing and never walked around like that, now I have my own house I do.

If I was visiting with family or friends I wouldnt.

I dont class it the same as a bikini because I have alsorts of different underwear and bar my period knickers (the thick kind with the absorbant lining) non are remotely like a bikini they are all thin material, some skimpy (little thongs, boy shorts where my ass hangs out etc...), alot are seethrough (mesh, lace, netting) etc... I have never seen someone on a beach in a see through 1 layer lace thong and matching bra.

JenGin · 19/08/2022 13:25

I will do. We'll have a chat tonight and I'm sure it'll go fine, apart from perhaps a little bit of ribbing from her. I just wanted to see if I'm over reacting or being prudish. Judging by the mixed responses it was worth asking because there have been plenty of replies saying she should/can do what she's doing etc but I'd say the majority of replies echo what I think about it in terms of decency. I'd disagree with some regarding her motives but considering they're seeing this from an outsiders point of view without knowing my sister and our relationship that's completely understandable.

OP posts:
Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 19/08/2022 13:22

My last post was in response to @Tamzitface

Maireas · 19/08/2022 13:22

JenGin · 19/08/2022 13:20

About what? The thong and bra? Sorry if it seems that way but it isn't the case. I just wanted to clarify it's not ALWAYS underwear and mostly her PJ's, but as said before her PJ's aren't just short shorts, they're lacy hotpants which show a lot!

Ok, you'd better speak to her then.

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 19/08/2022 13:21

It matters because it’s disrespectful to OP.

It’s disrespectful to be doing something that purposefully tries to catch the attention of someone in a relationship - and I would say the same whether it’s man or woman.

What I don’t like is all this pretence of ‘she can do what she likes it doesn’t impact anyone’ - well it does, everyone is fallible to temptation - even if that temptation only remains as thoughts and looks rather than actions, why would any decent person want to encourage that in the partner of someone they care about?

JenGin · 19/08/2022 13:20

Maireas · 19/08/2022 13:17

Well, you're backpedalling here a bit, OP.

About what? The thong and bra? Sorry if it seems that way but it isn't the case. I just wanted to clarify it's not ALWAYS underwear and mostly her PJ's, but as said before her PJ's aren't just short shorts, they're lacy hotpants which show a lot!

OP posts: