Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
DobbyHasASock · 20/08/2022 13:30

In my experience NCT were fair in that they covered bottle feeding. I mostly let it wash over me because I was adamant I was going to bf.
But shit happened. And once I'd given birth the breast is best narrative was the only one I heard. I was made to feel guilty by every health professional that I failed at bf because I wasn't trying hard enough. The absolute gaslighting. In addition to this I knew my baby couldn't do it and was told he's just a lazy boy.
Turns out I was right and he has a disability. Again, the absolute gaslighting. It was either I was doing it wrong or not forcing him enough. He literally would have died if I hadn't FF.
And yes, god the toll on my relationship with my baby. Hours of someone else holding him whilst I pumped. Being told I just needed to try harder or he's get it eventually I kept it up for months. Got no sleep. Developed severe and I mean severe pnd. And for what? After all the pumping HCP deemed pumped milk on par with FF anyway.

You cannot underestimate how damaging the bias in the NHS is. As I said previously, despite all my history I'm not receiving the same script from midwife for baby two despite it being so bad for my baby.
Incidentally, when I gave up pumping and trying to bf my son made the most progress. Neuroplasticity is unpredictable, but I believe getting.proper attention from his mum helped enormously.

Absolutely fuck off with your non promoting bollocks. Shame on you for denying mums options

SeasonsOfLife · 20/08/2022 13:27

I think this thread demonstrates why ff mums feel like they do. We've got the militant breastfeeding mums, we've got the NHS professionals not wanting to say the wrong thing from the script and we've got a lack of understanding around what's led up to ff.

Here's what led me to ff...
3 day labour, forceps, torn artery, 3 litre blood loss, blood transfusion. No one said to me, you've been through a lot, your milk might take a while, etc. They pushed me in hospital to bf. Consequently, first day we got home, ds went floppy through dehydration so back in we went. Formula from then on.

Second baby. Planned to try breastfeeding again but she had to go into special care and nil by mouth for a while. This caused great stress and I just couldn't emotionally cope with breastfeeding too. Formula from then on.

Add to that my own pnd and pna. Ff allowed others to help me which I totally needed. When I read all that back, I think yes I did the right thing but I still felt/feel guilty and a failure. So attitudes need to change, there does need to be more compassion and understanding, particularly around the mental health aspect. Everyone's story is different.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 13:24

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 13:13

And the view that everyone bar a tiny minority can actually BF if they JUST TRY HQRDER (a view reinforced by mothers whwho did try hard and got it going - good on them for that) is one of the hardest things to hear when you did absolutely everything in your power for months, sometimes causing mental health problems for mothers and malnutrition for babies.
I could cry when I look back at some of the photos from the first 3 months of my babies lives they were so thin, they look half starved. but women are lied to even about giving formula top ups. I was repeatedly told giving bottles as well as breast would mean they would reject the breast and this was BAD. its not true and it IS the absolute minimum I actually needed to do to keep them healthy. My babies were in the 0.4 and 3rd centile for weight because I could not produce enough milk for 2, even when almost continuously attached to a pump and taking domperidone. But yeah sure that's better than giving them formula as well right? Honestly this is all so fucking triggering. I could cry. And still people think its because I didn't try hard enough or didnt have enough support. And this is NOT uncommon.

I’m really sorry you went through that and you were clearly incredibly let down by the people who should have been helping you.

My story isn’t the same as yours but I had a lot of difficulties breast feeding my first and even though he’s 8 years old now, I can still get tearful when I recall how guilty and low I felt in my darkest moments.

Anyone who makes you feel like you didn’t try hard enough is an absolute arsehole

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 13:19

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 13:11

But it wouldn’t be ‘suggesting’ would it? As I said, provide information on both, mum makes up her mind then asks for help with whatever she needs. Isn’t that the best way?

Of course - I have never said otherwise.

The WHO provide information on bottle feeding.
UNICEF provide information on bottle feeding.
The NCT provide information on bottle feeding.
The Baby Friendly Initiative provides information on bottle feeding.
NHS websites and leaflets provide information on bottle feeding.

The information is out there and is non-judgemental provided by those listed above who are classed as the main advocates for the protection of breast feeding.

There is no law to say that HCPs cannot inform and educate bottle feeding mothers, it is their professional duty to do so.

Hence why I said that if any HCP refuses to have these conversations then they should be reported.

whumpthereitis · 20/08/2022 13:19

It’s not one or the other. Supporting formula doesn’t mean you can’t also support breastfeeding. It’s also perfectly possible to support breastfeeding without denigrating formula, or the issues that formula feeding mothers face.

