Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 10:17

You assume I'm anti formula because I named a few of the top companies that make it 🤣 ok, I like your logic.

OP posts:
jay55 · 19/08/2022 10:17

Maybe we have a don't shame mothers for feeding their children month.

Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 10:17

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:14

I think formula month could be good for all sorts of reasons. One would be to help mums who feel guilty or depressed about formula feeding (me for example).

Another would be to educate how to formula feed correctly which would be incredibly beneficial for infant health.

A third would be to ease the stigma on formula and formula feeding to encourage more supermarkets etc to make own brand formula. That could really bring prices down and help poorer mums.

all around it’s a great idea.

How on earth does ‘stigma’ against ff prevent for-profit companies from making a profitable (and highly in demand given it’s by far the dominant way to feed a baby) product? Bonkers.

justagirlstandinginfrontofcake · 19/08/2022 10:16

I would have literally killed my son if I breastfed him.

This didn't stop SO many mums choosing to tell me what I was doing was wrong, what I actually needed to do, how I was damaging my son. Which is always so useful when you're a new very stressed mum.

We need a "mind your own business" month!

AdamRyan · 19/08/2022 10:16

also there’s no such thing as “formula companies”. That’s just a fake bogeyman lots of people who like to put women down bandy about.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.businessinsider.com/nestles-infant-formula-scandal-2012-6%3famp

www.swissinfo.ch/eng/who-slams-baby-milk-industry-for-rampant--manipulative--marketing/47369706

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:14

I think formula month could be good for all sorts of reasons. One would be to help mums who feel guilty or depressed about formula feeding (me for example).

Another would be to educate how to formula feed correctly which would be incredibly beneficial for infant health.

A third would be to ease the stigma on formula and formula feeding to encourage more supermarkets etc to make own brand formula. That could really bring prices down and help poorer mums.

all around it’s a great idea.

MayThe4th · 19/08/2022 10:14

Well a few weeks ago it was national emoji day. So really. Just pick a topic, allocate it a day and then start promoting “national mcDonalds day” or whatever on social media and there you have it.

We don’t need any of these months. Not even a breastfeeding one.

You can spread awareness without having to dedicate a time or a hashtag to it.

Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 10:12

Dinodigger · 19/08/2022 10:09

It is the same sort of thing as saying we need straight pride and all life's matter. We don't need these things.

Exactly. Massive whataboutery - we don’t need straight pride as being straight is statistically more common and no disadvantage to to. Formula feeding is VASTLY more common than breastfeeding; that some women feel guilty about it doesn’t mean it’s stigmatised (although obviously people can be unnecessarily nasty about it). Stigmatised things don’t tend to be the significantly more common option! HCP promoting breastfeeding for health benefits to both baby and mum, as they rightly do, is not stigmatising formula. That seems to be the most common ‘shaming’ women experience; being told, like adults, one option is objectively better (although harder) and the other is absolutely fine. Something that’s already dominant doesn’t need promoting further.

SpaghettiSquash · 19/08/2022 10:11

We certainly need more education about formula feeding. The amount of posts on here and misinformation about correct ways to make up a bottle are proof of that. I don't think a formula feeding day is the solution though as it would just turn into a marketing campaign. We need a "Mum, you're doing a great job whatever your feeding choice" day!

Dinodigger · 19/08/2022 10:09

It is the same sort of thing as saying we need straight pride and all life's matter. We don't need these things.

MrsSkylerWhite · 19/08/2022 10:09

“Why’s it helpful- to ease peoples unfounded guilt“

in the same way that some people will find breastfeeding month helpful, to provide information.

dont understand at all why anyone else cares how others feed their babies.

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps ·

That is an absolutely terrible argument, used in any context.

The day people are forbidden to care about anything that doesn't immediately impact them personally is the day people stop donating to charities which provide communities in developing countries with access to clean water or rescue and relief after natural disasters or for refugees fleeing war, and the day they stop picking up liter unless it's in their garden, or volunteering at foodbanks, homeless shelters and animal sancturies... and a million other things which help make the world a slightly less bleak and evil place”

no it isn’t. How a woman chooses to feed her baby is no-one else’s business. Unless you’re suggesting that ff is “bleak and evil”?

all of those examples you mention may well affect me/my family one day. How you feed your child won’t.

ScarlettSunset · 19/08/2022 10:08

gatehouseoffleet · 19/08/2022 09:32

Some of us didn't choose how to feed our babies - maybe we need a "how to feed your baby any old how so s/he doesn't die" month?

The bottle versus breast debate is very tedious and yet another example of trying to tell women what to do because they're too stupid to make decisions for themselves.

I completely agree with this.
For some people, there is no choice, it's just doing what you can to ensure your baby gets fed at all.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:06

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:56

The main manufacturers of formula are

Nestle
Danone SA
Reckitt benckiser
Abott
Kraft Heinz
HiPP GmbH

This is who we mean by formula companies. And yes they make a fucking fortune off of formula.

I dont think formula needs advertising any more than it already is, even though I dont disagree with formula feeding and am totally impartial to how others feed their baby

Clearly you do disagree with formula feeding. All of those companies make all sorts of food stuffs. Others make formula too such as Aldi. There is nothing wrong with that. Without formula many millions of babies would starve every year.

We need to stop stigmatising formula and formula feeding mums. That will bring more companies into the market and bring prices down.

Formula is an essential food for babies. The fact that the above companies (and others) make good quality formula is a good thing. Food companies and manufacturers (and farmers) make a profit on all foodstuffs. That’s fine by me - we have a good competitive market for food in the uk that brings us good quality food at a reasonable price.

