Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
Grizzlac · 20/08/2022 12:07

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 17:50

Lol You’re not actually “genuinely speechless”though as you wrote a big reply.

I read the article yes. Did you? Doesn’t seem like you did from the hyperbole above. As I said- war on want wrote an article about nestle that they were successfully sued for as it wasn’t true. It wasn’t about “formula companies” as there is no such thing. It was about nestle.

im a second generation immigrant. In the developing country where some of my family are from, babies who can’t breastfeed in poorer families are often fed sugar water, boiled cows milk and so on. Because they can’t access formula free and it’s too expensive to buy. Or if they do get formula they dilute it too much or don’t make it up properly. That’s why education is so essential and probably a lack of stigmatization would make it more readily available.

Babies are still dying from poverty and lack of adequate nutrition in the developing world. That didn’t disappear in the 70s. Nor did banning nestle from promoting one of its products solve the problem. Because the problem was more complicated in the first place.

of course women in the developing world shouldn’t be encouraged to use formula if they don’t need it and can’t afford it (many in the developing world can afford formula just fine of course).

But not everyone can breastfeed regardless of your dogma or wish to find a simple answer. That’s true in the developing world too. Many women need formula in the developing world too and if it was cheaper and less shame associated that would help. Also if there was better education on bottle prep etc.

However we are talking about the uk anyway. shaming women in the uk for using formula because you think nestle (who produce no formula in the uk) behaved inappropriately in the developing world in the 70s is bonkers. Campaign against smarties or something instead.

if one company produced a rogue or ineffective medicine would you rail against all medications no matter who produced them? It’s nonsense. What nestle did (or according to the court didn’t) do in the 70s in Africa doesn’t justify the maltreatment of women in the uk in 2022 and stigmatization of the use of a generic product in the uk which isn’t even produced by nestle.

anyway as I said, formula milk correctly used saves millions of babies globally on a daily basis. It’s a wonderful thing and we should stop behaving as if it’s poison.

I formula fed because I couldn’t breastfeed. Some women in the uk formula feed because they want to. so many of us are made to feel awful for doing so. Also we are not given information on how to make up bottles etc. that needs to change. It’s a feminist issue imo.

@MsPincher you’re trolling now. Of course I read the article, hence my entire post being mentioning points made in the article. The semantics of ‘Nestle kills babies’ was found to be libellous but they were also court ordered to fundamentally change all their immoral practices that DID lead to the deaths of millions of babies. How you can ignore that, or find that less important than the ‘shame’ you feel (or apparently don’t feel, though your engagement on this thread implies otherwise) about ff baffles me. I was and remain speechless in response to your position; all I could manage was summarising the points in the article to check YOU actually read it. So unbelievably myopic.

And yes, formula has instructions (in a language most of us can read!) on the tin; boobs don’t. There is a WEALTH of information out there on ff, not least from the formula companies who would be delighted for all mothers to abandon bf and start buying their profitable products. Breastfeeding is hard, can be painful and takes skill and practice to get established. Some women choose to push through that, some don’t, and a small number can’t. All those options are fine. But no one needs encouragement to ff; it’s everywhere, the default option, promoted ALL the time and widely available. It’s only expensive cos the formula-producing companies (I’ll give in to your pedantry about ‘formula companies’ not being a thing) spend millions on misleading marketing implying there’s anything noticeably different between their products and own brand, which there isn’t. An NHS standard formula would also remove the need for fake follow-on formula as a cheaper alternative to first formula with marketing promotions being legal, as the formula itself would be cheaper.

I like ‘supported is best’; fed is not best, it is minimal. All women should be supported to feed their baby the way they choose with full knowledge on the benefits and pitfalls of both. With 88% of children being ff, at least partially, by 4 months clearly the ‘stigma’ isn’t stopping women from ff. stigma against bf and lack of support to do so clearly is stopping mothers from bf, though.

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 20/08/2022 03:21

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 17:57

Obviously this is a nasty goady OP. The I'm not against formula but... is on a par with I'm not racist but.. I hate all these goady trolly posts about formula, babies ears and fanny hair. So transparently nasty.

Me the goady one? Lol. You are the only one resorting to name calling, dear.

What's this about fanny hair and baby ears? What's that got to do with anything?🤣 perhaps you've had enough internet for today.

I will say it again. Promoting breastfeeding and saying we don't need formula month is not shaming formula. It is not goady to promote breastfeeding. Repeat until understood x

And there we go. No need to feed it any more.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:41

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 00:05

They have been argued, and studied, many times. The benefit is so small it can only be seen when studying hundreds of thousands of infants. It really isn’t anything to get upset about, and the babies aren’t being ‘deprived’. Much more important are genetics, diet, exercise, mental health etc.