Formula feeding mothers in this thread are saying they would have/ would currently appreciate the support. Because they’re not the same issues that breastfeeding mothers face does not mean they’re not issues worthy of addressing. Why shouldn’t women who formula feed have support? Why shouldn’t their choices, as autonomous adults, be respected?

You don’t have to invalidate one choice in order to support another. There’s room for both.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 13:14

I knew it was the right decision for me but society and the medical profession still push their bias to breastfeeding and I think it needs to be handled more sensitively.

100%

Its awful when mums who are struggling to breastfeed feel pressure from those in the medical profession to continue as the guilt it can cause to mothers it immense. I think HCP’s could probably do with some training on the long term emotional damage they can cause by not listening to or supporting mothers who make the choice to switch to formula feeding.

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 13:13

And the view that everyone bar a tiny minority can actually BF if they JUST TRY HQRDER (a view reinforced by mothers whwho did try hard and got it going - good on them for that) is one of the hardest things to hear when you did absolutely everything in your power for months, sometimes causing mental health problems for mothers and malnutrition for babies.
I could cry when I look back at some of the photos from the first 3 months of my babies lives they were so thin, they look half starved. but women are lied to even about giving formula top ups. I was repeatedly told giving bottles as well as breast would mean they would reject the breast and this was BAD. its not true and it IS the absolute minimum I actually needed to do to keep them healthy. My babies were in the 0.4 and 3rd centile for weight because I could not produce enough milk for 2, even when almost continuously attached to a pump and taking domperidone. But yeah sure that's better than giving them formula as well right? Honestly this is all so fucking triggering. I could cry. And still people think its because I didn't try hard enough or didnt have enough support. And this is NOT uncommon.

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 13:11

But it wouldn’t be ‘suggesting’ would it? As I said, provide information on both, mum makes up her mind then asks for help with whatever she needs. Isn’t that the best way?

SeasonsOfLife · 20/08/2022 13:10

I don't think there needs to be a month devoted to it but perhaps a campaign to promote the happy mum, happy baby message around feeding would be good.
I had pnd after both my children and for various complex reasons tried and stopped breastfeeding both times but I felt awful and guilty about it too. I'd see other mums breastfeeding and felt inadequate like I'd failed.
I knew it was the right decision for me but society and the medical profession still push their bias to breastfeeding and I think it needs to be handled more sensitively.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 13:09

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:56

But it doesn’t need to be one or the other @DreamToNightmare does it? Nobody is saying you can promote bottle feeding OR breastfeeding. If you truly believe in choice, information should be objectively provided on both, and then the mums can make up their own minds. Why wait until formula feeding mums are struggling before helping them? Nobody would promote that attitude for bfing.

But why on earth would a HCP suggest formula to a breast feeding mother who wasn’t struggling? What would be the need? Or the point?

If a breastfeeding mother states that she is struggling and wants to swap to formula then that is her decision to make and should be supported, but formula feeding shouldn’t be suggested if there is no need for it to be used.

Over 80% of women, when pregnant, say they want to breastfeed when the baby is born. For the other 20%, if they still want to formula feed when the baby arrives then they should be given the correct advice.

I recently completed a year of NCT training and there was lots of information around bottle feeding, and when I sat in on the breast feeding teaching sessions a lot of information on bottle feeding was also given to the parents.

UNICEF work with the WHO to try and improve breast feeding rates and even on their websites there are information leaflets for parents on how to bottle feed.

The Baby Friendly Initiative (which is a status that the whole country is trying to achieve regarding the protection of breast feeding) also have lots of information about bottle feeding on their webpages.

Staff who are trained to support with infant feeding (midwives and Heath visitors for example) ARE allowed to discuss bottle feeding / formula feeding with parents if that is the feeding method they choose.

Any HCP who refuses to have these discussions with new mothers are not acting professionally and need to be reported.

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 12:58

But no one needs encouragement to ff; it’s everywhere, the default option, promoted ALL the time and widely available.

This is actually bollocks. If you read my previous post as well as posts from many others you would see that plenty of mothers could definitely do with encouragement to FF, when BF struggles are causing them serious mental health issues. I did both and I can absolutely guarantee you the stress of feeling like FF would damage my babies - a view reinforced by NHS policies not to advise or give help on FF caused me a lot more stress than people sneering at my for BF.in public.If you BF sure some ignorant people might think you're weird but NOBODY thinks you're a negligent mother fpr it and I can promise you that is the difference.

And FF isn't promoted. That's illegal.

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:56

But it doesn’t need to be one or the other @DreamToNightmare does it? Nobody is saying you can promote bottle feeding OR breastfeeding. If you truly believe in choice, information should be objectively provided on both, and then the mums can make up their own minds. Why wait until formula feeding mums are struggling before helping them? Nobody would promote that attitude for bfing.

