Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:48

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:56

The main manufacturers of formula are

Nestle
Danone SA
Reckitt benckiser
Abott
Kraft Heinz
HiPP GmbH

This is who we mean by formula companies. And yes they make a fucking fortune off of formula.

I dont think formula needs advertising any more than it already is, even though I dont disagree with formula feeding and am totally impartial to how others feed their baby

You don’t sound impartial at all…

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 20:48

Bejeweled · 19/08/2022 20:32

I'm sure FF mums do face twattish comments but after doing both, this has been my experience.

Being asked to go upstairs in the presence of male relatives, and being accused of neglect for undernourishment (genuine nonsense to put me off doing it) stand out. Nobody ever commented when I FF.

I've done both too I ebf to 6 months & then combi fed, no one ever batted an eyelid or made any remarks at all about me FF and funny enough I didn't need help regarding getting started, prep instruction were on the formula tub, I tried a few bottles to find which suited my kids, DD1 like Tommy tippee & DD2 got on best with Dr. Brown. I knew how to wash bottles and Steriliser came with instructions ... anything I was unsure of I googled the guidelines ...

I found bf harder, more intense, but I'm fortunate I got on well with both bf & ff, my major hurdle with bf was feeding out and about, firstly getting over my own reservation/nerves and then dealing with others being uncomfortable by me feeding.

bakewellbride · 19/08/2022 20:48

@Wouldloveanother on tv.

girlmom21 · 19/08/2022 20:47

Dajeeling · 19/08/2022 20:46

God this is such a small stage of life… once you get out of the baby bubble seriously no one gives a shit either way.

But when you're in the baby bubble it's really bloody hard. And lots of women choose not to have a second baby because they found feeding the first too difficult.

Some women feel the psychological effects of their feeding struggles long after their babies have stopped needing breast or formula milk.

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:47

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:44

Is anyone else confused about this malign intent bordering on conspiracy that MN posters ascribe to formula companies?

They sell a product. Of course they would be pleased at the prospect of selling more of it. But it’s an individual’s choice whether to buy it or not. So what’s the issue? If there was no formula, how many babies would be dead? It isn’t Diet Coke.

@Wouldloveanother It baffles me too. Though, many things on this site do...

Dajeeling · 19/08/2022 20:46

God this is such a small stage of life… once you get out of the baby bubble seriously no one gives a shit either way.

girlmom21 · 19/08/2022 20:45

The thing is midwives and health visitors don't even need to promote formula feeding. They just need to be allowed to support women who formula feed.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:44

Hugasauras · 19/08/2022 09:48

And yes I bet the formula companies would be rubbing their hands in glee! Probably a FF company shill who sowed the seed for the idea in the first place on social media or something.

Is anyone else confused about this malign intent bordering on conspiracy that MN posters ascribe to formula companies?

They sell a product. Of course they would be pleased at the prospect of selling more of it. But it’s an individual’s choice whether to buy it or not. So what’s the issue? If there was no formula, how many babies would be dead? It isn’t Diet Coke.

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:44

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:40

Google would have cleared it up easily, midwives aren’t allowed to be seen to promote/help with formula feeding, if it helps I got jack shit help from them with breastfeeding either

@Navigatingnewwaters It didn't clear it up easily though as there was so much conflicting advice. This could have been avoided if MWs were allowed to promote FFing aswell as BFing.

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 20:42

Some useful formula questions I would have benefitted from...
Which milks are halal, vegan, vegetarians above but add in milk allergy
That the NHS do not consider pumping to have the same benefits as breastfeeding so after all that effort you basically are considered to have formula fed
Why some babies find even formula feeding difficult and are these red flags
How much formula is ok, if you have a baby that just won't feed.
As for it being easier, I have a notepad full of mathematical calculations for FF because of the difficulties we had with it.
And yes, the stigma absolutely does exist. Pregnant with my second and despite severe pnd and use of domperidone, tears and all the rest, the midwife heard my story, which will be one of the sadder ones and decided to still push breast is best at me.

Parker231 · 19/08/2022 20:42

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:27

No we don’t need a formula feeding month, yes breastfeeding is better, no formula isn’t poison and we are lucky to have a decent alternative but it doesn’t need a month of promotion, it should be there for those who can’t breastfeed and there shouldn’t be a stigma surrounding that but it is a product and a month celebrating it is simply product placement

Why not for formula feeding - some of us positively chose formula - had no idea whether I could have bf but I’d never made up a bottle before so some support would have helped.

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:42

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 20:33

It all you needed to do was Google those questions and the information is there.

Whereas inverted nipple (been there!) is much trickier and needs a person who actually knows what they’re doing to sit with you to get it right.

One I can do on my phone and the other I can’t.

Its not a competition of course but I don’t think we should ever try and claim that both are exactly as hard as the other to establish.

I also think that people assume others need support to FF because they dont use cooled boiled water sometimes, for example, when making a feed. when in fact people know exactly how they’re supposed to formula feed but are happy to take short cuts, so to speak, because the risk of harm coming to a baby of you add cold water to formula and heat it up is still pretty low.

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet If that's the case, all the techniques, positions etc that are relevant to BFing are all on Google too, handed out in leaflets throughout pregnancy etc so why do we need a BF week? Going by your way of thinking, all of that is quickly done through Google?

It is a competition. Many FF mothers feel that BFing is the only way to go as that is what they've had drummed into them. Many FFing mothers feel that they are failing because again, BFing is drummed into them as 'being the best'. I'm not saying BFing mothers don't have struggles, they do - but please don't dismiss the struggles that FFing mothers have too.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:42

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 19/08/2022 09:45

In the last infant feeding survey in 2010, 12%(!!!!!) of babies were exclusively breastfed at 4 months. I imagine there will be a few anomalies where babies are incorrectly given cows milk (or early weaned), but this means a huge amount of babies are having formula. Given that the main beneficiaries of a formula feeding month will be the formula companies, it seems an absolutely absurd idea.

