Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 19/08/2022 16:56

I will feel guilty until my last breath for not being able to breast feed

Please, please don’t. It’s heartbreaking to think you feel guilty on top of something so dreadful happening to you. 💐

ivfbabymomma1 · 19/08/2022 16:53

I will feel guilty until my last breath for not being able to breast feed.

I had surgery on my breasts which involved removing my nipples years before I gave birth so I physically couldn't. Yet I still don't feel a need for FF month.

Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 16:44

But I actually think formula not being able to be advertised at all (with the bs fake ‘follow-on’ loophole closed) is great and that there should be a standard NHS formula produced and supplied at cost to mothers who need it. And maybe you’d get it from the HV so it’s not in your face everywhere in shops, on tv, insidiously the message everywhere that baby = bottles. Cheaper for parents, better for babies (as more would end up with at least some breast milk and to their parents who did ff would have more spare cash with spending less on formula) and what absolutely is a lifesaving product isn’t subject to the whims of the free market and profiteering. No idea how you’d do that and of course it will never happen. The ‘armies of breastfeeding support going bed to bed’ sounds great; what is the problem with giving brand new mothers the help and support they need to bf? I don’t think it’s bad that ff wasn’t promoted, although of course PP shouldn’t have been left struggling to find sterilising equipment etc after a c section with no help. That’s obviously not on. But my experience of HCP is actually a huge willingness to abandon bf or at least ‘top up’ (like a baby is a kettle?!) with formula at the first sign of trouble, or even when there’s no trouble at all. Trying to redress the balance so that bf is the normal, default option rather than that being ff (as has been for decades in the UK); I can’t see how that’s a bad thing, although it of course has to be done sensitively and supportively and not abandoning new mums to not know how to feed their babies if bf doesn’t work out. Incidentally my NCT class covered ff in detail; I don’t recognise this stigma about bottles. I DO feel the stigma and stares of bf my 18 month old still and did when she was younger too; endless, endless questions of ‘when will you just give a bottle / why not give a bottle / give yourself a break it’s fine / aren’t they supposed to go onto follow-on formula at 6 months?’ Lots of insecurity and defensiveness and also just wild how deep seated all the misleading formula marketing has been; multiple people genuinely thought you ‘had to’ move on to follow-on formula, a completely redundant product.

blebbleb · 19/08/2022 16:38

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 19/08/2022 09:45

In the last infant feeding survey in 2010, 12%(!!!!!) of babies were exclusively breastfed at 4 months. I imagine there will be a few anomalies where babies are incorrectly given cows milk (or early weaned), but this means a huge amount of babies are having formula. Given that the main beneficiaries of a formula feeding month will be the formula companies, it seems an absolutely absurd idea.

I agree. I formula fed my son but I don't feel like I need a month to go on about it and to profit the big companies. It doesn't need to be "normalised", it already is.

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 16:35

@Grizzlac 👏👏👏👏

I'm not home so can't write long replies but that sums up what I think quite nicely

I'm not against formula. I've used it myself. But I'm not naive enough to think the manufacturers care about anything other than profits. All of the 'closer to breastmilk' bs is nothing other than a marketing technique to get your money 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Annaritanna · 19/08/2022 16:34

Formula feeding is absolutely shamed.
I breastfed DS until he was 2yo.
With DD i struggled since early months. I power pumped, supplemented, woke up every 2 hours to increase my supply for mo nths. Now she is 9 months old and 75% formula fed. I really really tried my best.
And i still get the random people looking at me like i am a bad mother.

Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 16:30

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 16:03

So what that article says is that war on want did an article that “nestle kills babies” in the 70s and nestle sued them and won because it wasn’t true. Did you actually read it?

as I said above too, nestle does not produce baby formula in the uk.

You read that article, that horrifying article about millions - MILLIONS - of babies dying because their vulnerable mothers were manipulated by immoral and awful business practices from formula companies who lied about their products, all but bribed HCPs and deliberately weren’t clear about the ongoing cost of formula (cos they’re keen on that - profit!), including marketing their products deliberately in a language customers couldn’t read, making it impossible for them to prepare formula for their babies safely so that MILLIONS died of malnutrition and diarrhoea, and that’s your take away? Genuinely speechless.

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 16:29

I'm not sure a month is needed, but there definitely needs to be more advice and support for those who formula feed for whatever reason.

My hospital was a "baby friendly" hospital, and the midwife told me that this meant that they could not advise on "artificial feeding" as they sneerily referred to it. I was left on my own to find the bottle washing facilities, sterilisers, fridge etc which was tucked away down a very long corridor. No one would even tell me where they were - and hobbling round looking for it after a general anaesthetic c section wasn't fun. Armies of breastfeeding supporters went from bed to bed helping others. I think it's great they had the support, but a shame even basic advice wasn't available to me.

