Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don't need a formula feeding month

336 replies

LilacSky95 · 19/08/2022 09:22

I have seen a couple of mum 'influencers' on Instagram writing posts about how it's not fair we have breastfeeding month when so many mums can't/didn't breastfeed, and we should start a formula feeding month too.

AIBU to think this is totally unnecessary?

Disclaimer - Not looking to start a breast v bottle debate

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DobbyHasASock · 22/08/2022 09:14

Maybe I'm being sensitive, but disability awareness month has just slipped by without being acknowledged, in favour of extending pride month another month.
But posters ignoring my posts and saying breast is best etc need to acknowledge that a lot of babies are unable to feed, and they are prioritising chastising mums who choose not to bf over providing helpful information for those that can't.

I know it's convenient of you to think we're an anomaly but twenty percent of the UK have a disability so we can't be hand waved away when it doesn't fit the narrative.

GalactatingGoddess · 21/08/2022 22:35

Not the same at all really.
I think most rational people would agree that, in the U.K., where we have access to good sanitation, formula feeding is fine.

However, people also need to remember that breast milk was designed for babies! There is no getting away from that.

Fed is best. But, breastfeeding rates are low and so a formula feeding week is unnecessary.

What about a mothers mental health week? Or a how to support a new mum week? Or a red flags before having children week? Much more useful.

UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 22:34

DobbyHasASock · 20/08/2022 13:50

Indeed, The thing is, I would like to bf my due baby if I can. But I'm so nervous because I know from experience the NHS will push it beyond the point of good sense and having not successfully breastfed I've no idea what safe bf looks like. I'm worried as babies do die die to pushing of bf above all others, this is I believe why the fed is best campaign started.
And as I said, the midwife insensitively pushes it is quite difficult for me emotionally. Not helpful at all.
A helpful stance would be acknowledging that this pregnancy is different and whilst it might mean I am able to bf, it's no guarantee. Acknowledging the guilt and toll on my mental health would help too.

But it's so much easier to parrot a three word slogan and treat me like a smoker or crack user because I've expressed the opinion it might not work out for me.

I'm so sorry to hear what you went through. It is odd because in my experience FF is pushed once the baby is born not BFing. The push by the midwives for me to bottle feed really affected my mental health. I think the wish of the mother (if she has a preference) should be accepted (unless of course FF is needed for the baby's health.)

DocsandSocks · 21/08/2022 22:33

@Overthisnow98 Thankyou for your lovely message Smile

I'm so sorry to hear of your experiences too Sad I haven't read the full thread so apologies if you've written this already but have you had any support for what you've been through?

I had many midwives throughout pregnancy and labour/aftercare (Covid has a lot to answer for!!) who were all so kind and supportive. However, that one midwife is the one that I remember the most and all for the negative reasons!

Overthisnow98 · 21/08/2022 22:23

DocsandSocks · 21/08/2022 21:53

@Theneverendingtories I have an inverted nipple so my daughter would not latch. However, the worst midwife I had told me that I would not be discharged until I had BF three times. Luckily, my husband was there and told her that I would feed our daughter twice, however I seem fit, and then he would be coming back to collect us (Covid times) and we'd be walking out of that hospital whether she discharged us or not. I am so glad that he was there to advocate for me because after three days of no sleep with giving birth added into the mix, I was tired, I was exhausted and I was emotionally drained.

The midwife would not show me what to do with formula. Luckily, we'd bought the ready made bottles. Looking back now, I definitely had PND (albeit mild) and I put it down to that midwife and even now, I still feel so angry/upset by it all!

I’m sorry to hear this! And yes , I think when we are that tired and that vulnerable we are so easily affected by other people’s behaviour so what might sound minor to someone outside of that situation can cut really deep in the moment and properly fuck your head up. I’m glad my childbearing days are behind me . I had terrible experiences at both births and also at the news one of mine had passed away in the second trimester was handled terribly too. I’m lucky my kids are so healthy because just going near a hospital maternity unit ( which are invariably next to paediatrics and a&e ) always makes me feel like I’m going to throw up! I can’t even watch births or labouring women on tv . I’m sorry that MW ruined your experience too! I totally understand. Who’d be a woman eh? X

UndertheCedartree · 21/08/2022 22:19

Wouldloveanother · 20/08/2022 12:11

its not opinion, it’s fact! And surely much more reassuring than ‘your child missed out on an enormous and noticeable health benefit’. And my point was it isn’t for bfing mums to act all faux concerned about FF kids ‘being deprived’ of health benefits (as pp said).