I don't think you should be dictating what mother's can 'get upset' about. Many mums have posted on this thread saying they were upset at not being able to breastfeed or at being judged for formula feeding. Should we just tell them 'it isn't anything to get upset about'. I don't find that attitude supportive atall.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:36

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 23:59

@DreamToNightmare what’s that got to do with this thread? It’s about formula feeding.

The discussion has been a bit more nuanced than that. Many of us have been talking about how the real problem is mother's being shamed for however they choose to feed their baby.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:34

DreamToNightmare · 19/08/2022 23:57

Absolutely. I have two children and breast fed them until they were just under 3 and people were horrified. The looks and comments I used to get were very upsetting as they couldn’t understand they weren’t just having cow’s milk.

I asked them why they thought giving my child milk that’s been extracted from a cow was better for them than human milk and they obviously had no answer.

It’s all about social norms and sadly we have a long way to go until breastfeeding becomes “normal” and accepted without any judgements from others.

Yes, same. You feel you have to hide the way you are feeding your DC which is so wrong.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:32

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 23:54

If you believe women have the right to choose how to feed, then neither should be ‘prioritised’ over the other. Just information given and then support them in their decision. At the end of the day the health benefits are negligible and therefore not worth anyone getting too upset over.

I've not given my opinion just started it is against the law.

But if you really believe in a mother's right I find it strange that you say 'the health benefits are negligible and therefore not worth anyone getting too upset over'. As a new mum I felt the health benefits were worth it to want to breastfeed. It was very important to me. And the push to formula feed did upset me and cause a lot of stress. I found that kind of talk so divisive because it just invalidates the feelings and opinions of some mothers. We shouldn't be shaming any mother, not for formula feeding or for 'getting upset' about being pushed not to breast feed.

shreddednips · 20/08/2022 00:30

Scottishskifun, I think 'supported is best' is a really good way of putting it. All these awareness weeks won't achieve that, it requires proper investment and effort not just 'awareness.'

shreddednips · 20/08/2022 00:15

We don't need a FF awareness week. We also don't need a breastfeeding week either. What we need is properly funded, effective support for women who wish to breastfeed.

What I wasn't aware of before reading this thread is that healthcare professionals aren't providing advice to new parents on formula feeding. That's absolutely shocking to me, it's a matter of safety and information gleaned from Google isn't always reliable. So as well as MUCH better breastfeeding support, we also need readily accessible access to high-quality formula feeding advice and support.

Even if the aim was to increase breastfeeding rates, I can't even understand the logic of refusing to advise on formula feeding. I don't believe for a second that women come away from that experience feeling inspired to breastfeed because their HV refused to tell them how to safely make a bottle. I can't wrap my head around how that's ethical to refuse a new parent advice on how to feed their baby safely.

It's really sad that this causes such a divide among women. I've done both and frankly, there's no shame-free option. Bottle feed and you're shamed for not choosing the 'best option', breastfeed and you're asked to move to a toilet and tutted at for being indecent and asked when you plan to stop. I completely believe everyone on this thread who says they've been shamed for either way of feeding, whatever you choose will come with judgement and shame because misogyny.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 00:14

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 00:05

They have been argued, and studied, many times. The benefit is so small it can only be seen when studying hundreds of thousands of infants. It really isn’t anything to get upset about, and the babies aren’t being ‘deprived’. Much more important are genetics, diet, exercise, mental health etc.

I once read a short overview of a study which had been done on breast feeding rates and it said that 80% of women who are pregnant want to try breastfeeding and when they were asked why they wanted to breast feed the main reason wasn’t for the health benefits.

As a medical person I remember being quite surprised by this as it was the massive driving force behind why I breast fed my own children and I really wish I had gone on to find the actual study itself to learn more about women’s reasons.

I find the concept of differing women’s attitudes towards breastfeeding so complex and interesting and I often wonder what leads to each woman’s individual way of thinking taking into account their social circles and external influence etc.

I remember when I was at a really low point when trying to breast feed my second, I was having so many difficulties and life seemed so shitty and bleak and I used to look at women who had made the decision to switch to formula and actually feel jealous of them.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:12

Scottishskifun · 19/08/2022 22:54

I don't think you need a FF month as others say it will just be used by companies for promotion which they aren't allowed to do for first milks.

