Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:27

No we don’t need a formula feeding month, yes breastfeeding is better, no formula isn’t poison and we are lucky to have a decent alternative but it doesn’t need a month of promotion, it should be there for those who can’t breastfeed and there shouldn’t be a stigma surrounding that but it is a product and a month celebrating it is simply product placement

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 20:25

Second class" is a little dramatic, your not segregated or stripped of your right to vote ffs... doubt you've ever even been asked to cover your baby's head while feeding or had friends/family sugest you go home/into a separate room/ or sit on the public toilet to feed your baby 🙄or had it suggested by well meaning staff that you might be "more comfortable" in the parent & baby room that smells like dirty Nappies....FF mums have never been secluded or hidden away

amen to that

OP posts:
Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 19/08/2022 20:25

Depends on if a month is needed to raise awareness of a particular issue or if it is just being done because breast feeding has a month (I’m assuming from the op).

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:24

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 20:20

"Second class" is a little dramatic, your not segregated or stripped of your right to vote ffs... doubt you've ever even been asked to cover your baby's head while feeding or had friends/family sugest you go home/into a separate room/ or sit on the public toilet to feed your baby 🙄or had it suggested by well meaning staff that you might be "more comfortable" in the parent & baby room that smells like dirty Nappies....FF mums have never been secluded or hidden away

'Second Class' isn't being dramatic - it's reality for many FF mothers. All through pregnancy, it's heavily put on mothers to be that 'Breast is Best' with no talk whatsoever about formula feeding. You ask for help, you're given no help but many talks on BF and how it's 'best for the baby'. Hmm

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 20:21

Maybe we need a 'stop shaming women' month?

It seems that many FF mothers have been made to feel shame. As a BF mother I was also made to feel shame. Even more so as my babies got older.

Also it seems that both FF and BFing mothers don't feel they get the support they need after birth. My experience was that it was all 'breast is best' before birth but once my baby was born there was pressure to bottle feed. I was told my baby wasn't feeding for long enough and he needed bottles a few days after birth. He hadn't even be weighed at this point. When he was weighed he hadn't even lost weight as most babies do after birth but had gained! If I hadn't been so set on BFing I may well have caved.and given formula unnecessarily.

I struggled with breastfeeding at times - found it painful and hard to get baby to latch on with my first and went through bouts of mastitis and the pain of thrush on my nipples. And I'm proud that I got through all that and did something that was beneficial for my DC. So many people think you must have had it easy if you breast fed. I'm happy about my DC not having ever had ear infections and not needing braces which may have been helped by breastfeeding. But talking about those things is almost taboo because you don't want another mum to feel bad. But we all do various different things to try to benefit our DC and I think it's ok to feel proud of our struggles to benefit our DC. I guess what I'm saying is it is a shame baby feeding is divisive. As it's really just another way for the patriarchy to keep women down.

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 20:20

"Second class" is a little dramatic, your not segregated or stripped of your right to vote ffs... doubt you've ever even been asked to cover your baby's head while feeding or had friends/family sugest you go home/into a separate room/ or sit on the public toilet to feed your baby 🙄or had it suggested by well meaning staff that you might be "more comfortable" in the parent & baby room that smells like dirty Nappies....FF mums have never been secluded or hidden away

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 20:13

Feel likeits a bit county fuckerish to be going on about how easy formula feeding is when some babies on formula will have disabilities or be tube fed.
Fuck that ablest nonsense. How lovely your healthy baby was able to earth mama feed. Those whose babies lives were saved by formula don't appreciate your tone.

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:13

Bunnyfuller · 19/08/2022 20:07

Does it matter?.

speaking as someone who wouldn’t have kids if ff didn’t exist, why the fuck not? Tired of being made to feel second class because I couldn’t b/f, babies too small to piss around for weeks trying to make it happen. Why not celebrate the alternative?

@Bunnyfuller 100% this!

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:12

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 20:02

None of that requires an awareness month, just a MHS leaflet which I’m sure women get in pregnancy. Also all this information is entirely objective, and applies to every single baby on formula, and in the age of Google shouldn’t be hard to find. Whereas BF is practical, and the experience and issues will be different for every woman, MUCH more support is needed.

Actually, much more support is needed for both. I couldn't breastfeed (inverted nipple meant that baby could not and would not attach) and the help I had from the midwife was nothing short of shocking. I was always of the view that I would try breastfeeding but as soon as it became hard/stressful, then it would be straight onto FF and that's exactly what I did.

However, I knew nothing about FF. The post I have quoted is precisely the questions that I had. Luckily, I had my Mum and MIL who provided answers that were not on the tin or a leaflet which you are sure women get in pregnancy (I didn't).