My point is people can be upset about whatever they like - if they are upset, they are upset. You shouldn't be trying to shut them up. I was upset at being pushed to FF. If someone had 'reassured me' that despite all my research and BFing being important to me (to me the health benefits were worth it, they don't have to be 'enormous' to be worth it just significant) that actually I was getting upset over nothing, that would have completely invalidated me and indeed gaslit me as during pregnancy the benefits of breastfeeding were explained and the message 'breast is best'.

DocsandSocks · 21/08/2022 21:53

Theneverendingtories · 20/08/2022 16:06

personally I’m still a bit fed up and upset after several years at the approach taken by the midwives on the post natal ward that led me to walk out 21 hours after a section because they refused to acknowledge my personal choices. I had stated quite clearly that DS was welcome to the breast for a few hours after delivery to give him a few shots of colostrum as an immune boost but I was absolutely not going to offer breast past that stage. It was an informed choice having been bullied into BF his sibling many years before and hating every second of it I was certain of my plan. I sent his father to go sort a bottle out and they swarmed in on me like the gestapo and one even had the cheek to touch my breast and try to shove it into DS face! I was furious and told her to Fuck off. I was hot and in pain and I told them he was hungry and needed a proper feed I also did not want my tits out in a room full of people. I knew if I let him continue to latch I’d end up with a much worse amount of pain and leakage in the days to come and I’d been through quite enough thank you. Anyway, between this altercation and their previous catalogue of balls ups that nearly cost us our lives they agreed to let me go home soon after that. It was an unnecessary addition to the existing trauma of those days and it still makes me angry now to think of it .
so BF support should be there for those who want it but there should not be be any pressure on those of us who have our reasons for refusing it .

@Theneverendingtories I have an inverted nipple so my daughter would not latch. However, the worst midwife I had told me that I would not be discharged until I had BF three times. Luckily, my husband was there and told her that I would feed our daughter twice, however I seem fit, and then he would be coming back to collect us (Covid times) and we'd be walking out of that hospital whether she discharged us or not. I am so glad that he was there to advocate for me because after three days of no sleep with giving birth added into the mix, I was tired, I was exhausted and I was emotionally drained.

The midwife would not show me what to do with formula. Luckily, we'd bought the ready made bottles. Looking back now, I definitely had PND (albeit mild) and I put it down to that midwife and even now, I still feel so angry/upset by it all!

Faciadipasta · 21/08/2022 07:24

@Papyri I'm so sorry. That's awful to hear. Long term issues caused by the malnutrition is one of my biggest fears. I'm not aware of any issues in my children (although they are both quite small) so hopefully we got lucky. I'm very glad to hear your daughter is getting better now.

Papyri · 21/08/2022 00:23

I am struggling to keep up with everything but just wanted to add @Faciadipasta you are not alone, I so identify with so much of your journey.
I had to delete some pictures of my daughter, I cried over how thin she looked in retrospect.
When we just FF her she went from the 9th to the 99th centile. The guilt was horrendous.
My daughter ended up Ill and I ended up suicidal all through trying to pursue breastfeeding. She still has to see a paediatrician now through health problems caused by breastfeeding related malnutrition though thankfully it’s getting better now.

FF being promoted is absolute bollocks- I had no idea about how much to give her, what teat size, what was normal or not and no one will tell you either.
There would probably be fewer illnesses associated with FF if HCP actually gave people proper advice.