I understand the point of bf month it's because rates are low and many women before bf feel self conscious about it and many have been subjected to comments or worse.

I personally believe that supported is best. That a mum has the required help whatever she chooses sadly this doesn't happen.

I've been in baby groups and many ff mums straight away feel the need to defend their reasons for bottle feeding when I start bf. I mostly fins it sad that they feel they need to explain when I haven't said anything. My usual response is I have no idea how you do it I am so disorganised I would never leave the house and would have a screaming baby constantly from getting timings wrong!

I've found that can help put minds at ease and soften any nervousness and it's completely true I would completely suck at it!

Yes, I've experienced this. FF mums feeling they need to explain why they don't BF. Of course they don't need to. But it did used to rub me up the wrong way as they'd explain how it hurt or this or that and I felt I couldn't talk about how much it hurt me etc as it would seem a criticism of them! So we were all tying ourselves up in knots for no reason. I would often say the same about how hard it must be for them having to get up in the night to make bottles and remember to pack everything (and genuinely I would have struggled with that so much!) but it wasn't plain sailing breastfeeding either just for different reasons.

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:06

Faciadipasta · 19/08/2022 22:31

The lack of help for FF and the push for BF as the ONLY acceptable way to feed is absolutely negligent.
I had twins. I breastfed them for 5 months. Have you ever tried to BF twins? There is no way to do it discreetly. You have to lift your entire top. My babies both lost so much weight by day 7 we were sent to A and E who told me I HAD to give them a bottle or they would been to be admitted. But they couldn't provide formula, that's not allowed. So we had to find an open supermarket at 10.30pm. I combined fed for 3 days, they regained the weight and the HV told me to stop FF. They lost weight again, I saw lactation Consultants, was on domperidone for months. We had both of them privately fixed for tbeir tongue tie. I had to weight them before each breast feed, them weight them each afterwards, and calculate how much more formula they needed based on grams of weight gain. Every 2 hours. And pump after each feed. Throughout the night too.
I couldn't leave the house. I was bullied by every health visitor and midwife I saw into believing if I didn't do this insane ritual my babies would somehow be harmed. I developed PND. Every other mum I knew bar 1 who had babies at the same time BF and I felt awful to even WANT to quit even though it was dragging me into a dark hole of despair. I know PP see saying FF is the norm but I guarantee in my peer group it London it absolutely isn't.
And I kept this up for 5 FUCKING LONG DARK BLACK TRAPPED MONTHS because of all the pressure.
When 1 of my babies was blue lighted to hospital with bronchiolitis at 5 months I literally broke down to the pediatrician saying it must be my fault because I hadn't managed to EBF and was having to do formula top ups.
The pediatrician sat me down and told me this was crazy. It would not have made a blind bit of difference and it was fine to switch to formula right away if I wanted to.
I did that day. The only thing I regret was not doing it sooner. It took over my life and stopped me bonding with my babies in the early months.
I still get anxiety if I think back to those awful days.
So while I totally agree with their being a need for more BF help and promotion, the bullies who constantly shove "breast is best" down new mums throats or decide that midwives aren't allowed to give impartial help with FF can fuck off.

This is really eye opening to me because I had no idea that HCP wouldn't give help with formula feeding. Now of course the health benefits of BFing should be promoted in pregnancy, once it is clear what method (or combination of methods) a mother is using surely help should be given either way. My own experience was the opposite in that I wanted to BF but had FF shoved down my throat. It doesn't sound like anyone is being listened to!

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 00:05

They have been argued, and studied, many times. The benefit is so small it can only be seen when studying hundreds of thousands of infants. It really isn’t anything to get upset about, and the babies aren’t being ‘deprived’. Much more important are genetics, diet, exercise, mental health etc.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 00:04

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 23:59

@DreamToNightmare what’s that got to do with this thread? It’s about formula feeding.

I was replying to a comment made by someone else.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 00:03

At the end of the day the health benefits are negligible and therefore not worth anyone getting too upset over.

Long term, maybe.

But the benefits of breast milk over formula during the first 6-12 months of life can’t really be argued, for many reasons, but especially in relation to how it protects the baby’s digestive system and how it improves the immune system.

This is why formula cannot be advertised because the companies would be promoting and profiting from a product that deprives young infants of numerous health benefits.

TartanGirl1 · 20/08/2022 00:00

Of course you are trying to start a breast v bottle debate 🙄

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 23:59

@DreamToNightmare what’s that got to do with this thread? It’s about formula feeding.

