Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
noclothesinbed · 19/08/2022 11:19

Whatever ? Cba to get het up over it just feed your baby makes no difference which

Sunnyqueen · 19/08/2022 11:17

Formula d

DameHelena · 19/08/2022 11:14

LookingOverHereAllNight · 19/08/2022 11:10

A friend of mine was reduced to tears by a midwife (a fucking midwife!) very soon after giving birth because she found BF difficult and painful. That isn't OK and as long as that continues then yes we jolly well do need a formula week.

No, we need to ensure that we don’t allow midwives to behave like cunts. A formula week wouldn’t stop this midwife being nasty to new mums. About half of the midwives I had in my two births were rude, impatient and had a bad attitude.

I don't disagree some midwives probably behave badly in lots of contexts (and I'm sorry you've had poor experiences with them and I agree it needs to change).
I was just giving this example as it fits the topic of this discussion.
I could as easily say another friend was met with silence and frostiness in a baby group when she wanted to discuss FF.

LookingOverHereAllNight · 19/08/2022 11:10

A friend of mine was reduced to tears by a midwife (a fucking midwife!) very soon after giving birth because she found BF difficult and painful. That isn't OK and as long as that continues then yes we jolly well do need a formula week.

No, we need to ensure that we don’t allow midwives to behave like cunts. A formula week wouldn’t stop this midwife being nasty to new mums. About half of the midwives I had in my two births were rude, impatient and had a bad attitude.

SnoozyLucy7 · 19/08/2022 11:02

Slimemonster · 19/08/2022 10:48

Breastfed children are a minority.
The majority of mothers who begin breastfeeding, are forced to stop before they are ready.
(due to lack of support/undermined/heavily marketed ads/etc. Soo many other reasons)

This is why we need breastfeeding awareness.

We don't need a formula week because it's already a multi billion £ industry that violates advertising laws at every corner and undermines vulnerable new parents at every opportunity.

Turn on TV - did you see a breastfeeding advert? No.

But you saw 4 different formula ads....they don't need any more advertising. They already have nearly 100% of the market at the expense of new mothers.

These companies know they can't make money out of breastfeeding mothers, so they created the devide.

Feed your baby formula if you want to.

Breastfeed if you want to.

But if you had to stop feeding before you were ready to, then you have massively been let down and you shouldn't be cross at other mothers for that - it's the formula industry you need to direct your anger too.

Thank goodness for these companies, making these formulas, as an alternative to breast feeding- for those who can’t breast feed, for what ever reason, or simply because they do not want to. Like it’s been said up thread, there should be more companies, coming up with their own formula, to bring the prices right down.

DameHelena · 19/08/2022 10:59

We don't need a formula week because it's already a multi billion £ industry that violates advertising laws at every corner and undermines vulnerable new parents at every opportunity.
Even accepting that, I can't agree that we don't need a formula week. Look at the stories on this thread alone of women who were pressured/bullied/guilt-tripped about either not wanting to BF or (maybe even worse) being unable to.
A friend of mine was reduced to tears by a midwife (a fucking midwife!) very soon after giving birth because she found BF difficult and painful. That isn't OK and as long as that continues then yes we jolly well do need a formula week.

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 19/08/2022 10:54

MsPincher I object to MrsSkylerWhite 's argument that posters are not entitled to an opinion unless they are negatively effected. That is a really dangerous argument to bow down to no matter what the topic is.

babyboybabygirl · 19/08/2022 10:54

I think it’s interesting that whatever a mothers choices to feed there is shame attached. There’s a big mix in my group of friends between breast and formula feeding and everyone at some point has been made to feel like absolute shit for their choice. In reality, you couldn’t tell which kids where fed in which way.

if you don’t like the week/month, just ignore it.

Any positivity around how we feed/raise our kids has got to be a good thing as even though you might not need it someone else may.

ArtichokeAardvark · 19/08/2022 10:50

I voted YABU purely for your disclaimer. Of course you're looking for a breast v bottle debate.

With regards a formula feeding month, I really couldn't care less. I didn't even know there was a breastfeeding month - does anyone pay any attention to this sort of thing? Every day of the year seems to be part of such-and-such week/month.

Slimemonster · 19/08/2022 10:48

Breastfed children are a minority.
The majority of mothers who begin breastfeeding, are forced to stop before they are ready.
(due to lack of support/undermined/heavily marketed ads/etc. Soo many other reasons)

This is why we need breastfeeding awareness.

We don't need a formula week because it's already a multi billion £ industry that violates advertising laws at every corner and undermines vulnerable new parents at every opportunity.

Turn on TV - did you see a breastfeeding advert? No.

But you saw 4 different formula ads....they don't need any more advertising. They already have nearly 100% of the market at the expense of new mothers.