Theneverendingtories · 20/08/2022 16:06

personally I’m still a bit fed up and upset after several years at the approach taken by the midwives on the post natal ward that led me to walk out 21 hours after a section because they refused to acknowledge my personal choices. I had stated quite clearly that DS was welcome to the breast for a few hours after delivery to give him a few shots of colostrum as an immune boost but I was absolutely not going to offer breast past that stage. It was an informed choice having been bullied into BF his sibling many years before and hating every second of it I was certain of my plan. I sent his father to go sort a bottle out and they swarmed in on me like the gestapo and one even had the cheek to touch my breast and try to shove it into DS face! I was furious and told her to Fuck off. I was hot and in pain and I told them he was hungry and needed a proper feed I also did not want my tits out in a room full of people. I knew if I let him continue to latch I’d end up with a much worse amount of pain and leakage in the days to come and I’d been through quite enough thank you. Anyway, between this altercation and their previous catalogue of balls ups that nearly cost us our lives they agreed to let me go home soon after that. It was an unnecessary addition to the existing trauma of those days and it still makes me angry now to think of it .
so BF support should be there for those who want it but there should not be be any pressure on those of us who have our reasons for refusing it .

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 15:49

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 15:32

Formula is the go to when it comes to any breast feeding problem, no matter how minor.

But for me I needed formula. My babies were losing so much weight they were sent to A and E. I was ordered to give them top ups along with BF and then as soon as we were home I was told to stop. They lost weight again. To the point that the HV was coming round every 3 days or so to weigh them. They were clearly malnourished and I was struggling mentally with PND, terrified people would think I was starving them or that I just didn't want to breastfeed because I was a bad mother". I tried literally everything. It took over my whole life, and everyone I saw was acting like this was fine and normal. I was too mentally unwell to see it was neither.
And I had twins so looking back it really can't have been a surprise that I didn't produce enough milk. But STILL I was told not to FF even supplementally. No its better to use domperidone, pump constantly, not leave the house for months because there wasn't time between the feeding, weighing and pumping and not even have a chance to bond.

That HV should be struck off for putting the lives of two vulnerable babies at risk never mind allowing the emotional trauma to you escalate to the point it did.

Its horrifying that this happened to you and your babies. I can’t even begin to work out how the HV thought what she was allowing to happen was justified.

And it’s also horrifying that new mothers are so consumed by the pressure that they feel like they have lost their voice. HCPs cannot force a mother to only breastfeed or give expressed milk and they cannot tell a mother not to give formula, but sadly as in cases like yours, mothers can be too vulnerable and broken down to realise they have the right to make their own decisions about feeding their own babies.

It’s terrifying all round actually. The vulnerability of new mothers when it comes to feeding difficulties is so underestimated and I imagine PND and long term emotional trauma are the result of new mothers feeding decisions, and the emotions they are wrapped up in that, being controlled by others

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 15:32

Formula is the go to when it comes to any breast feeding problem, no matter how minor.

But for me I needed formula. My babies were losing so much weight they were sent to A and E. I was ordered to give them top ups along with BF and then as soon as we were home I was told to stop. They lost weight again. To the point that the HV was coming round every 3 days or so to weigh them. They were clearly malnourished and I was struggling mentally with PND, terrified people would think I was starving them or that I just didn't want to breastfeed because I was a bad mother". I tried literally everything. It took over my whole life, and everyone I saw was acting like this was fine and normal. I was too mentally unwell to see it was neither.
And I had twins so looking back it really can't have been a surprise that I didn't produce enough milk. But STILL I was told not to FF even supplementally. No its better to use domperidone, pump constantly, not leave the house for months because there wasn't time between the feeding, weighing and pumping and not even have a chance to bond.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 15:23

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 20/08/2022 15:17

@Faciadipasta I’m in Hampshire. It’s crazy that things are so different, but I think the underlying cause is a lack of support services overall, which is absolutely scandalous.
@DreamToNightmare that sounds exactly like mine. When we were finally admitted to paediatrics after weeks of poor weight gain, someone finally sat with me to look at my baby’s latch, which apparently wasn’t right, and then I was promptly told that I must give her formula, and despite my tears, they sat and fed her a bottle right there and then. After weeks of struggling, I wasn’t strong enough to know whether this was right or not. I then had bottles and bottles handed to me, like sweets like you say, and told I must use them. And then I was given no follow up.
For those people on the thread who say it doesn’t matter how your baby is fed, for some of us it really really does matter. That’s what those HCPs did to me, and they made me feel totally worthless.

This is so, so horrifying and it shouldn’t be happening. People have no idea how heartbreaking it can be for some women when breastfeeding doesn’t go as planned and staff have no awareness of the emotional damage they can cause by making the mother feel like she wasn’t good enough or that she failed.