DreamToNightmare · 19/08/2022 23:57

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 23:51

And just from personal experience if you do breastfeed past 6 months/1 year you are often made to feel a bit 'wierd' as everyone expects you to have 'moved on' to a bottle.

Absolutely. I have two children and breast fed them until they were just under 3 and people were horrified. The looks and comments I used to get were very upsetting as they couldn’t understand they weren’t just having cow’s milk.

I asked them why they thought giving my child milk that’s been extracted from a cow was better for them than human milk and they obviously had no answer.

It’s all about social norms and sadly we have a long way to go until breastfeeding becomes “normal” and accepted without any judgements from others.

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 23:54

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 23:47

I've seen lots in the past.

I'm not sure what you mean about 1yos drinking milk. Well, they can but many mums give them 'follow on' milk or breast feed them. But that's not really relevant. It's not about pretending formula doesn't exist but it being normalised over breastfeeding. What I said was it was against the law not that companies are out to get you.

If you believe women have the right to choose how to feed, then neither should be ‘prioritised’ over the other. Just information given and then support them in their decision. At the end of the day the health benefits are negligible and therefore not worth anyone getting too upset over.

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 23:51

And just from personal experience if you do breastfeed past 6 months/1 year you are often made to feel a bit 'wierd' as everyone expects you to have 'moved on' to a bottle.

UndertheCedartree · 19/08/2022 23:47

Wouldloveanother · 19/08/2022 21:15

I have never once seen an advert like that. Over 1s should still be drinking milk anyway, and even bfing mums give their kids dairy in some form. I really don’t understand what the issue is. I find this ‘shut down any advertising, let’s pretend formula doesn’t exist, the companies are out to get you’ to be really controlling.

I've seen lots in the past.

I'm not sure what you mean about 1yos drinking milk. Well, they can but many mums give them 'follow on' milk or breast feed them. But that's not really relevant. It's not about pretending formula doesn't exist but it being normalised over breastfeeding. What I said was it was against the law not that companies are out to get you.

DreamToNightmare · 19/08/2022 23:34

Girlmama · 19/08/2022 22:48

So many comments on here saying 'not to promote formula feeding but......'
Why not 'promote' formula feeding as a perfectly normal way to feed a child? And OP this vey much sounds like trying to engage breast v bottle

Because for health reasons breast milk is the best source of nutrition for a baby.

Yes formula isn’t poison, but it is a substitute for breast milk.

Marketing laws do not allow for formula to be advertised because by doing so it is promoting a substandard source of nutrition for babies (not my words) meaning babies do not receive what is considered to be the best source of nutrition - breast milk.

In the same way that adverts for seeets and McDonald’s etc are no longer shown on TV, because they can’t advertise food that comes with possible health problems, or, as in the case of formula, be advertising the use of a product that takes away the health benefits of other sources of nutrition, like breast milk.

FWIW, I work in infant feeding and although I don’t promote the use of formula I will ALWAYS give support and information to any mothers who are bottle feeding. I am classed as an Infant Feeding Specialist and that to me means I am there to support mothers regardless of which method they choose to feed their baby. If I was only there to support breast feeding mothers then I would be called a breast feeding specialist.

On the unit where I work I can safely say that although we support and assist with breastfeeding we are also happy to support and give information to mothers regarding formula too.

There is a big difference between promoting formula and providing information about formula feeding on and I do not think there is anything wrong with the latter and it saddens me to think that some women don’t receive this guidance and advice from the HCPs.

Papyri · 19/08/2022 23:28

@Dajeeling

Whole bloody books and bodies of research have been written about the biopsychosocial models behind breastfeeding guilt and trauma.
Just because you personally don't understand it does not been it is not a well recognised and complex phenomenon.

Papyri · 19/08/2022 23:26

@Faciadipasta

Not twins but I totally empathise with your post.

I feel like I'd been brainwashed into pursuing breastfeeding far beyond what was healthy for my baby or me; the relentless feeding and pumping cycle meant I essentially just didn't sleep.
I can guarantee having a suicidal depressed mother is definitely far worse for a baby's development than formula will ever be!

AlviarinAesSedai · 19/08/2022 23:16

I hardly know anyone who BF when I had my children and at all of baby groups I went to, everyone was FF.
I was the one who was odd and people made horrible comments.
I think mother’s should stop putting pressure on themselves, nobody really cares. Maybe there should be a campaign to stop judging mother’s.

Faciadipasta · 19/08/2022 23:06

@Dajeeling your post is supremely dismissive. You don't understand all the angst. Good for you. If you would like to understand it why not read some of the posts explaining it?