These companies know they can't make money out of breastfeeding mothers, so they created the devide.

Feed your baby formula if you want to.

Breastfeed if you want to.

But if you had to stop feeding before you were ready to, then you have massively been let down and you shouldn't be cross at other mothers for that - it's the formula industry you need to direct your anger too.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:45

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 19/08/2022 10:33

MrsSkylerWhite I've already posted on the topic of formula feeding week up thread - my opinion (as I've already stated) is that fed is best but a formula feeding month would need to walk the fine line between accepting that fed is best and formula is perfectly fine way to feed babies, without allowing for profit companies to exploit it for free advertising and promotion of formula as better (as in the Nestlé scandal in the 70s/ 80s).

Your argument that people are not allowed to care about anything that doesn't immediately adversely affect them would be a really terrible basis for shutting people up in any context because its an essential that people care about things which don't impact them personally in an immediate context. Without that there's no civilization, no humanity, no society, no charity, no ultruism.

You're advocating for pure self interest only.

What doesn't adversely impact us today may adversely impact upon our children tomorrow - that includes turning a blind eye to media campaigns and keeping our mouths shut about things that are fraught with problems but don't impact us.

Maternity care and breastfeeding don't impact me any more because I've finished child bearing; but I have a daughter who might be directly impacted by the consequences of changes in policy now, as indeed less directly might my sons if they become fathers, and theoretical potential grandchildren.

Nobody should be told not to voice reservations about anything on the basis that it doesn't adversely effect them. Its hardly ever true - as you yourself say things might come around unexpectedly, might impact family members, or ripple effects can mean consequences for people other than the intended target audience.

Promoting formula definitely could have negative effects. A "fed is best" month or a "Baby feeding month", "0-6 months nutritional campaign" or even better just generally better support for women and their families postpartum would be better surely - emphasising that any responsible way of feeding a baby is acceptable is unlikely to be objected to by anyone.

@ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps just sounds like you’re determined to continue to stigmatize formula though. We need to stop that immediately. As I’ve pointed out above it’s causing all sorts of public health issues.

there is nothing wrong with formula and we don’t need to be so careful not to promote it in the uk that we are shaming women and not educating them on how to feed their babies. Even in the developing world formula is often required - there are many issues with babies being fed cows milk, sugar water etc. more availability of cheap good quality formula would undoubtedly save lives.

perhaps we should have an NHS certified bargain basement formula to avoid any commercial interests. But anyway the most essential thing is to stop shaming women for bottle feeding (and for having c- sections and epidurals and so on).

bakewellbride · 19/08/2022 10:41

@Blossomtoes I genuinely am sorry for your struggles and have honestly been nothing but supportive to anyone I know in real life who has FF. I bought my friend a lovely bottle warmer and am always positive, supportive and encouraging to my FF friends. All I'm asking is to be treated with a bit of kindness and not negatively. I'm sorry if my post hit a nerve with you but I really don't see what I've said that's wrong, just worded my own opinion / experience. Well done on FF your baby Flowers

MrsAvocet · 19/08/2022 10:35

Nothing is stopping them to start on it with some company
Well except maybe The International Code of Marketing of Breastfeeding Substitutes.

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 19/08/2022 10:33

MrsSkylerWhite I've already posted on the topic of formula feeding week up thread - my opinion (as I've already stated) is that fed is best but a formula feeding month would need to walk the fine line between accepting that fed is best and formula is perfectly fine way to feed babies, without allowing for profit companies to exploit it for free advertising and promotion of formula as better (as in the Nestlé scandal in the 70s/ 80s).

Your argument that people are not allowed to care about anything that doesn't immediately adversely affect them would be a really terrible basis for shutting people up in any context because its an essential that people care about things which don't impact them personally in an immediate context. Without that there's no civilization, no humanity, no society, no charity, no ultruism.

You're advocating for pure self interest only.

What doesn't adversely impact us today may adversely impact upon our children tomorrow - that includes turning a blind eye to media campaigns and keeping our mouths shut about things that are fraught with problems but don't impact us.

Maternity care and breastfeeding don't impact me any more because I've finished child bearing; but I have a daughter who might be directly impacted by the consequences of changes in policy now, as indeed less directly might my sons if they become fathers, and theoretical potential grandchildren.

Nobody should be told not to voice reservations about anything on the basis that it doesn't adversely effect them. Its hardly ever true - as you yourself say things might come around unexpectedly, might impact family members, or ripple effects can mean consequences for people other than the intended target audience.