I was given a leaflet to say that breastfeeding is best and therefore no bottle advice would be given and to ask my gp if I needed advice.

Luckily I had done lots of research so knew how to safely make up a bottle or what to do when my baby started to refuse his bottles. Unlike other formula feeders I've since witnessed who were still mixing powder with cooled boiled water. In my personal network I don't actually know anyone who formula fed, so I didn't have friends etc to ask at the time.

Twice I had strangers come up to me in cafes and tell me off for formula feeding. Seems like you can't win, no matter what you do.

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 19/08/2022 16:27

I think for a lot of people on here, the hatred of formula is so tribal it helps them feel less insecure and inadequate. And that's fine, I doubt anyone who made a choice or actually didn't even think about it, isn't interested in their bile. We are too busy going back to the gym and work 😀

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 19/08/2022 16:21

Either would be pathetic, attention seeking and ridiculous. Really, apart from the militants who are borderline lunatics, nobody, but nobody gives a fuck how you feed your baby, gerbil or self.

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 16:14

An easy breach to point out would be aptimils famous lie 'closer that ever to breastmilk'
Aptimil were found to be telling lies and the whole ad had to be pulled cause funny story, its nowhere near breastmilk.

Yep, this too.

OP posts:
LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 16:12

The judge ordered them to drastically change their marketing tactics because they were misleading new mothers. And they won in the end but that does not change the fact millions of babies did die. They only care about the £££

OP posts:
Slimemonster · 19/08/2022 16:12

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 15:32

I actually don’t think I am aware of any breach of advertising laws by any company that produces formula never mind the wild claims above. What are examples of such breaches?

the ridiculous stigmatization of formula (it’s treated like cigarettes) is why there are not more companies in the market and why it is so expensive (and profitable). It’s essential food for babies that some women choose to feed their babies and others have to use to feed their babies. It’s an excellent and essential product and we should stop demonizing it.

If it were 'treated like cigarettes' it would be in plain packets behind a counter, behind closed shelving. With ads on it telling you of the health risks.

It isn't any of that in the UK as far as I am aware.
An easy breach to point out would be aptimils famous lie 'closer that ever to breastmilk'

Aptimil were found to be telling lies and the whole ad had to be pulled cause funny story, its nowhere near breastmilk.
A quick Google will show you plenty of other breaches.
And just the fact they had to make up/invent different 'stages' of formula to get around the laws speaks volumes.

Babies = bottles is so ingrained on us that we can't see the woods for the trees.

No one is a bad parent for using formula.

girlmom21 · 19/08/2022 16:06

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 15:42

Formula isn't ridiculed and stigmatized. Formula advocates just see it that way when other people explain the benefits of breast milk. Simply talking about the benefits of breastfeeding does not = formula shaming. However you may want to look into some of the history of formula milk and Nestle for example, and how they have exploited poor women. That is shameful IMO.

Formula absolutely is ridiculed and stigmatised.

I felt horrendous for opting to combi-feed with baby #1 because of the stigma around formula.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 16:03

So what that article says is that war on want did an article that “nestle kills babies” in the 70s and nestle sued them and won because it wasn’t true. Did you actually read it?

as I said above too, nestle does not produce baby formula in the uk.

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 16:01

Well no actually @MsPincher it's not irrelevant

OP posts:
Loics · 19/08/2022 15:56

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 15:32

I actually don’t think I am aware of any breach of advertising laws by any company that produces formula never mind the wild claims above. What are examples of such breaches?

the ridiculous stigmatization of formula (it’s treated like cigarettes) is why there are not more companies in the market and why it is so expensive (and profitable). It’s essential food for babies that some women choose to feed their babies and others have to use to feed their babies. It’s an excellent and essential product and we should stop demonizing it.

Kendamil had 4 breaches last year alone: bsna.co.uk/news/2021/further-ruling-by-advertising-standards-authority-against-kendal-nutricare-ltd-for-breaches-of-infant-formula-advertising-rules

This report from the WHO shows how manipulative and indisidous the advertising can be (This is a big one and is backed by organisations such as UNICEF): www.who.int/news/item/28-04-2022-who-reveals-shocking-extent-of-exploitative-formula-milk-marketing

There have been many advertising breaches from formula companies, Pfizer, who produce SMA, have been caught out as well.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 15:52

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 15:42

Formula isn't ridiculed and stigmatized. Formula advocates just see it that way when other people explain the benefits of breast milk. Simply talking about the benefits of breastfeeding does not = formula shaming. However you may want to look into some of the history of formula milk and Nestle for example, and how they have exploited poor women. That is shameful IMO.

Yes it is. For example I was told in the hospital they couldn’t give me formula (I was too unwell to breastfeed) because it was bad for my baby and they were not allowed. My health visitor told me she couldn’t help me or tell me how to prepare bottles as she wasn’t permitted. My best friend whose baby was losing weight was told by a health visitor not to take her to hospital as she would be told by drs to give her formula as she needed food. And so on. It’s disgraceful. That’s the NHS in London.

so many women are shamed for formula feeding. It needs to stop.

