Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 21:50

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 21:45

And how do we know rates of breastfeeding are low in the UK? The latest data is a decade old and numbers were climbing then

You really think that it has changed much in just a decade? The fact that formula companies are making more money than ever tells you everything you need to know. They make money off the back of women not BFing.

When you say shamed in public what do you mean?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 21:48

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 21:42

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet theres only so much breastfeeding advice that can be given, there’s no golden bullet and sometimes you can exhaust everything and it doesn’t work out and nobody knows why. Most of the routine advice can be given online.

Which is why so much physical support is needed rather than just going ‘oh well what can be done, off to Google you go!’.

Getting BF right isn’t a case of being objective.

Getting FF right is.

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 21:45

And how do we know rates of breastfeeding are low in the UK? The latest data is a decade old and numbers were climbing then

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 21:44

Whilst I don't feel strongly about a formula feeding month, i do strongly believe there is a need for more advice and support for bottle feeding parents.

It's so saddening to read so many comments here brushing off real people who have said they would appreciate more support. If real women are telling you they couldn't get the information they needed from Google, that their health visitors and midwives were not allowed to give advice or support, that they were shamed in public (as I was by two strangers) and that they suffered guilt, depression and anguish - why isn't that reason enough?

No one is denying the challenges breastfeeding mothers face or wanting to strip away or divert support, but you don't have to brush aside one demographic to support another.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 21:42

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet theres only so much breastfeeding advice that can be given, there’s no golden bullet and sometimes you can exhaust everything and it doesn’t work out and nobody knows why. Most of the routine advice can be given online.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 21:38

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:42

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet If that's the case, all the techniques, positions etc that are relevant to BFing are all on Google too, handed out in leaflets throughout pregnancy etc so why do we need a BF week? Going by your way of thinking, all of that is quickly done through Google?

It is a competition. Many FF mothers feel that BFing is the only way to go as that is what they've had drummed into them. Many FFing mothers feel that they are failing because again, BFing is drummed into them as 'being the best'. I'm not saying BFing mothers don't have struggles, they do - but please don't dismiss the struggles that FFing mothers have too.

No, something that needs physical and practical support cannot be done through Google.

Also BF rates in this country are abysmally low. It’s also about raising awareness of the benefits, support (which is shit but anyway), resources and reasons to BF. On a population health level it’s in the interest of NHS/Government to support and promote BF. Meaning it’s not in their interest to promote FF. not that it needs prompting anyway!

namechangetheworld · 19/08/2022 21:33

I think it's a great idea. There are so many mothers out there who feel pressured to start/continue breastfeeding, usually to the detriment of their own mental health, and it might reassure them that there's a perfectly acceptable alternative out there.

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 21:17

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 21:15

I think the every mother can bf and every infant can too bullshit should go for a start.
It's hard not to blame yourself if you are being bombarded by messages of it just takes time. Nope. Seven months trying. Just try x holds etc. Work through the pain, all mums produce enough milk etc.

Whoever says every Mother/Baby can is a idiot

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 21:15

I think the every mother can bf and every infant can too bullshit should go for a start.
It's hard not to blame yourself if you are being bombarded by messages of it just takes time. Nope. Seven months trying. Just try x holds etc. Work through the pain, all mums produce enough milk etc.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 21:15

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 21:10

Newborn formula (i.e the only formula babies need) isn't but they get round it by advertising completely unnecessary 'follow on' formula. And the adverts all say 'if you're thinking of moving on' as if it is a necessary thing to do. They also show babies that often look younger than 6 months and feed them in a newborn hold. They do try their best to advertise formula feeding of babies of any age. Whether you agree with that or not it is against the law.

I have never once seen an advert like that. Over 1s should still be drinking milk anyway, and even bfing mums give their kids dairy in some form. I really don’t understand what the issue is. I find this ‘shut down any advertising, let’s pretend formula doesn’t exist, the companies are out to get you’ to be really controlling.

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 21:13

Bunnyfuller · 19/08/2022 21:12

I found the main group to make me feel second class for ff was other mums - as this thread is confirming

It doesn’t make anyone second class, I have 3 and the one I swapped on to formula doesn’t stand out in anyway 😄

MarmadukeSpillageEsquire · 19/08/2022 21:12

AdamRyan · 19/08/2022 09:37

Breastfeeding month is necessary - too many people still see it as somehow sexual/disgusting/shameful for women to breastfeed in public and so breastfeeding mums can feel pressure to stay at home. More needs to be done to normalise it and make it so it's an unremarkable act - as unremarkable as a woman giving a baby a bottle when out and about.

I don't think formula feeding families have that issue, so a national formula month isn't needed. Also like others said it would be a gift for marketing. Can't see Amy positives to it really.

I was formula fed and I formula feed. I agree with you.

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 21:12

There is a lot of misinformation though, I remember watching a programme about teen mums and one of them choose SMA as she’d heard it was powdered breast milk and she wanted the best for her baby

Bunnyfuller · 19/08/2022 21:12

I found the main group to make me feel second class for ff was other mums - as this thread is confirming

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 21:10

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:49

Which newborn formula is advertised on TV?