FallOutPloy · 19/08/2022 10:05

I'm not a hardcore breast is best advocate. Formula feeding certainly shouldn't be demonised- 2 of my kids were combi-fed at various stages, and I was very grateful to have the option of safe, nutritious formula, and sanitary conditions to prepare bottles.

But I don't think it should be actively celebrated. That would basically just be an advert for formula milk.

FWIW I'm not sure we need a breastfeeding month either tbh!

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 10:04

@ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps 👏👏👏👏👏

OP posts:
category12 · 19/08/2022 10:03

I'm just bored with months (and days) for "awareness", it's so over-done. It's beyond saturation.

Today is World humanitarian day, international bowtie day, kool aid day, aviation day, orangutan day, men's grooming day, potato day and soft ice-cream day.

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 19/08/2022 10:02

MrsSkylerWhite · 19/08/2022 09:46

Will it affect you, personally, in some adverse way?

if not, what’s the problem? It could be extremely helpful to other people.

That is an absolutely terrible argument, used in any context.

The day people are forbidden to care about anything that doesn't immediately impact them personally is the day people stop donating to charities which provide communities in developing countries with access to clean water or rescue and relief after natural disasters or for refugees fleeing war, and the day they stop picking up liter unless it's in their garden, or volunteering at foodbanks, homeless shelters and animal sancturies... and a million other things which help make the world a slightly less bleak and evil place.

DameHelena · 19/08/2022 10:01

I don't see why not. I've got friends who faced real pressure/guilt trips (from so-called professionals too, not just friends/the public) for not being able to or not wanting to breastfeed. The more formula feeding is talked about and considered as valid as breastfeeding the better, IMO.

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 10:00

Agree @Hugasauras

OP posts:
ShowOfHands · 19/08/2022 10:00

Women are shamed because we live in a patriarchal society and that's just the norm. The way we look, what we say, our relationships, parenting choices and inevitabilities, education levels, careers and on and on ad infinitum. Often, we turn that shame and guilt on ourselves. I did it because I had a cs. Not because a cs is shameful but because I was trying to attain an impossible standard.

Do I think we need a ff month? Not really. It would just be an excuse for a furthering of the disingenuous marketing from formula companies I suspect. Supporting new mothers is something which needs to happen regardless and the whole attitude to this probably needs overhauling. Within that, I'd argue that establishing general feeding support is necessary and that should in turn work to address bfing rates, support and information as a key focus.

The word "best" is so loaded and "fed is best" is not objectively true. Fed is non negotiable and breastmilk or formula are largely, the two ways of doing this. One is the biological norm and the other is a safe, often necessary alternative. Bit like giving birth. Natural labour is the norm and then we have lifesaving alternatives which are available through necessity and choice. The "best" rhetoric just feeds into the judgment.

Hugasauras · 19/08/2022 09:59

Perhaps a week aimed around postnatal mental health would be more appropriate then rather than a FF week? Is there one of those already?

Change123today · 19/08/2022 09:59

I fed one bottle one breast.

I struggled with the thought of breast feeding with my first, the how and fear of being a failure. I did try and it didn’t work out and thankfully the bottle feeding was an option.

If I’m really honest with myself with my first the thought of breastfeeding gave me the ick and I was so freaked out by the idea! I just couldn’t relax and overthought everything from it hurts to is she getting enough milk.

The second time around I was more relaxed with the process - I had also matured - being a mother already knew that if it didn’t work out bottle feeding would be ok! It was a lot easier process.

We don’t need bottle feeding month - it is already normalised (and that’s ok) what we do need is fed is best. But also proper funding and support around breast feeding we need to normalise it in the same way bottle feeding is. Watching my Mum freak out as I was about to feed my child she thought I should be hidden away - it was fine and no one got a shot of my nipple - but I realised their generation bottle feeding was the best thing and the marketing really did a number on her and I guess when I had my first it also rubbed of on me (without me realising). We do have to undo a lot of that marketing and normalise breast feeding again. But it’s so difficult without someone feeling judged.

Yes Fed is best - breastfeeding is normal and shouldn’t be hidden, it should be promoted positively and honestly. Also a bottle feed baby will also be just fine.

SnoozyLucy7 · 19/08/2022 09:59

Formula is fine, breastfeeding is fine- it’s all fine!! People should know about both. I guess if this needs a special “month” for each, to raise awareness, that’s great! Women should know that they can go for either option and what ever that choice is, for whatever reason - it’s fine, as it’s no one else’s god damn business!

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 09:57

Neverfullycharged · 19/08/2022 09:41

Everyone knows formula feeding is OK. Any residing guilt anyone feels about not breastfeeding is not going to vanish with a formula feeding month, is it?

No they don’t. Women feel appallingly guilty and depressed because they can’t breastfeed. We absolutely need to stop that. Formula is fine and to be honest I doubt it makes any difference.

also there are all sorts of misconceptions about how to sterilize bottles and powder formula which can be harmful to young babies health if you get them wrong. My health visitor told me she couldn’t advise on that (which is absolutely ridiculous). Education on that and other formula matters is crucial.

Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 09:57

bakewellbride · 19/08/2022 09:37

I'm against the idea of a 'formula feeding month'. Formula feeding is something that's absolutely everywhere in our society already. The majority of mums in this country do it, it's advertised everywhere and it's in every shop.

I'm breastfeeding and have only ever breastfed but have experienced a lot of pressure throughout my journey to bottle feed from many different angles. Formula feeding month really would be the icing on the cake.

Absolutely agree. I am still breastfeeding my 19 month old and I had people asking when (not if!) I was going to give bottles since he was a few weeks old. Encouragement to formula feed is EVERYWHERE, and companies really don’t need the opportunity to ram their products down our throats more than they already do. Formula feeding is absolutely fine, but it doesn’t need promoting - it’s by far the most common way to feed a baby in the UK!