Parker231 · 19/08/2022 20:12

I don’t see why you need a bf or ff month - just leave families to make their own decisions. I had no intention or interest in bf - was more than happy to use formula from day one. No guilt. Mn is the worst for creating guilt - am very glad it wasn’t around when DC’s were born.

Bunnyfuller · 19/08/2022 20:07

Does it matter?.

speaking as someone who wouldn’t have kids if ff didn’t exist, why the fuck not? Tired of being made to feel second class because I couldn’t b/f, babies too small to piss around for weeks trying to make it happen. Why not celebrate the alternative?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 20:03

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 19:54

I really don't understand the guilt around formula feeding... I know, in my own real life, only ~10 women that BF... I'm a bottle fed baby, my mum FF all four of her kids, I have 3 aunts and 14 uncles all married with kids that were all FF, all my cousins with babies FF, my older sister has 5 kids all FF and my younger sister has 3 kids all FF ... all my friends were FF as babies and those with kids of their own mostly FF (apart from about 10, and none stuck it out past 4 months and all eventually EFF).
I can say without one moment of hesitation that my mum, aunts, sisters or cousin never felt one onze of guilt or shame about formula. Not one of them ever considered breastfeeding, most of them think it's gross, my mum freaks tf out if I try to bf in front of her, my sisters are the same... we're Irish, our bf stats are prob lower than UK and it's just not a norm here. If anything I'm constantly having to justify why I choose to bf and put up with bunched up disgusted faces and "ew how could you do that?" remarks.

I have 3 DC, my oldest two were EBF to 6 months each before combi feeding and eventually EFF by 8/9 months, my youngest is only 7 weeks and is EBF. I'll prob combi feed at 6 months again. I have absolutely no problem with formula & felt zero guilt introducing formula when I did. I refuse to believe the majority or even a large minority of FF mothers feel guilt or shame, most FF because they want to & never wanted to bf and that's as good enough reason as any other as far as I'm concerned.

I think a FF awareness month is ridiculous, most mothers don't feel guilty bout feeding their babies formula & the argument that it's needed to promote safe instruction of bottle prep, I was preparing bottles for my little brother when I was 12, its not rocket science, instructions are on the tub 🙄

I BF my kids but I don’t get formula guilt either. I just wanna say to people who say they feel guilt “Own your choice FFS, because nobody else even cares how you feed your baby.”

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 20:02

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 19:38

@MolliciousIntent things that are not on the tin:

  • how to feed when you're travelling
  • what to do about sterilisation when you're out and about
  • warm or room temp milk?
  • prep machine or not?
  • types of bottle
  • volume to feed
  • responsive feeding/ on demand feeding
  • feeding positions
  • proper cleaning and sterilisation
  • how to deal with feeding strikes
  • teats and flow rates

I'm not saying it's as difficult or more difficult than breastfeeding, but it's still a minefield and support wouldn't go amiss.

Not everyone goes to NCT - I didn't - and NHS ante natal group provide no advice whatsoever. (Mine refused to offer any advice on c-section birth or epidural aswell!)

None of that requires an awareness month, just a MHS leaflet which I’m sure women get in pregnancy. Also all this information is entirely objective, and applies to every single baby on formula, and in the age of Google shouldn’t be hard to find. Whereas BF is practical, and the experience and issues will be different for every woman, MUCH more support is needed.

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 19:54

I really don't understand the guilt around formula feeding... I know, in my own real life, only ~10 women that BF... I'm a bottle fed baby, my mum FF all four of her kids, I have 3 aunts and 14 uncles all married with kids that were all FF, all my cousins with babies FF, my older sister has 5 kids all FF and my younger sister has 3 kids all FF ... all my friends were FF as babies and those with kids of their own mostly FF (apart from about 10, and none stuck it out past 4 months and all eventually EFF).
I can say without one moment of hesitation that my mum, aunts, sisters or cousin never felt one onze of guilt or shame about formula. Not one of them ever considered breastfeeding, most of them think it's gross, my mum freaks tf out if I try to bf in front of her, my sisters are the same... we're Irish, our bf stats are prob lower than UK and it's just not a norm here. If anything I'm constantly having to justify why I choose to bf and put up with bunched up disgusted faces and "ew how could you do that?" remarks.

I have 3 DC, my oldest two were EBF to 6 months each before combi feeding and eventually EFF by 8/9 months, my youngest is only 7 weeks and is EBF. I'll prob combi feed at 6 months again. I have absolutely no problem with formula & felt zero guilt introducing formula when I did. I refuse to believe the majority or even a large minority of FF mothers feel guilt or shame, most FF because they want to & never wanted to bf and that's as good enough reason as any other as far as I'm concerned.