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:55

A lot of them did die out, Dizzy. It only takes a handful to keep a species going.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 12:55

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:44

do you acknowledge that formula is necessary, @DreamToNightmare ? Do you acknowledge that women should have the freedom to choose how to feed their child? If yes and yes, then how do you suppose women should be able to have the information to make the choice that is right for them and if that means formula, how to prepare and feed it properly and hygienically?

Do you accept the first hand stories on this thread of mums who were unsure how to feed their babies with formula milk because of a lack of information and support? Who was this benefitting? Was depriving them of information making the breastfeeding rate higher?

As I said, I work in Infant Feeding and fully support formula feeding mothers and I absolutely know formula is necessary in many cases and will advocate for it when there is a medical need for it.

And yes, I have worked with many families who are struggling with bottle feeding for many reasons and I support them in the same way I support breast feeding mothers. So yes, I do accept the stories on here that women have included about the struggles of bottle feeding as I know those problems are out there…..I come across them very frequently. I have never denied that women come across difficulties when bottle feeding.

However, I will not actively promote formula feeding over breast feeding.

dizzydizzydizzy · 20/08/2022 12:53

The human race would have died out millennia ago if there are lots of women who can't breastfeed. Most who tried and couldn't do it didn't get the right help. They were let down.

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:50

Actually studies don’t show any discernible difference once you control for other factors anyway.

I think this is the bone of contention for bfing mums to be honest. I think some of them (particularly those who struggled to get breastfeeding going - like me!) feel peeved that the effort they went to, won’t really translate into any noticeable health benefit in their child.

it does seem strange that the benefit is so tiny given, on paper, breastmilk honestly sounds like a miracle substance.

but when you consider how overwhelming the other factors are - genetics, weight, exercise, nutrition, fresh air, mental health, etc - it puts it in proportion a bit.

MsPincher · 20/08/2022 12:44

Grizzlac · 20/08/2022 12:07

@MsPincher you’re trolling now. Of course I read the article, hence my entire post being mentioning points made in the article. The semantics of ‘Nestle kills babies’ was found to be libellous but they were also court ordered to fundamentally change all their immoral practices that DID lead to the deaths of millions of babies. How you can ignore that, or find that less important than the ‘shame’ you feel (or apparently don’t feel, though your engagement on this thread implies otherwise) about ff baffles me. I was and remain speechless in response to your position; all I could manage was summarising the points in the article to check YOU actually read it. So unbelievably myopic.

And yes, formula has instructions (in a language most of us can read!) on the tin; boobs don’t. There is a WEALTH of information out there on ff, not least from the formula companies who would be delighted for all mothers to abandon bf and start buying their profitable products. Breastfeeding is hard, can be painful and takes skill and practice to get established. Some women choose to push through that, some don’t, and a small number can’t. All those options are fine. But no one needs encouragement to ff; it’s everywhere, the default option, promoted ALL the time and widely available. It’s only expensive cos the formula-producing companies (I’ll give in to your pedantry about ‘formula companies’ not being a thing) spend millions on misleading marketing implying there’s anything noticeably different between their products and own brand, which there isn’t. An NHS standard formula would also remove the need for fake follow-on formula as a cheaper alternative to first formula with marketing promotions being legal, as the formula itself would be cheaper.

I like ‘supported is best’; fed is not best, it is minimal. All women should be supported to feed their baby the way they choose with full knowledge on the benefits and pitfalls of both. With 88% of children being ff, at least partially, by 4 months clearly the ‘stigma’ isn’t stopping women from ff. stigma against bf and lack of support to do so clearly is stopping mothers from bf, though.

This is just more nonsense. The court did not order nestle to change any practices in Africa - at least if it did it’s not on the article. Unlikely a European libel court would have jurisdiction to make orders on marketing in Africa anyway.

You’re not listening at all. Lots of women have come on this thread to explain how they were shamed by the NHS and others for not breastfeeding and (therefore) formula feeding. They were also not given any education on bottle prep etc.

Yet you continue to deny it and claim “no one needs encouragement to formula feed” and that “it’s promoted all the time” even though it isn’t and many women have already told you how they were treated. But this is classic formula shaming- ignore women when they give their perspective and just tell them the nasty “formula companies” are duping them. Treat them as if they are stupid and irrelevant.

ultimately though many women (me included) are sick of being mistreated for formula feeding. Sick of being ignored and patronised and treated like we are gullible idiots.As I said I was upset at the time but now I’m just angry at the misogyny.

Actually studies don’t show any discernible difference once you control for other factors anyway. It’s our choice as mothers and women to breastfeed or formula feed. They’re our breasts and it’s our choice.