Promoting formula definitely could have negative effects. A "fed is best" month or a "Baby feeding month", "0-6 months nutritional campaign" or even better just generally better support for women and their families postpartum would be better surely - emphasising that any responsible way of feeding a baby is acceptable is unlikely to be objected to by anyone.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:33

Blossomtoes · 19/08/2022 10:26

I'm breastfeeding and have only ever breastfed but have experienced a lot of pressure throughout my journey to bottle feed from many different angles

Poor you. Try genuinely not being able to breastfeed and see what pressure’s brought to bear on you with a large side dish of guilt to go with it.

I don’t think we should pressure women to do either. Breastfeed if you can or want to but if you don’t here’s how to bottle feed. There should be no stigma either way.

at the end of the day it’s our bodies.

Mariposista · 19/08/2022 10:33

Neither needs celebrating! Neither method is better or worse: whichever method works for that particular baby, mother and wider family is the best!

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 19/08/2022 10:33

@Blossomtoes

Totally agree, I went through that myself during covid with my inability to breastfeed my DS and constantly getting judged.
I had severe PND because of it but hey my DS is fine and has a healthy immune system even though he was raised on formula.
How about a fed is best month with helpful advice for both.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:31

Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 10:18

I’m really sorry you feel so bad about ff though; you don’t deserve to and I hope you can let it go. Formula is a completely valid, safe and healthy option for your DC, who I’ve no doubt will grow up to be wonderful humans!

I am aware of that now - actually I’ve looked into it and studies show it makes little difference. I now don’t feel guilty at all, just angry at the poor treatment I received by the NHS.

My dds are thriving and I have no doubt that formula did them no harm at all.

I did go through a difficult time as many women do due to the stigmatization of formula feeding by the NHS and others such as NCT. I am passionate about it - we need to stop doing that to women.

Blossomtoes · 19/08/2022 10:26

I'm breastfeeding and have only ever breastfed but have experienced a lot of pressure throughout my journey to bottle feed from many different angles

Poor you. Try genuinely not being able to breastfeed and see what pressure’s brought to bear on you with a large side dish of guilt to go with it.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:25

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 10:17

You assume I'm anti formula because I named a few of the top companies that make it 🤣 ok, I like your logic.

I assume you’re anti formula because your posts clearly reveal that. There’s nothing wrong with any of the companies you mentioned for making formula or any of their other products (many of which are favourites of mine).

in fact as I was unable to breastfeed without formula my daughters would have been malnourished or could have died. Thanks so much to the formula companies for making an essential foodstuff for babies I say! I would like more companies to make it though so it could be cheaper.

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:20

Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 10:12

Exactly. Massive whataboutery - we don’t need straight pride as being straight is statistically more common and no disadvantage to to. Formula feeding is VASTLY more common than breastfeeding; that some women feel guilty about it doesn’t mean it’s stigmatised (although obviously people can be unnecessarily nasty about it). Stigmatised things don’t tend to be the significantly more common option! HCP promoting breastfeeding for health benefits to both baby and mum, as they rightly do, is not stigmatising formula. That seems to be the most common ‘shaming’ women experience; being told, like adults, one option is objectively better (although harder) and the other is absolutely fine. Something that’s already dominant doesn’t need promoting further.

whet or not something is common is irrelevant! There are still good reasons to promote formula awareness and to stop stigmatization of mums who formula feed.

the anti formula brigade are very harmful to many mums mental health. That may not be something you recognize or care about but it’s important to me and many other mums (including on this thread) who have experienced it.

equally education on proper formula feeding is not being given because of stigma. That absolutely should be stopped.

we don’t need a month necessarily but we absolutely should stop stigmatising mums who formula feed and formula itself. Maybe we should just do that every day.

PuttingDownRoots · 19/08/2022 10:20

I would support a Safe feeding day/week. Concentrating on amounts, hygiene, making up bottles etc plus safe weaning timescales.

The UK is one of those countries fortunate enough to have a plentiful and clean water supply so formula is a safe option here. Not everywhere in the World is as fortunate, there is a reason behind the marketing rules.

category12 · 19/08/2022 10:20

I agree with the people who have said it would just turn into a massive advertising campaign for the various brands. I'm sure they'd pump huge amounts of money into it.

And the influencers pushing for it will have their eyes on the money, not helping people.

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 10:18

@MsPincher

OP posts:
Grizzlac · 19/08/2022 10:18

MsPincher · 19/08/2022 10:14

I think formula month could be good for all sorts of reasons. One would be to help mums who feel guilty or depressed about formula feeding (me for example).

Another would be to educate how to formula feed correctly which would be incredibly beneficial for infant health.

A third would be to ease the stigma on formula and formula feeding to encourage more supermarkets etc to make own brand formula. That could really bring prices down and help poorer mums.

all around it’s a great idea.

I’m really sorry you feel so bad about ff though; you don’t deserve to and I hope you can let it go. Formula is a completely valid, safe and healthy option for your DC, who I’ve no doubt will grow up to be wonderful humans!