Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 23:06

Dajeeling · 19/08/2022 23:03

Well just formula feed then- no-one cares, the only judgement around it is your own. Honestly I just see this as creating problems for the sake of it. I’ve had 3 myself, I don’t understand all the angst and never will.

if nobody cares why has a breastfeeding mum started up a thread specifically to say mums making a different feeding choice shouldnt have their own month raising awareness?

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 23:05

Hv, go, lactation consultant, midwife. All regularly judged and commented for seven months and I was actively trying to bf.
Id hate to see what they'd do if you just went straight to FF.

Lack of empathy astounding.

Somethingsnappy · 19/08/2022 23:05

No, we don't don't need a FF month, but we do definitely need to acknowledge that parents who choose/need to use formula also need support and advice. The newborn days can be so hard. Deliberately trying to make it harder for mothers to FF, doesn't and won't improve BF rates anyway. It just adds a touch of unnecessary misery to the difficult early days and weeks, I would imagine.

Dajeeling · 19/08/2022 23:03

girlmom21 · 19/08/2022 20:47

But when you're in the baby bubble it's really bloody hard. And lots of women choose not to have a second baby because they found feeding the first too difficult.

Some women feel the psychological effects of their feeding struggles long after their babies have stopped needing breast or formula milk.

Well just formula feed then- no-one cares, the only judgement around it is your own. Honestly I just see this as creating problems for the sake of it. I’ve had 3 myself, I don’t understand all the angst and never will.

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 23:00

Faciadipasta · 19/08/2022 22:55

Thanks for your kind words @DobbyHasASock I'm sorry you experienced similar. Im finding all the minimising on this thread of why people might need support with FF really upsetting

Yes, I find this particular topic seems to attract people who think because they were lucky and able to bf they are somehow qualified to say it's easy for everyone.
I.e dicks.
I find it very triggering but feel I need to say something because we're largely voiceless and people chose to ignore the inconvenient details like illness, disability, pnd etc.

Faciadipasta · 19/08/2022 22:55

Thanks for your kind words @DobbyHasASock I'm sorry you experienced similar. Im finding all the minimising on this thread of why people might need support with FF really upsetting

Scottishskifun · 19/08/2022 22:54

I don't think you need a FF month as others say it will just be used by companies for promotion which they aren't allowed to do for first milks.

I understand the point of bf month it's because rates are low and many women before bf feel self conscious about it and many have been subjected to comments or worse.

I personally believe that supported is best. That a mum has the required help whatever she chooses sadly this doesn't happen.

I've been in baby groups and many ff mums straight away feel the need to defend their reasons for bottle feeding when I start bf. I mostly fins it sad that they feel they need to explain when I haven't said anything. My usual response is I have no idea how you do it I am so disorganised I would never leave the house and would have a screaming baby constantly from getting timings wrong!

I've found that can help put minds at ease and soften any nervousness and it's completely true I would completely suck at it!

Girlmama · 19/08/2022 22:48

So many comments on here saying 'not to promote formula feeding but......'
Why not 'promote' formula feeding as a perfectly normal way to feed a child? And OP this vey much sounds like trying to engage breast v bottle

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 22:37

Faciadipasta · 19/08/2022 22:31

The lack of help for FF and the push for BF as the ONLY acceptable way to feed is absolutely negligent.
I had twins. I breastfed them for 5 months. Have you ever tried to BF twins? There is no way to do it discreetly. You have to lift your entire top. My babies both lost so much weight by day 7 we were sent to A and E who told me I HAD to give them a bottle or they would been to be admitted. But they couldn't provide formula, that's not allowed. So we had to find an open supermarket at 10.30pm. I combined fed for 3 days, they regained the weight and the HV told me to stop FF. They lost weight again, I saw lactation Consultants, was on domperidone for months. We had both of them privately fixed for tbeir tongue tie. I had to weight them before each breast feed, them weight them each afterwards, and calculate how much more formula they needed based on grams of weight gain. Every 2 hours. And pump after each feed. Throughout the night too.
I couldn't leave the house. I was bullied by every health visitor and midwife I saw into believing if I didn't do this insane ritual my babies would somehow be harmed. I developed PND. Every other mum I knew bar 1 who had babies at the same time BF and I felt awful to even WANT to quit even though it was dragging me into a dark hole of despair. I know PP see saying FF is the norm but I guarantee in my peer group it London it absolutely isn't.
And I kept this up for 5 FUCKING LONG DARK BLACK TRAPPED MONTHS because of all the pressure.
When 1 of my babies was blue lighted to hospital with bronchiolitis at 5 months I literally broke down to the pediatrician saying it must be my fault because I hadn't managed to EBF and was having to do formula top ups.
The pediatrician sat me down and told me this was crazy. It would not have made a blind bit of difference and it was fine to switch to formula right away if I wanted to.
I did that day. The only thing I regret was not doing it sooner. It took over my life and stopped me bonding with my babies in the early months.
I still get anxiety if I think back to those awful days.
So while I totally agree with their being a need for more BF help and promotion, the bullies who constantly shove "breast is best" down new mums throats or decide that midwives aren't allowed to give impartial help with FF can fuck off.