Not really true.

Just one sip of formula (often given in the first day or two to help clear jaundice before milk comes in) means a baby doesn’t count as ‘EBF’. One poster on here said her baby had one bottle of formula in the hospital then was EBF for 3 years, and even she wouldn’t count as far as the statistics are concerned.

if you’re counting babies that are still being breastfed at certain ages but have had formula at some point, or mix fed, the statistics are a lot better:

The rate of any breastfeeding at six weeks was 55% (rising from 48% in 2005), while at six months it was 34% (rising from 25% in 2005). These improvements coincided with a marked increase in engagement with the Baby Friendly Initiative.

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:40

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:36

@Navigatingnewwaters I had many questions that the midwife simply would not answer.

  • What bottles to use? What teats to use? How to store the bottles? How to clean and sterilise them properly? How to FF when travelling around?
They are just some of the very basic ones. Thankfully, my Mum and MIL were on hand to help. However, some women don't have that luxury.

Google would have cleared it up easily, midwives aren’t allowed to be seen to promote/help with formula feeding, if it helps I got jack shit help from them with breastfeeding either

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:38

bakewellbride · 19/08/2022 09:37

I'm against the idea of a 'formula feeding month'. Formula feeding is something that's absolutely everywhere in our society already. The majority of mums in this country do it, it's advertised everywhere and it's in every shop.

I'm breastfeeding and have only ever breastfed but have experienced a lot of pressure throughout my journey to bottle feed from many different angles. Formula feeding month really would be the icing on the cake.

where is it advertised, given it’s illegal to do so? 🤔

MrsSkylerWhite · 19/08/2022 20:38

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · Today 10:54
MsPincher I object to MrsSkylerWhite 's argument that posters are not entitled to an opinion unless they are negatively effected. That is a really dangerous argument to bow down to no matter what the topic is.@LilacSky95”

I object to you having an opinion about how other mother’s feed their babies. It’s none of your business.
The whatever the subject is argument is BS. How an individual feeds their child has no impact on you whatsoever.
I bf, if it’s at all relevant. It probably isn’t.

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:36

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:30

What help do you feel is necessary?

@Navigatingnewwaters I had many questions that the midwife simply would not answer.

  • What bottles to use? What teats to use? How to store the bottles? How to clean and sterilise them properly? How to FF when travelling around?
They are just some of the very basic ones. Thankfully, my Mum and MIL were on hand to help. However, some women don't have that luxury.
Hoowhoowho · 19/08/2022 20:35

I actually could see the use of a government sponsored formula feeding month.
clear unambiguous information
eg


  • all first stage formula is fine for one year

  • Perfect prep machine- yes or no

  • do formula fed babies need water?

it would be a space for evidence based information on infant feeding which is actually sorely lacking.
Could make it Baby feeding month and do the same for starting solids. A regular dose of updated evidence based information would be beneficial for everyone.

workiskillingme · 19/08/2022 20:35

My birthday is international creme brûlée day.
Yes there is an I'm living for it

hewouldwouldnthe · 19/08/2022 20:35

Course it's unnecessary. Formula feeding is simple and needs no support. Open a bottle and feed. End off. Influencers are another name for pointless individuals

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 20:34

Lol at FFsrs being second class!

Laws werent brought in to protect FFers because they were being discriminated against.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 20:33

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:12

Actually, much more support is needed for both. I couldn't breastfeed (inverted nipple meant that baby could not and would not attach) and the help I had from the midwife was nothing short of shocking. I was always of the view that I would try breastfeeding but as soon as it became hard/stressful, then it would be straight onto FF and that's exactly what I did.

However, I knew nothing about FF. The post I have quoted is precisely the questions that I had. Luckily, I had my Mum and MIL who provided answers that were not on the tin or a leaflet which you are sure women get in pregnancy (I didn't).

It all you needed to do was Google those questions and the information is there.

Whereas inverted nipple (been there!) is much trickier and needs a person who actually knows what they’re doing to sit with you to get it right.

One I can do on my phone and the other I can’t.

Its not a competition of course but I don’t think we should ever try and claim that both are exactly as hard as the other to establish.

I also think that people assume others need support to FF because they dont use cooled boiled water sometimes, for example, when making a feed. when in fact people know exactly how they’re supposed to formula feed but are happy to take short cuts, so to speak, because the risk of harm coming to a baby of you add cold water to formula and heat it up is still pretty low.

Bejeweled · 19/08/2022 20:32

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 20:20

"Second class" is a little dramatic, your not segregated or stripped of your right to vote ffs... doubt you've ever even been asked to cover your baby's head while feeding or had friends/family sugest you go home/into a separate room/ or sit on the public toilet to feed your baby 🙄or had it suggested by well meaning staff that you might be "more comfortable" in the parent & baby room that smells like dirty Nappies....FF mums have never been secluded or hidden away

I'm sure FF mums do face twattish comments but after doing both, this has been my experience.

Being asked to go upstairs in the presence of male relatives, and being accused of neglect for undernourishment (genuine nonsense to put me off doing it) stand out. Nobody ever commented when I FF.

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:30

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:24

'Second Class' isn't being dramatic - it's reality for many FF mothers. All through pregnancy, it's heavily put on mothers to be that 'Breast is Best' with no talk whatsoever about formula feeding. You ask for help, you're given no help but many talks on BF and how it's 'best for the baby'. Hmm

What help do you feel is necessary?

DreamToNightmare · 19/08/2022 20:30

Formula feeding is not allowed to be advertised or promoted so I’m not sure how a Formula Feeding month would work….