When I was in hospital with my first baby the breastfeeding hadn’t been going well and his sugars were a little low and so on Day 2 of life the midwives said he needed some formula and sat in front of me and gave him a 30ml bottle of Apatamil. I have never felt as much of a failure as I did in those few short minutes. I couldn’t even bring myself to watch her give him the bottle. It was horrendous.

Stories like yours really upset me.

Thankfully I work in a role that means I have a lot of power to stop this from happening but I’m sure it happens to thousands of women every day across the country and it’s so, so wrong.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 15:18

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 15:08

@DreamToNightmare can I ask where you are too, if you don't mind?
It's so weird that the treatment in your area is literally the opposite of what we experienced (london)
I just don't get how policy can be so vastly different depending on region.

It isn’t about policies though because the care that is being given actually goes against all the policies in the hospital surrounding breast feeding support and the management of feeding difficulties etc.

The fact is that the midwives either don’t care about breast feeding or don’t have the time to support mothers and so simply give them mothers formula instead. Formula is the go to when it comes to any breast feeding problem, no matter how minor. For example, I have even known of a mother be given a bottle of formula when her baby was 11 hours old because he had only breast fed twice since he was born.

I believe that short staffing and bed management plays a large part in why formula is so easily handed out in Maternity as opposed to investing time in getting the breast feeding off to the right start.

I work with about 30 babies a month who end up back in hospital due to breast feeding difficulties and the stories I hear are horrifying in terms of what “support” and “education” received in Maternity.

I am based in the West Midlands.

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 20/08/2022 15:17

@Faciadipasta I’m in Hampshire. It’s crazy that things are so different, but I think the underlying cause is a lack of support services overall, which is absolutely scandalous.
@DreamToNightmare that sounds exactly like mine. When we were finally admitted to paediatrics after weeks of poor weight gain, someone finally sat with me to look at my baby’s latch, which apparently wasn’t right, and then I was promptly told that I must give her formula, and despite my tears, they sat and fed her a bottle right there and then. After weeks of struggling, I wasn’t strong enough to know whether this was right or not. I then had bottles and bottles handed to me, like sweets like you say, and told I must use them. And then I was given no follow up.
For those people on the thread who say it doesn’t matter how your baby is fed, for some of us it really really does matter. That’s what those HCPs did to me, and they made me feel totally worthless.

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 15:08

@DreamToNightmare can I ask where you are too, if you don't mind?
It's so weird that the treatment in your area is literally the opposite of what we experienced (london)
I just don't get how policy can be so vastly different depending on region.

DreamToNightmare · 20/08/2022 15:02

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 20/08/2022 14:21

I’m so surprised by all these comments about the NHS, because my experience was the exact opposite! I was desperate to breastfeed, but my baby was struggling to latch and wasn’t gaining weight. So instead of ANY breastfeeding support, I was told to formula feed. And then I was told to increase the formula, again and again, until my breast milk had almost dried up, at which point I was told I had better just formula feed the . I was given plenty of advice on formula, including which formula to use (yes, the most expensive one!) by midwives, nurses, GPs etc. I was made to feel selfish for wanting to breastfeed, and stubborn for pushing it so hard. So clearly my experience is completely different to most of yours, but that is why in my opinion, there is no need for a formula awareness month, as it is pushed and pushed and pushed by my local NHS.

This is my experience too of the Trust I work in.

The maternity department are awful, they hardly provide any breast feeding support and give formula at the first sign of any problem…for example if newborn baby hasn’t breast fed for 4 hours they give the mum a bottle of formula.

The Paediatric unit are the same when it comes to babies who are re-admitted for breast feeding difficulties, rather than try and support the mother to overcome the feeding difficulties the doctors just throw formula at the problem.

Formula is handed out like sweeties where I work.

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 14:37

@wedonttalkaboutyouno do you mind if I ask which area of the country you are in? I wonder if its a regional.thing maybe? In London where I am BF is absolutely the norm and the NHS do nothing to help with FF. Even if you are actually in hospital and have been told to give formula top ups by the pediatrician, they still do not provide any formula or advice at all. Then every single health professional works to try and get you to stop FF even if as in case it's just supplemental and has been recommended by doctors. I was told that as my babies had regained the last weight I should stop.the top ups or I'd never produce enough milk. Obviously they just lost weight again. It seems to HVs, midwives and plenty of others it's better to have malnourished babies than add any formula at all...
No matter what damage that does to mothers mental health or their babies physical health

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 20/08/2022 14:23

And just to say, I am now exclusively breastfeeding, because I paid for support, and sought help from the NCT etc. so the problems were not insurmountable (although so so hard) but I did need help, which the NHS should have given.