I don't have twins but I relate so much to that and so much is similar to my experience.
You are not alone in feeling like this and I especially relate to being dragged back into that put even though feeding is behind us now.
I think it's great someone in the NHS eventually told the truth, though it's a shame they could have saved you so much pain by admitting it earlier.
Flowers

Hshhshsh · 19/08/2022 22:37

Hugasauras · 19/08/2022 09:45

Yeah I think it's nonsense. We know formula feeding is already more common in breastfeeding in lots of areas so it's not like people need encouraged to do so, and it doesn't have the same difficulties in getting established or emotional/physical impact etc that breastfeeding does. I'm not sure why anyone needs support or raising awareness of putting powder and hot water in a bottle and then in baby's mouth 🤷‍♀️

Haha so true

Faciadipasta · 19/08/2022 22:31

The lack of help for FF and the push for BF as the ONLY acceptable way to feed is absolutely negligent.
I had twins. I breastfed them for 5 months. Have you ever tried to BF twins? There is no way to do it discreetly. You have to lift your entire top. My babies both lost so much weight by day 7 we were sent to A and E who told me I HAD to give them a bottle or they would been to be admitted. But they couldn't provide formula, that's not allowed. So we had to find an open supermarket at 10.30pm. I combined fed for 3 days, they regained the weight and the HV told me to stop FF. They lost weight again, I saw lactation Consultants, was on domperidone for months. We had both of them privately fixed for tbeir tongue tie. I had to weight them before each breast feed, them weight them each afterwards, and calculate how much more formula they needed based on grams of weight gain. Every 2 hours. And pump after each feed. Throughout the night too.
I couldn't leave the house. I was bullied by every health visitor and midwife I saw into believing if I didn't do this insane ritual my babies would somehow be harmed. I developed PND. Every other mum I knew bar 1 who had babies at the same time BF and I felt awful to even WANT to quit even though it was dragging me into a dark hole of despair. I know PP see saying FF is the norm but I guarantee in my peer group it London it absolutely isn't.
And I kept this up for 5 FUCKING LONG DARK BLACK TRAPPED MONTHS because of all the pressure.
When 1 of my babies was blue lighted to hospital with bronchiolitis at 5 months I literally broke down to the pediatrician saying it must be my fault because I hadn't managed to EBF and was having to do formula top ups.
The pediatrician sat me down and told me this was crazy. It would not have made a blind bit of difference and it was fine to switch to formula right away if I wanted to.
I did that day. The only thing I regret was not doing it sooner. It took over my life and stopped me bonding with my babies in the early months.
I still get anxiety if I think back to those awful days.
So while I totally agree with their being a need for more BF help and promotion, the bullies who constantly shove "breast is best" down new mums throats or decide that midwives aren't allowed to give impartial help with FF can fuck off.

namechangetheworld · 19/08/2022 22:23

MolliciousIntent · 19/08/2022 18:33

The thing I really don't get is people getting aggy about how there "isn't enough education on how to formula feed" when they're doing NCT etc. Just read the fucking tin! If you need educating on how to follow simple instructions you probably shouldn't be having a baby in the first place.

If you can't comprehend some of the problems that formula feeding mothers might face, both practical and emotional, then you must have a serious lack of imagination and empathy. Telling a FF mother to "read the fucking tin" is the same as telling a BF mother "just stick your fucking tit in the kid's mouth."

There's a myriad of conflicting, and dangerously inorrect, advice out there regarding formula feeding, especially online. For a worried young mother with no real life support that's very hard. I would sit in tears fretting over whether I was using the right formula, whether the teats were too big for the baby, whether I was keeping the bottles out for too long, whilst my midwife simply shrugged at me. With a huge poster promoting a fucking breastfeeding cafe plastered on the wall behind her.^^

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 22:16

But I have FF I said in my earlier reply I FF both my older kids from 6 months

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 22:05

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 22:03

My earlier reply stated why I don't think formula feeding needs awareness ... its simply because its already the norm .. you could read my earlier reply, its on page 8 but people were asking why should bf get a month and not ff so I was addressing why bf needs more awareness

But you haven’t formula fed so what right to you have to suggest it should be taken away from others? You don’t ‘know’ what they need because you haven’t done it.

DobbyHasASock · 19/08/2022 22:05

Every hv, every midwife and every GP for me. A lactation consultant, private, too.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 22:04

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 22:01

@Wouldloveanother I totally agree. It blows my mind that healthcare professionals absolutely point blank refuse to provide advice that keeps babies safely fed . It felt negligent to me.

It is negligent! I see no reason why there can’t be more information about correct formula feeding whilst also supporting and highlighting the benefits of breastfeeding. It isn’t either/or. And I’m stumped as to how some posters on here support ‘women’s right to choose how to feed’ yet feel they should be nudged to the ‘right’ decision by withholding information from them.