Formula milk is an essential and healthy food for babies and infants. There is absolutely nothing wrong with feeding it to babies or producing it and selling it. Stop shaming formula feeding mums and it’s producers as if it was some sort of poison. It isn’t. Quite the opposite

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:44

do you acknowledge that formula is necessary, @DreamToNightmare ? Do you acknowledge that women should have the freedom to choose how to feed their child? If yes and yes, then how do you suppose women should be able to have the information to make the choice that is right for them and if that means formula, how to prepare and feed it properly and hygienically?

Do you accept the first hand stories on this thread of mums who were unsure how to feed their babies with formula milk because of a lack of information and support? Who was this benefitting? Was depriving them of information making the breastfeeding rate higher?

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 12:41

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:28

So that law should be changed 🤷🏼‍♀️

It’s not going to be changed.

It was put in place by the World Health Organisation who recognised the damage that formula companies were doing to breast feeding and to the health of babies as a secondary effect.

Formula companies are a business and all that matters to them is making money from their products. Formula companies know that if women are breastfeeding they aren’t buying their products and so trying to discourage breastfeeding is ultimately their aim.

Formula is a suitable form of nutrition for a baby but let’s not kid ourselves that formula companies care about the babies…..their focus is on making money and profit - Just like every other business. Formula companies are no different to any other companies in that respect.

I’m sure that someone once told me that formula companies are the biggest money making businesses in the world….

The World Health Organisation is not going to overturn the law and allow formula companies to further damage breastfeeding rates (and potentially impact on the health of infants/children) for no other reason than their own financial gain.

Bejeweled · 20/08/2022 12:40

@MsPincher I don't accept formula is as difficult as breastfeeding. It's tricky for everyone to navigate feeding a newborn and getting used to it.

With formula, the milk is right there. I'm sure some people have issues, sure, but it's generally more straightforward. With breastfeeding, the milk might not be coming out. Or it's excruciating to just feed your baby (broken nipples, mastitis, uterine contractions for second births) etc.

In response to pp's comment, yes, breastfeeding is much harder to establish. I could've phrased it as 'more support for breastfeeding' though.

My intention wasn't to put anyone down, but establishing breastfeeding is generally much kore challenging for multiple reasons relating to mum and baby

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:28

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 12:19

nah it just seems bf mums have turned up to say they wouldn’t want more awareness of Ff as it would make them feel invalidated.

Its nothing to do with what breast feeding mothers want or say.

Its the law that formula feeding can not be publicly promoted or advertised hence why a Formula Awareness month simply cannot be done.

So that law should be changed 🤷🏼‍♀️

MsPincher · 20/08/2022 12:19

Bejeweled · 19/08/2022 18:28

Everyone is aware of the existence of breast

In answer to this, breastfeeding has to be established. You can encounter lots of pain, bleeding nipples, massive engorged breasts, leaking, getting the right latch, breast changes after. Which isn't the same as buying formula off a shelf and preparing it.

Like someone else said, you don't really need support to be able to formula feed (unless you're switching from breast to formula). So if there was a formula awareness thing, it makes sense it be done alongside breastfeeding rather than as a standalone thing.

That’s actually not true at all. There can be lots of issues with formula feeding from reflux to proper preparation to different types of bottles. It’s not as simple as buy it off the shelf and bung it in.

also as has been said many times it would be really useful to tackle mums who formula feed because they couldn’t breastfeed and have guilt or issues with that.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 12:19

nah it just seems bf mums have turned up to say they wouldn’t want more awareness of Ff as it would make them feel invalidated.

Its nothing to do with what breast feeding mothers want or say.

Its the law that formula feeding can not be publicly promoted or advertised hence why a Formula Awareness month simply cannot be done.

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:13

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:36

The discussion has been a bit more nuanced than that. Many of us have been talking about how the real problem is mother's being shamed for however they choose to feed their baby.

nah it just seems bf mums have turned up to say they wouldn’t want more awareness of Ff as it would make them feel invalidated.

lets just provide information on both and let mums choose and get on with it.

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:11

UndertheCedartree · 20/08/2022 00:41

I don't think you should be dictating what mother's can 'get upset' about. Many mums have posted on this thread saying they were upset at not being able to breastfeed or at being judged for formula feeding. Should we just tell them 'it isn't anything to get upset about'. I don't find that attitude supportive atall.

its not opinion, it’s fact! And surely much more reassuring than ‘your child missed out on an enormous and noticeable health benefit’. And my point was it isn’t for bfing mums to act all faux concerned about FF kids ‘being deprived’ of health benefits (as pp said).