Newborn formula (i.e the only formula babies need) isn't but they get round it by advertising completely unnecessary 'follow on' formula. And the adverts all say 'if you're thinking of moving on' as if it is a necessary thing to do. They also show babies that often look younger than 6 months and feed them in a newborn hold. They do try their best to advertise formula feeding of babies of any age. Whether you agree with that or not it is against the law.

bakewellbride · 19/08/2022 21:08

@Wouldloveanother that wasn't your question, you didn't specify newborn. I'm so sorry for the misunderstanding! I agree you're quite right - I think that's not allowed.

Every mum obviously feels differently but to me the countless formula adverts do add to the whole 'formula is everywhere and the norm and breastfeeding is not' thing. To me this effect is achieved whatever age babies the milk in the ads is for as it's just another way that formula is promoted and breastfeeding is not so it feels unequal. I respect that plenty of others would disagree though.

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 21:02

isadoradancing123 · 19/08/2022 21:00

We most certainly did not need a breast feeding month

I’d be inclined to agree with this too, I think the money would be better spent providing better antenatal and postnatal care for all.

isadoradancing123 · 19/08/2022 21:00

We most certainly did not need a breast feeding month

DocsandSocks · 19/08/2022 20:57

Bejeweled · 19/08/2022 20:52

@DocsandSocks

Don't most FF mums choose to do so? I don't see how anyone can say they feel like they're failing (at what?) if you chose it.

If breastfeeding is so easy, they could just use Google.. in reality it's not so straightforward because it involves your physical body. Generic advice only goes so far whereas formula instructions are pretty hard to fluff up.

Not having a go, btw. Seems like mums sometimes their own biggest critics. I don't get the whole failure and guilt stuff.

@Bejeweled A lot of Mum's do choose to FF and some simply do it because they have no other option. I think what people are trying to say (me included) is that nobody should be made to feel guilty for the way they feed their child.

It isn't straightforward to breastfeed but I disagree that FF is hard to 'fluff up' too. I had so many questions, so many doubts, so many 'what ifs' with regards to FF that midwives didn't (couldn't) help me with. Don't get me wrong, I had mostly lovely MVs who were very helpful but no with feeding which is the thing I struggled the most with.

I know you're not having a go Smile Mum's are their own biggest critics but this could be helped with more information etc.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:56

so I BF for 8 months and bottle fed for 4.

I needed more help with bottle feeding than breastfeeding. Mistakes I made because I thought ‘surely it’s just shoving powder and water in a bottle and feeding the baby?’:

  1. I didn’t get why it was taking DD SO long to finish her bottle. Turns out I had the wrong size teat. I thought they were all the same. Who know 🤷🏼‍♀️
  2. I didn’t know how long a bottle was good for after making it up, I would Chuck it away instantly if she didn’t drink it all. Turns out it would’ve been fine for an hour or so after.
  3. I didn’t know that her poo would look a bit different and panicked 🤦🏼‍♀️
  4. I didn’t know ‘paced’ bottle feeding would be better for a baby that had extended reflux
i could go on really. But yes, more awareness of correct bottle feeding procedure is needed.
Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:55

Oh and when I went over to FF the only person that shamed me was me.

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/08/2022 20:52

Parker231 · 19/08/2022 20:42

Why not for formula feeding - some of us positively chose formula - had no idea whether I could have bf but I’d never made up a bottle before so some support would have helped.

Why would you actively choose it with no reason? I gave up BF with my first due to OBD, lack of support and a feeling of being out of control, it was the right decision at the time and I’d choose it again given the same set of circumstances. No one showed me how to make up bottles either but it really isn’t the same thing to get to grips with.

Bejeweled · 19/08/2022 20:52

@DocsandSocks

Don't most FF mums choose to do so? I don't see how anyone can say they feel like they're failing (at what?) if you chose it.

If breastfeeding is so easy, they could just use Google.. in reality it's not so straightforward because it involves your physical body. Generic advice only goes so far whereas formula instructions are pretty hard to fluff up.

Not having a go, btw. Seems like mums sometimes their own biggest critics. I don't get the whole failure and guilt stuff.

Theneverendingtories · 19/08/2022 20:50

It all seems daft and quite the carry on .Who cares how anyone feeds their kid so long as it’s fed. And if anyone needs a month of awareness then that’s just showing that clear advice isn’t found easy enough. Mums should research how to do both and be prepared to do both before baby arrives if they are in any doubt at all about the method they’ll use. And there should be zero stigma or persuasion either way . It’s just a few months of a child’s life that will have no effect on them when they are older and chugging beer with their uni mates so just do what’s easier for mum at that time. It’s a personal choice that’s all . Months of awareness / support make me cringe tbh. Publish solid , concise advice online and people can go there for what they need .

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 20:49

bakewellbride · 19/08/2022 20:48

@Wouldloveanother on tv.

Which newborn formula is advertised on TV?