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 22:03

My earlier reply stated why I don't think formula feeding needs awareness ... its simply because its already the norm .. you could read my earlier reply, its on page 8 but people were asking why should bf get a month and not ff so I was addressing why bf needs more awareness

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 22:01

@Wouldloveanother I totally agree. It blows my mind that healthcare professionals absolutely point blank refuse to provide advice that keeps babies safely fed . It felt negligent to me.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 21:58

To add to that, it wouldn’t be about ‘making formula feeding socially acceptable’ it would be about answering all the questions mums have about bottle feeding which midwives and health visitors currently refuse to answer. Like the ones in my post upthread.

Tuxedokitty · 19/08/2022 21:57

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet I had a woman come up to me in cafe Nero when I was bottle feeding my baby and shout at me that I should at least try to breastfeed and that I was letting my baby down. I had a man approach me on a bench and tell me it was not natural to use a bottle. Oh I also had a pair of acquaintances in a restaurant tell me in front of a group say that they don't know why any educated woman would ever not breastfeed.

I have to keep repeating that this does not detract from the challenges breastfeeding women face, but does contradict the many comments here claiming that formula feeders face no stigma. No matter what you do, you're subject to people's judgement .

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 21:56

My point is bf awareness is needed

But that’s not the topic of this thread. The topic is whether there should be a formula feeding awareness month. The OP (who I assume doesn’t FF) has gone out of her way to say there shouldn’t be. So it’s the bfing mother’s feeling invalidated here and interfering in something that’s not to do with them.

Tandora · 19/08/2022 21:56

gatehouseoffleet · 19/08/2022 09:32

Some of us didn't choose how to feed our babies - maybe we need a "how to feed your baby any old how so s/he doesn't die" month?

The bottle versus breast debate is very tedious and yet another example of trying to tell women what to do because they're too stupid to make decisions for themselves.

Love this post ❤️

Skittlesthough · 19/08/2022 21:54

Here's the thing though so many FF mothers take offence to bf promotion like it's about them, it isn't aimed at you and it isn't a dig at you.

The first time I ever bf in public was in a large cafe, late afternoon. The cafe was mostly empty and I choose a corner booth at the very back, with loads of empty tables around it. My DD was crying/hungry, I put on my bf scarf and began to feed her looking around to make sure no one could see, not that there was anything to see I was fully covered. I began to relax and was eating a sandwich. The booth was beside the bathrooms. An older woman approached to use the bathroom, she spotted me and leaned in and told me "you know they have rooms for doing that" I said I was fine and she bunched up her nose and said "but people are eating and don't want to see it" I was mortified, I was only 18 and hadn't been out of the house in 3 months long enough to need to feed in public, I had built myself up and told myself no one would say anything but in that moment I wished I was invisible. I stopped feeding and quickly left, for the next 3 months I scheduled any necessary trips out of the house around DDs feeding schedule, I felt utterly trapped and secluded and depressed. I was diagnosed with pnd at 6 months and switched to combi feeding so I could get out of the house more.
With DD2 I was armed with breast pump so I'd never have to feed publicly but I still barely left the house just incase and began combi feeding at 6 months again.
I've had friends and family so uncomfortable with bf that they'd only pop round if baby wasn't due a feed and if I needed to feed while they were there they'd leave the room or say they had to go. If I was in my mums house and DD fussed she'd immediately direct me to an empty room. I dealt with so many backhanded "questions" asking why I would bf, from people who thought it was disgusting or why I wouldn't just give her a bottle, was told I was looking for attention by being awkward/difficult by choosing a method that made everyone else uncomfortable when it wasn't necessary.
I'm in my 30's now with dd3 she's 7 weeks old and again ebf, I've already had a friend suggest we meet for coffee when I've weaned dd3 off bf, cause god forbid I take a bf baby with me to a cafe and do that in public.

My point is bf awareness is needed because at the moment it's still seen as shameful, something that needs to be hidden away and not seen. The more the public is exposed to bf as a norm the less uncomfortable they'll be when they see it. The breast is best campaign not only encourages women to try to bf but also, hopefully, educates the public as a whole about why a woman would choose to breastfeed and drums the message that it is normal and not something to be hidden away, even my mum is starting to come round to it, never thought I'd see it lol, she still gets uncomfortables seeing it but she's at least more encouraging and understanding than she was 13 years ago and that's largely due to these bf campaign's. Ff mums are not the target of bf campaigns, & it's so odd to me that people that claim to have wanted to bf but unfortunately could not would then take offense to something that promotes bf acceptance and prevents mothers being made to feel ashamed to feed their babies. If your breastfeeding journey had gone differently and it worked out would you still be defensive about efforts made to help normalise breastfeeding?

namechangetheworld · 19/08/2022 21:51

Also, it would be SO helpful in promoting safe and effective formula feeding to new parents. There's so much conflicting information out there about things like pre-making bottles, whether to use boiling or cool, boiled water, the types of teats and when to change them, how to sterilise properly. As a struggling, first time mother with a baby who wouldn't feed I found it incredibly upsetting to have a midwife who simply shrugged her shoulders and told me she couldn't help with anything related to formula. I spent hours scouring the Internet for tips.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/08/2022 21:51

What support do FFers need that they can’t get off the NHS website or Google?