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 20/08/2022 14:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

wedonttalkaboutyouno · 20/08/2022 14:21

I’m so surprised by all these comments about the NHS, because my experience was the exact opposite! I was desperate to breastfeed, but my baby was struggling to latch and wasn’t gaining weight. So instead of ANY breastfeeding support, I was told to formula feed. And then I was told to increase the formula, again and again, until my breast milk had almost dried up, at which point I was told I had better just formula feed the . I was given plenty of advice on formula, including which formula to use (yes, the most expensive one!) by midwives, nurses, GPs etc. I was made to feel selfish for wanting to breastfeed, and stubborn for pushing it so hard. So clearly my experience is completely different to most of yours, but that is why in my opinion, there is no need for a formula awareness month, as it is pushed and pushed and pushed by my local NHS.

DobbyHasASock · 20/08/2022 13:50

Indeed, The thing is, I would like to bf my due baby if I can. But I'm so nervous because I know from experience the NHS will push it beyond the point of good sense and having not successfully breastfed I've no idea what safe bf looks like. I'm worried as babies do die die to pushing of bf above all others, this is I believe why the fed is best campaign started.
And as I said, the midwife insensitively pushes it is quite difficult for me emotionally. Not helpful at all.
A helpful stance would be acknowledging that this pregnancy is different and whilst it might mean I am able to bf, it's no guarantee. Acknowledging the guilt and toll on my mental health would help too.

But it's so much easier to parrot a three word slogan and treat me like a smoker or crack user because I've expressed the opinion it might not work out for me.

DobbyHasASock · 20/08/2022 13:41

@Faciadipasta thank you, I would not wish it on anyone.
At the same time it would be lovely if the read the tin brigade could develop a smidge of empathy or actually engage.
Have to remember not al bf mums are so callous. I've some supportive bf friends as well as the judgemental ones.

SeasonsOfLife · 20/08/2022 13:39

DobbyHasASock · 20/08/2022 13:30

In my experience NCT were fair in that they covered bottle feeding. I mostly let it wash over me because I was adamant I was going to bf.
But shit happened. And once I'd given birth the breast is best narrative was the only one I heard. I was made to feel guilty by every health professional that I failed at bf because I wasn't trying hard enough. The absolute gaslighting. In addition to this I knew my baby couldn't do it and was told he's just a lazy boy.
Turns out I was right and he has a disability. Again, the absolute gaslighting. It was either I was doing it wrong or not forcing him enough. He literally would have died if I hadn't FF.
And yes, god the toll on my relationship with my baby. Hours of someone else holding him whilst I pumped. Being told I just needed to try harder or he's get it eventually I kept it up for months. Got no sleep. Developed severe and I mean severe pnd. And for what? After all the pumping HCP deemed pumped milk on par with FF anyway.

You cannot underestimate how damaging the bias in the NHS is. As I said previously, despite all my history I'm not receiving the same script from midwife for baby two despite it being so bad for my baby.
Incidentally, when I gave up pumping and trying to bf my son made the most progress. Neuroplasticity is unpredictable, but I believe getting.proper attention from his mum helped enormously.

Absolutely fuck off with your non promoting bollocks. Shame on you for denying mums options

@DobbyHasASock totally agree. There is a bias in the NHS which is wrong because (as in my case when ds went floppy through dehydration) when bf doesn't work and your child suffers, it puts more strain on NHS services which doesn't help anyone. It could have been avoided if someone had used their best judgement and common sense rather than sticking to the standard NHS script.

Interestingly, I had a private midwife for dc2 who was also NHS. Because I saw her privately, she was far more realistic and understanding. Because she, as a professional, used her own judgement without having targets to meet (privately). A very different, less pushy experience for me with that midwife.

Faciadipasta · 20/08/2022 13:34

@DobbyHasASock I totally understand. And I'm so sorry you went through that. It is SO damaging.