I don’t believe Nestle even produce formula in the uk. But irrelevant anyway. Formula saves millions of lives every day.

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 15:48

I'm very pro breastfeeding, fed both mine til 4. But if people are talking about it I think it is important to listen. Why do they feel formula feeding needs 'a month'? For what purpose?

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 15:47

www.businessinsider.com/nestles-infant-formula-scandal-2012-6?r=US&IR=T

OP posts:
MsPincher · 19/08/2022 15:46

FallOutPloy · 19/08/2022 12:33

I know that for those of us who didn't have the "breastfeeding journey" we were hoping for, the breast is best message can feel like a personal attack.

But whilst being mindful of the feelings of mothers who struggled with breastfeeding, we shouldn't be glossing over the fact that objectively, nutritional, breast milk is better than formula. It makes us feel better to say "oh, well, there's nothing in it really", but unfortunately that's just not true.

Of course it's not the be all and end all. Formula is perfectly fine, it's not the start of a life of drugs and crime! But there needs to be nuanced approach, where parents do understand the benefits of breastfeeding, but they all also understand those benefits may be outweighed by physical/mental harm to the mother.

Lots of women can’t breastfeed. When they say this they are told they are not trying hard enough and that everyone can breastfeed. It leads to awful mental health problems.

lots of women don’t want to breastfeed. That’s their choice.

despite all the research there is no good evidence that breastfeeding actually causes any health benefits. It’s more likely the effect is just a correlation.

in any event, we women are adults. We can choose to formula feed if we like or if we find breastfeeding too hard or can’t do it. We don’t need ridiculous patronizing “nuanced” approaches to formula. We should be able to formula feed without stigma and disapproval.

of course the same applies to breastfeeding (but this thread is about formula).

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 15:42

Formula isn't ridiculed and stigmatized. Formula advocates just see it that way when other people explain the benefits of breast milk. Simply talking about the benefits of breastfeeding does not = formula shaming. However you may want to look into some of the history of formula milk and Nestle for example, and how they have exploited poor women. That is shameful IMO.

OP posts:
MsPincher · 19/08/2022 15:38

Slimemonster · 19/08/2022 11:22

It won't bring the price down at all.
If a parent wants or chooses to feed using formula then there is nothing wrong with that, like I already said 'feed your baby formula if you want too' there isn't anything wrong with choosing to feed your baby formula.

But that's not the issue here.
Read the rest of what I said to understand what the real issue is...

Of course more producers and own brand formula will bring the price down. There is nothing wrong at all with feeding your baby formula as has been said. There is also nothing wrong with producing formula- an essential food which saves many millions of lives every day.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 15:32

DameHelena · 19/08/2022 10:59

We don't need a formula week because it's already a multi billion £ industry that violates advertising laws at every corner and undermines vulnerable new parents at every opportunity.
Even accepting that, I can't agree that we don't need a formula week. Look at the stories on this thread alone of women who were pressured/bullied/guilt-tripped about either not wanting to BF or (maybe even worse) being unable to.
A friend of mine was reduced to tears by a midwife (a fucking midwife!) very soon after giving birth because she found BF difficult and painful. That isn't OK and as long as that continues then yes we jolly well do need a formula week.

I actually don’t think I am aware of any breach of advertising laws by any company that produces formula never mind the wild claims above. What are examples of such breaches?

the ridiculous stigmatization of formula (it’s treated like cigarettes) is why there are not more companies in the market and why it is so expensive (and profitable). It’s essential food for babies that some women choose to feed their babies and others have to use to feed their babies. It’s an excellent and essential product and we should stop demonizing it.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 15:25

Slimemonster · 19/08/2022 10:48

Breastfed children are a minority.
The majority of mothers who begin breastfeeding, are forced to stop before they are ready.
(due to lack of support/undermined/heavily marketed ads/etc. Soo many other reasons)

This is why we need breastfeeding awareness.

We don't need a formula week because it's already a multi billion £ industry that violates advertising laws at every corner and undermines vulnerable new parents at every opportunity.

Turn on TV - did you see a breastfeeding advert? No.

But you saw 4 different formula ads....they don't need any more advertising. They already have nearly 100% of the market at the expense of new mothers.

These companies know they can't make money out of breastfeeding mothers, so they created the devide.

Feed your baby formula if you want to.

Breastfeed if you want to.

But if you had to stop feeding before you were ready to, then you have massively been let down and you shouldn't be cross at other mothers for that - it's the formula industry you need to direct your anger too.

If you had to stop breastfeeding before you were “ready” it has nothing to do with companies that sell baby formula. How on earth do you come up with that nonsense?