I think a FF awareness month is ridiculous, most mothers don't feel guilty bout feeding their babies formula & the argument that it's needed to promote safe instruction of bottle prep, I was preparing bottles for my little brother when I was 12, its not rocket science, instructions are on the tub 🙄

WhereAreMyAirpods · 19/08/2022 19:43

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts

Funded by Cow and Gate, Nestle, Aptamil, Hipp, SMA....

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 19:38

@MolliciousIntent things that are not on the tin:

  • how to feed when you're travelling
  • what to do about sterilisation when you're out and about
  • warm or room temp milk?
  • prep machine or not?
  • types of bottle
  • volume to feed
  • responsive feeding/ on demand feeding
  • feeding positions
  • proper cleaning and sterilisation
  • how to deal with feeding strikes
  • teats and flow rates

I'm not saying it's as difficult or more difficult than breastfeeding, but it's still a minefield and support wouldn't go amiss.

Not everyone goes to NCT - I didn't - and NHS ante natal group provide no advice whatsoever. (Mine refused to offer any advice on c-section birth or epidural aswell!)

girlmom21 · 19/08/2022 19:34

MolliciousIntent · 19/08/2022 18:33

The thing I really don't get is people getting aggy about how there "isn't enough education on how to formula feed" when they're doing NCT etc. Just read the fucking tin! If you need educating on how to follow simple instructions you probably shouldn't be having a baby in the first place.

By that reckoning you shouldn't have a baby if you can't establish breastfeeding without any help because it's natural and should be instinctive.

As it is neither of those things are as easy as they should be and we should be supporting mothers, not sneering at them.

XSnoe · 19/08/2022 19:03

Establishing breastfeeding is considerable harder than whipping up formula. If you didn't click this, then I guess we do need breastfeeding week after all

Not for all women. I found making up bottles more faff.

BattenburgDonkey · 19/08/2022 18:55

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 18:44

Perhaps because many women face problems and barriers breastfeeding and don’t know the answer to fix it because there’s nothing written on our tits.

Yiud have ti be exceptionally stupid to get the tin instructions wrong.

But it isn’t just about the tin instructions,
those are simple. A lot of people don’t realise it’s not recommended to pre make formula bottles now, or that different teats have different flow rates which can be helpful information if your baby throws up a lot/has colic, guzzles or has a weak sucking reflex (like my youngest did due to prematurity, she was combi fed), that feeding the baby in different positions can help with winding. Then there’s which options are best for sterilising bottles, how to do it properly. It’s not just about the bottle or the breast, it’s about feeding the baby and making that advice accessible to anyone to needs it, even if they are ‘stupid’ according to some on this thread.

BattenburgDonkey · 19/08/2022 18:50

MolliciousIntent · 19/08/2022 18:46

...seriously? Breastfeeding successfully is a skill that the vast majority of mums and babies need at least a little bit of support to acquire. Positioning, latch, supply support, draining blocked ducts etc etc...

I absolutely agree, but the poster recons there’s absolutely nothing to formula feeding other than reading the can which just isn’t true for a lot of people, implying those people who could do with a few extra pointers shouldn’t even have children is exactly the type of formula shaming others have mentioned. If people see a need for both months and even combi feeding months then why not just let people have it?

Bejeweled · 19/08/2022 18:47

By that logic why would you need a breastfeeding month either? Doesn’t even require instructions on a tin.

Establishing breastfeeding is considerable harder than whipping up formula. If you didn't click this, then I guess we do need breastfeeding week after all😂

CloudCatz · 19/08/2022 18:46

I don't think we need either.

MolliciousIntent · 19/08/2022 18:46

BattenburgDonkey · 19/08/2022 18:41

By that logic why would you need a breastfeeding month either? Doesn’t even require instructions on a tin.

...seriously? Breastfeeding successfully is a skill that the vast majority of mums and babies need at least a little bit of support to acquire. Positioning, latch, supply support, draining blocked ducts etc etc...

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 18:44

BattenburgDonkey · 19/08/2022 18:41

By that logic why would you need a breastfeeding month either? Doesn’t even require instructions on a tin.

Perhaps because many women face problems and barriers breastfeeding and don’t know the answer to fix it because there’s nothing written on our tits.

Yiud have ti be exceptionally stupid to get the tin instructions wrong.

70billionthnamechange · 19/08/2022 18:44

Don't need either